Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not think its right to bouble barrell child's name after divorce?

85 replies

BlueEyesWhiteDragon · 23/02/2022 15:44

Parent A (female) and B (male) split last year. No affairs, no DV. Parent A felt B checked out of marriage and family life despite repeated requests to change didn't so instigated split. Parent B doesn't agree obviously felt blindsided by split and initially hoped they'd get back together. Now has new partner.

They have 2 DSs aged 7 and 2. DSs are with B every other weekend and 1 midweek for tea every week.

Split is not amicable in that they do not get on, all communication is by email, they handover on the doorstep, its still quite fraught.

A legally changed her name a few months ago. It's not her maiden name but a name she has chosen that has meaning to her. Oldest DS is upset that he no longer shares the same name as mummy. She's had discussions with him about double barrelling and DS likes that idea so she has asked B to agree with her new name being first.

B doesn't want to agree as he feels it's a wider pattern of punishing him and wanting to erase anything to do with him in As life (impossible as they share DCs). Is scared to say doesn't agree as likely to result in contact being messed with.

Both parents are friends of mine but this is causing massive issues (and in the wider group) as the issue is just being spoken about all the time.

I've lost my temper with both of them this week because well I'm just sick of the whole thing.

A has text me this morning to say

"I'm disappointed that you as a mother cannot see the importance for DC1 to feel connected to both of his families by sharing a name. We have been friends for many years and I expected more from you in terms of support. Its clear that your desire to not take sides between me and B is resulting in you taking his side. I think until you can see reason it's best that we hit pause on the friendship"

I have known A for 15 years and met B through her (so known him 12). I never married my DCs father and gave them both my surname.

I admit I don't understand the importance of it. I don't think a 7 year old can really be that bothered or understand the intricacies of changing a name.

AIBU? Am I missing something massively fundamental? As a child is having a different name to one parent really that traumatising?

OP posts:
MichelleScarn · 23/02/2022 16:02

So A has chosen a completely different name, has discussed this with the children, and B is now being guilt tripped into agreeing to the change?
A is now guilt tripping the OP with the twee and frankly controlling 'pause on friendship' which is basically, 'you're not doing what I want so I'm not talking to you till I decide to'....

BlueEyesWhiteDragon · 23/02/2022 15:59

The DS (in my opinion) has the habit to say whatever which parent he's with him at the time wants him to say so I'm a bit sceptical that he is absolutely distraught about it. Indeed he has a tendency to just agree with whoever is asking him anything (child or adult) so I'm not sure how much weight can be put on that.

But then I admit I might be missing something. I don't know anyone who as a child felt that strongly about their name being different to a parent and I knew/ know many with different names.

A obviously feels very strongly about it and that's making me question what I'm missing I suppose other than a vague well why not

OP posts:
Bdhntbis · 23/02/2022 15:58

I can understand why she’d want to and why the child would want to; it really bothered my DSD to have a different name to her mum.
However I do think you need to accept that in a situation like this you can’t remain in the middle and you have to pick which person you want to continue a friendship with.

LadyDanburysHat · 23/02/2022 15:54

YABU the child wants to have a name that inlcudes both parents. And frankly it doesn't matter who ended the marriage or why

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 23/02/2022 15:53

Traditionally in double barrelling the mother’s name goes first, and the last name is seen as more important

Suprima · 23/02/2022 15:53

@BlueEyesWhiteDragon

Parent A (female) and B (male) split last year. No affairs, no DV. Parent A felt B checked out of marriage and family life despite repeated requests to change didn't so instigated split. Parent B doesn't agree obviously felt blindsided by split and initially hoped they'd get back together. Now has new partner.

They have 2 DSs aged 7 and 2. DSs are with B every other weekend and 1 midweek for tea every week.

Split is not amicable in that they do not get on, all communication is by email, they handover on the doorstep, its still quite fraught.

A legally changed her name a few months ago. It's not her maiden name but a name she has chosen that has meaning to her. Oldest DS is upset that he no longer shares the same name as mummy. She's had discussions with him about double barrelling and DS likes that idea so she has asked B to agree with her new name being first.

B doesn't want to agree as he feels it's a wider pattern of punishing him and wanting to erase anything to do with him in As life (impossible as they share DCs). Is scared to say doesn't agree as likely to result in contact being messed with.

Both parents are friends of mine but this is causing massive issues (and in the wider group) as the issue is just being spoken about all the time.

I've lost my temper with both of them this week because well I'm just sick of the whole thing.

A has text me this morning to say

"I'm disappointed that you as a mother cannot see the importance for DC1 to feel connected to both of his families by sharing a name. We have been friends for many years and I expected more from you in terms of support. Its clear that your desire to not take sides between me and B is resulting in you taking his side. I think until you can see reason it's best that we hit pause on the friendship"

I have known A for 15 years and met B through her (so known him 12). I never married my DCs father and gave them both my surname.

I admit I don't understand the importance of it. I don't think a 7 year old can really be that bothered or understand the intricacies of changing a name.

AIBU? Am I missing something massively fundamental? As a child is having a different name to one parent really that traumatising?

I think your A’s response is fair, respectful and I agree with her. Why shouldn’t they double barrel? She will be doing the bulk of the child rearing- it makes sense.

I’d pause on a friendship with you too. You seem far too involved for her to text you that and I don’t really know why.

SmellinOfTroy · 23/02/2022 15:52

Oldest DS is upset that he no longer shares the same name as mummy. She's had discussions with him about double barrelling and DS likes that idea

YABU - why shouldn't the child have both parents names - especially when they WANT to??

GeneLovesJezebel · 23/02/2022 15:50

Maybe she should have kept the same name as her children, or double barrelled herself.
And before anyone says it’s her ex’s name, it’s also her children’s name, the ex doesn’t own it.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 23/02/2022 15:48

YABU

Why on earth shouldn’t the child share a name with both parents if they want to?

TheSnowyOwl · 23/02/2022 15:46

YANBU. If it’s that important to her child why doesn’t she double barrel to have both. That way she can have her child’s name and her new one.