Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not think its right to bouble barrell child's name after divorce?

85 replies

BlueEyesWhiteDragon · 23/02/2022 15:44

Parent A (female) and B (male) split last year. No affairs, no DV. Parent A felt B checked out of marriage and family life despite repeated requests to change didn't so instigated split. Parent B doesn't agree obviously felt blindsided by split and initially hoped they'd get back together. Now has new partner.

They have 2 DSs aged 7 and 2. DSs are with B every other weekend and 1 midweek for tea every week.

Split is not amicable in that they do not get on, all communication is by email, they handover on the doorstep, its still quite fraught.

A legally changed her name a few months ago. It's not her maiden name but a name she has chosen that has meaning to her. Oldest DS is upset that he no longer shares the same name as mummy. She's had discussions with him about double barrelling and DS likes that idea so she has asked B to agree with her new name being first.

B doesn't want to agree as he feels it's a wider pattern of punishing him and wanting to erase anything to do with him in As life (impossible as they share DCs). Is scared to say doesn't agree as likely to result in contact being messed with.

Both parents are friends of mine but this is causing massive issues (and in the wider group) as the issue is just being spoken about all the time.

I've lost my temper with both of them this week because well I'm just sick of the whole thing.

A has text me this morning to say

"I'm disappointed that you as a mother cannot see the importance for DC1 to feel connected to both of his families by sharing a name. We have been friends for many years and I expected more from you in terms of support. Its clear that your desire to not take sides between me and B is resulting in you taking his side. I think until you can see reason it's best that we hit pause on the friendship"

I have known A for 15 years and met B through her (so known him 12). I never married my DCs father and gave them both my surname.

I admit I don't understand the importance of it. I don't think a 7 year old can really be that bothered or understand the intricacies of changing a name.

AIBU? Am I missing something massively fundamental? As a child is having a different name to one parent really that traumatising?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MakkaPakkas · 23/02/2022 19:25

I'm completely confused as to why any of this is your business?

picklemewalnuts · 23/02/2022 18:11

And if he was an uninvolved parent, then I'd be wary of him suddenly stepping up. If he was unable to be responsible when he lived there, why would I trust him when he doesn't? Does he know and understand and prioritise any medical needs, diet needs, routines etc? a does he know where the doctors is, when needed. I'd be reluctant to trust my kids to a man that was playing silly buggers, introducing new partners, and failing to provide.

HomeHomeInTheRange · 23/02/2022 18:10

What a shame A changed her name and gave the baby his name alone in the first place.

In principle, of course a mother should be able to give her children her surname.

She isn’t wanting to eradicate his name, just add hers.

He was happy enough when she and the child took his name. Can’t he see why she would also feel the children should have hers?

No matter what her reasons, why is he objecting? He is being a patriarchal knob. And exerting his patriarchal knob power in vetoing the name change.

I am surprised you are not agreeing with her about adding her surname.

picklemewalnuts · 23/02/2022 18:08

If it doesn't matter that they don't have her name, why does it matter if they do have her name? Make your mind up, OP.

picklemewalnuts · 23/02/2022 18:07

B is making this all about him, and trying to control her. I think, OP, you've been blinded by charm and unconscious misogyny.

It's reasonable of her to want to distance herself from the name that came with the husband. She is no longer connected to him, why should she have his name? The DC are connected to both of them, so can have both names.

Names are important to children- they are the first things they learn to write. They are called out at register each morning. They are on their books, clothes, pegs.

LaChanticleer · 23/02/2022 18:03

YABU. Why shouldn’t the children have the names of both their parents?

It’s such a sexist idea that some men gave: “My children have to have my name”

MrsBertBibby · 23/02/2022 18:00

A is an absolute disgrace. She stopped the children seeing dad for no reason but spite for 3 months. She changed school unilaterally.

I don't blame B for being paranoid. She's absolutely malignant, and she is harming her kids with this manipulative name bullshit.

