Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think school have over reacted

284 replies

worriedmum2022 · 24/02/2022 09:24

So my girls are 7 and 9 and they were playing at home and got a bit rough, my husband separated them and one of them had hold of a game in a plastic box.

The girls were fighting over who had the box husband intervened the side of the box had split and youngest 7 year old daughter got a cut on her hand. Cleaned up, girls spoken too all sorted job done

Yesterday the headteacher of dd7 rang my husband at work to say she asked dd why she had a plaster on her hand and she said daddy snatched a box off me and it cut me

She has reported this as a safeguarding concern

I mean I get they have a duty of care but this just seems a total over-reaction

No previous issues or incidents with the school but my husband is worried sick as he works where he has to have a DBS and he's worried this will be on his record

Can anyone offer any advice on this type of thing?

OP posts:
CloseYourEyesAndSee · 04/03/2022 08:03

@FortunesFave

they absolutely should inform the parents that they have done so unless there are very immediate safety concerns

But that's very open to interpretation isn't it? "Immediate safety concerns" could be construed as "Well I saw an injury and decided the risk was real so chose not to inform the parents"

When they call the MASH to make the referral they are asked if they have discussed with the parents. If the answer is no, the referral officer should ask them to go and do that. If the referrer isn't sure whether it's an immediate safety risk, a screening social worker will look at it and in conjunction with a manager, make that decision.
CloseYourEyesAndSee · 04/03/2022 08:02

@Foolsrule

You shouldn’t have been told the school had contacted anyone. Sounds like the school know nothing about proper safeguarding to me.
Is this a typo? Because if not, you are wrong
SlashBeef · 04/03/2022 08:01

Are you completely sure there's nothing else? Have the school raised any concerns any other time?

RosesAndHellebores · 04/03/2022 08:01

If everything is as the op said, I'd be speaking with a family solicitor today. I'd let them handle the SDAR and the formal complaint. I'd also be looking at other schools.

Once my family's name was cleared, I'd expect a full and unequivocal apology from the head teacher.

FortunesFave · 04/03/2022 08:01

they absolutely should inform the parents that they have done so unless there are very immediate safety concerns

But that's very open to interpretation isn't it? "Immediate safety concerns" could be construed as "Well I saw an injury and decided the risk was real so chose not to inform the parents"

liveforsummer · 04/03/2022 07:23

@Foolsrule

You shouldn’t have been told the school had contacted anyone. Sounds like the school know nothing about proper safeguarding to me.
Not true. If I write a welfare concern the parents are informed. When one was written for my own dd (because of her dad/my ex) I was informed.
liveforsummer · 04/03/2022 07:18

Wow, what weird and leading questions she asked. Is your dd usually good and relaying information accurately or could she be getting confused?

I write welfare concern forms all the time and normally they are just reported to the head teacher or family worker within school. I've had a hell of a lot worse than a cut hand from a snatched box that hasn't been taken any further. Normally with what your dd has said id chat to a parent (or someone senior to me would) without even writing a form. Are you sure they don't have other concerns? Your daughter exaggerated the incident with the box (if your account is fully accurate) could she be doing this with other things? I recently found out dd had been telling her friends that our dog uses her bedroom as a litter tray. She pee'd in there twice as a puppy and is now 2 years old. Hmm if id heard a child say that id have reported that one

freemantel · 04/03/2022 07:14

Op, if this happened to my family I would write down exactly what happened from your perspective, in a factual (not emotive) way, send it the the headteacher and ask them to put it on record.

Beefcurtains79 · 04/03/2022 07:13

Why were they asking your kid if you smoke? Is smoking now illegal or a sign you abuse your kids or something?
You poor thing, this is every decent parents worst nightmare.

MsJinks · 04/03/2022 07:10

It is about the picture building. It’s best to cooperate and also be seen to recognise the reason for the concern rather than debating it.
The school should tell the parent of referral to social unless that itself is seen as a risk, as others have said.
It should all be resolved smoothly, however, it is faintly possible that there’s been a previous random note made to social services and they are now being additionally careful. Every referral to social is logged with new customers getting a record created - and all have to be followed up to an appropriate (and resource driven!) extent. These referral logs are not deleted if found to be of no concern of themselves, as there is potentially ‘picture’ building with a number of small incident referrals. There are also very keen sw around, though that can be understood when you think of some high profile cases.
Regards to your husband’s DBS then if it’s basic that is police record, if it’s enhanced then contact is made with social to see if you are known to them - people can have a concerning social record that police have not on behaviour with vulnerable people. He will now be known to them as his name will be there, but obviously records will not show concern around this one incident or a couple of small ones - I imagine it would be very significant history including adverse fact finds in family courts, huge numbers of allegations for example, before impacting on anyone’s clearance.
I would look into submitting a subject access request (SAR) at some point - I’d think a bit after this is resolved, some might say now but I’m thinking it’s best and easiest to be fully cooperative and not show any concern or annoyance. You would need to do it for your child as well as most info will be recorded in her name - I’m not sure how much they release of that though to be honest.
Hope all works out well for you all.

