Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not let DS6 watch 12 rated films

67 replies

MrsMillhouse · 24/02/2022 18:40

DS6 goes to after school and breakfast club.

They ask parents to sign a permission slip to allow kids to watch 12 rated films. DH and I haven’t signed it as we are a bit worried they might scare him.

It turns out that most of his wee pals parents have signed the form and they can watch 12 rated films.

Are we being too strict?

OP posts:
Babyfg · 25/02/2022 00:02

I wasn't allowed to show a pg in my year one class (fundraising where the class project was to create a cinema and raise funds with tickets and snacks). We are only allowed to show a pg film for educational purposes with parental permission. It's quite shocking they would consider showing the class a 12 rated film

Kite22 · 24/02/2022 23:34

@TabithaHazel

If you trust the after school club to look after your kid then you should trust them to choose appropriate films. If you don't trust them you shouldn't be sending your child there in the first place.
Firstly, ASC isn't something there usually is a choice about - you go to the one at your school. You can't 'shop about', and if you work and no CMers locally have spaces, then that is it. However anyone providing a professional childcare service should not be suggesting doing any activity that is not recommended for children of the age they are looking after. Yes, we should be able to trust an after school club to make sound decisions, but it seems in this case they have proved that they are not able to make sensible choices, so therefore it is right that any parent challenges them on it.
Kerrie21 · 24/02/2022 22:58

You've just made me realise, my nursery showed my (and other) 3 year olds a PG movie with no parent consent.

ldontWanna · 24/02/2022 22:48

What is the film?

What's the exact set up of the ASC? Is it on school premises? Is it manned by school staff or an external provider? Are the kids mixed ages(reception to y6)? Is this a one off or a regular thing? Who picked the movie?

TabithaHazel · 24/02/2022 22:45

If you trust the after school club to look after your kid then you should trust them to choose appropriate films. If you don't trust them you shouldn't be sending your child there in the first place.

SmallestInTheClass · 24/02/2022 22:43

At 9 or 10 and watching at home with parents around, I'd be OK with it, but there's no reason at all to need this in childcare. It's very unreasonable for them to think it is OK. I'd approach the school governors (I'm a governor and would take something like this very seriously).

Bakewelltart987 · 24/02/2022 22:39

@MrsMillhouse

I think the only 12 films that they actually watch are Harry Potter films (which, I’ve never seen!)
Harry potter films are scary for little dc the first 1 is fine and a pg I think, my dd 6 can watch that but no others.
NellWilsonsWhiteHair · 24/02/2022 22:03

Yanbu. 6 is young. They're being ridiculous.

My 10yo is OK with Harry Potter (he wouldn't have been at 6 though) but even now I wouldn't sign off on a generic 'can watch 12-rated films' permission slip. It's a case by case basis IMO, which is why it might work at home but not in a childcare setting!

MaChienEstUnDick · 24/02/2022 21:58

I think you should do more than not sign the form, I think you should raise it formally with the ASC. My DS watched a Potter film that he was too young for (completely my fault, we were at a friend's house and I didn't realise the film's rating) - he got very scared, swore off HP and has literally never looked at a HP book or film since.

It's also massively easier to hold the line on all sorts of age-rated things if you are always consistent. Children ask for a lot of things through the years and it's soooooo much easier if they know the first words out of your mouth are going to be 'what's the age rating? And are you that age, hmmm?'

There's NO need for a childcare setting to be showing non-age appropriate films. It means that DCs like yours will be ostracised, everyone will have a harder job parenting, and fgs, it's a childcare setting, they kind of need to be following the rules! I'd complain and I'm not one of life's complainers.

AlabamaWorleyyy · 24/02/2022 21:52

Also, on the point about being ostracised from his peers…. what?! At 6 years old?! Surely adults have to protect children and make decisions on their behalf at this age, not just go along with the majority! It’s different when they’re 14, but not at 6!

