Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have got angry with sister over the state of her house?

183 replies

ThreePac · 23/02/2022 20:05

Last year my sister came over to my house and suddenly burst into tears saying she was sick of her house being a shithole. She’s never been houseproud but to be honest her house has got gradually worse over the years, nothing gets redecorated , stained carpets don’t get cleaned, walls don’t get washed or repainted, broken stuff doesn’t get replaced … but I’ve never said anything as she seemed happy living like that and it wasn’t my place to question it. She was so upset and kept going on about how she loved my house but can’t seem to recreate it herself. So, I offered to help her do it up. We spent months repainting, buying replacement doors to replace the ones with holes in etc!! We recarpeted (money was never the issue) and I went around shops with her picking on out rugs, cushions, curtains, vases, mirrors etc … you name it. We completely redid her house and it took months of hard work. It looked beautiful when we’d finished and she loved it, I was so happy for her. She was posting photos on social media and everything.

I’ve not been to her house since last September.

She invited me over today. Walking into the kitchen one of the cupboard doors was hanging off and there was food splattered all over the walls and used tea bags just splattered onto the work tops. The house stunk of poo and wee from the dog … she said “look at this, you’ll love it” and took me to the living room. She’d pulled all her furniture out and given the entire room to the dog. There was stains all over the carpet and just a dog bed in the middle of the room. She’d put all her living room furniture into the dining room squashing the dining table up against the wall. I said “what the fuck have you done?” And she replied “given the dog his own room so that I dont get the rest of the house messy!” The fucking living room???!! I spent weeks decorating that for her. I’m livid. I ended up telling her “THIS is why your house never looks nice! You don’t look after stuff and make stupid decisions!” She got defensive and said it was her house and she could live however she wants. I replied “yes, but don’t ask me to help you with it ever again”.

Obviously we’re now not talking. Yes it’s her house but why let me spend months trying to make it look nice for her if she prefers it being a shithole???

OP posts:
WindyKnickers · 23/02/2022 22:40

@NellWilsonsWhiteHair

I get why you feel fed up but I think YABU, sorry. Helping her get it sorted was a kind thing, but she doesn't owe you anything in return.

It does sound like for whatever reason she really struggles to know how to keep it nice. Depression? Exec function problems? I would be wary of making it your problem to solve though if you can't do that without expectation.

I agree with this. You don't need to help her if it's too stressful for you to see her let things go to ruin again but you also don't need to fall out with her about it. You don't have to live there or even visit and she doesn't need to keep it nice for your benefit.
Whataboutye88 · 23/02/2022 22:40

I completely agree with everything @lborgia says. It’s so easy to brand someone as lazy or filthy, but your sister is obviously distressed by the condition of her house or she wouldn’t have asked for your help to start with it. That’s not to say you’re not justified to feel immensely frustrated, but there are obviously deep-rooted issues at play here that aren’t just your sister being ‘lazy’.

Embracelife · 23/02/2022 22:38

She sounds unwell. Tell her gp your concerns. They can decide what to do with the information

lborgia · 23/02/2022 22:38

@lljkk - I agree, it's as if she sees the dog as a special doll, that needs a dolls house. She not seeing it as a separate sentient being, with its own needs and demands.

Much like the children actually.

TatianaBis · 23/02/2022 22:36

It’s surely recipe for a dog going crazy and attacking someone in the house that it’s never allowed our for a walk. One has to hope it’s not aggressive as well as strong.

MimiDaisy11 · 23/02/2022 22:35

She doesn’t sound well. I know people have said you just get lazy people but the way she’s dealing with the dog suggests she can’t deal with issues like a normal person. I mean I’ve been lazy and unclean in my student days but this is something else. Also you say she just laughs it off but that’s what you are on the surface and could just be defensive.

lborgia · 23/02/2022 22:35

Understanding is not the same as making excuses, which implies that I just think they should be allowed to carry on as they are.

I'm not saying that at all. I think it's cruel to say someone is lazy, when it's something outside of their control.

lljkk · 23/02/2022 22:33

I'm not understanding the no-dog-walks thing. There's a petite 60+yo woman up the road who walks an energetic over-excitable husky daily by my home -- she knows how to handle him. I sometimes see a local woman walking 2 giant super-sized huskies on the beach (to be fair, they are pretty mellow). But enormous dogs, for sure.

No excuses.

I'm a complete slattern but I couldn't stand to be in sister's house, either.

BornBlonde · 23/02/2022 22:31

I'm concerned that her children think the way they are living is normal. Was the husband their father? If so how selfish he left without then

Also concerned for your sister and the dog.

Agree there must be an underlying cause. I would report to the RSPCA & SS though appreciate no previous assistance was given

lborgia · 23/02/2022 22:30

Just because she's laughs and appears to think it's funny, doesn't mean there isn't something underlying it. The"funny" might be a coping mechanism, or something is going on with the wiring in her brain.

Pp who said this was bollocks, well despite your clear and scientific response, I would still argue that no one is "just" anything.

You rarely see any other animal live in its own mess, and generally it is human nature to keep some sort of order..at least in the food and sleeping areas.

Anyone who is living in squalor has a glitch somewhere.

As for those who proudly agree they're lazy - they've probably assumed that is what it is.

Lots of us tell ourselves we're lazy, stupid etc. Partly because we don't understand why we do things, partly because charming relatives tell us so. Hmm

The 4 or 5 friends I know who really struggle with varying degrees of mess/squalor, have all told me they are just lazy at some point or another.

