Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is the UK in danger from Russia?

614 replies

hereforalongtimenotagoodtime · 24/02/2022 21:58

Keep receiving conflicting information. I am sick to my stomach and quite simply hate the unknown. So a simple question - is it likely that the UK will be in danger from Russia? And if so what does that look like? Cyber attacks, bombs being dropped?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
youhadmeatjello · 28/02/2022 22:32

@Lia198 sympathy it’s hideous isn’t it. We were watching a film tonight and I was looking around the room trying to work out what furniture we could use to put up against the windows and patio doors in the event of a nuclear strike. I can’t tell the rational from the irrational at the moment - usually I can managed my anxiety as I can recognise the irrational thoughts but right now it’s hard as everyone seems pretty anxious.

I’m having a cup of herbal tea and trying to get an early night instead of doom scrolling all night. I’m feeling very guilty about bringing DS into this world too, I love him more than life itself but what is happening in the world right now is beyond bleak.
I think I need to remember that although this is a scary situation a lot of my physical reaction and constant dread is down to my anxiety diagnosis.

Lia198 · 28/02/2022 21:22

@youhadmeatjello

Im very much struggling today (I have generalised anxiety disorder) but can’t stay away from the news. Trying not to panic but it just seems to get worse and worse and I’m struggling to see any positives or hope. Some of these posts and the ones on the invasion threads are helping keep me somewhat balanced though. Mainly I’m terrified for toddler DS. I am so devastated for the parents and children of Ukraine and every time I see footage or pictures I imagine it being DS. I’ve donated and am also sorting out childrens clothes that the Red Cross is asking for in our area to be sent over. Just feel so helpless and like it’s getting more likely that something (even more) drastic will happen but I can’t trust my own very anxious mind at the moment.
I also have generalised anxiety disorder (that I was finally doing quite well in managing) and this whole thing has made me feel really ill. I feel guilty for bringing children into this horrible world. I don’t know how to make myself relax, I feel on edge 24/7 Although some of the rational comments on here def do help give me some comfort (thank you).
Libraryghost · 28/02/2022 21:19

The ogliarchs and the Russian mafia will bring Putin down. Their villas and handbags are being threatened. Nobody loves their luxury goods as much as the Russians, except perhaps those vulgar Dubai wankers. A criminal will sort Putin out then Russia will descend back into the days of the 1990s. A power struggle and mafia wars.

Libraryghost · 28/02/2022 21:15

So many appeasers on Mumsnet. It embarrassing, worried about upsetting Putin because they think it will make things worse. Go back to basics, what do you tell your kids? You stand up to a bully because it will only get worse if you don't. Putin is a bully and trying not to upset him is as stupid as trying to be nice to the Yorkshire ripper and hoping he won't stick a hammer in your head. I hope Boris appears on telly and threatens to stick a rocket launcher up Putins arse. For anyone who thinks appeasement works, have a read about Hitler and 'peace in our time'

Notanotherwindow · 28/02/2022 21:05

If Boris keeps making threats then it's highly likely we will be nuked.

It is NOT highly likely we will be nuked. For starters we would retaliate swiftly and even if we were somehow unable to, Russia would then have America to contend with who would retaliate on our behalf.

He won't strike first against a NATO country. Its literally suicide. He's batshit crazy but he's not stupid. If it went nuclear there is no version where Russia walks away.

user1481055867 · 28/02/2022 20:58

@hereforalongtimenotagoodtime

I was watching russian speaking independent channel "Дождь" yes one exists and member of Russian duma was going through how Britain they refer to it as "Туманный альбион/Foggy albion" was always an enemy going back when Geroge the V didnt help Romanovs escape yet kept the gold, to Liz Truss - who he also thought talks a lot of bs to Boris Johnson.I dont think they will nuke, but Putin is insane now and nobody in his circle dare to oppose him.He is humiliated by failure to capture Kiev in 3 days and growing desperate.Only powerful oligarchs can stop him as they are speaking up against the war openly, which is punishable in Russia, means they are not afraid and will be willing to act.

Chocolattay · 28/02/2022 20:54

He’s never seen it before but has always been meaning to. Of course he has to put it on now 🙄

HighlandCowbag · 28/02/2022 20:46

Fucking hell, Threads is awful. I watched it in year 7 many years ago, just before the 87 storm, thought the button had been pressed. Then covered it again last year for uni, in lockdown.

I definitely won't be watching it anytime soon Shock.

The whole situation is a fucking shit show, as much as I feel sorry for Ukraine,selfishly I am praying the EU doesn't let them join, I can't see how that would be less inflammatory than joining NATO.

