Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think school have over reacted

284 replies

worriedmum2022 · 24/02/2022 09:24

So my girls are 7 and 9 and they were playing at home and got a bit rough, my husband separated them and one of them had hold of a game in a plastic box.

The girls were fighting over who had the box husband intervened the side of the box had split and youngest 7 year old daughter got a cut on her hand. Cleaned up, girls spoken too all sorted job done

Yesterday the headteacher of dd7 rang my husband at work to say she asked dd why she had a plaster on her hand and she said daddy snatched a box off me and it cut me

She has reported this as a safeguarding concern

I mean I get they have a duty of care but this just seems a total over-reaction

No previous issues or incidents with the school but my husband is worried sick as he works where he has to have a DBS and he's worried this will be on his record

Can anyone offer any advice on this type of thing?

OP posts:
newnameforthis76 · 24/02/2022 13:17

I don’t think your husband understands what a DBS check actually covers - it’s for criminal records. It has nothing to do with any safeguarding notes. They don’t access that information.

I know it’s horrible when you feel like you’re being accused of something, but that’s really not what’s happening here. In your case, it’s something-and-nothing, but for another family it might be part of something bigger. This isn’t personal; the teacher isn’t making any judgements.

My brother’s daughter broke her leg when they was very little - just a freak accident that could happen to any small child in the blink of an eye. But he and his wife were questioned very robustly and extensively, and I think separately, about it when they took her to A&E. Which was obviously a horrible experience for them, but as my SIL said, in a way it was also reassuring to know that they are at least alert to the possibility. Because another toddler might desperately need that level of concern.

Jellycatspyjamas · 24/02/2022 13:07

If she's reported it to the designated safeguarding lead she shouldn't actually have reported that to you. Imagine if your daughter really was being abused at home and she rang to say she had reported it! If she decided to call she should have just asked how it happened and left it at that. Seems weird that she would tell you!

Good practice in all but extreme cases to tell parents, unless really you have reason to think there’s an immediate risk and that the child isn’t safe to return home. It keeps communication open, retains the relationship with the school and means the parent doesn’t have social work contact out of nowhere.

HiJenny35 · 24/02/2022 12:59

Hopefully as schools we are learning through the vast missed cases, report report report, it might be nothing but if one teacher has noticed this, another an explainable burn, another a bruise that had a reason, another coming in hungry but home had a reason, another missing clothing but mum had a reason, on their own it's nothing, together it starts a picture, especially after Arthur I hope all schools are getting better at reporting everything even if it's seems honest. Nothing will come of it op but it's a responsibility and not over the top of the school.

Zilla1 · 24/02/2022 12:55

If that is what your DD told the school then wouldn't you want that being considered for safeguarding even if there is a reasonable explanation and if there's been no other concerns then it seems likely no further action will occur? I would.

TabithaHazel · 24/02/2022 12:55

I don't think they have over-reacted - your daughter has obviously reported it in a way that has caused some concerns, but as we all know kids sometimes like to exaggerate so find out exactly what your daughter has said before accusing the school of over-reacting.

toomuchlaundry · 24/02/2022 12:48

It gets transferred to next school.

Many cases of child abuse are picked up by schools. It can be various bits of the jigsaw that finally give you the bigger picture

Unfortunately not all cases do get picked up. But having parents complaining about safeguarding reports or people being advised to keep their sticky beak out don’t help

godmum56 · 24/02/2022 12:45

@JuergenSchwarzwald

If I notice an injury on a child and the parent hadn't mentioned it to me at drop off, I'm going to be asking that child about it. Do you think I should ignore it

a plaster isn't an "injury"! For goodness sake you can get a paper cut and need a plaster.

Totally different from a suspicious pattern of bruising.

Common sense needs to prevail here, otherwise teachers will be wasting time on stuff that takes them away from the important things.

yes you can put a plaster on a papercut but there is no knowing what is under a plaster....and every suspicious pattern starts somewhere. Do you not think that safeguarding is important....and how long does it take to say to a child "oh you have a plaster, how did you get that?"
CaptaNoctem · 24/02/2022 12:42

How long is all this data being kept by the schools? And who has access to it?

Whilst all these minor cuts and grazes are being dutifully logged, many real cases of child abuse are going undetected regardless.

George Orwell's society is well and truly upon us.

ChocolateMassacre · 24/02/2022 12:41

I was asked about so many injuries when my DS was at nursery - he was (is still) very active and prone to taking risks and not looking where he was going.

Kids don't always give a clear picture of what happened either. My DS once told his key worker 'Mummy hit me with a bag', without adding that it was by accident, which was interesting (I swung round and accidentally smacked him in the face with my bag) Confused. My favourite was 'Umm, we noticed that DS had a big bruise on his leg and he says his daddy grabbed him on the climbing-frame and pushed him off". What actually happened was that another child accidentally pushed DS, DH tried to catch DS as he fell, DS caught DH in the face with his muddy boot and broke his (DH's) nose and they both collapsed on the ground with DS on top of DH. DH definitely got the worst of it.

They have to ask and we've never yet been phoned by social services.

WonderfulYou · 24/02/2022 12:29

Please do not worry.
It does seem like an overreaction but it’s always better to be safe than sorry.

These incidents are logged to create a bigger picture.

Kids that are often getting abused don’t come in covered in bruises and saying their parents hurt them - it’s small incidents that can easily go unnoticed but actually if you add them all up it starts becoming more clear.

ohfook · 24/02/2022 12:17

We can't live in a country where everybody complains when innocent things are checked up on (not interrogated) but every abuser is caught and every abused child is saved. The two are not mutually exclusive.

