Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Y5 taught about child prostitution

57 replies

ShiteheadRevisited · 24/02/2022 06:44

Help me get some perspective.

DD(9) told me last night that as part of their class learning about children's rights in R.E. yesterday, that "there was a really sad one" about "adults who make children have sex for money!"

She looked very shocked and upset telling me. Their teacher (very experienced with older daughter herself) apparently said that "you should all know what sex is" and that "this (adults making children have sex) is really, really horrible" and then moved on.

They have not covered human reproduction yet, and school's curriculum states that sex ed will occur in Y6, with a letter going home to parents beforehand (it's a small independently primary).

Our daughter knows about human reproduction/birds & bees etc but not sex for pleasure or anything else yet.

I don't consider myself a prude but am feeling very out of touch and actually quite emotional that a piece of childhood innocence has been taken from her.

AIBU to feel this way? I honestly don't know whether I'm being a bit of a pearl-clutcher and that this is normal content for primary schools nowadays, or if I have a right to feel pissed off??

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
bellac11 · 25/02/2022 07:51

@ThinWomansBrain

I find it sad when children are so au fait with a number of professional phrases and terminology like grooming and self harm etc. Really? - I rejoice that that they are not in ignorance so that in the event they are abused, they have the knowledge and confidence to tell someone and stop it happening. All that these hushed tones of secrecy and keeping the subject taboo achieve is to create a safe haven for abusers.
I not sure where I said that issues should be kept secret or taboo or children kept in ignorance, its about the level and how you do it. Children using almost professional terminology on a regular basis tells me that we are going about it the wrong way.
Hasselhoffsheadband · 24/02/2022 19:31

@ThinWomansBrain

completely agree with Opal4 Hasselhoffsheadband - if you RTFT, OP states "No, the teacher didn't use the term "child prostitution" "
Yes I know, I did RTFT. The teacher said 'making children have sex for money'. And as I said upthread, most 9 years only have an abstract concept of what 'sex' is and so wouldn't understand 'sex for money' and how it is abusive.

This is entirely different to teaching kids about reducing risk via something like the NSPCC Pants campaign.

ThinWomansBrain · 24/02/2022 19:26

I find it sad when children are so au fait with a number of professional phrases and terminology like grooming and self harm etc.
Really? - I rejoice that that they are not in ignorance so that in the event they are abused, they have the knowledge and confidence to tell someone and stop it happening.
All that these hushed tones of secrecy and keeping the subject taboo achieve is to create a safe haven for abusers.

ThinWomansBrain · 24/02/2022 19:20

completely agree with Opal4
Hasselhoffsheadband - if you RTFT, OP states "No, the teacher didn't use the term "child prostitution" "

bellac11 · 24/02/2022 18:56

@CarbonelCat

"I would expect a nine year old to know what sex is, and what a prostitute is."

Really? Really?

My dc have all known about sex for reproduction as a matter of course - no big reveal or discussion but the conversations around healthy relationships, consent, sex for pleasure etc have only really happened with mine since end of primary and they certainly haven't got as far as transactional sex or organised sexual exploitation. Why on earth would they?

How can children possibly be expected to understand these topics and the amount of nuanced discussion around them (why should they) so all that happens when you tell 9 yr olds about CSE is that they feel less safe, more scared and potentially being their lifelong learning about sex and relationships with the sense that sex is exploitative, done to them, not based on consent and something to dread.

I can't see that you're basing this on real life knowledge and experience of 9 year olds really?

Completely agree with this, among other factors, Im of the opinion that childrens MH has deteriorated and anxiety increased in children partly due to adults insistence that we talk to them about a number of adult worries, grooming, climate change, CSE, gangs, drugs etc etc in an effort to educate, empower and inform but what inadvertently we are also doing is raising their anxieties. I find it sad when children are so au fait with a number of professional phrases and terminology like grooming and self harm etc. I worry that the trend in recent years, probably over the past 10 years to include and explore children's opinions, give them a say also may have increased a disproportionate level of responsibility onto their shoulders, without meaning to obviously. Children do need to be informed and heard but Im not sure we are going the right way about it.
Gowithme · 24/02/2022 18:47

'You should all know what sex is' - what sort of teacher makes that assumption about 9 year olds?? and to tell them that they should all know - as if they've done something wrong if they don't know - is just appalling IMO. And then to brush over 'adults making children have sex' like that with a 'really, really horrible' but that's the end of it is just shocking. Were they watching a video? It obviously wasn't age appropriate. This is such a sensitive subject and really, really shouldn't have been handled in this way. It's obviously really affected your daughter negatively, teachers should not be frightening children like this, it could really affect the MH of an anxious child. You really need to contact the school about it and get them to now cover this in a much better way.