Shuuu · 28/02/2022 20:39

@youhadmeatjello

Im very much struggling today (I have generalised anxiety disorder) but can’t stay away from the news. Trying not to panic but it just seems to get worse and worse and I’m struggling to see any positives or hope. Some of these posts and the ones on the invasion threads are helping keep me somewhat balanced though. Mainly I’m terrified for toddler DS. I am so devastated for the parents and children of Ukraine and every time I see footage or pictures I imagine it being DS. I’ve donated and am also sorting out childrens clothes that the Red Cross is asking for in our area to be sent over. Just feel so helpless and like it’s getting more likely that something (even more) drastic will happen but I can’t trust my own very anxious mind at the moment.
This ^^ I’m terrified too but bounce between “he won’t to “he will” Sad
Chocolattay · 28/02/2022 20:31

This whole thing has made DH finally get around to watching Threads, he’s brought it on Amazon and is watching it as we speak. I’ve had to leave the room.

youhadmeatjello · 28/02/2022 20:16

Im very much struggling today (I have generalised anxiety disorder) but can’t stay away from the news. Trying not to panic but it just seems to get worse and worse and I’m struggling to see any positives or hope.
Some of these posts and the ones on the invasion threads are helping keep me somewhat balanced though.
Mainly I’m terrified for toddler DS. I am so devastated for the parents and children of Ukraine and every time I see footage or pictures I imagine it being DS. I’ve donated and am also sorting out childrens clothes that the Red Cross is asking for in our area to be sent over.
Just feel so helpless and like it’s getting more likely that something (even more) drastic will happen but I can’t trust my own very anxious mind at the moment.

RoseRedRoseBlue · 28/02/2022 18:56

@marieantoinehairnet I am happy to tell, you that she shouldn’t STFU. We have to stand up to these barbaric acts.

Whammyyammy · 28/02/2022 15:05

@RedToothBrush

It is so very unlikely to happen that it is not worth wasting energy worrying about it.

I think more to the point, if it happens there's really fuck all you are going to be able to do to protect yourself anyway.

You either die in it or survive and face utter chaos and panic or die in the aftermath.

Not sure I much fancy any of those options tbh.

This I don't think it will happen. Both the U.S and Russia have circa 4500 nuclear war heads each, then add what warheads are in the Eu/uk to that total. If nukes were launched, there would not be a planet left.🤷‍♂️
marieantoinehairnet · 28/02/2022 12:43

Now tell me Liz Truss shouldn't STFU!!

"There had been statements by various representatives at various levels about possible conflict situations and even collisions and clashes between Nato and the Russian Federation," said Dmitry Peskov, spokesman for Vladimir Putin.
"We consider such statements absolutely unacceptable. I will not name the authors of these statements, although it was the British foreign secretary."
It's not clear which comments by Truss the Russian government objects to, although on Sunday she said she would support individuals from the UK joining an international force to fight for Ukraine.

HelpMeHiveMind · 28/02/2022 06:40

@WingingThis are you able to summarise yesterday's Ukrainecast about nukes? I was interested but don't really get on with podcasts, prefer to read.

Wingingthis · 28/02/2022 06:27

BBC have a daily podcast called Ukrainecast (I listen on the apple podcast app) which I find brilliant. They discuss and explain everything that has happened that day

HesterAndPearlInBrightSunshine · 27/02/2022 22:16

Lets call it the Gambling Man Scenario rather than the Mad Man Scenario we are used to. I think this is the one we perhaps need to be most wary about, rather than an out and out suicide strike.

^^ This.
Putin is a keen chess player.

Ciaram55 · 27/02/2022 21:36

One thing I'm clinging on to is that Putin is well known to like the finer things in life....luxury villas, yachts etc. Is he willing to lose all that, which he surely will if he went nuclear?

RedToothBrush · 27/02/2022 20:46

@HelpMeHiveMind

By saying this *@RedToothBrush*, do you imply it's more likely he'd go for either a non Nato country or one without nuclear capability themselves e.g. he wouldn't attack one of those with nukes because of M.A.D? As you say in a later post, that does depend whether he's selling it as "If I go down, you're dead anyway so you may as well take these guys down with us"? OR if he's gone all ISIS style and believes he's purging the world of the evil of NATO...in which case, surely sacrificing themselves in the process would be a better necessary evil than existing alongside us?
I can see a scenario potentially arising which is probably our worst case one. But it could also be the route to a face saving exercise.

The principle of 'The Nuclear Deterrant' only works if your enemy truly believes you are willing to see your intention to fire back.

The principle of the Nuclear Deterrant originated at a time when only the Americans and the Soviets had nukes and the world was largely divided neatly in two between Pro-American and Pro-Communist groupings. Thats not true now and perhaps is a lot more complex - not least because more countries have nukes.

When the US got the Atomic Bomb, the point was it HAD to be used to illustrate the willingness to use it and the destructive force of it. They had to produce 'The Fear'. Thats the true power of nukes - not how many people they can blow up in a single blast.

