Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not think its right to bouble barrell child's name after divorce?

85 replies

BlueEyesWhiteDragon · 23/02/2022 15:44

Parent A (female) and B (male) split last year. No affairs, no DV. Parent A felt B checked out of marriage and family life despite repeated requests to change didn't so instigated split. Parent B doesn't agree obviously felt blindsided by split and initially hoped they'd get back together. Now has new partner.

They have 2 DSs aged 7 and 2. DSs are with B every other weekend and 1 midweek for tea every week.

Split is not amicable in that they do not get on, all communication is by email, they handover on the doorstep, its still quite fraught.

A legally changed her name a few months ago. It's not her maiden name but a name she has chosen that has meaning to her. Oldest DS is upset that he no longer shares the same name as mummy. She's had discussions with him about double barrelling and DS likes that idea so she has asked B to agree with her new name being first.

B doesn't want to agree as he feels it's a wider pattern of punishing him and wanting to erase anything to do with him in As life (impossible as they share DCs). Is scared to say doesn't agree as likely to result in contact being messed with.

Both parents are friends of mine but this is causing massive issues (and in the wider group) as the issue is just being spoken about all the time.

I've lost my temper with both of them this week because well I'm just sick of the whole thing.

A has text me this morning to say

"I'm disappointed that you as a mother cannot see the importance for DC1 to feel connected to both of his families by sharing a name. We have been friends for many years and I expected more from you in terms of support. Its clear that your desire to not take sides between me and B is resulting in you taking his side. I think until you can see reason it's best that we hit pause on the friendship"

I have known A for 15 years and met B through her (so known him 12). I never married my DCs father and gave them both my surname.

I admit I don't understand the importance of it. I don't think a 7 year old can really be that bothered or understand the intricacies of changing a name.

AIBU? Am I missing something massively fundamental? As a child is having a different name to one parent really that traumatising?

OP posts:
goldfluffyclouds · 23/02/2022 17:09

just stay out of their dramas - if the only basis they want to be friends with you is involving you in all their dramas then you need to walk away as its clearly not getting better but worse.
oh and my kids 8 and 5 still have their dads name not mine - funnily enough they've never thought that's a problem because its never been suggested its a problem - i agree with your view that the ideas are being planted on them - but like i said before - stay out of the dramas.

Roeslein · 23/02/2022 17:03

My son’s name is double-barrelled with my name first (we are happily married, it just sounded better than the other way around), it seems completely normal to me as women don’t change their name upon marriage in my country and not sharing a name can make travel difficult. I don’t understand the problem here, surely she can’t be expected to keep her ex’ name and she should share a name with her DCs if only for practical reasons?

Sweetlikejollof · 23/02/2022 17:02

@crosstalk

Oh for heaven's sake, what a palaver.

I kept my own name after DC who took their father's.

Mine was already double barreled. Theirs would have been triple barreled.

Neither of them minded at all.

Or they could have just taken your name. They wouldn’t have minded that, either.
LyricalBlowToTheJaw · 23/02/2022 17:01

YABU OP. You need to critically interrogate the fact that B considers A having a name of her choosing as punishing and erasing him. There's a good deal of male privilege around naming traditions and it's showing up in this situation.

crosstalk · 23/02/2022 16:59

Oh for heaven's sake, what a palaver.

I kept my own name after DC who took their father's.

Mine was already double barreled. Theirs would have been triple barreled.

Neither of them minded at all.

QuirkyTurtle · 23/02/2022 16:57

So no good reason for her to change her name.

No good reason to change your married name when you are no longer married? I feel like the whole not being married anymore thing is a good reason.

Sweetlikejollof · 23/02/2022 16:57

And obviously a double barrelled surname does not erase him. He’d have lost me at that.

I know! The lack of logic is baffling. How is that even an argument?

Sweetlikejollof · 23/02/2022 16:56

YABU. I’m not seeing the problem with double barrelling, from either your or his perspective? How does that remove him from the kid’s life?

Also, you seem to understand a father wanting his kids to have his last name, but not a mother wanting the same. Why is that?

Shamoo · 23/02/2022 16:50

Well YABU and at first I thought this must be a reverse but I see it’s not.

You are also being a hypocrite if your kids have your name!

A doesn’t sound like she’s managed it all brilliantly, but B sounds like an utter dick. And obviously a double barrelled surname does not erase him. He’d have lost me at that.

BlueEyesWhiteDragon · 23/02/2022 16:50

They both being dickheads and I thought - clearly wrongly - that our friendships were strong enough that I could disagree with either of them and it be OK.

OP posts:
picklemewalnuts · 23/02/2022 16:49

Honestly, sounds like he was a lazy dad. Tried to stop her ending the relationship. Then he got a new relationship within a year. Took a massive paycut to reduce his maintenance contributions.

She's lost patience with him, changed her name to reduce her connection with him, realised the DC will be sad they don't share a name so planned a perfectly good compromise- the kids have both names.

I can't see what he's done that not self serving, here.

BowerOfBramble · 23/02/2022 16:47

Honestly she sounds manipulative and he sounds self-pitying. OP I suggest you move to Timbuktu and cut them both off.

BlueEyesWhiteDragon · 23/02/2022 16:45

@ForeverSingle881 because I've been friends with him for 12 years! Originally when they split they were both very much this is going to be amicable, no need for any drama.

Then A went to stay with her grandparents for 3 months and withheld contact whilst there and B got angry and threatened solicitors and did talk about just going to get DC. A returned and contact was agreed at every other weekend and weekly mid week.

