Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

WWYD? We're landlords

192 replies

Woahthehorsey · 24/02/2022 20:20

To stop the derailing of another thread, I thought I would post separately.

DH and his brother inherited a house a few years ago. The plan was to sell it, split the funds and go separate ways. SIL was living in the house (she had been relatives carer, had inherited savings from relative and planned to buy so was staying whilst she bought).

BIL dragged his feet during the sale until it turned out that he'd got a secured loan on the property which he was now defaulting on and the house was going to be repossessed. The sale couldn't go through until the loan was repaid - because it wasn't a mortgage, it couldn't be repaid following the sale, and had to be repaid prior.

During this time SIL was diagnosed with cancer, which was terminal and she was unable to buy her house. To prevent DSIL needing to move out on her death bed, DH and I secured a mortgage and repaid BILs loan. BIL retained 50% ownership due to the legalities. It was a residential mortgage with permission to let because a family member was living in it. We were really really lucky to get the mortgage as the house is "non-standard construction".

DSIL died and we prepared to sell the house. Because the house is no standard, it's virtually unmortgagable (not completely so, but so much so it's really difficult) so is worth about half a brick built house it. Because of this, BIL realised he wouldn't get any money from the sale, as it wouldn't fully repay the mortgage so has refused to allow the sale. We're currently seeking legal advice, covid delayed it.

To repay the mortgage we got tenants in. BIL has legal rights to some of the rent, which he takes. The rent doesn't cover the mortgage and we also pay tax on it. We lose about £200 per month, which has been manageable so far.

Due to the mortgage situation and the construction we can't remortgage and the initial rate has expired and we are on a variable rate. This has now increased due to inflation/ all that shit and we're now losing between £300-400 per month. This is unsustainable. It's putting us financially in a really difficult place. We have a good income but high housing costs plus 2 kids in childcare. Much more and we're going to start getting in debt.

On the other thread I've been called some awful names for considering putting the rent up, but I don't see another option. Currently the rent is low for the area and rents generally have recently gone up in the area. We've not put the rent up in the 2.5years they've been there.

Options as we see it:

  1. put rent up more inline with local rents. Tenant keeps tenancy, we don't go further in to debt. Continue the legal route with BIL.
  2. evict tenants, pay full mortgage ourselves for a bit and hope loss of income encourages DBIL to sell.
  3. increase mortgage on our house, buy BIL out at half current value, evict tenant, sell ASAP. We've tried to do this before but couldn't raise enough, we've had payrises since though.
  4. default on mortgage, let property be repossessed, let bank kick tenants out.
  5. (Poster on other threads preferred option) continue to lose money on the house but keep the rent low, risk getting in to very very significant debt, risk our own house/ security of our children.

Final option is evict tenants, get self build mortgage, raze property, build new house, sell. BIL wants to do this but we can't afford it and BIL is unable to get a mortgage. So it's a none starter.

So which option would you do?

OP posts:
Woahthehorsey · 25/02/2022 19:49

@Lineofconcepcion

Op some of the stuff on here is so wrong. Why don't you ask to transfer this to Legal, there are a few lawyers on there who give sound advice.
I'm not really asking for legal advice - I'm paying for that! I'm just venting/ asking what others would do.
OP posts:
Woahthehorsey · 25/02/2022 19:48

@brainhurts

Thanks for cleaning it up , I still don't understand why BIL is entitled to rent . Surely he only gets his share of rent after the mortgage is paid . How quick do you realistically think a sale would take if you terminate the lease
To get rid of it we'd probably take it to auction, so it'd be 4 weeks.

Re why he gets rent, read my response above. Basically it's like a business having to pay employee's salary regardless of whether it makes profit or not.

OP posts:
Woahthehorsey · 25/02/2022 19:41

A solicitor advised you to take out a mortgage on a property that your BIL had placed an illegal loan on

I didn't say that. I said we got a solicitor to draw up a document so we didn't have to pay BIL half the sale amount.

And he has already taken us to court to stop the sale and challenge the force of sale.

EddieLizzard the mortgage is in DHs name, therefore is DHs expense. We can't legally take DHs expenses out of BIL rent. The rent that is paid to DH and BIL (to a letting agent) is separate to any expenses. So let's say we pay to fix the boiler, we can bill BIL for half, but have to take him to court for none payment and a court order to take it out of rent owned to him.

Anyway, I've spoken with tenant today and drafted the new contract. I felt awful but they were actually really understanding. I obviously didn't go in to detail. We've agreed it'll come into effect from their April payment, so 2 month's notice and if they changed their minds and moved out before that it was obviously fine.

