Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not think its right to bouble barrell child's name after divorce?

85 replies

BlueEyesWhiteDragon · 23/02/2022 15:44

Parent A (female) and B (male) split last year. No affairs, no DV. Parent A felt B checked out of marriage and family life despite repeated requests to change didn't so instigated split. Parent B doesn't agree obviously felt blindsided by split and initially hoped they'd get back together. Now has new partner.

They have 2 DSs aged 7 and 2. DSs are with B every other weekend and 1 midweek for tea every week.

Split is not amicable in that they do not get on, all communication is by email, they handover on the doorstep, its still quite fraught.

A legally changed her name a few months ago. It's not her maiden name but a name she has chosen that has meaning to her. Oldest DS is upset that he no longer shares the same name as mummy. She's had discussions with him about double barrelling and DS likes that idea so she has asked B to agree with her new name being first.

B doesn't want to agree as he feels it's a wider pattern of punishing him and wanting to erase anything to do with him in As life (impossible as they share DCs). Is scared to say doesn't agree as likely to result in contact being messed with.

Both parents are friends of mine but this is causing massive issues (and in the wider group) as the issue is just being spoken about all the time.

I've lost my temper with both of them this week because well I'm just sick of the whole thing.

A has text me this morning to say

"I'm disappointed that you as a mother cannot see the importance for DC1 to feel connected to both of his families by sharing a name. We have been friends for many years and I expected more from you in terms of support. Its clear that your desire to not take sides between me and B is resulting in you taking his side. I think until you can see reason it's best that we hit pause on the friendship"

I have known A for 15 years and met B through her (so known him 12). I never married my DCs father and gave them both my surname.

I admit I don't understand the importance of it. I don't think a 7 year old can really be that bothered or understand the intricacies of changing a name.

AIBU? Am I missing something massively fundamental? As a child is having a different name to one parent really that traumatising?

OP posts:
BlueEyesWhiteDragon · 23/02/2022 16:33

B has the maximum amount of contact A would allow. Shes been very clear he would have to take her to court for more. He says he wants more but he's not gone to court for more and I am undecided if that's because he likes to play the victim or if it is that he's saving up to do so like he says.

I'll have to come up with a phrase to just say every time they try and discuss it and repeat repeat repeat until they stop talking to me about it Grin

OP posts:
MrsBertBibby · 23/02/2022 16:32

Your friend A sounds like a right precious self-absorbed fool.

The children had her name : the one she chose to assume on marriage. If she wants to keep the same as them, she just has to stick to that.

My son has his dad's name, it seemed a tiny gift when he was born, to give him a link to his Dad and family. It has never bothered either of us, and he is now 18.

StepAwayFromGoogling · 23/02/2022 16:30

People whose needs are most important in this scenario: DC. People who are prioritising their needs in this scenario: Both Mum and Dad. Mum, by changing her name when it was clearly going to upset her DC. Dad, by kicking off when DC want to double barrel their name.

AnotherEmma · 23/02/2022 16:30

YABU because you're claiming that you don't want to take sides but you're clearly on his side.

Also this idea of "erasing" his name is bullshit, she wants to add her name, not remove his.

You're also a hypocrite because you share a surname with your children and yet you're being dismissive of your friend's desire to share a surname with hers. Different circumstances of course but still.

All mothers should share a surname with their children, most will agree and I suspect that those who don't have mostly been conditioned to accept the status quo. And most men care about sharing a surname with their children even if they don't actually do any parenting.

ForeverSingle881 · 23/02/2022 16:29

YABU!! Why are you standing by him when she was your friend first? And what re you getting involved? If you don't want to hear about it, don't socialize with that group anymore. Your response was rude and you are clearly not her friend. Her response is perfectly reasonable.

QuirkyTurtle · 23/02/2022 16:26

Just the other day there was a thread about a divorced woman not wanting to give up her married surname because she wanted to have the same name as her kids, and this was applauded.

If mum has changed her name and the kids want to share a name, I don't see any reason other than pettiness to not accommodate this.

However, you are not being unreasonable to not want to be involved in this bullshit - it's theirs to sort out.

BlueEyesWhiteDragon · 23/02/2022 16:25

I'm only involved cos it's all she bloomin talks about. She's still very hurt and cross at B and I suspect us all remaining friends with him probably isn't helping. I suspect a PP is right and ill have to "pick" a friend.

I suppose this post was about trying to see if anyone has experienced a child feeling that strongly about it because it's just alien to me (I have a different name to DM) and a couple of posters have responded about that.

I didn't give my DCs my name because I felt strongly about it. DC1 has my name beside ex had left me whilst pregnant and all the advice I had at the time (including on here) was to give him my name to make everything easier. DC2 was then just matched.

Obviously other people feel similarly to A and so I perhaps need to be less annoyed about her message this morning!

OP posts:
Ponoka7 · 23/02/2022 16:24

My 7 year old GD doesn't like that she has a different surname to her Mum and I know a few children who feel the same. I don't understand unmarried Mums give the child the Dad's name. Some people find it nice to have a family name connection, especially to the resident parent. B has got to stop playing the victim and get it out of his head that he was being punished, she has the right to a happy life. If he didn't want any of this, he could have been a good partner and Dad. Is there a reason why he has so little contact?

