Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is the UK in danger from Russia?

614 replies

hereforalongtimenotagoodtime · 24/02/2022 21:58

Keep receiving conflicting information. I am sick to my stomach and quite simply hate the unknown. So a simple question - is it likely that the UK will be in danger from Russia? And if so what does that look like? Cyber attacks, bombs being dropped?

OP posts:
User1isnotavailable · 25/02/2022 13:30

@Tealightsandd

If not Russia, there's Long Covid. Despite rumours to the contrary that threat has not gone away.
A bit of tiredness that all the experts agree diminishes with time and the vast majority that 'suffer' appear to be a certain sort of person. A compare that with potential for nuclear strikes on parts of Europe if anybody interferes! Hmm

There are some that suffer the after effects of covid where they had the need for intubation etc but that's a completely different thing.

bakewelltarty · 25/02/2022 13:29

Rosehugger - Kyiv (pronounced Keev) is what they Ukrainians call it. Kiev is how the Russians pronounce it.

Livelovebehappy · 25/02/2022 13:18

Reassuring to hear the government saying we will not interfere by sending troops to fight the Russians, as that would trigger a world war. Whilst it’s heartbreaking to hear of what the people of Ukraine are going through, I don’t want to sacrifice the safety of my family on the alter of the Ukraine invasion.

MangyInseam · 25/02/2022 13:17

@Iggly

It's complicated basically, and I don't think we have any business getting involved in this war. In fact I don't think we have any business getting into any wars that don't directly affect us, as sad as that is for people around the world who cannot protect themselves

As we are not anywhere near close enough to being self sufficient, we don’t have the luxury of not getting involved. We’ve sold most of our national infrastructure and assets to overseas companies, we have not invested in home grown technology and have just encouraged foreign investment which means we have little control over a lot of our economy.

That is why our government is so easily bought by the likes of Russian donors.

So sadly we are involved whether we like it or not.

I don't want to get into a partisan political argument, but this is the kind of thing that has fueled a lot of people's worries around globalism, and fed into culture wars in the UK, USA, and now Canada. I kind of hate to point to Trump as having a brain of any kind but the fact is that in the US, he was the guy talking about beefing up industry and energy independence, not Biden or Clinton. And in the UK it's sure not Labour who has been talking about that.

Now whether Trump or anyone else actually cared or it was just talking points I don't speculate, but it has not been the liberal left that has been talking about these things and security at the nation level in terms of supply chains, energy, food. Quite the contrary a lot of them seem to despise any talk of that kind.

bringonsummer2022 · 25/02/2022 13:13

I think cyber is a threat but that's nothing new and the best people on our side have been preparing for cyber attacks for years.
Check your passwords, make sure you're secure personally. There are people on our side protecting the banks, NHS and so on.

cooldarkroom · 25/02/2022 13:13

They are using cyber attacks on banks & hacking private accounts in Ukraine already I heard on the French News, the viruses created were developed in Dec 2021... he's been planning this for months/years.

Chernobyl is already in a danger zone & europe is checking for radioactive leak already, they have said they can't control the site if there are bombs falling, the technicians can't get access.

Putin is ruined if he doesn't "win" Ukraine, he will not back down

Rosehugger · 25/02/2022 13:09

Why does Clive Myrie say "Keev"? Everyone else (including Ukrainians) seems to say Kyiv or Kiev. Surely it's not pronounced to rhyme with Steve.

Jaxhog · 25/02/2022 13:09

@JuergenSchwarzwald

They didn't need to take Chernobyl to do damage, they just needed to blow it up. They probably think they can use it as a bargaining chip though.
I doubt Russia want's any hassle here. It was just on the way to Kyiv.
AnotherSillawithanS · 25/02/2022 12:54

@youhadmeatjello people will start emptying their bank accounts

JuergenSchwarzwald · 25/02/2022 12:50

They didn't need to take Chernobyl to do damage, they just needed to blow it up. They probably think they can use it as a bargaining chip though.

RedToothBrush · 25/02/2022 12:36

Critical infrastructure like air traffic control has to have a backup system which is on a completely separate system with no interaction for precisely this reason.

This strategy is employed for some systems outside crucial infrastructure, but not all.

The NHS can switch to hand written systems and notes if it has to, to a certain extent. But thats time consuming and means that you cannot always have relevant documents to hand as they are in another location rather than immediately accessible on your screen.

I think in terms of how we deal with the threat, i think we can all do things to help. It might be as simple as having addresses and telephone numbers written down somewhere. Or thinking about who you have locally who you could use for support in a crisis (another parent from school even if you aren't close). Its hard to know what more you can do which is realistic and useful tbh. Everyone should have an emergency pack as a rule to a certain extent anyway.

