Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask would you be happy in a relationship only ever having sex whilst actively TTC?

59 replies

FrustratedTeddyLamp · 23/02/2022 19:59

Im just interested in seeing the answers due to another thread where there are lots of posters saying if men don't want children they shouldn't have sex. I don't really want to get into that on this thread I'm just trying to be completely open about the context of the question.

I'm just interested how many other posters would be happy with this solution? Would you be happy to be in a relationship when you both only have sex when wanting a child? So not just for fun or waiting 8 years after your wedding night if you get married at 22 but don't want kids until your 30s

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
YoBeaches · 24/02/2022 06:29

@FrustratedTeddyLamp

But would you be happy if your partner said he wasn't happy to accept any risk at all that your contraception (and condoms) could fail, and therefore would only have sex when you were TTC?

I assume that's what OP means, as an abstract idea...q

^ was more of a point not in a quote as I know some don't read replies that seem longer

Exactly this. If a partner said this to me then he wouldn't be my partner and I wouldn't have sex with him.

The burden on women is horrific. A little more honesty and ownership from men would be refreshing.

JPI7 · 23/02/2022 23:25

We pretty much have this relationship. We have lots of foreplay and always orgasm but no penetration as I find it painful as he is pretty big and he doesn’t want any more kids. He is happy with BJ’s and HJ’s.

ImInStealthMode · 23/02/2022 23:15

Interesting thread OP, and the other one.

I do see where you're coming from. It's all very well to talk about contraception but when it comes down to it if a Woman's contraception fails during sex for pleasure and she doesn't want children she still has a choice (and rightly so).

If a Man is perfectly sensible with contraception and has sex for pleasure but it fails, his future then depends entirely on the Woman's decision.

Likewise I'm sure there have been Men who've been desperate to keep a surprise baby, but whose partner has chosen to abort. I appreciate that is whole different kettle of fish and that no Woman could ever be expected to follow through with a pregnancy she didn't want, but it doesn't make it any easier on the Man and there's often a stark lack of sympathy around that kind of scenario, especially on MN.

Mangoberries · 23/02/2022 22:46

Great thread!
If a man doesnt want children but wants sex, what options does he have?
Condoms, which arent 100% reliable, and then he must take responsibility for a child he doesnt want.
No PIV at all was suggested, which by this thread isnt a very popular option and women suggesting this didnt mean it literally Confused
He could have a vasectomy, which I'm not sure would be easy unless he went private, as most doctors dont want to perform sterilisation for someone who doesnt see it as a permanent option. A man who has not had children would find it tough to get a dr to agree to perform a vasectomy.

If my DH had a vasectomy before he met me, and said it was because he didnt want to risk a pregnancy, and we had to go through the whole reversal procedure, potentially never having children, that would be awful.

Would I only ever have sex whilst TTC?
If the man was worried enough about pregnancy and didnt want to risk a contraceptive failure with condoms, then yes.
However, this wouldnt just affect us before we had children, but also when we had completed our family.
We would be in a sexless marriage once we had finished our family of neither of us wanted any more children, or to be sterilised. Shock

wompom · 23/02/2022 22:28

In answer to the OP, not particularly but this is the situation I find myself in. It doesn't bother me enough to leave him though. He's a good man & a good father to our DC.

scarpa · 23/02/2022 22:15

It's tricky isn't it, because I read this and thought - well, that's effectively a conversation DH and I had early on.

I don't want kids, nor does he. We're both settled on that and in agreement that we'd terminate any accidental pregnancy (we use contraception, of course, and DH will be looking at a vasectomy after this IUD of mine runs out - we agreed 10 years of reversible methods in case one of us changed our mind and then we'd look at one or both of us making more permanent choices when we were old enough for the doctor to be more likely to take our decisions seriously).

We have sex with both of us under the assumption the other person would agree with the choice to terminate should I get pregnant. But the risk for me (in terms of having/not having a baby) is much lower - were I to get pregnant and change my mind, I have the control and he has none. Were I to get pregnant and HE changed his mind and wanted us to keep the baby, he still has no control and I still have it all.

