Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Being offended by “womanface” (drag) is bizarre

158 replies

MrsWinters · 23/02/2022 16:41

Is anyone else thrown by the fact the Daily Mail has described the concept of being offended by drag as bizarre? I thought there was enough debate on the topic-and it has been going on for long enough to not be labelled as “bizarre”.
I’m not saying that I want to ban drag or anything, but surely I have a right to find it offensive? Otherwise aren’t we into the realms of thoughtcrime?

OP posts:
MarshaBradyo · 24/02/2022 15:34

I agree with Jellyfizz on last few posts

PlopperDoo · 24/02/2022 15:27

Oh and naturally we need to be cool with it being introduced to our children too.

Fuck that.

WiseUpJanetWeiss · 24/02/2022 15:27

The way it appears to work, to me, is that any male attempting to wear more stereotypically feminine clothing is met with jeers that they are parodying or mocking women and it is offensive and/or a fetish.

Again, no. You're making things up. Any male wearing stereotypically female clothes should just crack on. It's insane that men can't wear dresses and makeup without fear of being jeered at.

Men putting on swishy skirts and claiming to be women so they can get their rocks off in a women's changing room is where the problem lies.

Do you really not understand the difference?

PlopperDoo · 24/02/2022 15:26

I honestly don't know how anyone can suggest things like a drag queen called Miss Carriage etc... Is about anything other than mocking women.

Can you imagine if someone dressed up as an exaggerated example of POC stereotypes and called themselves something that was so clearly a mockery of a race issue?

It's disgusting. But again, us women aren't allowed to be offended by anything. We just need to be kind to all the poor men who believe it's their right to parade around as exaggerated women with fake huge breasts and names like Ana Bortion.

The same people who think this is okay would be horrified at the equivalent in blackface.

ThatsNotMyGolem · 24/02/2022 15:22

Its about gay culture far more than it is about women.

It's really not. It's about mocking women and belittling female issues for entertainment. Names like Miss Carriage and Ana Bortion - how is that anything to do with gay men and their identities?

jellyfrizz · 24/02/2022 15:02

[quote suggestionsplease1]@jellyfrizz , o that's good, so it's certainly not prescriptive at all, and if you happen to be the right sort of man (was it Harry Styles that was mentioned?) and you wear the right sort of approved clothes choices (maybe we could get a council together to make decisions on this?)...then men are free to wear whatever they want.

ok Wink[/quote]
I really don't give a shit what they wear as long as they aren't mocking women (or punching down at other groups).

PlopperDoo · 24/02/2022 15:00

Only some people are allowed to be offended these days OP.

Women aren't allowed to be offended by anything... Oh unless you're a man who wants to be a woman of course, then you can be.

suggestionsplease1 · 24/02/2022 14:56

@jellyfrizz , o that's good, so it's certainly not prescriptive at all, and if you happen to be the right sort of man (was it Harry Styles that was mentioned?) and you wear the right sort of approved clothes choices (maybe we could get a council together to make decisions on this?)...then men are free to wear whatever they want.

ok Wink

jellyfrizz · 24/02/2022 14:55

@InPraiseOfBacchus

As a woman and a feminist, I cringe at the word "womanface". It is the height of indulgent, middle class, white feminism to conflate drag (whether or not you consider it an aggression towards women) with blackface, which is a product of racism and colonialism and so, so much worse.

No, I don't really dig drag acts either. I avoid them completely. It's just completely gross to match the discrimination I might face as a western woman with the oppression of people from racialised communities.

Oh yes it’s fine to mock women now that YOU aren’t treated too badly.

In many countries women are still treated as second class citizens, not able to vote, aborted or killed at birth because of their sex, sold into marriage at a young age, have no reproductive choices…

I reckon you shouldn’t parody a class of people who are already treated like shit for entertainment whatever that class is.

JesusMaryAndJosephAndTheWeeDon · 24/02/2022 14:42

They didn't like it much when Clarkson made a jibe about Ant's drink driving

JesusMaryAndJosephAndTheWeeDon · 24/02/2022 14:39

Men can wear traditionally female clothing without parodying or appropriating womanhood and that's what we should be encouraging to make young people comfortable in their bodies and sexualities. Not enforcing rigid boundaries that can only be bent in limited circumstances such as trans or drag.

