Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

WWYD? We're landlords

192 replies

Woahthehorsey · 24/02/2022 20:20

To stop the derailing of another thread, I thought I would post separately.

DH and his brother inherited a house a few years ago. The plan was to sell it, split the funds and go separate ways. SIL was living in the house (she had been relatives carer, had inherited savings from relative and planned to buy so was staying whilst she bought).

BIL dragged his feet during the sale until it turned out that he'd got a secured loan on the property which he was now defaulting on and the house was going to be repossessed. The sale couldn't go through until the loan was repaid - because it wasn't a mortgage, it couldn't be repaid following the sale, and had to be repaid prior.

During this time SIL was diagnosed with cancer, which was terminal and she was unable to buy her house. To prevent DSIL needing to move out on her death bed, DH and I secured a mortgage and repaid BILs loan. BIL retained 50% ownership due to the legalities. It was a residential mortgage with permission to let because a family member was living in it. We were really really lucky to get the mortgage as the house is "non-standard construction".

DSIL died and we prepared to sell the house. Because the house is no standard, it's virtually unmortgagable (not completely so, but so much so it's really difficult) so is worth about half a brick built house it. Because of this, BIL realised he wouldn't get any money from the sale, as it wouldn't fully repay the mortgage so has refused to allow the sale. We're currently seeking legal advice, covid delayed it.

To repay the mortgage we got tenants in. BIL has legal rights to some of the rent, which he takes. The rent doesn't cover the mortgage and we also pay tax on it. We lose about £200 per month, which has been manageable so far.

Due to the mortgage situation and the construction we can't remortgage and the initial rate has expired and we are on a variable rate. This has now increased due to inflation/ all that shit and we're now losing between £300-400 per month. This is unsustainable. It's putting us financially in a really difficult place. We have a good income but high housing costs plus 2 kids in childcare. Much more and we're going to start getting in debt.

On the other thread I've been called some awful names for considering putting the rent up, but I don't see another option. Currently the rent is low for the area and rents generally have recently gone up in the area. We've not put the rent up in the 2.5years they've been there.

Options as we see it:

  1. put rent up more inline with local rents. Tenant keeps tenancy, we don't go further in to debt. Continue the legal route with BIL.
  2. evict tenants, pay full mortgage ourselves for a bit and hope loss of income encourages DBIL to sell.
  3. increase mortgage on our house, buy BIL out at half current value, evict tenant, sell ASAP. We've tried to do this before but couldn't raise enough, we've had payrises since though.
  4. default on mortgage, let property be repossessed, let bank kick tenants out.
  5. (Poster on other threads preferred option) continue to lose money on the house but keep the rent low, risk getting in to very very significant debt, risk our own house/ security of our children.

Final option is evict tenants, get self build mortgage, raze property, build new house, sell. BIL wants to do this but we can't afford it and BIL is unable to get a mortgage. So it's a none starter.

So which option would you do?

OP posts:
Speakuptomakeyourselfheard · 24/02/2022 23:57

OP lots of people have asked why you continue to pay half of the rent to your BIL, but I don't think you've answered, just said that he's entitled to half, but bearing in mind that he's played dirty throughout all this, and is continuing to do so, why make his life easy, while he's making yours as difficult as possible? You've also been asked who the rent is paid to, again, no answer, how can you ask for advice if you don't answer questions? Tell him he get's his share of the rent, once the house is sold but for the time being you need it to pay the mortgage, and if he won't play ball with that, you'll hand the keys back and he'll get sweet F.A! Seems to me you've got to start playing hard ball. It's all very well to be taking legal action, but I don't think any court in the land would say that you have to pay him half the rent without first deducting costs.

Ericaequites · 24/02/2022 23:38

Put rent up to market rates, after telling BIL and talking to tenants. Offer to let them move out if they can’t afford new rent. If they move out, follow as for 3. Maintain insurance on the house until the day of closing. Owning property with siblings can be hell.

newbiename · 24/02/2022 23:37

@mumda

Sell it. Nothing else makes sense.
Really 🙄 ?
1Dandelion1 · 24/02/2022 23:35

Its not unreasonable or unfair to increase rent to the market rate, the tenant has a choice they can stay or move on.

Not a legal expert, but I also think that you should not be passing half the rent to BIL, it should be half the profit after mortgage and costs are deducted. By the sounds of it his solicitor isn't going to be forthcoming in taking action against you.