ByGrabtharsHammerWhatASavings · 23/02/2022 16:22

B sounds like a prat. Giving the child both his name and her name somehow erases him, but the child having only his name and not her name is fine? Her asking for their names to be equal is her punishing him, but him refusing has nothing to do with punishing her? He sounds like a misogynist and if I was A I'd be really hurt that you hadn't supported me. When my kids were born we gave them both my partners name and I wasn't bothered but years later when we went through a rough patch I realised how sad I'd be if we split up and they didn't share my name at all so we got them double barrelled. It's important to her, important to the child, and doesn't affect B in any way since his name is still included. Sounds like he's just putting up barriers to get one over on A.

groeggmeg · 23/02/2022 16:22

To some, a name is a large part of their identity. Even if her son isn’t traumatised about it as you
suspect, the idea to double barrel seems completely sensible.

Peachtoiletpaper · 23/02/2022 16:20

YABU why would it make any difference to the child if he is happy to add another name? How is it removing the father from his life if it's not omitting his name? The child's life won't change in any way.

Ohwowhoho · 23/02/2022 16:20

YABU. I know quite a few people who double barrelled their name after parents got divorced.

I changed my surname to my Mums when I was a teenager. Luckily my DF gave permission or I would have had to wait until I was 18. I actually think it is important.

Holskey · 23/02/2022 16:20

YABU
You're not being a very good friend to dismiss A's desire because it wouldn't be important to you. You also seem too opinionated and invested.
Further, IME nobody likes it when their friend doesn't pick their side in a split.

IVflytrap · 23/02/2022 16:18

I don't see how double-barrelling the DC's name will "erase" (Hmm) Parent B. Does B not know what double-barrelling actually means? His child will literally still have his surname.

Sounds more like he's trying to erase A if anything, by not wanting his DC to share a name with their own mother, while also ignoring his DC's wishes.

People are really strange about double-barrelling surnames. It's the most egalitarian way of naming children, and yet so many people have such strong negative feelings about it.

SmellinOfTroy · 23/02/2022 16:17

@LesLavandes

In divorce, I kept my married surname as my children wanted me to and I wanted the same surname as my children. To change your name to something completely new and expect all parties to be happy with this double barrelled name is ridiculous
What all parties? 2 parents and a child - if the child wants it then the child should be able to make that decision
Ursusmajor · 23/02/2022 16:16

YABU. Child should have both parents’ names.
Also there’s no fucking point in ´parent A’ and ´parent B’ when you’ve said that A is female and B is male. Call them Mum and Dad and make your post ten times clearer for readers.

SmellinOfTroy · 23/02/2022 16:16

@mrsm43s

Mum shouldn't have changed her name if it was that important to her son that she kept the same name as him. Very selfish of her to put her wants above his needs. There was no reason for her to have changed her name at all, and I imagine her children would have preferred the exact same name as both parents. It's a bit rich for her to be arguing that he has the right to the same name as her when she deliberately changed her name from being the same as his. He had the same name as her - she took that away by changing her name!

Ultimately though, its up to the 2 parents to sort this out between them, and its not up to you to get involved, so I'd back off.

You have no idea why she doesnt want his name any more?
Sally872 · 23/02/2022 16:15

A wants her child to also have her name. That is not u reasonable. She would be unreasonable to remove current surname or if the child didn't want to change but if child agrees then I think it makes sense. Father is objecting as "he feels punished" needs to grow up and Co parent.

frazzledasarock · 23/02/2022 16:14

I thought a child couldn’t possibly understand the implications of changing surname. And ignored her.

My DC us patiently waited till she turned eighteen and changed her surname to mine and DH’s. Completely removed her fathers name as per her wishes as a child.

You’re DC have your name. You obviously felt strongly about it when it came to your child’s name.

Why are you so invested in your friend not double barrelling her child’s name? The ex is not losing out his name will remain she’s adding her on too.

Movingsoon21 · 23/02/2022 16:13

Another thread showing why women absolutely should not automatically change their name when they marry, or automatically give the kids the dad’s surname…

MsPavlichenko · 23/02/2022 16:12

I did not change my name. DC (adults) have father’s name. Never made any difference to them or me before or after split. One has my name as middle name and at about 18 started using both. But at end of the day it’s only a name.

mrsm43s · 23/02/2022 16:11

Mum shouldn't have changed her name if it was that important to her son that she kept the same name as him. Very selfish of her to put her wants above his needs. There was no reason for her to have changed her name at all, and I imagine her children would have preferred the exact same name as both parents. It's a bit rich for her to be arguing that he has the right to the same name as her when she deliberately changed her name from being the same as his. He had the same name as her - she took that away by changing her name!

Ultimately though, its up to the 2 parents to sort this out between them, and its not up to you to get involved, so I'd back off.

MichelleScarn · 23/02/2022 16:09

I expected more from you in terms of support. Its clear that your desire to not take sides between me and B is resulting in you taking his side
And re-reading op A just sounds petty, she doesn't want OP to do the mature thing and not 'take sides', it's As side or that's friendship over?

LesLavandes · 23/02/2022 16:06

In divorce, I kept my married surname as my children wanted me to and I wanted the same surname as my children. To change your name to something completely new and expect all parties to be happy with this double barrelled name is ridiculous

SpiderVersed · 23/02/2022 16:06

Why would you care what your friend's 7yo wants to call himself? If he has a double-barrelled name that's n o skin of anyone's nose. He stil;l has his Dad's surname (as well as his Mum's surname too, now).