Foolsrule · 04/03/2022 07:09

You shouldn’t have been told the school had contacted anyone. Sounds like the school know nothing about proper safeguarding to me.

Rivermonsters · 04/03/2022 07:06

@Benjispruce5 I agree, seems like OP is in denial of something

Benjispruce5 · 04/03/2022 07:03

@marvellousmaple think about it. Do you know the op? Could there have been other incidents? School don’t get social workers in. They report worrying things and social workers are overstretched so don’t turn up at school lightly.

Rivermonsters · 04/03/2022 07:02

YABU they’re doing their job plus why worry when he’s done nothing wrong Hmm odd post

marvellousmaple · 04/03/2022 07:00

Fecking hell. This sounds Orwellian. The kid went to school with a plaster and now is dragged out of class and interviewed ( without a parent) for an hour and you are all - yep. All good. Are you all crazy? I'm sorry OP. Is there a new member of staff on a mission? I'd be furious if someone dragged my child into an interview with a random on this basis. I think we all know if many cases of kids attending many many services and nothing happens. This is bizarre and terribly wrong - going on the OP's story.

Benjispruce5 · 04/03/2022 06:57

Ah just seen your second post. Sounds odd. There must have been other incidents to generate that response.

Benjispruce5 · 04/03/2022 06:55

Agggh. Lead not leaf, note , Head obviously.

Benjispruce5 · 04/03/2022 06:55

Reported? Normally with things like this, our safeguarding leaf would ask parents about it and make a not on our internal system. This goes no further unless other information is collected. In that case a chat with the local MASH team would be the next step. Even then, if nothing suspicious that would be it. I would ask the ahead what they mean by reported. I totally understand how you feel but it is all about protecting your children and if just a silly accident, you have nothing to fear.

HettytheHoover · 04/03/2022 06:41

Yep, school perfectly valid in reporting what your child has told them and then your husband (amid more extenuating circumstances) has told them.
Reported in case there are several more incidences of "daddy/sister caused this other small cut, this cut, this one, here, here"

ThanksItHasPockets · 04/03/2022 06:41

This is very very strange indeed.

Strictly1 · 04/03/2022 06:28

@wearewizardsofoz

If she's reported it to the designated safeguarding lead she shouldn't actually have reported that to you. Imagine if your daughter really was being abused at home and she rang to say she had reported it! If she decided to call she should have just asked how it happened and left it at that. Seems weird that she would tell you!
You are meant to tell parents you are reporting it and if you don't, you need to have a good reason. It's one of the first questions safeguarding ask when you report an incident.
voxnihili · 04/03/2022 06:27

I’m a safeguarding lead in my school. We encourage staff to record the little things as it helps to build a picture. They don’t have access to all the records but myself and the other DSLs do. Most of the time these little things really are nothing to worry about but occasionally they are.

Following your update it sounds to me like maybe they’re worried about aggression / domestic violence if your DD has used language such as snatched and fighting. Children often have a knack of elaborating the details which can make incidents seem worse than they are.

I’ve had to sign the book at my DD’s pre-school on numerous occasions as she’s active and clumsy. I’m convinced I’ll get a phone call from social services one of these days due to the way my DD describes incidents.

To be honest, I think it’s best at this stage to cooperate with the social worker. Any hostility could be viewed negatively. They’ll soon see if there’s no cause for concern.

I know it’s difficult but by recording everything and swift action being taken, the services have more chance of being able to reach those children who really need the help.

CloseYourEyesAndSee · 04/03/2022 06:13

@FortunesFave

The social worker should of contacted you first as they have to have your permission for a start

I'm pretty sure that's not true. Why would social workers seek the permission of potentially abusive parents to talk to kids in school? Things could escalate quickly if they did that.

It's not nice at all OP but the best course of action is to be absolutely helpful to them. Don't block them or be outraged or anything. Just listen and do what they say, it will probably be signed off and forgotten.

This is incorrect. Before visiting a child, a social worker absolutely must contact the parents and seek consent. The only time that would be overridden would be in the case of serious immediate harm, in which case a strategy discussion would have take place with police who would have carried out a joint visit alongside the social worker.
CloseYourEyesAndSee · 04/03/2022 06:10

@prh47bridge

The school is right to record the incident. It won't affect your husband's DBS at all. The only thing wrong here is that the school told you what they have done. They should not have done so. It has left you unduly worried. Worse, if there was any genuine abuse, telling you that they were reporting the incident could have put your daughters at greater risk. Putting that aside, the school have not over-reacted.
Again, if schools are making reports to social services they are expected to inform the parents.
CloseYourEyesAndSee · 04/03/2022 06:07

@wearewizardsofoz

If she's reported it to the designated safeguarding lead she shouldn't actually have reported that to you. Imagine if your daughter really was being abused at home and she rang to say she had reported it! If she decided to call she should have just asked how it happened and left it at that. Seems weird that she would tell you!
This isn't true at all. When schools report concerns to children's services they absolutely should inform the parents that they have done so unless there are very immediate safety concerns
Swipe left for the next trending thread