DogsAndGin · 24/02/2022 18:29

@ShiteheadRevisited

Thanks all for your responses. No, the teacher didn't use the term "child prostitution" - that's my own clumsy vocabulary and I realise now that this term is wrong (told you, I'm a dinosaur!).

She did (apparently) say the words "sometimes adults have sex with children for money".

I will have a chat with her to find out the context and her version of events, and then possibly raise it further with headteacher.

Thanks again for you comments, they've really helped.

Yes. You should raise it with the head. Children her age shouldn’t be taught about sex yet, as you’ve mentioned their curriculum states. Really not ok. You said ‘there was this really sad one’ - are you referring to a video? If so, the teacher should have watched the whole video before to check it was appropriate
Hasselhoffsheadband · 24/02/2022 18:29

@Opal4

For those arguing children shouldn't know, how are they to protect themselves if they don't know.

I was sexually abused through my childhood I didn't know it was wrong. And also had no one to tell. I was told I would be punished and taken away.
Dd is 9 I have given her knowledge. She knows about pants and privates and not touching. She also knows it's ok to challenge an adult to scream shout, kick punch whatever if she doesn't feel safe.
And most importantly I reiterate that it's ok to tell us anything we will not be cross, angry, she won't be in trouble.
This is how too many abusers get away with it.

Yes, but that is different to a teacher telling kids about prostitution. The knowledge you have given your daughter is about making her aware is age appropriate advice about keeping safe and knowing its OK to tell an adult things if you are uncomfortable. That is not the same as telling kids that sexual abuse happens on a wide scale. Otherwise, by that logic, we would tell children all the bad things that happen in the world from the moment they understand language, which is obviously not appropriate.

I am so sorry for what happened to you Flowers

Opal4 · 24/02/2022 18:25

For those arguing children shouldn't know, how are they to protect themselves if they don't know.

I was sexually abused through my childhood I didn't know it was wrong. And also had no one to tell. I was told I would be punished and taken away.
Dd is 9 I have given her knowledge. She knows about pants and privates and not touching. She also knows it's ok to challenge an adult to scream shout, kick punch whatever if she doesn't feel safe.
And most importantly I reiterate that it's ok to tell us anything we will not be cross, angry, she won't be in trouble.
This is how too many abusers get away with it.

Beetlebum1981 · 24/02/2022 17:25

As a Y6 teacher I'm quite surprised this was covered. We're just starting sex Ed and I know there'll be a lot of children who have heard the word 'sex' but not actually know what it is. There's nothing wrong with having a word with the head and voicing your concerns about addressing such an issue before they've had sex Ed.

Ericaequites · 24/02/2022 17:22

Nice homes, posh cars, and fancy clothes don’t protect children from sexual abuse from parents, stepparents, much older siblings, and other relatives. Wealthy people can access private therapy, hide or ignore ill health, and aren’t likely to come to the attention of social workers. Many busy doctors don’t and can’t do the forensic work to reveal abuse. American private schools acquiesce in abusive situations, and not just with teacher situations. Many women later in abusive relationships were sexually or physically abused came from abusive homes. As adults, the trauma and chronic physical issues don’t go away. Many abuse substances to cut the pain.

IsItTooHotInHere · 24/02/2022 17:17

AlternativePerspectiveThu 24-Feb-22 07:01:45
I would expect a nine year old to know what sex is, and what a prostitute is

Really?! FFS, why must children know about those things?

IsItTooHotInHere · 24/02/2022 17:14

That's very wrong, in my opinion. I'd be complaining to the school.

Hasselhoffsheadband · 24/02/2022 17:13

I would expect a nine year old to know what sex is, and what a prostitute is

What sex is? Yes, probably for most of them, although not all. And that's OK. 9 is the age for a lot of kids where things start to fall into place though.

What a prostitute is? Hell no. The concept of sex for most 9 year old (not all Sad) is still completely abstract and they are still piecing things together that they don't fully understand. Most 9 year olds wouldn't be able to understand the concept of 'sex for money' abuse, because they still don't fully understand what sex involves or how it makes people feel.

Kids don't need to know this stuff at 9.

ThinWomansBrain · 24/02/2022 17:07

@MrsMo21 - thanks, comforting to know

PeterPanda · 24/02/2022 14:17

@AlternativePerspective

I would expect a nine year old to know what sex is, and what a prostitute is.

And I would also expect a 9 year old to have an understanding that many children are exploited in many different ways, including them being sold as child prostitutes, even though the terminology is wrong, that is how they’re seen by the perverts who exploit them.

We spend far too much time trying to protect children from a world which others of their age are a product of.

