Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is the UK in danger from Russia?

614 replies

hereforalongtimenotagoodtime · 24/02/2022 21:58

Keep receiving conflicting information. I am sick to my stomach and quite simply hate the unknown. So a simple question - is it likely that the UK will be in danger from Russia? And if so what does that look like? Cyber attacks, bombs being dropped?

OP posts:
Olden · 25/02/2022 11:51

@Dinosaurs1994 what do you mean? His threat is against anybody who interferes, why do you say he's made a threat against the UK specifically?

Dinosaurs1994 · 25/02/2022 11:48

Is Putin threatening the USA in the same way he is us? I'm avoiding the news at the minute before anybody suggests I look it up

TheSnowyOwl · 25/02/2022 11:47

@Ereshkigalangcleg

Thank you to the people who answered my question about retaliation with cyber attacks, I wonder what we would do, and whether it would then become a more physical conflict.
Pretty much everything ultimately relies upon technology to run.

Take down energy companies and their smart meters, so no power. No power means not being able to buy anything from shops or stay warm/lights on. No power means computers can’t stay powered and companies cannot work. No power means mobiles can’t be charged and used. No power means emergency services cannot connect and get to places. No power means hospitals don’t have enough back up generators to last long.

And that’s just taking out energy companies. And the older style meters won’t necessarily mean you escape it either. This is before we even have energy supplies to the U.K. limited as well.

A proper cyber attack would be as bad as physical warfare. It’s just different. Just as bad, but different.

ClaudineClare · 25/02/2022 11:47

@cherrysthename

Fucking hell I hope no one feeling anxious about this clicked on to the thread in the hopes of rational perspectives. Some posts are shit ya pants scary, and deliberately so.
I agree. Nothing wrong with having an understanding of what might happen, but some posters seem to relish setting out worst case scenarios.
MistressoftheDarkSide · 25/02/2022 11:46

Ooh, yes, and also Polish.... phew, I have options..... rum really doesn't do it for me ..... thank you!!

RedToothBrush · 25/02/2022 11:44

@MistressoftheDarkSide

Yes, vigilance and awareness, plus a dose of pragmaticism and a little preparation perhaps. I find a dash of vodka helps..... but am now conflicted... perhaps I'll switch to run, just to help with economic sanctions..... (yes, very dark humour us my coping mechanism, you should hear some of the stuff that's come out of my mouth while organising DPs funeral. If I believed in hell my ticket is stamped already )
Icelandic vodka is very good....
RedToothBrush · 25/02/2022 11:44

Hybird modern warfare doesn't need to be within range. You can do it from your bedroom. Your place of work is also more likely to be a target.

Why does anyone want to use a nuke? The fallout will affect you too. And you are liable to ensure an strike on your own popular.

A preemptive cyber strike on a society more dependent than you on technology on the other hand, is less of a risk to yourselves but may have significant strategic benefits. You are far less likely to have domestic unrest.

I remain unconvinced that Russians would have had the same level of drama over KFC...

Ereshkigalangcleg · 25/02/2022 11:42

Thank you to the people who answered my question about retaliation with cyber attacks, I wonder what we would do, and whether it would then become a more physical conflict.

MistressoftheDarkSide · 25/02/2022 11:41

Yes, vigilance and awareness, plus a dose of pragmaticism and a little preparation perhaps. I find a dash of vodka helps..... but am now conflicted... perhaps I'll switch to run, just to help with economic sanctions..... (yes, very dark humour us my coping mechanism, you should hear some of the stuff that's come out of my mouth while organising DPs funeral. If I believed in hell my ticket is stamped already )

ThreeRingCircus · 25/02/2022 11:39

@fghjk

Although Vlad is acting the hard man, Russia's capacity to wage war on multiple fronts would be limited. Western Europe would be a different proposition. Any attacking forces would have to get past multiple hostile NATO powers before they reach us. We can also fight back. Russia does have the nuclear option, but so does NATO, and Russia would suffer terribly in a reprisal (MAD). They also have limited manpower.

This is worth repeating as @Usou is speaking a lot of sense, unlike some of the other posts on this thread.

I feel like Usou is thinking in terms of a war fought with an infantry though i.e attacking forces would have to get through multiple NATO countries. Like they're looking at the Dad's Army map with the big red arrows and seeing how much physical land sits between them and us.

Modern warfare doesn't have to be fought like that (and in fact I think you'd have to be massively underestimating the man and his cohort's intelligence to think it would be).

From what I can gather (and again, I'm not an expert) it feels like certain countries have been slyly provoking this for a long while. Kicking the dog under the table in the hopes it snaps and bites so they can justifiably shoot it. Or even more covertly, take it to the Vet's and have it humanely put down.

