Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who is in the wrong here, me or partner?

113 replies

Sofiegiraffe · 23/02/2022 20:51

Bit of a back story - partner has form for putting his job first before anything else and not really considering that it's me left picking up the slack at home when he makes arrangements to do overtime etc that I don't know about... We've had a few disagreements about this in the past and he's agreed to always discuss any plans for extra shifts with me so I'm at least aware of when I'm alone with the baby.

Partner called me from work today to say he is extending a late shift next week (which is already a 7.30pm finish meaning he's home by 7.45pm) "by a couple of hours". We always discuss any changes to his shift pattern or overtime etc as we have a baby so I'd be left on my own with the baby if he's working a different pattern to normal. I said "ok" on the phone thinking this meant 9-9.30pm ish. He's just come home and informed me it's an 11pm finish, meaning home by 11.15pm. I expressed that I wasn't happy with this as it's an evening before work for me, and pre work evenings / work mornings are always stressful for me as I sort tea, bath baby, get all baby's things plus mine ready for the next day, settle baby for bed (a mammoth task as she doesn't sleep well), have a shower, make lunches for both myself and baby for the next day, clean the kitchen, etc. It really helps when I have a second pair of hands on those evenings. I (reluctantly) accepted 9.30pm finish, which is how he made it sound on the phone, but 11pm?! How is that "a couple of hours"?!

He says I'm being unfair as I "agreed to this on the phone". I say he wasn't clear on the phone (plus I was juggling baby at the time and trying to give her medicine etc...)

AIBU to think he wasn't clear and I didn't agree to this?!

OP posts:
Neenawneenaw76 · 24/02/2022 06:38

[quote OnaBegonia]@Graphista
Many workplaces have an opt
out of working time directive in their contracts, so gap between shifts doesn't apply.[/quote]
This isn't true, gaps between shifts always apply, you can ONLY opt out of the working hours limits, so if you opt out you can work 60 hours a week rather than 48, the gap between shifts remains as do all other leave rules (like 24 hour period off every week or 48 hours every 2 weeks).

Sofiegiraffe · 24/02/2022 06:36

@Graphista

Yes he's working more since the baby. But we have needed more money since the baby so I'm not entirely sure if this is just an avoidance tactic, although I am now questioning that.

I'm not sure if it's legal to do those shifts back to back to be honest.

I was FT before the baby yes.

OP posts:
Neenawneenaw76 · 24/02/2022 06:35

Honestly, are you sure he's at work? From what you've said it sounds like the shift patterns he's working are illegal and breach working limits, I can't see anywhere setting shifts for people from 6.30qm to 11pm. How do you know he is where he says he is?

Sofiegiraffe · 24/02/2022 06:34

Re finances. Yes, we share them in the sense that he makes a contribution each month to the shared household bills. Do I always know the exact amount he's paid and what's left in terms of disposable income? Not really...

OP posts:
Sofiegiraffe · 24/02/2022 06:33

@SC215

I would tell him that you need a shared calendar, you can get apps that do it, so that he can put his shifts in and you can see what he's working qnd what time he will be home.

Do you share finances/have access to his extra overtime money? Or is he making extra cash for himself to spend how he likes while you pick up the slack at home?

We have exactly this, it's agreed a month in advance - my working days and his shifts Inc any planned overtime. He often rings to make changes to this, that's where it falls down.

OP posts:
Sofiegiraffe · 24/02/2022 06:31

@OnaBegonia

In the big scheme of things is 4 hours really something to make a fuss about? Only on MN do I come across all these mums who MUST have DH at home of an evening as having one child is a mammoth task not to be managed alone.

You haven't read anything I've written clearly.

OP posts:
OnaBegonia · 23/02/2022 23:59

@Graphista
Many workplaces have an opt
out of working time directive in their contracts, so gap between shifts doesn't apply.

Graphista · 23/02/2022 23:53

Is he working more since you had the baby? To avoid being at home?

He can do overtime on other days that have no effect on the stress of my day / evening, he doesn't have to specifically do these hours.

Is he choosing to do overtime that means he's dodging "witching hour" with the baby (when the baby is tired and more fractious and needs more attention) ?

my mornings are more hectic and require more preparation than his anyway (his commute is 15 mins and no drop off).

Why isn't he pulling his weight in the mornings?

He was in the military for many years and was essentially conditioned to be "married" to his job.

Unfortunately very common in military types not pulling their weight at home

Time to put your foot down

This isn't I don't think just about the hours he does it's about his attitude to what needs done at home and who's responsibility he thinks it is - clue it's not just yours!

He's back in the next day at 6.30am so he wouldn't be doing drop off.

Is that even legal?! If he's doing a job managing anything manual especially machinery etc I'm pretty sure it's not!

And you're part time without being married? Were you full time before the baby?

OnaBegonia · 23/02/2022 23:52

In the big scheme of things is 4 hours really something to make a fuss about?
Only on MN do I come across all
these mums who MUST have DH at home of an evening as having one child is a mammoth task not to be managed alone.

Midlifemusings · 23/02/2022 23:48

I think you are being very nitpicky about the specific time. Neither of you specified a time - he said he would be late and you agreed.

However I think you need to address the bigger issue about how much time he is spending at work when he doesn't need to be there and you don't need the money. If he needed to be there to get his work done and it was expected or you needed the money - then fine. But in this case he is already leaving at 6:30 am and getting back at 7:45 pm most days. How much can he cut back without it impacting him at all work wise? I would have that conversation. He could aim to be home by 5:30 3 days a week if he really is just hanging about late those nights and not doing work that needs to be done.

