Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Government stuffing young people again, student loans

404 replies

Binjob118 · 24/02/2022 17:38

Great day to bury the news that from next year student loans will be repayed over 40 years instead of 30. This makes a massive difference. Hate this government and Tony bloody Blair for stopping free tuition. Of course, won't affect all the rich kids who never take out the loan. This on top of impossibility of young people ever being able to buy a home makes me want to scream. Totally screwed. Certainly don't think IABU!!

OP posts:
Kazzyhoward · 25/02/2022 15:48

@Alexandra2001

So why is the student loan interest rate so high? Surely the Govt don't want to be making money out of our students?

Typical redistribution by stealth. Those who make the repayments subsidise those who don't.

worriedatthemoment · 25/02/2022 15:40

@Alexandra2001 yes people don't get RPI , funny how the government don't use that when looking at public sector pay or benefits
Clearly some read and full for the goverment bullshit of how much fairer this will be and how much it will save taxpayers , etc

worriedatthemoment · 25/02/2022 15:38

@worriedmum2022 not everyone has a local uni and its not students faults the courses are 3 years , many many work alongside uni and in the holidays so there not all dossing around as you put it and not everyone can put aside the child benefit a fair system
Would be better for all rather than everyone criticising students and not looking at the bigger picture

Alexandra2001 · 25/02/2022 15:10

And in that vein, these changes are welcome because the interest will only be RPI, not RPI+3

RPI is always the higher figure and is way over the bank rate or what the Govt borrows at... which is where the money is coming from.

So why is the student loan interest rate so high? Surely the Govt don't want to be making money out of our students?

worriedmum2022 · 25/02/2022 15:09

I'm just saving all the child benefit now and trying to top it up so I'm saving £100-150 per month probably won't be enough but it's a good start

I'll also be telling mine that as they actually spend so little time in university they can go to a local university and live at home and there will be an expectation to have a part time job - not dosa around for 3 years when to be honest it could be done in 2 years!!! Saving people a fortune

worriedatthemoment · 25/02/2022 15:08

@Alexandra2001 its amazing that people can't see this isn't it
I don't think many are saying it should be totally free , just fair

worriedatthemoment · 25/02/2022 15:07

@DottyHarmer plenty of graduates also get jobs better paid ones than nmw like hotels etc
Infact many low paid industries like hospitality rely in students as a good percentage of the workforce as do leisure industries etc

Alexandra2001 · 25/02/2022 15:06

But should a student pay for their own uni education. Yes. They should

If the loan its self was repaid, then sure but they charge interest rates way over commercial loan terms, so as this is compounded, few students can ever repay.

We also have very large skills shortages in this country, from health to science to teaching, these aren't on the whole, high paying jobs, so if you want students to pay back for their education, pls don't complain when you can't get an operation or your kids are in a class of 50 or medical test results take months to get done.

Very short sighted policy.

worriedatthemoment · 25/02/2022 15:03

@DottyHarmer so is what the other poster said untrue as that is quite different to what you put
And pretty sure you have to pass here to stay on the course
Mn in general re: agenda as often you get a poster say in xxx they do this then someone who lives there calls it out

DottyHarmer · 25/02/2022 14:56

@worriedatthemoment - I hope you’re not posting about me: I have absolutely no agenda Confused

DottyHarmer · 25/02/2022 14:55

But there is the pyramid structure whereby loads start and few finish. If you don’t present yourself for enough exams you leave. That is how the “lawyers” are whittled down so you don’t have untold numbers graduating.

Incidentally being an “educated graduate” doesn’t mean any more in Italy than it does here. You’re still scrabbling round for a job in a hotel or sitting in your childhood bedroom at 38 asking Mamma what’s for dinner.

worriedatthemoment · 25/02/2022 14:54

@Geamhradh thanks for clarifying the actual truth its funny how people post something about other countries to suit their agenda as they don't expect someone to come along and call it out

worriedatthemoment · 25/02/2022 14:53

@TrueBuys and teachers , police officers , nurses , paramedics etc yes all useless careers, lets see if you can live without them all