OP posts:
SueblueNZ · 25/02/2022 19:40

@bluedodecagon
You are a very nasty person.

brainhurts · 25/02/2022 19:36

Stop paying BIL his part of the rent , you have already said you think he can't afford his solicitor so how will he get the money from you .
Put the rent up so it covers the mortgage, it will at least give you financial security.

bluedodecagon · 25/02/2022 18:00

Complete nonsense. A solicitor advised you to take out a mortgage on a property that your BIL had placed an illegal loan on in order to stop your SIL from having to move out though she would have been dead soon anyway?

Sure they did.

More likely your DH (who seems pretty weak and pathetic from this telling) came up with this ridiculous idea and you went along with it.

Put up the rent if you like but it makes no difference. If the tenants leave you could easily get a set of tenants who won’t pay then what will you do? Can you afford to receive no rent for the eight months or more that it will take to actually evict someone? You are playing with fire here.

I suggest instead of seeing yourself as some sort of benevolent overlord you see yourself as what you are: one (more) poor decision away from losing everything. You are not doing your tenants a favour, they have all the power.

Also stop giving your BIL the rent. He’d have to take you to court for it. FFS, what is wrong with your husband? He’s useless.

Eddielizzard · 25/02/2022 17:48

I agree - I don't understand why he gets share of rent before mortgage paid. Is that because mortgage is in your name?

bettybadger · 25/02/2022 17:31

How is BIL being paid the rent money?

Cherrysoup · 25/02/2022 17:28

2 or 3. Just remember you can’t increase rent more than a certain amount for current tenants. Your bill is a wanker.

brainhurts · 25/02/2022 17:12

Thanks for cleaning it up , I still don't understand why BIL is entitled to rent . Surely he only gets his share of rent after the mortgage is paid .
How quick do you realistically think a sale would take if you terminate the lease

Woahthehorsey · 25/02/2022 17:04

@brainhurts

Why do you have to give BIL half of the rent ? Surely his share should be after expenses. Can you hand the property over to the mortgage company ? I'm thinking you might be better off trying to walk away
We can, BUT it's entire possible that the sale by the mortgage company wouldn't cover the costs they incur plus the mortgage left. And we would be liable for the gap. Which would place our home I jeopardy. Plus it would seriously impact DHs credit rating and we may be unable to remortgage our own home.
OP posts:
brainhurts · 25/02/2022 17:00

Why do you have to give BIL half of the rent ? Surely his share should be after expenses.
Can you hand the property over to the mortgage company ?
I'm thinking you might be better off trying to walk away

Woahthehorsey · 25/02/2022 16:52

@bluedodecagon

Sorry but your decision making throughout has been really poor. Speak to a solicitor and TAKE THEIR ADVICE.

no solicitor could have advised you to take out a loan for your brother initially. Or to give tenants lower than market average rent and refuse to raise it.

Why do you keep making such poor financial decisions? Just get proper legal advice and follow it this time.

When we took out the mortgage we got a solicitor to write up that BIL would only get half of any profit after the mortgage, fees etc had been settled. BIL then refused to agree to sell because there was going to be no profit. We got a court order, but BIL fought it which has taken time.

When we started renting out the house it wasn't below market rent particularly - it was the local housing allowance rent, which is 90% of the average rent. Rents have gone up the LHA rate hasn't. Because we were fixed term for a period it didn't matter so much as our mortgage didn't go up and they've been good tenants. The rents in the local area have shot up in the last 9- 12 months. They've only been on a periodic for about 5 months. When they didn't ask to renew another year we thought they were planning to move so thought we'd put the rent up for the next one's if we got any.

We've followed all legal advice received and changed solicitor.

OP posts:
bluedodecagon · 25/02/2022 13:21

Sorry but your decision making throughout has been really poor. Speak to a solicitor and TAKE THEIR ADVICE.

no solicitor could have advised you to take out a loan for your brother initially. Or to give tenants lower than market average rent and refuse to raise it.

Why do you keep making such poor financial decisions? Just get proper legal advice and follow it this time.

RincewindsHat · 25/02/2022 12:55

Your BIL is a real piece of work. You repaid his loan on the house, and he is still taking rent even though you're paying the mortgage? Selfish asshole does not begin to cover it.

Option 1 is probably the safest for you.

Re 2: would BIL agree to a sale following loss of income or would he happily just take out more loans against the house and leave you and your DH in the hole so long as he's lining his own pocket?

Hate to say it, but you are going to have to figure out how to exert considerable pressure on him and quickly, or the greedy self-serving bastard is not going to budge on this.

