Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Identity politics in secondary school

153 replies

OrchidCarer · 24/02/2022 21:25

Please be gentle because I’m trying to work out how I feel about this issue.

I have 3 boys at secondary school. A new Head started in September. Since then I’ve noticed the school has increased the amount of teaching time given over to identity politics.

For example:

  • Students have special science lessons on LGBTQ+ Scientists. Surely they shouldn’t be recognised for their sexuality but for their achievements? Why is their sexuality even relevant to their job?
  • Every subject studies load of ‘Black History’ type subjects – so far my Y9 kid has studied slavery, the slave trade, the Windrush generation this year. This is in history, geography, English. These are presented in a way that makes all black people victims and all white people oppressors. The kids pick up on this and their friendship groups form around race (school is about 30% black, 65% white, 5% other ethnicities).
  • Assemblies all the time about how women are downtrodden, oppressed, victims and men are the aggressors, perpetrators. Female dominated classes with a female teacher discussing the patriarchy and similar themes.

I am uncomfortable about all of this division. We are all just human. There is a big difference between educating about past prejudice and forcing stereotypes on kids now.

Concerns

  • White straight boys are never in the oppressed group, so are constantly told they are the bad guys. My sons have given up trying to prove everyone wrong – the narrative against them is too strong. My eldest rails at home about the unfairness of it all, how he’s depressed, he can’t do right because he’s a straight white guy, he just wants to go and fight in Ukraine where he’ll be allowed to be a man, doesn’t care if he dies. It’s exhausting to deal with.
  • Push towards the far right. If you watch slightly right-wing content, algorithms recommend more. There is a danger that disenchanted boys will turn for comfort to online creators who exploit their anger and encourage sexist, racist and homophobic attitudes.
  • Where is the evidence that these interventions make the ‘oppressed’ groups feel supported?
  • Women, queer people, and people of colour need allies. We are all on the same side, in the end, and this divisive approach is having the opposite effect to the one intended.

There is a real taboo about saying these things. I raised the LGBTQ+ scientists question and got a dramatically long and patronising lecture in an email back again as though I was the bad guy.

Maybe I am being unreasonable?

Is there anything that I can do or do I just have to watch it all unfold?

OP posts:
Elsiebear90 · 24/02/2022 22:03

There’s a lot to unpick there, but why is it a problem to teach kids about LGBT scientists in a way which shows they are LGBT? I’m gay and sexuality was not discussed at all when I went to school which led me to believe it was wrong and a taboo, so the school is clearly trying to show kids positive LGBT role models and normalise it, I don’t see what’s wrong with that?

You can’t just say “we’re all human, so why do we need to talk about race/sexuality/gender?” because that’s not reality, people have and do suffer because they’re not straight white males and being a fellow human matters not one bit.

If your sons feel uncomfortable with being taught how straight white males have dominated, harassed, brutalised etc women and marginalised groups then good, that’s the point.

Iggly · 24/02/2022 21:56

These are presented in a way that makes all black people victims and all white people oppressors

Well I’m not sure how else you would present slavery….. or Windrush.

It’s uncomfortable because it touches on the fact that people were treated in a certain way because of the colour their skin, as simple as that.

That’s a very painful difficult thing to understand. Some end up pretty defensive about it and see it as an attack on them. When really, the purpose of teaching should be to learn lessons from our history.
In terms of the push to the far right, the best you can do is to disrupt what they’re watching on YouTube etc to mess with the algorithms. Limit the time on YouTube/social media if you can. Keep talking to them.

HelloCrocus · 24/02/2022 21:52

I don't think you're being unreasonable, and I was following your argument with general agreement, until you confused me by saying "women, queer people and people of colour need allies. We are all on the same side in the end"... Isn't this the divisiveness that you then criticise in the same paragraph? Or have I misread you? It sounded there like you do think it's everyone Vs the straight white men? What side are we all on? E.g. are the "queer people" necessarily on the same side as a devout Pakistani Muslim (say) but not on the same side as their white male colleagues?

(There is a term for that called the Global Majority gaining ground... Or "the GM" for short. It basically means everyone who is not the mythic evil straight white man, as far as I can make out. Actually, correction, it only refers to race, i.e. not white. I've actually only ever heard it said with a straight face by a middle-class white man who was essentially taking advantage of it as a marketing opportunity. I find it reductive and patronising, while it also manages to be white- and Western-centric...)

Anyway, it doesn't really matter what I think about all that - I'm rambling. What does matter is that identity politics is political (clue's in the name), therefore should not be taught uncritically in schools.

I also agree that an evidence base should be used and developed for any interventions like this. It's hard, as evidence-gathering comes under political attack too. E.g. the Sewell report, attacked because it didn't paint all minorities as victims. And all the flat-earthism of gender ideology. It's hard to discuss this stuff rationally sometimes because some professionals have absorbed it not just as one possible world view, but as a moral imperative. Like the email you received. Perhaps an in-person meeting might be more effective (picking your battles, obviously), and focus on evidence and critical thinking and freedom of thought, since it's supposed to be a place for education? Best of luck.

Swipe left for the next trending thread