Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Y5 taught about child prostitution

57 replies

ShiteheadRevisited · 24/02/2022 06:44

Help me get some perspective.

DD(9) told me last night that as part of their class learning about children's rights in R.E. yesterday, that "there was a really sad one" about "adults who make children have sex for money!"

She looked very shocked and upset telling me. Their teacher (very experienced with older daughter herself) apparently said that "you should all know what sex is" and that "this (adults making children have sex) is really, really horrible" and then moved on.

They have not covered human reproduction yet, and school's curriculum states that sex ed will occur in Y6, with a letter going home to parents beforehand (it's a small independently primary).

Our daughter knows about human reproduction/birds & bees etc but not sex for pleasure or anything else yet.

I don't consider myself a prude but am feeling very out of touch and actually quite emotional that a piece of childhood innocence has been taken from her.

AIBU to feel this way? I honestly don't know whether I'm being a bit of a pearl-clutcher and that this is normal content for primary schools nowadays, or if I have a right to feel pissed off??

OP posts:
ThinWomansBrain · 24/02/2022 09:11

@Porcupineintherough I wasn't denying online grooming happens - but expressing surprise at MrsMo21's suggestion that teaching was focused on the risk of being abuses by strangers, given that many studies, including a 2019 one by NSPCC, conclude that the vast majority of children who experience sexual abuse were abused by someone they knew.
If you prefer to live in NIMBY ignorance, carry on - but don't accuse others of being dumb simply because you prefer to bury your head in the sand.

AlternativePerspective · 24/02/2022 08:39

I can't see that you're basing this on real life knowledge and experience of 9 year olds really? at 9 I certainly knew what sex was and I knew what a prostitute is.

And let’s be honest here, there is no escaping sex or mention of sex. The news is full of it, television is full of it, you can walk past an Anne summers shop on the high street with vibrators in the window.

Anyone who thinks that 9 year olds are not aware that there is such a thing as sex for pleasure is naive. Especially those who have older siblings.

We teach our children that no-one should be permitted to touch them in certain places and to never have to keep such secrets from e.g. their parents.

So children are, or should hopefully be, taught about sexual abuse from a young age in order to hopefully be able to speak out if it is done to them, or even learn to say no to protect themselves from it.

So while I don’t agree that the lesson should be a straight “people pay to have sex with children,” I don’t see what is wrong with children knowing that there are extremely bad people out there who will do things to children which we as parents have taught our own children is wrong, and will pay money to do so, which makes them doubly awful.

Victims of child sexual abuse are very real. It’s not palatable but it’s a reality.

The terminology needs changing, “child porn/child prostitution”, but often instead of teaching our children about dangers we shield them from them, which makes them more likely targets, not necessarily of paid sexual abuse, but certainly of grooming etc.

Crazydoglady1980 · 24/02/2022 08:28

If the class was on the UN rights of the child, one of the rights are protection from sexual abuse and sexual exploitation so this may have been covered. However it sounds like the teacher maybe didn’t cover it quite right or had to respond to a difficult question.

CarbonelCat · 24/02/2022 08:26

"I would expect a nine year old to know what sex is, and what a prostitute is."

Really? Really?

My dc have all known about sex for reproduction as a matter of course - no big reveal or discussion but the conversations around healthy relationships, consent, sex for pleasure etc have only really happened with mine since end of primary and they certainly haven't got as far as transactional sex or organised sexual exploitation. Why on earth would they?

How can children possibly be expected to understand these topics and the amount of nuanced discussion around them (why should they) so all that happens when you tell 9 yr olds about CSE is that they feel less safe, more scared and potentially being their lifelong learning about sex and relationships with the sense that sex is exploitative, done to them, not based on consent and something to dread.

I can't see that you're basing this on real life knowledge and experience of 9 year olds really?

Porcupineintherough · 24/02/2022 08:18

@ThinWomansBrain denying the reality of online grooming as a gateway to the sexual abuse of children just makes you look really dumb.

TheHomesickRestaurant · 24/02/2022 08:08

@ThinWomansBrain

never talk to someone you don’t know online

wow - stranger danger myth still being supported then?

????

I still meet a lot of young people who are being groomed and then being forced to perform all kinds of acts online.
Just because it's more common to be abused by someone you know doesn't mean it doesn't happen in other ways.
Online abuse is tragically common.

SolasAnla · 24/02/2022 08:07

YANBU Parents should correctly informed of what is being taught.
The topic of a child being sexually abused by an adult should never be a taught with a 'mentioned in passing but swiftly moving on' attitude.
The children may interpret this as its shameful and/or should remain a secret.
And as pointed out the teacher is presenting with an assumption that none of the students are or were being abused.
Its sexual abuse and if in the curriculum should be taught as such.
It should always be linked with tell someone and you will be listened to and helped.
If a family member is involved there will be some form of emotional abuse and grooming so the emphasis should be that the child's actions are not within their own control and that no matter the circumstance the child can safely disclose the abuse.

I would be very curious as to how rights of children translated into the topic of adults buying childrens bodies and sex and child sex abuse. Was slavery the lead in or something else?

The right to have sex is an adult right.
It should not be covered in any depth because 9-10 year olds dont have that right.

I think you need to check the teaching materials your daughter has, get a better understanding of what happened in class and discuss it with the teacher to get her perspective.
If the curriculum covers CSA prior to formal sex education all the parents should be updated.
The teacher also should not have assumed that all the children have been taught about sex acts (as opposed to female/male body parts, mum grows the baby and bad touching).

Now that the school has brought the subject up you should have a conversation about it as part of a broader conversation about changes to her body including her right to leave a classroom when dealing with periods in school.