Woahthehorsey · 24/02/2022 23:35

@mumda

Sell it. Nothing else makes sense.
Have you read the thread at all 🤣 we want to sell, we've tried to sell, we are seeking legal rights to try again!
OP posts:
mumda · 24/02/2022 23:32

Sell it.
Nothing else makes sense.

milkyaqua · 24/02/2022 23:26

God, what a nightmare.

On the other thread I've been called some awful names for considering putting the rent up, but I don't see another option. Currently the rent is low for the area and rents generally have recently gone up in the area. We've not put the rent up in the 2.5years they've been there.

Options as we see it:
(1. put rent up more inline with local rents. Tenant keeps tenancy, we don't go further in to debt. Continue the legal route with BIL.
2. evict tenants, pay full mortgage ourselves for a bit and hope loss of income encourages DBIL to sell.

I would explain the need to raise the rent in line with local rents to the tenants, giving them the option to stay at the raised rent - or not.

When I was renting, I would have appreciated that option, rather than having to pack up and move.

Good luck with all the rest. So stressful.

VanGoghsDog · 24/02/2022 23:26

Stop giving money to BIL. Set aside the money you were giving him.

He's highly unlikely to sue you (he can't afford it). But, if he does, you have the money set aside anyway.

And definitely put the rent to a market rent. If the tenants leave you will find new ones (especially if you allow pets).

Zilla1 · 24/02/2022 23:24

@Island35 I think you are getting closer but perhaps some nuance required if it would unjustly enrich the BIL unless the OP has the highest of ethical standards.

FacebookPhotos · 24/02/2022 23:24

Building regulations absolutely do exist to keep people inside buildings safe. Where a building construction is sufficiently unusual as to be difficult to mortgage there is often (though not always) a risk of the property being unsafe to live in. Because often (though not always) things which present a financial risk to a home also present a safety risk.

I never said anything about “current” building regs because I know (having worked in the field) that there is no requirement to improve a building to meet current standards unless major renovation is being done. Only a very small proportion of buildings meet current building regs. The vast majority are still mortgageable.

I advised the OP to check insurance policies in case the non standard construction affects the payout and may leave her, and her family, liable for any injuries caused by the construction. Given the OP is confident the property is safe and properly insured that’s fine.

Cherryblossoms85 · 24/02/2022 23:22

Do whatever fucks over your awful BIL the most.

ChampagneLassie · 24/02/2022 23:20

1 & 3. Nothing wrong with charging market rate rent. Explain to tenants give them option, aware they may move out and you might also have to find new tenants.

Lineofconcepcion · 24/02/2022 23:17

@FacebookPhotos

Tbh I just can’t believe you’re renting out a property which doesn’t meet standard building regulations. Do the tenants know that?

Standard construction (using ordinary building regulations) exists to keep the occupiers of the property safe. Are you insured against the “non standard construction” causing injury to the tenants or their guests?

If I were you I’d issue an eviction notice to the tenants and apply to the court to force a sale. And check you’re properly insured.

Houses of non standard construction exist all over the country and there are no increased risks to the tenant.

Just so everyone is clear, there is no 'handing the keys back'. The ops liability does not end there. They can be pursued for any monies outstanding after the mortgage company has repossessed and sold the property, including all costs associated with it. If the sale of the property does not cover the expense, and it probably won't, they can put a charge on your other property and attempt an order for sale on that one so it's not an option.

The bil should be paid the rent net of all expenses. What you are doing is ridiculous, why would he negotiate its a win win for him.

Also there is no limit on the amount of times you can increase the rent, if it is with agreement of the tenant. You are only limited to 1 increase per year if you use a s13.

To be honest op, you don't seem to know what you're doing. You need a robust landlord and tenant solicitor or direct access barrister who can unpick it all and also deal with the application of order for sale.

Gonnagetgoing · 24/02/2022 23:17

@Xenia

Get solicitors to obtain a court order to for the BIL to agree to the sale and sell it at auction ASAP.
Definitely do this.
Holskey · 24/02/2022 23:16

Bloody hell. Judge Rinder?

Island35 · 24/02/2022 23:16

OP, so sorry to hear you're in this position. Would an option be to get planning permission for a new building and then market with the permission? Flatten the building so you sell a plot? Not sure how much those things cost? Alternatively, whilst nobody wants their rent to go up, you can't maintain this position and an honest conversation with your tenants about the rent increase is the only way forward.

Ddot · 24/02/2022 23:14

Dont pay him, put the money he supposed to receive in an account. What can he do, take you to court, not likely. If he does you have that cash to one side, he can then explain why he thinks you should pay for everything. Put the rent up, sorry but you have to, market value only.