WTF? Hmm

No 9 year old needs to know what sex for pleasure is or prostitution is. My kids have know about reproduction at various levels of detail since they were 3 years old, they know how babies are made (PIV) and how the baby comes out. They knew about periods and ovulation. They were also taught to trust themselves and value their own boundaries.

They knew nothing about sex, we didn't refer to reproduction as sex until they were in year 6 / 11 years old and built up their knowledge bit by bit guided by their maturity.

The teacher was out of order and I would subtly enquire what has happened and why this was brought up.

ChiselandBits · 24/02/2022 13:51

absolutely. There's a big difference between dealing with a derailing question out of context and properly planned, resourced and timed PSHE lesson where you can carefully explain nuance and detail and why "child prostitution" is a contradiction in terms. I did a lesson with Y12 recently on pornography and dealt with this exact issue. There is no such thing child porn, its sexual assault on a minor and would be treated as such by anyone caught accessing it. - hard to get that kind of nuance across to a Y5 class though!

LittleGwyneth · 24/02/2022 13:40

@ChiselandBits

I teach RS in secondary. Sometimes discussions go in a direction or a child asks a question at a tangent and you have to provide some sort of answer that is honest and true but you don't want to derail the lesson completely. It sounds like the teacher gave a straight, though oversimplified reply and moved on to get the lesson back on track. I think best thing now is for you, if your DD asks or is wondering, to give a little more context about how the children get no choice, emphasise the importance of speaking up and leave it there.
I would assume it was this - I doubt the teacher brought it up by choice, more likely the conversation came up and the teacher tried to engage with it. I remember being in year five when a boy in my class asked if it was true that the terrorists were raping the air hostesses on one of the 9/11 flights. Children ask questions, and teachers have to think on the fly.
autienotnaughty · 24/02/2022 12:46

@Stompythedinosaur

I work with children who have been sexually trafficked and exploited - I have worked with numerous 10yos who have had this experience.

Yes, it is horrifying, but it is an increasing problem and knowledge is power. I have certainly explained to my 10 and 8yos what sexual exploitation is.

It drives me mad, actually. The nspcc pants rule is so widespread, bit we expect to be about to tell kids "what's in your pants is private" and not have any follow up questions about sexual abuse and why someone might want to see their privates.

Telling kids about sex and abuse doesn't stop them being innocent.

I agree but in this case it wasn't explained it was glossed over.
QuirkyTurtle · 24/02/2022 09:50

It doesn't sound like this was handled well but that may just be your phrasing of it.

I think children at this age absolutely should be taught about sexual exploitation. We can't hide it, take no preventive measures whatsoever, and then act surprised that sexual abuse of children happens.

drspouse · 24/02/2022 09:21

Anyone who thinks that 9 year olds are not aware that there is such a thing as sex for pleasure is naive. Especially those who have older siblings.
We have brought in the topic of sex frequently, and with a light touch, with my 10 year old (also Y5) over the years. He has some SEN but the main way this has affected him is that he's missed whatever would have been covered in RSE due to missing bits and pieces of school and moving school.
I had a serious chat with him a few weeks ago and went through a book and it was totally news to him. He is still at the point of "eww, why would you do that" and shocked that MUMMY AND DADDY DID THAT.
He is adopted as is DD and at some point we need to explain that one of them is the result of sex for money - there is no way he is ready for that and DD is younger.

MedusasBadHairDay · 24/02/2022 09:19

I would expect a nine year old to know what sex is, and what a prostitute is.

No. Really no.

I'm all for kids knowing the facts about reproduction and their bodies, but there is no reason a 9 year old needs to know about prostitution.

Stompythedinosaur · 24/02/2022 09:18

I work with children who have been sexually trafficked and exploited - I have worked with numerous 10yos who have had this experience.

Yes, it is horrifying, but it is an increasing problem and knowledge is power. I have certainly explained to my 10 and 8yos what sexual exploitation is.

It drives me mad, actually. The nspcc pants rule is so widespread, bit we expect to be about to tell kids "what's in your pants is private" and not have any follow up questions about sexual abuse and why someone might want to see their privates.

Telling kids about sex and abuse doesn't stop them being innocent.

MrsMo21 · 24/02/2022 09:15

@ThinWomansBrain apologies - of course we go through consent and potential abuse by trusted members. Just for the purpose of a MN thread I didn’t really have time or the inclination to go through every single teaching point in my RSE curriculum. Please feel free to have a look at some online teaching curriculum tools for the whole low down on what we are meant to be covering.

Kgutdfn · 24/02/2022 09:13

FFS makes me want to home educate my baby when she grows older (I won't). Why can't kids be kids for a while.