ThinWomansBrain · 24/02/2022 08:04

never talk to someone you don’t know online

wow - stranger danger myth still being supported then?

Seashor · 24/02/2022 08:03

We want our children to be innocent and we want to protect them. However if you have adopted children, children in care, asylum children etc etc in your class then you have children who know horror.
I’ve had to broach some very difficult and quite frankly horrific subjects because of something a child has talked about with other children.
These subjects can’t and shouldn’t be brushed under the carpet and if children bring them up then they have to be dealt with. Talk to your daughter about it and help her understand that not all children enjoy her lifestyle.

BuyDirt · 24/02/2022 07:58

If you’re not happy, talk to the school to find out exactly what was said.

ChiselandBits · 24/02/2022 07:52

Also my ten year old knows about things like that from watching musicals, Les Mis, Hamilton, Miss Saigon, Wicked, all have themes around some form of prostitution, infidelity, child labour and abandonment. I explain them so she understands the plot. Its not awful that kids know this stuff, and teachers can't cover all bases in a class of 30, responding to every random question with a detailed and PSHE response.

WishIwasElsa · 24/02/2022 07:51

From the OP's post it doesn't seem to have been covered well at all. It is sad and awful but I agree we need to educate children in order to protect them better

ShiteheadRevisited · 24/02/2022 07:49

Thanks all for your responses. No, the teacher didn't use the term "child prostitution" - that's my own clumsy vocabulary and I realise now that this term is wrong (told you, I'm a dinosaur!).

She did (apparently) say the words "sometimes adults have sex with children for money".

I will have a chat with her to find out the context and her version of events, and then possibly raise it further with headteacher.

Thanks again for you comments, they've really helped.

OP posts:
lioncitygirl · 24/02/2022 07:46

😱 this is not ok.

Porcupineintherough · 24/02/2022 07:44

@cansu

The op used the words child prostitution.
Yes but did the teacher?
cansu · 24/02/2022 07:43

The op used the words child prostitution.

Porcupineintherough · 24/02/2022 07:41

I had a similar conversation with my kids at a similar age. Pretty hard to talk about grooming esp online grooming without explaining of what the adult in question is after. Mine were shocked/horrified too but I felt it important for them to know.

MrsMo21 · 24/02/2022 07:40

I’ve taught in year 5 for many years and can say there’s no reason for the teacher to have mentioned that in that way off her own back, the fact that she has is really bizarre. We do have to discuss grooming but it’s more ‘never talk to someone you don’t know online, there are some adults that aren’t kind and don’t want to keep you safe’ kind of stuff.
It could possibly have come up in conversation if a child asked a question (believe me some of the questions we get asked by children are eye opening) but the fact that she discussed it in those terms and then didn’t let the parents know via email afterwards that this had been bought up in class etc is really not ok.
Your daughter at 9 doesn’t have the vocabulary or wider world knowledge to have come up with that on her own so it’s definitely come from the adult; I’m really quite shocked to be honest!
I’d ask to speak to the teacher first to get her side then take it further to her phase lead and headteacher. We have a duty of care to the children in the class and discussing child ‘prostitution’ is not ok.

CharacterForming · 24/02/2022 07:37

Nothing in the OP suggests that this was presented as anything but a terrible crime forced on some child victims. Did the teacher actually use the dubious words "child prostitution"?

ChiselandBits · 24/02/2022 07:28

I teach RS in secondary. Sometimes discussions go in a direction or a child asks a question at a tangent and you have to provide some sort of answer that is honest and true but you don't want to derail the lesson completely. It sounds like the teacher gave a straight, though oversimplified reply and moved on to get the lesson back on track. I think best thing now is for you, if your DD asks or is wondering, to give a little more context about how the children get no choice, emphasise the importance of speaking up and leave it there.

SugarAndCoffee · 24/02/2022 07:11

Newsround spend ages thinking how to address the horrors of the world in a child friendly way, so I'm not against the tough stuff being taught. But this is the wrong way to do it and I don't think they should be describing child rape in this way or in fact at all at this stage.

I would complain. You should have even informed first and frankly if sex Ed isn't taught until y6 then this is going to make it seem scary.

ThinWomansBrain · 24/02/2022 07:09

but at 9 - in a class of 30 there's a fair chance that at least one child has been or is being sexually abused, or will be (nspcc stats are 1 in 20).
Surely better that children know about this, so that happens to them - or has already - they know what it is, that it is wrong and hopefully will feel empowered to something about it and get help, rather than suffer in ignorance and be blackmailed to keep secrets?
sadly it's probably those children at higher risk that will not be taught these skills in a supportive home environment.

autienotnaughty · 24/02/2022 07:04

Sex education fine, safeguarding fine. Discussing child abuse/peadophilia in such a dismissive sloppy way absolutely not. Discussions like that are need to be carefully thought out and yes I'd say nine is too young.

AlternativePerspective · 24/02/2022 07:01

I would expect a nine year old to know what sex is, and what a prostitute is.

And I would also expect a 9 year old to have an understanding that many children are exploited in many different ways, including them being sold as child prostitutes, even though the terminology is wrong, that is how they’re seen by the perverts who exploit them.

We spend far too much time trying to protect children from a world which others of their age are a product of.

NoSquirrels · 24/02/2022 07:00

I’m far from a pearl-clutcher, and don’t normally disagree with teachers tackling difficult subjects but I cannot imagine this came up through class discussion from a comment one of the children made independently, so the teacher chose to mention it.

It’s sexual abuse, it’s extremely serious. It’s not “sex for money” - those children aren’t being paid. It IS “really, really horrid” but it’s not “adults making children have sex” it’s adults raping children.

I’d be asking for an explanation.