Kite22 · 24/02/2022 21:35

@Bagelsandbrie

I think the difficulty is that if everyone else has said yes and you say no you might ostracise him from his peers. I’d just go with it personally.
The point is, they shouldn't be asking.

What is the point in them even having a rating on films if professional childcarers think they can just ignore them.

Of course YANBU. I would not only not sign, but I would take it up with the management as to what they were thinking in even suggesting it, partly for the reasons Bagels has pointed out, that there will be some parents who just sign it without even thinking about how many dc will be upset by being shown films that aren't suitable for them, but partly through what on earth they are thinking about.

labyrinthlaziness · 24/02/2022 21:31

This is really weird, I would not sign and tbh would lose confidence in the setting.

There are loads offline PG films.

Who runs the club? I'd complain to the provider.

Bunnycat101 · 24/02/2022 21:27

No I wouldn’t allow it for mine. I’d also be sending an email to the governors asking if they were ok with it. The provider has to be mindful of the youngest ones in their care and that does not include 12 certificate films.

AlabamaWorleyyy · 24/02/2022 21:24

If they’re watching 12s when they’re 6 then what will be they be watching by the time they’re 12?! I thought I was a bit lax letting my 10 year old watch 12s! No way should a school setting be doing this!

RightOnTheEdge · 24/02/2022 21:22

I let my kids watch 12 films they are 9 and 10 but my ds9 has been watching Marvel films for a while which are mostly 12a so I'm not super strict but I know that they would be fine with the films and not be scared.

I think though that YANBU.
A setting like that should be sticking to the rules. As PPs have said there are loads of U and PG films they could watch and 6 is still very young and no where near 12 obviously.
It's very inappropriate!

EdithRea · 24/02/2022 21:21

Not at all, that's totally unreasonable. There are plenty of films to show a little 6 year old without showing them 12s. I'd be reconsidering the club if they're that bloody thick.

There's no need to show little children 12s; the higher rated HP films have it because there are deaths, visible injuries and ever-present threat. They're not for 6 year olds. 12 rated films can include at least one F-work, references to sexual assault and quite intense levels of violence so long as there is no blood. The adult Batman films are 12s.

Lou98 · 24/02/2022 21:19

I would imagine it will be the likes of the marvel movies which are mostly 12's I'm sure.

Personally, I would be okay with it as I would trust that they're picking suitable films for the age group.
However, obviously what's classed as suitable differs for everyone so if you're not comfortable then don't sign it

PeacefulPrune · 24/02/2022 21:15

I'm shocked that they are even asking that. Why would they want to risk upsetting a bunch of kids?

ThanksItHasPockets · 24/02/2022 21:12

@BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz

Aren't most 12 movies produced in the last decade 12a? Which means suitable for under 12s at parental discretion?
12A is only used in cinemas. Films which were 12A in the cinema will be a 12 for DVD / release.
Ericaequites · 24/02/2022 21:12

My sister took me to see Annie Hall at 7. All the sex went over my head, but Diane Keaton entranced me. I still like butch women.
Most 12 or American PG13 films are highly unsuitable for kids. Only U films are suitable. I wasn’t allowed to see PG movies as a twelve year old. My mother was very annoyed when a slumber party at fourteen featured the first Police Academy, an R film the supervising parents approved.

Averyproperteaparty · 24/02/2022 21:11

@MrsMillhouse

I think the only 12 films that they actually watch are Harry Potter films (which, I’ve never seen!)
They’re quite dark for a 6 year old.
Bobbybobbins · 24/02/2022 21:10

I think you are right not to sign it. As pps have said there are tons of U or PG films out there!

MrsMillhouse · 24/02/2022 21:09

He’s definitely not allowed call of duty or fortnight

OP posts:
RandomDent · 24/02/2022 21:01

You’re allowed one F-bomb in a 12.
These will be the same parents who don’t see the harm in underage WhatsApp accounts or Call of Duty.

mattcockhand · 24/02/2022 21:00

no way are you being too strict. is it a primary school asc so they are targetting the older kids? ther3 are plenty of PG films that are suitable .