AllOfUsAreDead · 25/02/2022 12:28

I agree. Nothing wrong with having an understanding of what might happen, but some posters seem to relish setting out worst case scenarios.

Another misunderstanding sadly.

No we don't 'relish' what might happen. But our jobs are actually to try and keep society actually continuing. That includes having back up plans in place in case of a cyber attack. It includes back up plans when some dickhead goes and screws things up and decides he wants to be a bully. But there's only so much that can be done, and not every area has good back up plans. We try, but that doesn't mean everyone does. And there isn't really a back up plan incase everything goes to shit, because no one aligns with other, they don't talk, there isn't enough infrastructure in place to help if it does all go tits up. It's a terrifying prospect that we know cannot be resolved easily and will screw up many lives, including our own. We don't want it to happen, we'll be having to work 24/7 to get it resolved.

But yes, we relish it. Hmm

VelvetChairGirl · 25/02/2022 12:26

why would russia invade anywhere else we had the same fear mongering over Crimea.

the area has history, US backing of Svoboda etc.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 25/02/2022 12:24

The thing with hybrid warefare is how it creates multiple crisis at the same time in an effort to overwhelm.

Its the overwhelming that compounds any single issue.

I agree. It would be absolute chaos.

RedToothBrush · 25/02/2022 12:22

Tbh im largely hoping that we see more of a cold war standoff.

I think the financial stuff will compromise our ability to do more. And thats really what Putin is taking a gamble on.

I don't know that there is reward enough for Russia to invade an EU country (even one outside NATO).

I don't think we will have military level cyber attacks unless Putin feels he has no choice. I think the point is military level cyber attacks are the new nukes to an extent - and its the potential threat of them thats more important than actually using them to their full capacity.

We know that smaller attacks which may or may not be state sanctioned have been going on against the uk for a while.

Its like spying. Both sides know its going on, but dont kick off about it.

What does Putin ultimately want? Is it to expand into Europe? I'm not convinced it is. Is it more because he wants to distract from domestic issues, to create a legacy of Russian power under his control, he wants more influence internationally?

He doesn't need to necessarily move west nor launch a military level cyber attack to achieve that.

Is he an expansionist opportunist or is he a reckless megalomaniac? Thats the big question.

Is he more likely merely to push boundaries, he thinks he can get away with? And how far will the west allow it to continue? A gradual 'mission creep' strategy by Putin is much harder for the West to combat because of western public opinion. Putin has been charged with exacerbating refugee issues in the past to help weaken and destabilise western governments before. So thatd something else I would look out for. Particularly in terms of propaganda.

I think may thoughts would be to actually look further east in terms of how China interrupt this and how they eye up Taiwan which is rumoured to face a full invasion in similar fashion within the next couple of years (china's response to the invasion and the wording they use is interesting).

BUT i do think there is a real risk of a Franz Ferdinand type moment which could trigger a chain of events which could lead to defensive pacts being triggered in quick succession and thing exploding very quickly.

And in that sense thats why we should be taking the threat of cyber attacks much more seriously.

User48751490 · 25/02/2022 12:11

@elizabethdraper

Why have they taken Chernobyl

Think about the damage they can do to the whole of european with that one site
It is absolutely terrifying

That was my first thought this morning. Terrifying.
fghjk · 25/02/2022 12:06

@Dinosaurs1994 well the USA is the enemy? Or perhaps more widely the counties who primarily speak English and their clients / friends / allies.

The USA want Ukraine to join NATO which Russia could see as being forced into a lose-lose situation. He's equating NATO's expansion with Hitler's preparation to launch a surprise attack. It's your enemies buying the house directly across the street so they can start filling it with guns "just incase Wink".

So his lose-lose situation is he either stands by and watches it happen - lets the people he perceives as the enemy who seem to do what they like and wage wars all over the world for any reason they want pitch up on his doorstep... OR he takes aggressive action now before it happens and bargains that the consequences are worth the risk.

He appears to have chosen the later and I think it will all depend on how "we" react to it.

(If I've got this entirely wrong please feel free to correct me! I've had to try and learn all this in the space of a few weeks to understand what's happening but it's obviously a complex subject and most of the MSM talks about this in very simplistic Russia = BAD terms. While of course I agree the details are obviously a lot more nuanced).

elizabethdraper · 25/02/2022 12:05

Why have they taken Chernobyl

Think about the damage they can do to the whole of european with that one site
It is absolutely terrifying

bumblingbovine49 · 25/02/2022 12:02

@Thewindwhispers

Putin has little interest in Britain and does not want a big war. Putin does however want to be remembered in the history books as the man who recreates the Soviet Union (and preferably also who made Russia the top superpower).