It's very easy to say well " X is clearly not abuse let's apply common sense." People who say that I do not believe have been around abusers. Cigarette burns and black eyes aren't the only signs to be vigilant for.

SpiderVersed · 24/02/2022 12:11

You should be glad your child's school takes safeguarding seriously. It's routine, and nothing for you to worry about.

mummydoingamasters · 24/02/2022 12:08

We (secondary school) have to report changes in behaviour/sleep/attitude/clothing/bruises and cuts as something small could be the thing that actually identifies a bigger concern.

We have a state where consents are logged and filed or reported on to a authoritative body of required. We always call home unless there is a safety reason we can't or there is a wider known concern that could put the child at risk.

toomuchlaundry · 24/02/2022 12:06

Bit like the dirty jumper analogy. Child normally comes into school with clean clothes, then comes in with stained jumper couple of days on the trot. Teacher chats with child. Scenario A: ‘Oh miss you won’t believe it, it was so exciting, the washing machine blew up at the weekend, flames and everything! We can’t get a new one until next week. I’ve offered to keep the sane pants on all week to help but mum says no!’ You offer sympathy to parent at pick up and they confirm story.
Scenario B: ‘Oh miss you won’t believe it, dad got really angry at the weekend and smashed up the washing machine and went to hit mum’
Both scenarios put on school safeguarding system. Scenario B additional action also taken

Maddiemoosmum0203 · 24/02/2022 12:02

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

Girlmumdogmumboymum · 24/02/2022 11:59

Whilst you feel alarmed, and concerned for the repercussions of what was an innocent incident, this is a good thing given the amount of abuse that goes unnoticed in this country.

It doesn't mean that the teachers are all slagging your family off in the break room, but it does mean that injuries and signs of injury are being looked at and taken seriously.

You're unlikely to hear anything more of it.

I say this as a mother of a very accident prone teen! I remember keeping all of her injury forms from school; just incase something ever cropped up.

And even when it's innocent, kids do tell the story in a way that makes it sound terrible. When DD was 9 I convinced her to go on a zip line thing. I thought if she was brave she would really enjoy herself and it would be an exercise of sometimes things that seem scary end up being fun...let's take a chance sort of thing.

As it started to move, she let go!!

She hurt herself. Her elbow bled, its left a scar. She is still adamant I did it to her. She still tells the story. I always laugh and say, now can we have some proper details, like how it actually happened and the cake I bought you after please!!

Waddlegoose · 24/02/2022 11:58

They have to log everything, it doesn’t mean it’s on any formal record. My son burnt his finger on the toaster and it was logged.

It’s purely so that if there’s a pattern it’s more obvious to spot. It won’t show on an dbs checks and I can guarantee things have been logged before but you aren’t aware

lanthanum · 24/02/2022 11:56

@JuergenSchwarzwald

If I notice an injury on a child and the parent hadn't mentioned it to me at drop off, I'm going to be asking that child about it. Do you think I should ignore it

a plaster isn't an "injury"! For goodness sake you can get a paper cut and need a plaster.

Totally different from a suspicious pattern of bruising.

Common sense needs to prevail here, otherwise teachers will be wasting time on stuff that takes them away from the important things.

Child says "I cut myself on a piece of paper", mum says the same when asked at pick-up, it's not a regular occurence: job done.

Child has plasters every week, or mum's story different to child's, or child seems hesitant about answering: perhaps the plaster is actually covering something different.
Not all abuse is bruises.

JustLyra · 24/02/2022 11:53

I have to say it does sound over the top, unless the OP hasn't told us that it's the tenth such incident this year.

Without keeping a record then the fact it is the tenth one could be missed. That’s the point - so that when it is the tenth one someone knows that.

arethereanyleftatall · 24/02/2022 11:53

They haven't overcreacted at all. But you and your dh have.

Of course if a child says that they need to raise it!

toomuchlaundry · 24/02/2022 11:50

A plaster could be hiding a cigarette burn, a larger plaster could be hiding many different sorts of injuries

WouldIwasShookspeared · 24/02/2022 11:49

It's perfectly correct to report. They are doing what they should be doing.

I'm surprised that they told you. If a parent was actually abusive then telling them they have reported an incident could lead to a range of very bad outcomes for the child.

RobotValkyrie · 24/02/2022 11:48

Happens on school/teachers watch but no report, no safeguarding, again schools are above all that.

Yep, lots of unexplained injuries happen in schools, and they sure don't all get a formal record.
Have had my share of chats with teaching staff looking like they were in full ass-covering mode after minor but significant (near miss, e.g. scratch to face very near an eye) school "incidents", where the story consistently reported by my child happened to be very different from (and rather more credible than) official records (when such records even existed)
I've also seen them temporarily "lose" kids on school trips. But all is well than ends well, eh?

starfishmummy · 24/02/2022 11:47

@JuergenSchwarzwald

If I notice an injury on a child and the parent hadn't mentioned it to me at drop off, I'm going to be asking that child about it. Do you think I should ignore it

a plaster isn't an "injury"! For goodness sake you can get a paper cut and need a plaster.

Totally different from a suspicious pattern of bruising.

Common sense needs to prevail here, otherwise teachers will be wasting time on stuff that takes them away from the important things.

Exactly.
Amichelle84 · 24/02/2022 11:46

Posts like this annoy me so much.

Yes it's an overreaction to you because nothing untoward went on.

Its not an overreaction for them to record things like this though, for all they know the kid could be downplaying something and they could actually be getting abused.

I for one would like to know the teachers are being responsible.

Swipe left for the next trending thread