Maybe that's not what has been happening at all, but IF IT WAS, that's an act of modern warfare the same as any other. And it did not involve getting past the countless countries which physically sit between the dog and the one kicking it. It did not involve infantry with guns or rolling tanks or mobilising jets, and yet look how effective it's been....

I do see what you mean and agree that the later discussion on cyber warfare is also interesting and there are far more knowledgeable people in this area than I commenting (have now caught up with the full thread.)

DH works in IT security and spent all yesterday with his team suring up systems and removing access to any users in Russia, China and Ukraine but who knows what has already been planted and is out there lurking?

fghjk · 25/02/2022 11:34

Although Vlad is acting the hard man, Russia's capacity to wage war on multiple fronts would be limited. Western Europe would be a different proposition. Any attacking forces would have to get past multiple hostile NATO powers before they reach us. We can also fight back. Russia does have the nuclear option, but so does NATO, and Russia would suffer terribly in a reprisal (MAD). They also have limited manpower.

This is worth repeating as @Usou is speaking a lot of sense, unlike some of the other posts on this thread.

I feel like Usou is thinking in terms of a war fought with an infantry though i.e attacking forces would have to get through multiple NATO countries. Like they're looking at the Dad's Army map with the big red arrows and seeing how much physical land sits between them and us.

Modern warfare doesn't have to be fought like that (and in fact I think you'd have to be massively underestimating the man and his cohort's intelligence to think it would be).

From what I can gather (and again, I'm not an expert) it feels like certain countries have been slyly provoking this for a long while. Kicking the dog under the table in the hopes it snaps and bites so they can justifiably shoot it. Or even more covertly, take it to the Vet's and have it humanely put down.

Maybe that's not what has been happening at all, but IF IT WAS, that's an act of modern warfare the same as any other. And it did not involve getting past the countless countries which physically sit between the dog and the one kicking it. It did not involve infantry with guns or rolling tanks or mobilising jets, and yet look how effective it's been....

RedToothBrush · 25/02/2022 11:31

@cherrysthename

Fucking hell I hope no one feeling anxious about this clicked on to the thread in the hopes of rational perspectives. Some posts are shit ya pants scary, and deliberately so.
It is rational to be talking about the levelbof threat here! The dismissive comments over 'it will be over in 24 hours' are more worrying.

If we don't have conversations about food security and our over dependence on technology as a society we are at risk of all the things we don't want to talk about.

I've said it before - the collapse of civilisation as we currently know it is most likely to be from collective nervous breakdown than nuclear annihilation. This situation could trigger civil unrest in any country if infrastructure collapses and also civil opposition to government.

I'm inclined to agree. Purely on the basis of how people went nuts when KFC ran out of chicken.

We've seen how human viruses spread rapidly and how some people are more effected than others. What we could be talking about is a technological version of the same.

We should be taking it seriously.

Being anxious about it, wont make the threat go away. We do need to be vigilant and aware because so many of us work in jobs which involve techology. That puts NHS staff as front line in a cyber war for example.

We NEED awareness on this!

TheSnowyOwl · 25/02/2022 11:24

@Ereshkigalangcleg

This maybe a stupid question, but does the U.K. have the capacity to cyber attack back? Otherwise how would we retaliate, in a conflict situation?
To the same extent, almost certainly not. We also go about things in retaliation differently to Russia (and China etc).

Anonymous have waged a cyber war against Russia. Allegedly they are worldwide and whilst they are competent hackers, to quite what extent and long-standing they have remains to really be seen.

fghjk · 25/02/2022 11:24

God don't get me started on overpromoted managers not understanding tech and instead playing politics.

I lasted 10 years in defence manufacturing and left to go self-employed in an entirely different field. It got too much for me. The culture of jobs for life, jobs for the boys, three managers for every one technical person, and the fact I'd have to make the switch myself if I wanted to get ahead spelled out this was not the place for me.

Also despite being in the private sector it suffered from the same pitfalls I'm sure the public sector does. When your customers are governments with what feels like an endless / unlimited pit of money, the culture of the business is not the same as in a place where your customer is spending their own money and thus expect results on time and on budget. So much waste. So much pointless middle management. So many hours spent on pointless processes that could easily be optimised, but that would mean reductions in the amount of 'old boys' and their pointless positions.

I am so glad I'm out of it. No amount of money was worth going home every night feeling like you could have done so much and made a real difference and instead you spent the day pretending to be busy.

RedToothBrush · 25/02/2022 11:23

@Ereshkigalangcleg

This maybe a stupid question, but does the U.K. have the capacity to cyber attack back? Otherwise how would we retaliate, in a conflict situation?
Yes we probably do. But we are likely to have to withstand and deal with a 'preemptive strike' first.

I would be highly surprised if denable low level black ops weren't already in progress. As others have pointed out Russia and China have likely planted 'cyberbombs' in our system in case they ever need to activate them.