So, Putin has a problem. Many ex Soviet states are now in Nato and if/when he attacks them, he has to deal with all the Nato countries. This makes Putin very angry. (Bit like if Scotland declared independence, then joined the EU, and Britain wanted it back but didn’t want war with the whole EU.) So Putin has devotedbyears to weakening America and Europe: his fingerprints were all over Trump, Farage etc. Now post-covid he reckons Wurope and US are as weak as they’re gonna get so he has invaded Ukraine before it joins Nato, which it has been saying it wants to do.

Bombs will not land in Britain over Ukraine. You might see some retaliatory cyber attacks but let’s face it they do a lot of that anyway - our elections, our vaccine research, etc.

The much more dangerous issue is what happens if/when Putin goes after the countries that are now Nato members: Albania, Romania etc. Bit shocked Britain has vowed to go to war with Russia if needed to protect Albania but there we are.

And the very serious question is: has Putin still got all his marbles?

I was going to post a question asking how people would feel about the UK getting involved in a war if Russia invades a neighbouring country that is in NATO. I think there would be quite a few people unhappy with this, saying that it is nothing to do with us. I'm not of that opinion, as if you are in NATO that is the agreement. You can't choose which members you are willing to help defend , otherwise NATO is meaningless ( which I fully accept might be the case of course)

I desperately don't want Putin to invade a NATO country and I am very doubtful this will happen but if he does, then yes the UK would be in direct danger. I think that is a big IF though and as things stand we are not in any direct danger I'd say

RedToothBrush · 25/02/2022 12:02

@Ereshkigalangcleg

A proper cyber attack would be as bad as physical warfare. It’s just different. Just as bad, but different.

Yes, I'm not denying that, but my point was more that if we can't cyber attack to the same degree we might then have to do more physical stuff which would inflame Russia even more. We wouldn't be able to do nothing except react to what Russia did to us.

Your computer, power networks and communications systems are down.

How do you launch the nuke? How do you make the decision to launch the nuke? How do you ensure that the cabinet and Parliament are well informed? And your various defence departments elsewhere in the country.

Whilst these things are likely to be defended, just how well are they defended? And what things outside military control that are also needed to support the launch are vulnerable?

Remember before launching its physical attack in Ukraine, Russia launched a massive cyber attack first to try and knock out some of these things and make it more difficult for Ukraine to fight back.

So this is a legitimate question. It may not have as much impact as this, but you certainly would hamper the PM simply by producing a crisis elsewhere which he needed to deal with urgently simultaneously.

The thing with hybrid warefare is how it creates multiple crisis at the same time in an effort to overwhelm.

Its the overwhelming that compounds any single issue.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 25/02/2022 12:01

It is concerning, but as I can do zero about it on a personal level I'm just going to get out a reasonably small amount in cash, make sure we have some non perishables in the cupboard, and keep calm and carry on. And not click on any dodgy links.

BuddhaForMary · 25/02/2022 12:01

Nothing wrong with having an understanding of what might happen, but some posters seem to relish setting out worst case scenarios.

Indeed. It's like the covid boards all over again with know it all's talking about possibilities as if they're probabilities.

TheSnowyOwl · 25/02/2022 11:56

@Ereshkigalangcleg

A proper cyber attack would be as bad as physical warfare. It’s just different. Just as bad, but different.

Yes, I'm not denying that, but my point was more that if we can't cyber attack to the same degree we might then have to do more physical stuff which would inflame Russia even more. We wouldn't be able to do nothing except react to what Russia did to us.

I see what you mean and yes, maybe, although I think we would try other tactics first such as Russia being so reliant upon $ and £ to impact them financially. Is it 50% of their financial trading that is in £/$? If so, that’s a lot. Europe have € so couldn’t do the same but they could still support in other ways. Basically though, if Russia attacks us then that will invoke NATO and it will be war with a large enough number of countries to be considered another world war.
TheSnowyOwl · 25/02/2022 11:52

@Dinosaurs1994

Is Putin threatening the USA in the same way he is us? I'm avoiding the news at the minute before anybody suggests I look it up
From my understanding, he is threatening the rest of the world. It’s not specific to the U.K.
Ereshkigalangcleg · 25/02/2022 11:52

A proper cyber attack would be as bad as physical warfare. It’s just different. Just as bad, but different.

Yes, I'm not denying that, but my point was more that if we can't cyber attack to the same degree we might then have to do more physical stuff which would inflame Russia even more. We wouldn't be able to do nothing except react to what Russia did to us.