There are loads of examples of men wearing women's clothes without being offensive or trans. David Bowie, Julian Clary, Kurt Cobain or Evan Dando in the 90s, Barry Humphries as Dame Edna, Eddie Izzard back in the 90s, Prince, Brian Molko, Harry Styles, David Beckham, Jas Mann from Babylon Zoo, the school boys who wear a skirt as a protest because they aren't allowed to wear shorts, the runner up outfit in the final of the 2020 sewing bee, probably more besides.

It isn't about the clothes.

InPraiseOfBacchus · 24/02/2022 14:32

As a woman and a feminist, I cringe at the word "womanface". It is the height of indulgent, middle class, white feminism to conflate drag (whether or not you consider it an aggression towards women) with blackface, which is a product of racism and colonialism and so, so much worse.

No, I don't really dig drag acts either. I avoid them completely. It's just completely gross to match the discrimination I might face as a western woman with the oppression of people from racialised communities.

Ijustreallywantacat · 24/02/2022 14:26

I love a bit of drag. It has been around for years and stems from gay men having to hide their identities for fear of being arrested or killed. Its an exaggeration of their own 'femininity'. They like wearing make up, they like having a waist, and they like performing. Its about gay culture far more than it is about women.

Besides which, it goes much further than that nowadays. If you've ever watched Drag Race you'll know they dress as space aliens, weird yellow creatures with chest hair, and ice cream cones. They had a bio queen last year, and Drag kings are becoming increasingly popular.

Of course, it's not to everyone's taste. You're allowed to hate it. That doesn't mean you speak for all women or that it should be banned. I think calling it womanface is incredibly offensive, doesn't mean I think you should be locked up for saying it.

Missey85 · 24/02/2022 14:15

I like drag its fun! I don't get why it annoys you so much find something else to complain about if women can do what they like then so should men oh wait I forget "equality to you means women are better"

YouSetTheTone · 24/02/2022 14:05

The fact is that we live in a society where misogyny is so normalised that laughing at women, mocking women and parodying women is genuinely seen as amusing by lots of people. Most of the comments on the article go along the lines of ‘blimey people get offended by anything!! I find it funny!’

Yes, you probably do because you haven’t stopped to think that actually it’s not that funny to dress up as exaggerated versions of the oppressed minority and make inane or bitchy comments.

There’s no widely accepted genre of comedy where women go on the stage packing a massive donkey schlong, calling herself ‘Eric Tile Dysfunction’, walking like John Wayne and pretending she can’t cry or things like that are they. No form of such comedy that earns women loads of money, used as advertising by banks and all over the BBC.

I had the same thought as you op that the use of ‘bizarre’ in the headline was annoying. It’s not a bizarre complaint.

jellyfrizz · 24/02/2022 13:54

For instance: www.pinterest.com/pin/314689092703624100/

jellyfrizz · 24/02/2022 13:52

Marc Jacobs knows how to do it - google Marc Jacobs skirt. I think it's about getting the socks and footwear right.

jellyfrizz · 24/02/2022 13:40

@suggestionsplease1

They could just wear a skirt or flowery top once in a while if they wanted to expand the bandwith of normal for male clothing.

But you just know anything they attempted would come in for stick wouldn't it!?

Imagine they wore 'flowery tops' as you put it - you'd have people here saying "I can't believe that is their idea of more feminine clothing! How ridiculous, as if all women wear flowery tops! How misogynistic!'

The way it appears to work, to me, is that any male attempting to wear more stereotypically feminine clothing is met with jeers that they are parodying or mocking women and it is offensive and/or a fetish. Then the next thought is: 'Why don't they wear what most regular women wear if they want to diverge a bit and replicate women's fashions? In everyday fashion most women are wearing jeans! Why can't they just wear jeans for crying out loud!'

And then we're back at square one with everyone emulating an originally masculine attire and sending out the message that 'What is originally / stereotypically masculine is desirable and of value, and what is originally / stereotypically feminine is valueless, and will only be worn by males because they want to mock women, or for sexual fetish purposes.

At the heart of this thinking is a deeply anti-feminist message to my mind.

Nah, I'm not suggesting they wear flowery tops stating anything about feminine clothing.

Maybe something like this: silky floral number

Or these: nice floral trousers

suggestionsplease1 · 24/02/2022 13:01

Haha, and that's why I am against threads being taken down and I never report offensive posts. I really just think everything should be left to stand so that people can see how these threads unfold.

Waitwhat23 · 24/02/2022 12:37

The widely held theory of the feminism boards is that males wearing female clothing are generally assumed to be seeking sexual thrills, and how would people know if they're not, so they should just stop doing it, for the sake of women and children.

Utter nonsense. Keep repeating it if you like, but it's nonsense.

suggestionsplease1 · 24/02/2022 12:20

They could just wear a skirt or flowery top once in a while if they wanted to expand the bandwith of normal for male clothing.

But you just know anything they attempted would come in for stick wouldn't it!?

Imagine they wore 'flowery tops' as you put it - you'd have people here saying "I can't believe that is their idea of more feminine clothing! How ridiculous, as if all women wear flowery tops! How misogynistic!'

The way it appears to work, to me, is that any male attempting to wear more stereotypically feminine clothing is met with jeers that they are parodying or mocking women and it is offensive and/or a fetish. Then the next thought is: 'Why don't they wear what most regular women wear if they want to diverge a bit and replicate women's fashions? In everyday fashion most women are wearing jeans! Why can't they just wear jeans for crying out loud!'

And then we're back at square one with everyone emulating an originally masculine attire and sending out the message that 'What is originally / stereotypically masculine is desirable and of value, and what is originally / stereotypically feminine is valueless, and will only be worn by males because they want to mock women, or for sexual fetish purposes.

At the heart of this thinking is a deeply anti-feminist message to my mind.

MorningStarling · 24/02/2022 09:59

Personally I find drag highly offensive, but the reason the media tolerate it is the same as the reason blackface was tolerated back in the 60s/70s - "it's just a laugh" or "it's not meant to be offensive, lighten up."

I think there's also the view that white-on-black racism is The Most Offensive and Disgusting Thing Ever. Therefore other forms of discrimination and abuse like sexism are not as serious. Even other forms of racism are not as serious.

By this "standard" the media cannot treat drag as being as offensive as blackface, because that would suggest sexism is as bad as racism, which cannot possibly be.

jellyfrizz · 24/02/2022 09:56

@suggestionsplease1

Drag kings have been around for ages.

But yeah, in general girls and women have a lot more freedom to dress a variety of ways without censure. Women and girls have been permitted socially to wear traditionally male clothes for many generations now.

Boys and men do not have that luxury, you only need to look at the feminism boards here to see the fury and accusations of perversion levelled at men that dare to step outside of conventional clothing for their sex.

Ant and Dec would have got it in the neck by a minority for whatever stereotypically female clothes they had chosen to wear; any dress or skirt whatsoever, or however 'conservative' would have been considered an affront by a few, there would always have been an angle on it.

It is good that boys and young men see that they too can step outside of conventional expectations for what they wear, just like women have been doing for generations and have established as a new norm. Perhaps it is their time to establish new norms and freedoms of expression.

Great, but dressing up 'as a woman' is not going to establish new norms is it? It's still marking those clothes as 'women's' clothes.

They could just wear a skirt or flowery top once in a while if they wanted to expand the bandwith of normal for male clothing.

Aprilx · 24/02/2022 09:45

I am in my 50s, I don’t like drag so don’t watch it and have never given it much thought. And no I have never heard of drag kings. Looking back, I can think of countless examples of men dressing up as women (not drag per se just comedic dressing as women) for a laugh, very few example the opposite way.

Stopping to think about it, which I haven’t really done before, it is offensive and I am glad that people are starting to question it. When I was younger it was ok to mock people for being gay and being gay was an insult, times change and it can be good that people challenge things that were not challenged in the past.

NETSRIK · 24/02/2022 09:37

@0blio

To me it is offensive.

Can you imagine Ant and Dec parodying disabled people or people of colour? Not acceptable - but because drag is a caricature of women - that's OK?

Exactly!! I can't believe what Ant and Dec did. WTF were they thinking. Hope someone goes on the show next week and takes the piss out of a car crashing alcoholic. You know, for laughs. Idiots.