Bells3032 · 24/02/2022 23:12

Also put rents up to market value. You're not a charity. The people in these forums are redic that they think landlords should go bankrupt and lose their homes rather than heaven forbid increase rents. It's redic. This is a capatalist country. You need to take care of your family first not total strangers.

TiddyTidTwo · 24/02/2022 23:07

Hmm I'd be looking deeper into that previous loan company. Police might be interested but they must have been regulated at the time? FCA or FOS might be a course of action. Long shot perhaps though.

I'm sorry your BIL is behaving like this. You are limited with the property being non standard.

If it were me I would put the rent up and not pay BIL anything. What will he do?? Force a sale?

Bells3032 · 24/02/2022 23:06

Why is bil being paid the rent before expenses are taken out??

We own properties with others and all of them the expenses are held back Inc mortageges and profit paid out from what's left...

Id start doing this immediately and if he disagrees he can take you to court.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 24/02/2022 23:05

I would not be giving BIL any of the rent until the loan was paid off - I have no idea why you are giving him half the rent?
Let him take you to court!

Surely this is the obvious solution?

He owes this money, so of course he should forfeit his 'share' until he's paid off what he owes. There's no moral issue for you there in the slightest.

Legally, if he wanted to chance his arm anyway, to get what is not rightfully his, firstly, he would have to pay the legal charges, which it sounds like he doesn't have the funds for at all; secondly, if he did take you to court, you would be able to state your case and force into the spotlight his fraudulently-obtained loan, which forced you into your current position.

Stop gifting him any more of your money under his ruse that it's 'his share'.

As for him 'not getting any money' from the sale of the house, hence his reluctance to sell, he will very much get his share: it's just that, as his current balance is negative, his share will take it back up towards zero - but relief from debts is every bit as much 'getting your share' as those who have no debts and thus end up with a credit balance after their share.

Zilla1 · 24/02/2022 23:04

I suspected as such, OP, just wanted to reply so that you weren't accused unfairly of being an evil landlord jeopardising the safety of your tenants if that wasn't the case.

It sounds like you have a lot on and have tried to do your best in what sounds like challenging circumstances and unconscionable behaviour by your BIL.

Would you need BIL's agreement to sell the house or just need to give him half the proceeds after clearing the mortgage?

Good luck.

NumberTheory · 24/02/2022 23:03

@FacebookPhotos

Tbh I just can’t believe you’re renting out a property which doesn’t meet standard building regulations. Do the tenants know that?

Standard construction (using ordinary building regulations) exists to keep the occupiers of the property safe. Are you insured against the “non standard construction” causing injury to the tenants or their guests?

If I were you I’d issue an eviction notice to the tenants and apply to the court to force a sale. And check you’re properly insured.

Very few houses meet current building regulations because they change continuously. Hardly anyone in the country would be able to afford housing if it had to be continuously updated to meet building regulations everytime they changed.

"Standard construction" doesn't exist to keep occupiers safe. It's merely what is customary and known to the financial system so they can more easily quantify their financial risk.

RedToothBrush · 24/02/2022 23:02

So he's not paying his share on the upkeep of the property? Document, and bill him.

To whom is the rent paid? Your DH who then repays your BIL or both your DH and BIL. If its your DH alone you are being far too charitable. Take out his bills from the rent you are getting directly.

I doubt that legally he can say he's owed it, if you can demonstrate that the money is going on expensives on the property. You only get profit AFTER you've paid your expenses.

If you've fully documented this, it undoubtably be harder for him to challenge - especially as he's already defaulting on his legal expenses. He would need to go legal to challenge you, and I think you can make an assumption that he won't.

If this reduces what he's getting from the rent, its less worth his while. Indeed if he's playing silly buggers with his own legal fees, you could try and call his bluff and withhold the rent completely. If he already can't pay his legal bills, how does he go legal on you?

This might give you the leverage you need to either cover all the losses you are making OR force him to finally give it up and sell the property.

It might bit of a gamble to play, but it could force his hand.

I think your strong hand here, is that he looks like he's in financial trouble too. Its his weakness, and if your DH is the sole landlord on paper or in terms of the financial arrangements, thats your strength.

Woahthehorsey · 24/02/2022 23:02

@JustLyra

It reads as straightforward, but having tried to do it, it isn't.

It is a straightforward process.

If you have the same legal guidance as you did when you mortgaged to pay off his debt I’d advise you to change. Order of sale is a straightforward process.

We'll try again.
OP posts: