Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Being offended by “womanface” (drag) is bizarre

158 replies

MrsWinters · 23/02/2022 16:41

Is anyone else thrown by the fact the Daily Mail has described the concept of being offended by drag as bizarre? I thought there was enough debate on the topic-and it has been going on for long enough to not be labelled as “bizarre”.
I’m not saying that I want to ban drag or anything, but surely I have a right to find it offensive? Otherwise aren’t we into the realms of thoughtcrime?

OP posts:
WiseUpJanetWeiss · 24/02/2022 09:35

The widely held theory of the feminism boards is that males wearing female clothing are generally assumed to be seeking sexual thrills, and how would people know if they're not, so they should just stop doing it, for the sake of women and children.

It is entirely averse to males transcending the social norms of attire for their sex, and that's pretty regressive and restrictive for the males in our society.

Impressive straw man you have there.

The objection is to men saying that women's clothing makes them women.

Carbiesdreamhouse · 24/02/2022 09:23

I think most on the feminism boards are fine with men wearing whatever they want. It's when they identify as women becomes offensive. Dave in a dress, fine. Dave in a dress who insists that wearing a dress makes him a woman (because that's what all women wear obvs), insists we all call him 'they', insists he has periods and insists access to the women's loos. Nope.

suggestionsplease1 · 24/02/2022 09:04

@Waitwhat23

You mean when publically available examples are given of AGP males becoming sexually aroused when wearing women's clothing, and who wear women's clothing specifically to seek sexual pleasure? Are you accusing the men given in my example above of this? Or is that a completely different scenario to the one you referenced which was 'But certain sections of society, eg as may be found on the feminism boards here, maintain a viewpoint that this is deviant, perverted act, and this makes it harder for men to step outside of conventional norms for clothing, and ensures the continued popularity of drag queens.' You really don't see a difference between Men exploring gendered clothing, who are not seeking a sexual thrill,

And threads referencing AGP are deleted because it is a banned term because the misogynistic monitors really don't like it being discussed.

But you know that.

I'd be very surprised

The widely held theory of the feminism boards is that males wearing female clothing are generally assumed to be seeking sexual thrills, and how would people know if they're not, so they should just stop doing it, for the sake of women and children.

It is entirely averse to males transcending the social norms of attire for their sex, and that's pretty regressive and restrictive for the males in our society.

Darley368 · 24/02/2022 08:45

And I agree that the "aspirational" women in the media who are filled, surgically enhanced, fake tanned and dressed in a ridiculous manner are also caricatures of women. They are catering to the male porn market pure and simple.

Darley368 · 24/02/2022 08:42

Men could presumably be drag queens without large fake tits, tons of slap and clingy outfits whilst talking to each other in a completely affected bitchy way. They don't though because to them those are the defining characteristics of women. I agree with those who say it is autogynephilia.

Humour does not have to be at someone else's expense and is not a justification.

WiseUpJanetWeiss · 24/02/2022 08:34

I don't find drag acts offensive per se. Priscilla Queen of the Desert is one of my favourite "Oh let's just watch something funny" movies. I really don't like the use of the term "fishy" though. The term feels hatefully offensive to me.

And a pp mentioned clowns. I think that may be a huge part of it. Drag acts as they often appear these days (Drag Queen story time pictures) are in the "uncanny valley" and they are frankly frightening. Interestingly, I have a similar reaction to filled, sculpted and extremely made-up (mostly) women.

Stroopwaffle5000 · 24/02/2022 01:06

@Wonnle

There must be a phobia for it , a bit like the one people have of clowns . Most of them look like they should be in a circus act to me anyway
Yes!!! They freak me out in the way that clowns do! I remember being scared of them as a kid and I still don't like them now! Their heels and wigs make them appear even taller than they are and their whole presence is loud and intimidating!
ImJustMadAboutSaffron · 24/02/2022 01:05

I saw a guy in one of the university buildings on Monday. They had a wig on and make up resembling Dusty Springfield in the 60s, a pink and white dress and pink cardigan, tights and tennis shoes. They looked most definitely masculine. I've no idea who this was, member of staff or student, if they were transitioning or in drag. But students were staring, whispering and pointing/smirking.

PenStation · 24/02/2022 00:58

Men and women should have the freedom to wear what they want. But drag is offensive and unfunny.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 24/02/2022 00:46

But certain sections of society, eg as may be found on the feminism boards here, maintain a viewpoint that this is deviant, perverted act, and this makes it harder for men to step outside of conventional norms for clothing, and ensures the continued popularity of drag queens.

LOL yes it's all the fault of FWR of course.

Jaxhog · 23/02/2022 23:39

@balalake

I am offended by part of my licence fee (and everyone else's) being spent on Mrs Brown's Boys. Mind you, the fact it is full of foul language, not funny, and some of cast are alleged tax avoiders may be a large part, not the lead character being a man in drag.
This program is actually much more offensive.
Jaxhog · 23/02/2022 23:37

Not saying there's nothing wrong with Drag, but you do get women dressing as men for comic effect e.g. French and Saunders, Kathy Burke as Perry

The difference is that drag queens always have oversized boobs hanging out and exaggerated makeup. And they talk all camp as if this is what women talk like.

willithappen · 23/02/2022 23:27

Do you know any drag queens? Ask them why they are doing it?
I know plenty, and not one of them do it to parody women. They have a love for the clothing, make up etc

If you think that we, as women, are defined by these clothes and make up then I believe that's the issue. I'm not in the slightest offended or feel it's making fun/light of women.

CounsellorTroi · 23/02/2022 22:57

Erm. Drag Kings? Some fabulous male impersonation artists/entertainers.

Like Melissa McCarthy doing Sean Spicer.