SarahAndQuack · 23/02/2022 23:45

To me, an adult relationship means being able to have a discussion.

He thinks you agreed on the phone; you feel you were distracted and didn't. IMO it doesn't matter who thought what - you're not happy. If it's a one-off, a solution might be for you to go with it and him to make it up by arranging some child-free time for you later on?

I remember when DD was this age and I was biting DP's arm off come 6pm - it's those long shifts with a small child that are the killer!

Dibbydoos · 23/02/2022 23:43

Maybe he wasn't clear on purpose, but now you know his game you will next time be very specific with him, right?

This time, I def leave the kitchen. Also, talk about him dropping baby off when you've got to get to work. I hate that women are left accommodating kids, and men don't seem to need to - we are so capable, aren't we? Well, it's stressful, so drop some things onto him. I'd also suggest you agree absolutely no overtime if you're working the following day. Full stop.

Hope it all goes OK for you, you sadly stitched yourself up this time, but like I said, you know for next time....

tara66 · 23/02/2022 23:38

Let the kitchen cleaning and all the house work go for a few days - do they really matter? You do not have to clean the house at all.

NoSquirrels · 23/02/2022 23:27

Many millions of parents work full time & make dinner/bath the baby(&children) , do bedtime, prep for the next day etc. and do a bunch of school work, running kids to clubs, their own clubs/volunteering etc Just one small baby really isn't a big deal.

Wow, women supporting women, eh? Hmm

Those millions of parents all started out with just the one small baby. Then they worked their way up to coping with extra babies, kids at school & activities etc.

Don’t be an arse unless you absolutely can’t help it.

arethereanyleftatall · 23/02/2022 23:27

Some men work overtime to give their family the best finances they can.

Some men 'work' overtime to avoid home life.

I've included the first sentence as apparently they exist. Not my personal experience.

I remember when I started work in an office in my twenties needing to stay late one night, to finish something. By about 7pm all the bosses had gone and a group of middle aged blokes were drinking coffee and messing around in our lunch type area. I didn't think much of it at the time other than 'why don't they go home?' Once I'd had kids, I knew why. They all came back down at about 8pm, and fired off a few emails. One was promoted, I presume due to all the hours he put in, as in - the hours he was physically present in the office. Grr.

LightSpeeds · 23/02/2022 23:26

You say he's always been like this and was conditioned to be married to his job... Well, nothing has changed. He's still putting his job first and I'm sorry that you've chosen this man to have a child with as he doesn't seem very invested in family life. You probably need to have a very serious think about how you want the future to look and what compromise is possible with him.

peachy3 · 23/02/2022 23:23

I don’t think YABU, maybe asking him what time he would’ve been finishing would have helped but then at the same time he could have told you that without you having to ask so I suppose that’s a 50/50 miscommunication. It’s not unreasonable to want him, the other parent to your child, to be there to help. Not only that but to also be there to spend the evening as a family. If it’s not necessary overtime and he just enjoys being at work then I’d honestly be a little offended and quite irritated too. You’re not your daughters only parent, you both are and you both have jobs, his should never take priority over yours so the workload of home life should be as equal as possible.

Namechange12312 · 23/02/2022 23:23

Sounds like you had crossed wires and you have maybe overreacted a little. He’s working, not at the pub. Sure it’s hard work preparing for the next day alone but how long does it really take to make lunch? Leave the kitchen for one evening. He has given you plenty of notice so could you prep throughout the day? Personally I would let this one slide then when you’re feeling calmer sit him down and have a conversation about which days you would like him to be home ‘on time’ to help. I don’t mean to be rude but I am often on my own with 3 children under 8 (and have been since they were babies) and managed to get all of that done well before 11pm.

SC215 · 23/02/2022 23:22

I would tell him that you need a shared calendar, you can get apps that do it, so that he can put his shifts in and you can see what he's working qnd what time he will be home.

Do you share finances/have access to his extra overtime money? Or is he making extra cash for himself to spend how he likes while you pick up the slack at home?

Sofiegiraffe · 23/02/2022 23:19

@Doodar

he's avoiding all the boring stuff at home, lots of men do it, they miss the whole evening routine.

It's very convenient for them isn't it .....

OP posts:
SC215 · 23/02/2022 23:18

OP please don't listen to anything FantasticFebruary has said.

You are not the default parent.

Sofiegiraffe · 23/02/2022 23:17

@FantasticFebruary

I did say I was distracted giving the baby medicine (wrestling with her) when he called. I had him on loudspeaker while I was sorting her out and he said he'd been asked about extending a particular late shift by "a couple hours". Yes ok, perhaps I should have said "what time will you be finishing?" but I was a little preoccupied. He didn't mention a finish time though, either. Then to later say "you agreed to it on the phone" when I wasn't aware of the finish time, just isn't true.

I don't think feeling overwhelmed with juggling work and a baby equals a diagnosis of PND. I think many parents often feel this way especially with babies who don't settle / sleep well. I don't think wanting my partner home before 11pm to lend a hand means I have a mental health problem.

OP posts:
Doodar · 23/02/2022 23:12

he's avoiding all the boring stuff at home, lots of men do it, they miss the whole evening routine.

Sofiegiraffe · 23/02/2022 23:12

@FawnFrenchieMum

YABU for the amount of times you’ve said baby in your OP.
🙄
OP posts:
FawnFrenchieMum · 23/02/2022 23:11

YABU for the amount of times you’ve said baby in your OP.