LottyD32 · 25/02/2022 12:40

Options as we see it:

  1. put rent up more inline with local rents. Tenant keeps tenancy, we don't go further in to debt. Continue the legal route with BIL.
  2. evict tenants, pay full mortgage ourselves for a bit and hope loss of income encourages DBIL to sell.
  3. increase mortgage on our house, buy BIL out at half current value, evict tenant, sell ASAP. We've tried to do this before but couldn't raise enough, we've had payrises since though.
  4. default on mortgage, let property be repossessed, let bank kick tenants out.
  5. (Poster on other threads preferred option) continue to lose money on the house but keep the rent low, risk getting in to very very significant debt, risk our own house/ security of our children.

Final option is evict tenants, get self build mortgage, raze property, build new house, sell. BIL wants to do this but we can't afford it and BIL is unable to get a mortgage. So it's a none starter.

So which option would you do?

Option 1.
🤣🤣🤣🤣 for option 5.

Lineofconcepcion · 25/02/2022 12:22

Op some of the stuff on here is so wrong. Why don't you ask to transfer this to Legal, there are a few lawyers on there who give sound advice.

NettleTea · 25/02/2022 10:23

or alternatively offer to cover the mortgage to pay him the equity (50% of current value, less the mortgage still owing)

dont forget to account for the amount of mortgage that YOU have paid off too - he still owes you that.

Do not give him another penny of rent.

Buy him out and build your dream home on it - or apply for planning and sell it afterwards.

NettleTea · 25/02/2022 10:21
  1. Put rent up.
  2. put a charge against property equal to the BILs original fraudulent loan that was teaken out
  3. keep all the rent - if the mortgage is paying his loan, he either needs to cover that from his ''share' of the rent - and I mean ALL of it. Keep track of how much has been paid off, because thats what needs to be deducted from final 'share' of house
  1. Once house is sold, dont forget to take off the mortgage from his 50%. If that leaves him with nothing, then so be it - he has already had his share when the loan came out PLUS he got to live there rent free with SIL
  2. carry on with legal route to force a sale.
saleorbouy · 25/02/2022 09:55

Apply for planning permission to demolish the house and have plans approved for a new dwelling(s).
Sell it as a plot with planning approval to maximise you gains.
Fund the planning application yourself and deduct this from the sale price with your loan repayment for BIL before splitting the remaining money 50/50.

RedToothBrush · 25/02/2022 09:24

@hibbledibble

Why is BIL getting any income in rent, if the rent does not cover the mortgage? Surely he should only be getting a share of profits, if there is one.

I think you need to do 1, as a first step, so you aren't losing further money.

There's this. Its a joint property, if he's had a loan he has taken from joint asset. If you have then taken a mortgage on said joint asset even if hes not named, its an expense of the joint asset. He may not be named but if you default he loses his asset. So to keep the asset, i do think you could argue that the management of the finances of the joint asset requires expenses are taken out, which includes repayment of mortgage. You can't get rent from a property you no longer own because you have defaulted on the mortgage for.

He either contributes to the mess he created or he settles up his expenses and debt to you. Thats by agreeing to the sale.

I really think bad legal advice has been given here and I really think you have helped to make this situation much worse than it should be.

MorningStarling · 25/02/2022 09:15

I think all the suggestions to stop paying half the rent to the BIL are unhelpful. He owns half the property, he's entitled to half the rent and he's entitled to half the profit when the property is sold.

He took out a loan on the property which has since been paid off by the OP taking out a mortgage. Does the OP have a contract with the BIL to say that he agrees to repay that money or have it deducted from the value of his share? If not, that's the end of the matter, the BIL owns half the house and the OP is liable for the mortgage they took out.

AnotherForumUser · 25/02/2022 09:14

@FacebookPhotos

Tbh I just can’t believe you’re renting out a property which doesn’t meet standard building regulations. Do the tenants know that?

Standard construction (using ordinary building regulations) exists to keep the occupiers of the property safe. Are you insured against the “non standard construction” causing injury to the tenants or their guests?

If I were you I’d issue an eviction notice to the tenants and apply to the court to force a sale. And check you’re properly insured.

Do some fucking research before you spout yer shite. Non standard construction includes timber framed houses and prefabs.
MRex · 25/02/2022 09:13
  1. Buy out BIL and then you decide what option works best for you regarding the house. That might be putting up the rent, or getting new tenants, or knocking it down, or selling. Whatever, at least you are back in control. Good luck.
hibbledibble · 25/02/2022 09:04

Why is BIL getting any income in rent, if the rent does not cover the mortgage? Surely he should only be getting a share of profits, if there is one.

I think you need to do 1, as a first step, so you aren't losing further money.