Dick Emery/Stanley Baxter in the 70s were not “drag queens”.

Witheringtong · 23/02/2022 22:41

I think people are confused as the vote is opposite to the thread title.

RufustheFloralmissingreindeer · 23/02/2022 22:34

Absolutely you have the right to be offended by it

And im slightly surprised that as many as 18% of posters think you haven’t got that right

WiseUpJanetWeiss · 23/02/2022 22:14

@suggestionsplease1

There are constant references to autogynephilia on the feminism boards whenever males wearing women's clothes come up.

Then it turns into cries about women 'unwillingly being made to validate men's fetishes' just by being in the same room as a male wearing women's clothes.

And then, when posters get more graphic in their descriptions of what they think men are up to when wearing women's clothes, the mods delete the thread.

So I'm sorry - I would love to provide links to the threads, but they're always taken down.

Mumsnet - can you reinstate the deleted ones so we can all see what happens please? Thanks.

I think you have completely misunderstood. Most of the FWR posters have no problem at all with men wearing clothing traditionally associated with women. Why would they? Most feminists reject gender norms.

The issue is with adult males claiming that they are women and using women's spaces and competing in women's sports, so women have no female-only spaces and female-only sports. It's also with men using transwomen as Trojan horses to gain access to women's spaces.

Waitwhat23 · 23/02/2022 22:13

Posted too soon. Last sentence should read - I'd be very surprised if this post (and your own) aren't deleted for merely referencing AGP.

Waitwhat23 · 23/02/2022 22:12

You mean when publically available examples are given of AGP males becoming sexually aroused when wearing women's clothing, and who wear women's clothing specifically to seek sexual pleasure? Are you accusing the men given in my example above of this? Or is that a completely different scenario to the one you referenced which was 'But certain sections of society, eg as may be found on the feminism boards here, maintain a viewpoint that this is deviant, perverted act, and this makes it harder for men to step outside of conventional norms for clothing, and ensures the continued popularity of drag queens.' You really don't see a difference between Men exploring gendered clothing, who are not seeking a sexual thrill,

And threads referencing AGP are deleted because it is a banned term because the misogynistic monitors really don't like it being discussed.

But you know that.

I'd be very surprised

suggestionsplease1 · 23/02/2022 22:00

There are constant references to autogynephilia on the feminism boards whenever males wearing women's clothes come up.

Then it turns into cries about women 'unwillingly being made to validate men's fetishes' just by being in the same room as a male wearing women's clothes.

And then, when posters get more graphic in their descriptions of what they think men are up to when wearing women's clothes, the mods delete the thread.

So I'm sorry - I would love to provide links to the threads, but they're always taken down.

Mumsnet - can you reinstate the deleted ones so we can all see what happens please? Thanks.

balalake · 23/02/2022 21:46

I am offended by part of my licence fee (and everyone else's) being spent on Mrs Brown's Boys. Mind you, the fact it is full of foul language, not funny, and some of cast are alleged tax avoiders may be a large part, not the lead character being a man in drag.

Libertybear80 · 23/02/2022 21:43

It seems a real week for misogynistic gay men. First I watch the Adam Kay drama and that's belittling women in Labour then I read about John barrowman sticking his penis in his female colleagues faces and now womanface! What next?

Waitwhat23 · 23/02/2022 21:31

But certain sections of society, eg as may be found on the feminism boards here, maintain a viewpoint that this is deviant, perverted act, and this makes it harder for men to step outside of conventional norms for clothing, and ensures the continued popularity of drag queens.

I mean, this is nonsense in regards to the Feminism board. Men wearing traditionally 'feminine' clothes - Harry Styles, Billy Porter and the new romantics of the 70's and 80's - these are all examples of men wearing what they like. Fab!

What they aren't/weren't doing is presenting a ridiculously caricatured version of a women - fake boobs and over the top make up.

And the term 'fishy', referring to the smell of women's genitals, used as widespread terminology in drag is appallingly misogynistic. It's hard to understand how those who defend drag as not offensive to women are able to justify that to themselves.

WiseUpJanetWeiss · 23/02/2022 21:26

you only need to look at the feminism boards here to see the fury and accusations of perversion levelled at men that dare to step outside of conventional clothing for their sex.

What? Please provide receipts. I'd be very surprised if anyone on FWR said that men shouldn't wear traditionally feminine clothing, and if they did they were perverts. After all, many of us were teens and twenties in the 1980s.

suggestionsplease1 · 23/02/2022 21:10

It comes down to this: would it be hilarious and fabulous to see a woman dress in a suit or a dinner jacket? No. And that's not because 'women have more freedom in what to wear'. It's because things women have historically chosen or been expected to do and wear are viewed as either frivolous or sexual by men.

It would certainly have been both hilarious and fabulous to see a woman dress in a suit or a dinner jacket in the 1860s or 70s. Male impersonators had very popular stage acts during these decades and beyond.

Their popularity was due to their contrast with the social norms of the time, which did not conventionally permit women to wear masculine attire. Their acts involved accentuated portrayals of masculinity beyond attire - movement, voice etc - the more 'hyper masculine' the performance, the more popular the impersonator was.

And that is exactly what we are seeing now.

Drag kings do not seem so salient now (outside of LGBT+ community anyway) because it is not unusual or entertaining to see women wearing masculine attire: it is entirely conventional . And entirely unconventional for men to wear women's clothing.

When we get to a time that men can wear women's clothing and for it to be unexceptional, I imagine we will see a decrease in drag queens.

But certain sections of society, eg as may be found on the feminism boards here, maintain a viewpoint that this is deviant, perverted act, and this makes it harder for men to step outside of conventional norms for clothing, and ensures the continued popularity of drag queens.