They have also, at other times, told me about their adhd, anxiety, abuse, etc etc. Incapable of creating boundaries for kids because they had such a miserable childhood they can't bear to tell them off. Staring at something that needs doing, but literally fell unable to start the project. Anxious at the very thought of throwing things away.

None of these are normal situations. None of them have ever made a link in their own minds.

Just got to their 50s still berating themselves for being stupid, thick, lazy, bad...

Even when you have had the links explained to you, it doesn't mean you can stop/ keep to a plan.

I'm probably wasting my breath. So much easier to judge people than try to understand.

PurpleDaisies · 23/02/2022 22:30

But anger, YABU.

Anger is totally understandable. The op is absolutely allowed to vent here.

Chrispackhamspoodle · 23/02/2022 22:29

You can't fix her op.My family were similar and I spent wasted time trying to do just that. Infuriating and depressing if you let it get to you.

saraclara · 23/02/2022 22:27

@CJsGoldfish

She’s always been like this, it’s why her husband left her Nice. So she got what she deserved?

Do you even LIKE your sister?
This is not normal behaviour but, if everyone has just written her off as just 'being like that', I can see why it's continued.

Given the effort that OP put in, I'd say that she must like her sister to a degree. But I do wonder why no-one worried about these kids when they were younger.
PuzzledObserver · 23/02/2022 22:23

If you’d asked AIBU to be upset/disappointed/concerned about my sister’s house, I’d have said YANBU after you put in all that effort for nothing.

But anger, YABU.

Either there is something wrong (depression or ADHD spring to mind - NB I am not a doctor), in which case she needs compassion and support - when she is ready to accept it.

Or there is nothing wrong - and she is exercising her right to live as she chooses. And you can exercise your right never to clean up her house again.

Macademiamum · 23/02/2022 22:22

I think the ship has sailed regarding the teenagers. Social services have a high bar for removing teens, no matter how messy a house it won't cut it. It's not like with babies where they are crawling around and putting everything in their mouths. Even then social services don't have much sway even with total squalor unless there is other abuse or neglect.
The dog on the other hand, cannot clean the house itself can it? Doesn't escape to school or college. Doesn't even get walked. And what happens to dogs like that? They usually end up hurting somebody. That's what happens to dogs who are neglected. At that point it will be put down. Much better for it to be given up or taken now.

sst1234 · 23/02/2022 22:18

@lborgia

OMG the lack of insight and empathy is revolting.

I understand the OP feeling angry after all the work she put in, but seriously, did she really not have a clue that there were bigger issues here?

No one is JUST lazy. No one. How can you have known your own sister all these years, and not realise she has some kind of issues.

If she wasn't always liked this, something was a trigger, if she had always been this way, why had no one tried to get her help? Why would you think buying fucking vases would fix everything?

Completely bloody clueless.

Of course no one thinks they’re lazy. Not when you have people making excuses for laziness. It’s not empathy to constantly make excuses for people, it’s cruel and patronising.
CJsGoldfish · 23/02/2022 22:16

She’s always been like this, it’s why her husband left her
Nice. So she got what she deserved?

Do you even LIKE your sister?
This is not normal behaviour but, if everyone has just written her off as just 'being like that', I can see why it's continued.

SartresSoul · 23/02/2022 22:13

Guessing she’s mentally ill, there’s no other logical explanation for any of this. Making the dog its own room as if that’s totally normal is something my SIL would do during a manic episode, she has bipolar. It often goes undiagnosed for many years, people just think they’re eccentric or a bit wacky. You can’t force her to get help but she clearly needs it.

Fredstheteds · 23/02/2022 22:12

Why do people get a dog that has the potential to be so unsuitable. If you don’t want to walk it or can’t don’t have it. The dogs behaviour is worrying and yuck is all I can say. Poor animal. Please get the dog out of there

BananaPlants · 23/02/2022 22:11

Does she have behaviours associated with ADHD?

www.ameridisability.com/post/women-and-add-the-hidden-disability-what-you-need-to-know-about-attention-deficit-disorder/

oakleaffy · 23/02/2022 22:10

A “Strong” dog that cannot be walked because it pulls to much is wanton cruelty.
RSPCA have taken Staffies and Pits from houses like you described, encrusted with excrement and urine, and the dogs were never taken out.
It’s awful people like this keep animals ..
Never mind Children 😟

AutomaticMoon · 23/02/2022 22:09

Sounds like there’s more to this story. Does she have autism/executive dysfunction or a mental illness?

TatianaBis · 23/02/2022 22:02

What do you think OP, do you think she’s depressed? Or just naturally slovenly?

House proud MNers may assume a dirty house can only indicate mental illness, but some people genuinely just messy and dirty by nature.

MRS54321 · 23/02/2022 21:59

OP, yes it her house but it doesn’t mean you can’t be disappointed or frustrated at all your work going down hill
As others have said, this is ab normal and sounds like someone who can’t cope. ( a lazy person wouldn’t cry about it, surely?)
The only thing you can do is inform social services re: teens /dirty home/dog shit etc
But you probably won’t be thanked for it.
And the dog … well that’s just adding to the chaos

My own family are like this : think it’s normal when it’s gotten completely out of control.

marymay62 · 23/02/2022 21:58

As mentioned I think your sister has some serious problems. Do you have any contact with your nephew and niece ? Have you ever been concerned about their care ? Giving a room over to a dog to crap in is not within a normative range of behaviour with 3 children at home , even if one is an adult, and one 17. There is a 15 year old girl there . I would be worried for her - I would try and have a talk with your niece and make sure she is ok, sod the house !