Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

WWYD? We're landlords

192 replies

Woahthehorsey · 24/02/2022 20:20

To stop the derailing of another thread, I thought I would post separately.

DH and his brother inherited a house a few years ago. The plan was to sell it, split the funds and go separate ways. SIL was living in the house (she had been relatives carer, had inherited savings from relative and planned to buy so was staying whilst she bought).

BIL dragged his feet during the sale until it turned out that he'd got a secured loan on the property which he was now defaulting on and the house was going to be repossessed. The sale couldn't go through until the loan was repaid - because it wasn't a mortgage, it couldn't be repaid following the sale, and had to be repaid prior.

During this time SIL was diagnosed with cancer, which was terminal and she was unable to buy her house. To prevent DSIL needing to move out on her death bed, DH and I secured a mortgage and repaid BILs loan. BIL retained 50% ownership due to the legalities. It was a residential mortgage with permission to let because a family member was living in it. We were really really lucky to get the mortgage as the house is "non-standard construction".

DSIL died and we prepared to sell the house. Because the house is no standard, it's virtually unmortgagable (not completely so, but so much so it's really difficult) so is worth about half a brick built house it. Because of this, BIL realised he wouldn't get any money from the sale, as it wouldn't fully repay the mortgage so has refused to allow the sale. We're currently seeking legal advice, covid delayed it.

To repay the mortgage we got tenants in. BIL has legal rights to some of the rent, which he takes. The rent doesn't cover the mortgage and we also pay tax on it. We lose about £200 per month, which has been manageable so far.

Due to the mortgage situation and the construction we can't remortgage and the initial rate has expired and we are on a variable rate. This has now increased due to inflation/ all that shit and we're now losing between £300-400 per month. This is unsustainable. It's putting us financially in a really difficult place. We have a good income but high housing costs plus 2 kids in childcare. Much more and we're going to start getting in debt.

On the other thread I've been called some awful names for considering putting the rent up, but I don't see another option. Currently the rent is low for the area and rents generally have recently gone up in the area. We've not put the rent up in the 2.5years they've been there.

Options as we see it:

  1. put rent up more inline with local rents. Tenant keeps tenancy, we don't go further in to debt. Continue the legal route with BIL.
  2. evict tenants, pay full mortgage ourselves for a bit and hope loss of income encourages DBIL to sell.
  3. increase mortgage on our house, buy BIL out at half current value, evict tenant, sell ASAP. We've tried to do this before but couldn't raise enough, we've had payrises since though.
  4. default on mortgage, let property be repossessed, let bank kick tenants out.
  5. (Poster on other threads preferred option) continue to lose money on the house but keep the rent low, risk getting in to very very significant debt, risk our own house/ security of our children.

Final option is evict tenants, get self build mortgage, raze property, build new house, sell. BIL wants to do this but we can't afford it and BIL is unable to get a mortgage. So it's a none starter.

So which option would you do?

OP posts:
Myalternate · 25/02/2022 09:02

As your BIL has an interest in the property, surely he must also be party to the mortgage you've taken on?

BIL may be legally entitled to 50% of the rent payments but only after expenses have been accounted for.

Mummyoflittledragon · 25/02/2022 08:57

@RedToothBrush

I know people have commented to the contrary. However are they sure of the legalities and qualified to know that would stand in court?

If he's not paying expenses it damn well would.

True. He should only have ever been given the income minus all expenses : repairs, gas and electric safety checks, installations of smoke and co2 monitors, referencing fees, cleaning and so forth. That’s normal.

As he hasn’t paid expenses, op’s dh should and could immediately retrospectively charge him for his 50% share for the duration of the current tenancy as a minimum - possibly more difficult for when sil was alive. That would give them a lot of breathing space for now and free up some cash to fight him to a) get their money back and b) force a sale.

brainhurts · 25/02/2022 08:51

I would put the rent up while trying to force sale.
Can you keep BIL part of the rent , let him chase you for it ? He owes you so reverse it and you owe him .

doradoo · 25/02/2022 08:35

Can you do 3 - buy BIL out, then look at getting planning permission for something and sell as a building / development opportunity?

RedToothBrush · 25/02/2022 08:22

I know people have commented to the contrary. However are they sure of the legalities and qualified to know that would stand in court?

If he's not paying expenses it damn well would.

Heronwatcher · 25/02/2022 07:57

Good grief. Whatever you do don’t sink any more money into this. Yes put the rent up and for goodness sake get your BIL to start paying you back with his “share” either by threatening something like an attachment of earnings order or getting him declared bankrupt (obviously take legal advice on this but you can do the majority of the work yourself). No way would I be handing rent over to him in this situation.

HopelesslydevotedtoGu · 25/02/2022 06:35

Why did you rent it out below market rate, out of interest? Just wondering if there is a factor that makes it less desirable to tenants, hence the lower rent.

I would stop paying bIL half the rent. If he wants to pursue you for it he will have to pay his solicitors bill for starters.