He has to take it far more on trust than me when we have sex with fallible (if very safe) contraceptives.

If he was unhappy with that minimal but still not zero level of risk and decided for us not to have sex again, I wouldn't be happy, it's not what I signed up for.

(Obviously in the real world he can ask ask a vasectomy and that'd be that issue solved but as a thought experiment... interesting)

JellybabyGina87 · 23/02/2022 21:55

No but in a relationship you can talk about contraception. I'm sterilised so I don't need to worry about it but if I did fall pregnant I'd know my husband wouldn't leave me. I think the argument was more about men who have casual sex unprotected and then say afterwards they don't want a baby.

dworky · 23/02/2022 21:49

Double up with the condoms or no penetration. Most women don't get pleasure from penetration anyway.

TravellingFrom · 23/02/2022 21:46

I agree @HowlongWillThisTakeNow

It would be no kid = no sex = no relationship UNLESS both partners know they don’t want kids ever and have a vasectomy or tube tied.

It could open a world where women would freeze their eggs at a young age. Men would do the same for their Sperm and they could only conceive through IVF?? But they could safely have sex 😁😁

HowlongWillThisTakeNow · 23/02/2022 21:39

This is v much not a Poor Men comment - there are PLENTY, a worrying majority in fact, of men who don't consider this for a single second until the pregnancy happens and then they realise they should have thought for 0.1 second about the potential consequences. But in theory, were a man to try and behave according to his wish to take 0 risk to have a child, that'd be unacceptable to a lot of partners too and while I don't think most men are having sex out of the goodness of their heart to keep their partners happy, it's interesting to wonder what would happen if this approach was adopted en masse by men.

Interesting idea, I would say that at beginning of my relationships my female partners have probably wanted sex as much ( 1 partner more) than me, so I suppose one conclusion could be that no kids = no sex = no relationships.

Maybe a logical conclusion could be that the only sex would be for procreation and not fun, so why would people be in relationships at all ?

FrustratedTeddyLamp · 23/02/2022 21:30

I didn't know I'd had a sex change thanks for informing me

OP posts:
OppsUpsSide · 23/02/2022 21:29

Absolutely, not a fan of sex.

NeverChange · 23/02/2022 21:27

Hell no.

My brain actually hurts from trying to figure out your thinking on this one!!!!

TravellingFrom · 23/02/2022 21:21

@FrustratedTeddyLamp

😅But would you be happy if your partner said he wasn't happy to accept any risk at all that your contraception (and condoms) could fail, and therefore would only have sex when you were TTC?

I assume that's what OP means, as an abstract idea...😂 Yes you've explained more easily than me but I was trying to avoid loads of obstacles that ended up creating more

If the question is for a relationship that is established and strong, is it ok to say ‘nope not having sex unless ttc as it’s a too big risk’, then I’d say:

I assume this would have been the case right form the start so both partners would know and have agreed to that in the first place.

If your question is whether this is a satisfying arrangement, then the answer is clearly NO. That’s why men and women have always had sex despite the risks before contraception existed.

However, it is also possible to still have sex with no risk of pg at all. Men have a vasectomy. Women have their tube tied. You can still have sex wo the risk of pg.
This is Obviously incompatible with ‘I still want to keep the possibility to have a child later on’. It’s a choice really.

RedWingBoots · 23/02/2022 21:17

@Regularsizedrudy

What bizarre point are you trying to make exactly?
He wants to control the bodies of the women he sleeps with.

He can't get his head around the idea that if he has PIV sex and contraception fails (or more likely he can't be bothered to wear a condom), then he has no choice on what the woman decides to do with her body.

The OP fails to realise that until a child is born (at least in the UK) it is not a separate individual but regarded as part of a woman's body. Once the child is born then as he provided genetic material for half the child he has legal responsibilities to that child.