We assume that anyone firing a preemptive strike is a madman hell bent on destroying the world. There is now a question hanging over whether Putin could be that madman. I personally don't really buy that.

What if there is another possibility here too though?

I pose the question: Putin believes the West is weak. Does this mean that he thinks, that if he uses a nuke against a third party target, the West will definitely respond?

What is the situation if you have someone who doesn't believe that NATO will have the stomach to actually see it through in third party situation?

What if you ultimately though that you chuck a nuke, to prove how serious you were and thus how powerful you are, gambling that the opposition wouldn't chuck one back?

Lets call it the Gambling Man Scenario rather than the Mad Man Scenario we are used to. I think this is the one we perhaps need to be most wary about, rather than an out and out suicide strike.

He will know that if he launches and fails to pull it off all if lost. But if he does the rewards might be there as you redefine the balance of world power. So might think its worth it if he really does think he could play his cards like this and win.

Putin went into Ukraine on a gamble because he arrogantly thought he could win quickly and with little cost; he over estimated his power. He also underestimated the West's response. A lot of this is down to his bunker mentality and him being out of touch with reality as its been distorted by yes men.

This is a dangerous situation because it may also mean he is willing to take a gamble if he thinks there's a chance NATO will blink. Which doesn't have to be a reality - NATO may absoluetly not hesitate if a third party was nuked - Key point: he just has to believe this is the case.

I do think given this growing rhetoric there may be noises which stress the NATO position to try and disspell this. This will sound REALLY scary to the likes of us. But may be needed to close this third party idea about NATO blinking. It will also resonate back in Russia within the context of Putin's pretext...

Equally that could ultimately go too far, or Putin does decide to go suicidal and frames this as an act of aggressive so he has to go preemptive. But this is the extreme end of the scale of posibilities. There are many more in between. Don't overstate third party concerns.

The whole point of this constructed situation is about brinkmanship and trying to get the other to blink first especially if the ground attacks are still faltering and the economic crisis and public reaction is BAD. I'm guessing a certain amount of damage limitation going on regardless. Putin's philosphy has always been to turn a crisis into an opportunity to take advantage of. It could solidify his position back home, if he plays it right.

If this nuke talk does get ramped up increasingly over the next few days, its really not to be unexpected. Its likely to be something Putin has identified as a potential weakness and inevitability will try to exploit it - because he's not got too many cards in his hands right now, even if he has absoluetely no intension of following it through. Which obviously is going to push anxieties on here and elsewhere in NATO countries though the roof. (Its kind of the point)

And he has to do some serious performance acting to try and save face domestically - and to look like he is indeed 'standing up to NATO aggression'. (Thus a contrived Mexican Stand off might be what he's after - obviously with those sanctions on the table).

I think the tone of things will ramp up over the next few days - and get even scarier and giving everyone brown pants - again I stress I don't think this is a certainity and it still doesn't mean anything is likely to happen. Think Cuban Missile Crisis Type Moment.

Keep this in mind: in so many crisis, there needs to be an exit strategy available whereby a wounded party can exit without too much loss of face. Look out for them.

I would suggest in this context that trapping some of the Oligarchs in London rather than allowing them to travel home to potentially talk Putin down off the ceiling if thats where he's clinging, might not be the greatest idea if I'm honest.

The ultimate point here, is both parties have to be on the same page with nukes no matter what and that both really feel there is really nothing to be gained from going down that route.

Sit tight, hold your breathe and try not to panic. (Easier said than done, I know!)

DrHildegardeLanstrom · 27/02/2022 17:17

I came here looking for sense from @RedToothBrush - thank you!

Trainbear · 27/02/2022 17:15

@Valhalla17

If Boris keeps making threats then it's highly likely we will be nuked.
Put. Down. The. Glue.
illyawasthebest · 27/02/2022 17:11

@RedToothBrush I've followed your posts in brexit and feminism over the years and wanted to say thank you for being such a regular and wonderful poster here. I always value your input. Thanks

HelpMeHiveMind · 27/02/2022 17:11

By saying this @RedToothBrush, do you imply it's more likely he'd go for either a non Nato country or one without nuclear capability themselves e.g. he wouldn't attack one of those with nukes because of M.A.D? As you say in a later post, that does depend whether he's selling it as "If I go down, you're dead anyway so you may as well take these guys down with us"? OR if he's gone all ISIS style and believes he's purging the world of the evil of NATO...in which case, surely sacrificing themselves in the process would be a better necessary evil than existing alongside us?

GallopingHighRoad · 27/02/2022 16:48

Good post @RedToothBrush

Question everything. Everything.

MrsLargeEmbodied · 27/02/2022 16:37

thank you so much @RedToothBrush

i totally appreciate your time and your comments, as i am sure many others do

Swipe left for the next trending thread