I would raise the rent. You are far from the stereotypical bad landlord, raising the rent just because and enjoying yet another foreign holiday. You literally can't sell at the moment and can't afford not to raise the rent. Whilst I have sympathy for your tenants, I wouldn't get into debt for them, for a situation not of your making.

As a landlord you also need to have savings to fund any repairs in a timely manner. If the boiler goes you need to be able to afford to get it fixed quickly. It doesn't work if you are losing money every month.

A consideration is whether your tenants can afford it. if they can't how quickly can they move out and you find new tenants. Can you stretch to afford a brief empty period between tenants and any essential redecorating and repairs required in between?

For this reason I would increase the rent sooner rather than later, as if your current tenants can't afford an increase you may have some expenditure before you can get new higher paying tenants in. Don't wait until your finances are in crisis to do this.

Mummyoflittledragon · 25/02/2022 06:06

Until op gets proper legal advice and representation, as it stands today legally her dh has to give his brother 50% of the income. Until the fraudulently obtained loan situation is addressed, the mortgage is op’s dh’s debt and issue. Albeit not factual but from a legal standpoint, he profited from receiving the mortgage money and it is his responsibility to pay that out of the rent and the remaining portion by other means.

I know people have commented to the contrary. However are they sure of the legalities and qualified to know that would stand in court? This is why people are urging op to find specialist representation. These type of lawyers will have the answers and if they don’t, they will not waste their client’s time and money and will draft in a barrister for a couple of hours to provide them.

Charley50 · 25/02/2022 05:54

As others have said, why are you paying him any rent when you are losing money every month?

Mummyoflittledragon · 25/02/2022 04:34

I’m a ll. i keep my long term tenants under market rent. But I would put the rent up in this situation. It is self-preservation.

Have you asked the mortgage company if they will allow you to change to interest only? If they refuse, you could try asking for a 3 month payment holiday although that’s not ideal as the interest will continue to rack up.

I agree with others that you need a specialist solicitor. Someone, who can advise you on how to pursue your bil for the money, help you figure out if you can keep the rent and force a sale. You’ll also need advice from another solicitor to pursue your bil and the company for the fraudulent loan. It doesn’t matter that it folded as you say it’s been taken over by another company. If you contact a large law firm in your area, they should be able to help and sign post you.

hellithurt · 25/02/2022 03:57

Increase the rent, you're not a charity and it's financially crippling you.

Valeriekat · 25/02/2022 03:20

Get a better lawyer?
This really shows that no good deed goes unpunished.

Bickles · 25/02/2022 03:15

Obviously put the rent up. I’m a landlord too and would always be advised by my letting agent as to the going rate for rent and stick to it. It’s a business.

expat101 · 25/02/2022 03:05

If I read this correctly, your DH is the Landlord on the tenancy agreement... ?

If I have understood this correctly, then change the bank details for where the rent is paid to, so it all comes to DH's separate new account. House outgoings also come from this account.

Transparency.

That will force BIL's hand very quickly to initiate the matter in Court or grant settlement.

Having said all that, I'm at a loss if your BIL undertook some sort of fraud to obtain funds using the house as security, why you/DH have bailed him out.

This occurred in our family too, and it was a matter for the correct dept of the police force to handle the problem as well as legal action against the bank who gave family member the loan in the first instance, on the basis the bank did not undertake due diligence before giving family members the funds. I can assure you the Bank put the heavies on, and some of it went public, before they signed off on a confidential agreement and settled the matter with other family members who had been indirectly involved...

The family member may yet still serve time as they left for o/s.

ParisLondonTokyoSlough · 25/02/2022 02:41

@GrettaGreen

Can you stop all monies in rent to him and spend it instead on getting your solicitor to stall and string everything out for the next while? The double whammy on his pocket from no rent and an escalating bill from his solicitor could put him over a barrel where he has to sell because he won't be able to afford to continue defending his ridiculous position with solicitors with a hefty bill that he can't pay. Even if you should technically be paying that rent, it'll cost him money he doesn't have to fight it.
Completely agree with this. There’s literally no benefit to paying the rent money before you have an actual legal order to do so. Normally you would do it to maintain a good relationship and avoid litigation but sounds like that ship has long sailed.
nettie434 · 25/02/2022 02:40

I'd go with option 1. It's not unreasonable to put rent up in line with the local rates. If the tenants decide to leave then you can switch to the option of paying the mortgage, hoping that the lack of rent will persuade BIL to sell.

I might be wrong here but if you defaulted on the mortgage wouldn't it affect your ability to remortgage/move to a different property?

Even assuming you could get enough money to buy out BIL, it is unlikely he would agree to a realistic amount of money.

The worst option of all would be to go down the self build route. BIL clearly has a very unrealistic view of the property's value and has the morals of a ferret so you could be dragged into even more protracted problems.

I agree with the posters who suggest you need a solicitor who is experienced in this sort of situation. At some point no solicitor will act for your BIL when it becomes clear they won't be paid. What do the mortgage company say?