Israel certainly has developed and actively admitted using this type of technology and is a NATO member. Its inconceivable the US dont have it, and given we tend to be world leaders in this area, we are unlikely not to have it.

GCHQ will have this in its arsenal I'm sure.

Its the defence thats the problem. We know that Russia and China have much bigger operations than we do and perhaps arent as societies so dependant on the technology in the first place.

cherrysthename · 25/02/2022 11:21

Fucking hell I hope no one feeling anxious about this clicked on to the thread in the hopes of rational perspectives. Some posts are shit ya pants scary, and deliberately so.

ThreeRingCircus · 25/02/2022 11:18

@Usou

The chances of the UK coming under attack from Russia while not negligible are quite remote for a variety of reasons.

Although Vlad is acting the hard man, Russia's capacity to wage war on multiple fronts would be limited. Western Europe would be a different proposition. Any attacking forces would have to get past multiple hostile NATO powers before they reach us. We can also fight back. Russia does have the nuclear option, but so does NATO, and Russia would suffer terribly in a reprisal (MAD). They also have limited manpower.

A serious escalation cannot be discounted, but the greater likelihood is for a limited, if incredibly unfair, regional conflict.

The reality is that Vlad would never have attacked Ukraine if he didn't have a good chance of winning, however this will damage Russia's International standing for a long time.

This is worth repeating as @Usou is speaking a lot of sense, unlike some of the other posts on this thread.
EpicMugs · 25/02/2022 11:16

@Ereshkigalangcleg

This maybe a stupid question, but does the U.K. have the capacity to cyber attack back? Otherwise how would we retaliate, in a conflict situation?
Yes. But whether we have enough is a point of national security.

My own guess would be, we are way behind where Russia, China and maybe even Iran are on this. We have not given it the focus or money, though that is changing.

Like we haven't with food and energy security.

The US, on the other hand is likely to be much further ahead. And may help.

MistressoftheDarkSide · 25/02/2022 11:16

The nuclear threat is part of the psychology if modern warfare, and we have been primed for it for years.

Propaganda has the potential of such sophisticated levels due to technological advances we could potentially never know the truth about anything. Lack of trust in corrupt and allegedly bumbling governments adds to the mix.

I've said it before - the collapse of civilisation as we currently know it is most likely to be from collective nervous breakdown than nuclear annihilation. This situation could trigger civil unrest in any country if infrastructure collapses and also civil opposition to government.

It's very difficult behave faith or optimism for any sort of sensible resolution any time soon.

RedToothBrush · 25/02/2022 11:15

@EpicMugs

In all honesty - I've worked with a major supermarket and I now work with critical government systems.

I think the supermarket took security far more seriously and was far more diligent. It's not just the paying rate issue (though there is that), it's that government agencies suffer especially from (some) people joining and staying forever, being promoted through internal politics than skill. Their thinking is 10-20 years behind where the world is.

A bit like the saying that the army is always fighting the last war. Not this one. Government agencies are always responding the last attack - not looking for the next one.

God don't get me started on overpromoted managers not understanding tech and instead playing politics. The culture of jobs for life and skill degradation in IT in the public sector is a real issue.

It puts off those who do have the skills, even if the money didn't.

The whole sector is an utter shit show.

AllOfUsAreDead · 25/02/2022 11:14

@Ereshkigalangcleg

This maybe a stupid question, but does the U.K. have the capacity to cyber attack back? Otherwise how would we retaliate, in a conflict situation?
I don't think so. But maybe gchq does more on that than we are aware of.
Ereshkigalangcleg · 25/02/2022 11:13

Also, even if it were possible to keep up, some people just don't want to think about it.

Surprising which threads they choose to post on, then.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 25/02/2022 11:12

This maybe a stupid question, but does the U.K. have the capacity to cyber attack back? Otherwise how would we retaliate, in a conflict situation?

RedToothBrush · 25/02/2022 11:12

Also, even if it were possible to keep up, some people just don't want to think about it.

I think the first part is irrelevant. You don't need to keep up. You just need to be capable of googling 'what are the risks of a cyberattack' or similar.

I do agree with the second part massively. Its people who don't want to find out and use google to mitigate their lack of knowledge thats the problem.

However I had hoped that everyone would have at least grasped that things that happened in China, affected what they saw on their shelves here though. Everyone got it when they couldnt find bog roll or pasta or when they queued for petrol.

EpicMugs · 25/02/2022 11:11

In all honesty - I've worked with a major supermarket and I now work with critical government systems.

I think the supermarket took security far more seriously and was far more diligent. It's not just the paying rate issue (though there is that), it's that government agencies suffer especially from (some) people joining and staying forever, being promoted through internal politics than skill. Their thinking is 10-20 years behind where the world is.

A bit like the saying that the army is always fighting the last war. Not this one. Government agencies are always responding the last attack - not looking for the next one.