Then B quit his job and took a trainee position in different field which resulted in a 75% income drop and cut his child maintenance accordingly before raising it to slightly above the CMS minimum

A then left the family home and moved but moved 50 mins away from B and swapped DC1s school.

B then started dating C who was a mutual friend of us all including A. He introduced her to DC without telling A on the basis that DC already knew her.

It's just progressively getting worse and I've been trying to sit on the fence so much I've got splinters.

OP posts:
BowerOfBramble · 23/02/2022 16:45

She's already changed her name twice, I'd wonder how many more times is she going to, and expect the kids to change their names as well to "match"?

I'm all for double-barrelling but I think it's a bit much to pick a random surname and then complain it doesn't match your kids.

Having said that if I were the dad I couldn't get excited about this one-off change but I wouldn't be agreeing to any more.

incognitoforthisone · 23/02/2022 16:45

I would be surprised if the child involved is upset that he and his mother don't have the same surname. I suspect it's more that the mother doesn't want to have a different name from her son, which is much more common in my experience, but also doesn't want the same name as her ex-husband. It's understandable that she doesn't want her ex's name, but I think that making it all about the seven-year-old is unfair. He's seven. He'll say whatever he thinks will please his mummy.

A's message to you is emotional blackmail and it's manipulative and unfair, and my guess is that the conversation with her child involved her saying 'Aw, but you don't want to have a different name from Mummy, do you? Wouldn't that make you sad? Don't you like Mummy's new name?' until he said yes to the name change.

While I can understand why she wants to double-barrel her son's name, I think it's telling that she wants to put her name first, as that makes B's name the one it would be easier to quietly drop further down the line. Also, it's a random name that she's picked for herself because she likes it, not her maiden name, and I suspect that both those things are a big part of why B isn't agreeing to the name change, and I think she just has to suck it and deal with it. Ultimately, I don't think anyone can expect their ex-partner to be happy with a change so fundamental as their own child's name.

Either way - A talking about you 'taking sides' and ending a friendship over this just because you have a different opinion from her on this is really bloody toxic. The 'you as a mother' line is so revealing - she's trying to make you feel guilty or that you are less of mother than she is because you don't feel the same way as her, and that's despicable. It's absolutely insane that she says 'by not taking sides, you are actually taking B's side' - that's just backing you into a corner that means the only acceptable solution is for you to agree with her all the time, and that's horrible of her, as is dragging you into this mess in the first place.

Ponoka7 · 23/02/2022 16:44

@mrsm43s, when a man checks out if family life and his partner is begging him to change and giving ultimatums, rarely there isn't a level of emotional abuse, manipulation and gas lighting, as well as the lies etc. To get another partner he's had to do all of the things that the ex asked for, he's no victim.

QOD · 23/02/2022 16:42

Yes.

It was to me in 1980 so I changed my name
to my step dads which hurt my dad and I wish I hadn’t.

It’s none of your beeswax

Ponoka7 · 23/02/2022 16:40

@BlueEyesWhiteDragon, is he short of £240? That's how much it costs to go to court. He sounds as though he likes to play the victim. She gave him ultimatums, he chose to ignore them.

thepeopleversuswork · 23/02/2022 16:39

YABU. My DD is double-barrelled post divorce. She's got my surname first, his last. Suits all of us. Even my ex wouldn't be petty enough to have a problem about his daughter keeping her mum's surname.

No I don't think its "traumatising" for a child to have a different surname from his mother but I also don't see why its skin off anyone's nose to let him go along with it? The dad is being a macho prick and needs to get over himself.

SpiderinaWingMirror · 23/02/2022 16:39

Honestly, I would respond to both that this is one of a wide number of issues that you have no opinion on as it does not involve you. I would also say that if they value your friendship, the conversation needs to move from their divorce and their kids pronto.

SmellinOfTroy · 23/02/2022 16:38

@mrsm43s

You have no idea why she doesnt want his name any more?

Well it says clearly in the OP no affairs, no DV. So no good reason for her to change her name. Her son had the same name as her. She chose to change her name despite it being upsetting for her son. She wants them to have the same name - she can change her name back.

You can bet your bottom dollar if the name does get double barrelled, Mum will shorten it to her name only pretty quick smart, because very rarely are double barrelled names used day to day.

oh your bar is low - could have been anything, obviously enough for A not to want to be married to B anymore.

Just because there were no 'known about' DV or affairs doesnt mean that A&B were both blameless

WishIwasElsa · 23/02/2022 16:38

I understand your skepticism, however my dcs are 5 and 7 and they would prefer me to ha e the same surname as them and this is unprpmpted from me just because they are aware we don't have the same from conversations

StrawberryFever · 23/02/2022 16:35

Even if this were being driven solely by A wanting to have equality in name recognition of parentage I'd agree with them. That it comes from the child... well I think we can all see why the marriage failed if this is representative of the fragility of B's ego

Thoosa · 23/02/2022 16:35

@Movingsoon21

Another thread showing why women absolutely should not automatically change their name when they marry, or automatically give the kids the dad’s surname…
This.

Start as you mean to go on.

mrsm43s · 23/02/2022 16:35

You have no idea why she doesnt want his name any more?

Well it says clearly in the OP no affairs, no DV. So no good reason for her to change her name. Her son had the same name as her. She chose to change her name despite it being upsetting for her son. She wants them to have the same name - she can change her name back.

You can bet your bottom dollar if the name does get double barrelled, Mum will shorten it to her name only pretty quick smart, because very rarely are double barrelled names used day to day.