ParisLondonTokyoSlough · 25/02/2022 02:39

Stop paying him the rent and let him sue you for it, and when he does, counterclaim for the loan owed to be paid of against rent monies.

I can’t believe you’re still transferring him the rent money. Just start treating him like he treats you and let him go through legal routes for his rent money- which would give you the opportunity to seek a legal order in respect of the loan.

GrettaGreen · 25/02/2022 02:28

Can you stop all monies in rent to him and spend it instead on getting your solicitor to stall and string everything out for the next while? The double whammy on his pocket from no rent and an escalating bill from his solicitor could put him over a barrel where he has to sell because he won't be able to afford to continue defending his ridiculous position with solicitors with a hefty bill that he can't pay. Even if you should technically be paying that rent, it'll cost him money he doesn't have to fight it.

Nat6999 · 25/02/2022 01:35

Is it one of those concrete cancer houses? I would put the rent up to market value & then get all rent paid to you to pay the mortgage. No way should BIL be allowed 50% of any sale value, you paid off his loan. Take out an interest only mortgage to pay the repayment one you currently have on the house & keep a record of how much you repay, BIL is only entitled to 50% - amount you paid off his loan, if you are feeling generous include 50% of the rent. Go down the legal route.

SleepingStandingUp · 25/02/2022 01:06

I say this as a tenant but if your rent is below market value and your rent doesn't cover your costs, you put the rent up towards market rent. If your tenants can't afford market rent for your area unfortunately that isn't your problem.

Spacecadetagain · 25/02/2022 00:42

@FacebookPhotos- non standard construction is a term used to describe a property which has been built from materials other than a standard brick , this includes most houses which were built quickly after the war to combat the housing crisis and were essentially pre built in factories using concrete blocks , the houses were then erected on site using steel joists . These houses were originally only intended to last 25 years but of course most are still standing . They aren’t mortgageable because it’s considered that the houses will ultimately suffer structural damage due to degeneration of the steel/concrete mix but many are still standing with no issues over sixty years later . I live in a non standard construction property , cash purchase only and. Structural surveys show my house is still perfectly sound .
OP it sounds a nightmare for you - It’s a shame the we police won’t investigate your BIL as the loan was fraudulent, no decent loan company would have given him a loan secured on a property that was NSC and that he didn’t fully own - so just to clarify , you re mortgaged your own home to pay off HIS debt ? If so , you owe him nothing , put your tenants rent up (as much as is reasonable) and do not hand him over any rent money , what ever he still owes you Id have put as a charge on the house so he can’t get it in the sale .
Sack your solicitor and either get a better one or alternatively file your own notice to sell to the court

MindTheGapMoveAlong · 25/02/2022 00:34

Yiou need to get a decent private client/probate solicitor. Surely the fact that BIL has already effectively ‘spent’ his share of the inheritance (apparently fraudulently by securing funds on a property which he didn’t actually own) needs to be set against his original entitlement via a deed of variation?

JustLyra · 25/02/2022 00:08

You’re making it far too complicated.

Stop paying him rent until expenses are covered.

Get the order of sale (you don’t even need solicitors for that - and you certainly don’t need to negotiate with his).

Then sell.

If it’s not going to be easy to sell with tenants in situ give them notice. If it’s likely to sell to another landlord don’t.

RedToothBrush · 25/02/2022 00:07

@Speakuptomakeyourselfheard

OP lots of people have asked why you continue to pay half of the rent to your BIL, but I don't think you've answered, just said that he's entitled to half, but bearing in mind that he's played dirty throughout all this, and is continuing to do so, why make his life easy, while he's making yours as difficult as possible? You've also been asked who the rent is paid to, again, no answer, how can you ask for advice if you don't answer questions? Tell him he get's his share of the rent, once the house is sold but for the time being you need it to pay the mortgage, and if he won't play ball with that, you'll hand the keys back and he'll get sweet F.A! Seems to me you've got to start playing hard ball. It's all very well to be taking legal action, but I don't think any court in the land would say that you have to pay him half the rent without first deducting costs.
Indeed.

Op has been back after several people asked this, with no comment.

I almost get a sense of op being too nice or too stupid or simply wanting to play the role of the martyr when the most obvious leverage to force the BILs hand is there.

I also think the OP has either had poor legal advice, misunderstood legal advice or just ignored it in order to be nice.

Except the OP literally can not afford to be nice.

Strikes me Op and husband need to find some balls and be proactive and financially aggressive rather than be passive doormats in this. The brother bullies and the husband just rolls over.

I do wonder whethee thats been the dynamic in the relationship since childhood. The people pleaser who can't understand why people are sometimes just need challenging.

tkwal · 25/02/2022 00:00

How did he get the secured loan ? The house has never been in his sole possession so who signed the application form ? Is it possible he forged a signature (criminal act) if so he's guilty of fraud. Which because you and your DH are thoroughly decent people you are enabling him to profit from. I would seek legal advice and point out to the BIL that you're not going to sub him any more