This may already have been said, but university is not for everyone. Lots of people are ignoring the alternate criteria of EE at A Level. These are the lowest grades available at A Level, below that it’s a U. Students who cannot pass their A Levels will flounder at uni (if they get in). And if they do get in, they are likely going to an institution with very low entry requirements/expectations and therefore will be unlikely to ever land a job as a direct result of that degree that will earn them enough to pay back the loan. So essentially the tax payer is funding them and will never ever be paid back.
Don’t get me wrong, I don’t think the government have the right approach to equal opportunities in education. But rather than getting wound up that kids who are not a good fit for uni can’t go, we should be screaming about the fact that there are so few good alternatives for those kids. Vocational further education is shockingly underfunded. If the money saved from withdrawing these loans was redirected to that, that would be a pretty good policy in my view. (Admittedly haven’t read the proposal, but from previous form, I doubt this is their plan. Happy to be told I’m wrong!)