Geamhradh · 25/02/2022 14:43

[quote DottyHarmer]@Fernhurst - European degrees are very different. Italy, for example, has a pyramid structure; if you don’t pass the first year (and many don’t) you’re off the course. No cuddly diddums I can’t manage excuses (and the institution wanting to keep all the fee paying students no matter how crap they are).[/quote]
It's actually the opposite. In Italy you can usually stay at university as long as you like, as long as you keep paying the annual taxes. Students can take their exams generally as often as they want and when they want. It's not unusual for people to stay at university repeating exams over and over until they are well into their thirties. It's only universities with scholarships, or where you have to pass specific entrance tests to get in where you could "fail". Most universities however don't operate like that and are "open" literally to everyone who wants to go, they only need to have finished high school. Most law degrees are like that- it's another anomaly, in Italy, if you're not that brilliant or don't really know what to study, you do law. So you get the situation whereby when courses start in October, or November in some cases each lecture will have 600 kids. By Christmas that will be down to 300 and so on. Not because they've failed, just dropped out. Attendance isn't compulsory a lot of the time. Lots of students only go into university to do the exams. Never bother the rest of the time.
Things are changing a bit and more and more courses are becoming "closed numbers" with commensurate expectations of attendance and exams completed promptly, but they're still not going to kick people out while they keep paying to be there.

solbunny · 25/02/2022 14:41

@TrueBuys

University education is not necessary other than for a few careers. Doctors, dentists etc will be unaffected by this. Those affected will probably be doing pointless courses which never result in a decent salary. Why should everyone else subsidise pointless degrees?
What a truly miserable way to view education and life in general Sad
worriedatthemoment · 25/02/2022 14:36

@DdraigGoch rpi but not the same They use to calculate benefit changes etc , no the one that can go up more, thats still a lot of interest

worriedatthemoment · 25/02/2022 14:35

@InMySpareTime many can't grasp on here plus they also are less likely to be getting universal credit top ups etc as well so all in all could be costing the tax payer money
But the government just say that only 45% pay or whatever and x amount of millions is not paid back without all the finer details considered
Prob be fair to say that all that go even if on benefits or low income should pay something even £5 a month rather than nothing forever .
But to word it the way the goverment do makes it sound like many go and never pay a penny

DdraigGoch · 25/02/2022 14:33

@InMySpareTime

Most of the people who don't pay off their student loan actually pay back more than they borrowed, what they can never pay back is the compounded interest accrued on the loan. It's not that they're lounging about doing a couple of hours a week to avoid paying anything at all. The vast majority of students make payments on their student loan at some point, but there's a world of difference between paying nothing and paying it all.
And in that vein, these changes are welcome because the interest will only be RPI, not RPI+3.
worriedatthemoment · 25/02/2022 14:31

@Whammyyammy yes but why is it so high in the first place and why insist that jobs like teachers , police , nurses , paramedics etc need degrees when they will likely never pay enough to be able to pay the loan plus interest back apart from a few that go to the top and have no time off to have kids etc

InMySpareTime · 25/02/2022 14:31

Most of the people who don't pay off their student loan actually pay back more than they borrowed, what they can never pay back is the compounded interest accrued on the loan. It's not that they're lounging about doing a couple of hours a week to avoid paying anything at all.
The vast majority of students make payments on their student loan at some point, but there's a world of difference between paying nothing and paying it all.

worriedatthemoment · 25/02/2022 14:29

@Brieandcamembert but they prob are a lot paying back what was borrowed but not all the interest added which is high
Or we could make fees cheaper so not as much needs to be borrowed in the first place
There are other ways to do this

Whammyyammy · 25/02/2022 14:29

I think the clue is in the title. Its a loan, and needs to be payed back. Extending this period is a good start

Brieandcamembert · 25/02/2022 14:27

I can't believe how low the the percentage of people paying it back actually is. I think we need to make it tough to get more people to repay. It's absolute madness that you can take out a loan, go to uni, then not pay it back.

worriedatthemoment · 25/02/2022 14:16

@Frankola you addressed me first of all not the other way around
You states that of course a teacher would pay all the loan back
I haven't said it should be totally free either But that some countries do manage free or def a lot cheaper

Frankola · 25/02/2022 14:10

@worriedatthemoment but that wasn't what they were saying. Many posters were saying that university should be free.

That's what my whole history of posts on this thread have been in response to.

I have a student loan. I know the interest system on them is absolutely abhorrent and broken. But that has not been anything to do with my previous posts. You've just jumped on my comments and turned it into your own agenda/storyline.

You obviously haven't read my posts in the first place if you think I've made any comment about student loan interest. So why have you been trying to argue with me on points I haven't been making?

Yes. The interest system on student loans needs addressing. It absolutely does.

But should a student pay for their own uni education. Yes. They should.