FrustratedTeddyLamp · 23/02/2022 21:16

But would you be happy if your partner said he wasn't happy to accept any risk at all that your contraception (and condoms) could fail, and therefore would only have sex when you were TTC?

I assume that's what OP means, as an abstract idea...q

^ was more of a point not in a quote as I know some don't read replies that seem longer

OP posts:
TravellingFrom · 23/02/2022 21:12

Wo contraception I would be very weary of having sex if not TTC. I know that when I didn’t want a child, the fear if a possible pregnancy despite the OCP was very much there. I don’t think would have taken that risk wo it.

I would also have considered having my tubes tied to avoid the risk once I had the children I wanted.

FrustratedTeddyLamp · 23/02/2022 21:12

I wish I just wrote that now but starting another thread with just that wrote seems wasteful

OP posts:
FrustratedTeddyLamp · 23/02/2022 21:08

😅But would you be happy if your partner said he wasn't happy to accept any risk at all that your contraception (and condoms) could fail, and therefore would only have sex when you were TTC?

I assume that's what OP means, as an abstract idea...😂 Yes you've explained more easily than me but I was trying to avoid loads of obstacles that ended up creating more

OP posts:
Regularsizedrudy · 23/02/2022 21:04

What bizarre point are you trying to make exactly?

scarpa · 23/02/2022 21:02

@konasana

I'd be happy with it but only while using contraception that I was in control of.

I say this as someone who commented on the other thread that the only way a man can exercise his right to not have a baby is to not have sex. If I was a man, I'd be using condoms and accepting the fact that it could fail, or I'd refrain completely.

But would you be happy if your partner said he wasn't happy to accept any risk at all that your contraception (and condoms) could fail, and therefore would only have sex when you were TTC?

I assume that's what OP means, as an abstract idea...

That a lot of women wouldn't be okay with their partner abstaining entirely at all non-TTC times, but it's reasonably likely that some of those women would also be angry/upset/not want to take into account if a partner wasn't ready for a child as a result of an unplanned pregnancy due to contraception failure, citing that he knew it'd be a risk... so he's damned if he does and damned if he doesn't.

This is v much not a Poor Men comment - there are PLENTY, a worrying majority in fact, of men who don't consider this for a single second until the pregnancy happens and then they realise they should have thought for 0.1 second about the potential consequences. But in theory, were a man to try and behave according to his wish to take 0 risk to have a child, that'd be unacceptable to a lot of partners too and while I don't think most men are having sex out of the goodness of their heart to keep their partners happy, it's interesting to wonder what would happen if this approach was adopted en masse by men.

needmoreshinys · 23/02/2022 21:02

But there'd still be sex education and not be a secret that it's pleasurable. And yeah I fucked up saying only wanting sex when TTC. So yeah there'd be sexual urges etc but no rape!

But in certain schools, it is a secret that its pleasurable, which is where teenage pregnancies happen.

My whole point is, you can keep putting in a ton of shit rules to make yoru point, but you have missed the point of the original thread and you have now changed it to be completely different

HowlongWillThisTakeNow · 23/02/2022 21:00

😭

FrustratedTeddyLamp · 23/02/2022 20:55

@HowlongWillThisTakeNow

I’m a man, over 50, have been using condoms for 30 years for ‘fun’ sex, no unplanned pregnancies, no ttc. Last partner was post menopause and we both had STI tests and stopped using condoms ( her suggestion), and that made me feel abit anxious, bit like not using a safety net ! But since I never really wanted children, I suppose I would be a virgin still, and maybe never been in a relationship, or have the snip ?
You'd be a virgin in this scenario
OP posts:
HowlongWillThisTakeNow · 23/02/2022 20:53

I’m a man, over 50, have been using condoms for 30 years for ‘fun’ sex, no unplanned pregnancies, no ttc.
Last partner was post menopause and we both had STI tests and stopped using condoms ( her suggestion), and that made me feel abit anxious, bit like not using a safety net !
But since I never really wanted children, I suppose I would be a virgin still, and maybe never been in a relationship, or have the snip ?