Cyw2018 · 23/02/2022 17:56

YABU

Nailsbythesea · 23/02/2022 17:52

I totally agree with A. Fortunately both children had a double barrelled name mine first and then his. However should they have had just his when divorced I would have reverted to maiden name and then wanted it double barrelled for the kids.

My friend was Ms A and he was Mr B she became mrs B children both B at his insistence they divorced she went back to bring ms a the children were 8 and 3 and wanted her name mr B insisted they would not be a or indeed a-b. Refused to double barrel but a judge saw different and the children became a-b.

I would be irate if you didn’t support me.children are 50-50 and they should have names from both sides

TrashyPanda · 23/02/2022 17:50

I don't think a 7 year old can really be that bothered or understand the intricacies of changing a name

I was about 4 when my father contemplated changing our surname because of racism. And I remember being devastated. My surname was part of me and connected me to my father (I have my mothers maiden name as one of my forenames). We kept our surname, btw.

So I would say a 7 year old can have very deep and really feelings about what he wants his surname to be and it’s not on to diminish these.

ForeverSingle881 · 23/02/2022 17:48

B sounds like an arsehole to me. And you sound naive if you thought you can stay friends with both and choose random sides without affecting your friendship.

Ttcfinalbub · 23/02/2022 17:48

You aren't being unreasonable because it should have nothing to do with you and you shouldn't be dragged into the messy relationship! Send them to mediation. I think you are being unreasonable by thinking it isn't important, break ups can be rough on kids and anger and confusion they may feel lost and having the same name can mean alot. Other parent keeping what I presume might be a married name previously might be a big deal for her as for some losing the surname can be a big first step in rebuilding their life. IF it is genuinely important to the child ( parent a could be pushing this on child) both parents should be able to sort it out with respect on both sides to keep both parents name in.

WorriedMumsDontSleep · 23/02/2022 17:43

@Candycan

from everything you've written, the dad sounds a right pillock.

he has treated your friend appallingly tbh - checked out, didn't bother and didnt step up as a dad when they were together. she repeated asked/begged/pleaded for some effort on his behalf. nothing.

she has had enough of this so leaves him. He then decides he would like to be involved much more, which is convenient, especially considering he wanted to get back together. when this doesnt work, he shacks up with one of all your mutual friends.

you, who was originally the mums friend, have remained equal mates with both of them and judging from your posts on here, think much higher of him than of her.

aside from the fact, that I think it is entirely fair and understandable that she would want the children to have the same name somewhere in their surname, I don't think you would be my friend anymore.

Exactly. Yabvu.
rwalker · 23/02/2022 17:39

I'd keep out but the fact she's thinks it's ok to withhold access moved 50miles away and grant the bare minimum access .
Then done the name thing with kids
Sound like she's weaponising kids

personally I'd drop her she's going to end up with some damage kids how sad

Minesababycham · 23/02/2022 17:31

@StepAwayFromGoogling

People whose needs are most important in this scenario: DC. People who are prioritising their needs in this scenario: Both Mum and Dad. Mum, by changing her name when it was clearly going to upset her DC. Dad, by kicking off when DC want to double barrel their name.
Absolutely agree with this!
Candycan · 23/02/2022 17:31

from everything you've written, the dad sounds a right pillock.

he has treated your friend appallingly tbh - checked out, didn't bother and didnt step up as a dad when they were together. she repeated asked/begged/pleaded for some effort on his behalf. nothing.

she has had enough of this so leaves him. He then decides he would like to be involved much more, which is convenient, especially considering he wanted to get back together. when this doesnt work, he shacks up with one of all your mutual friends.

you, who was originally the mums friend, have remained equal mates with both of them and judging from your posts on here, think much higher of him than of her.

aside from the fact, that I think it is entirely fair and understandable that she would want the children to have the same name somewhere in their surname, I don't think you would be my friend anymore.

LyricalBlowToTheJaw · 23/02/2022 17:28

Yes, B's whole attitude to the names oozes with male privilege here.

Sweetlikejollof · 23/02/2022 17:26

@BlueEyesWhiteDragon

B is convinced that it will start off as smithson-Johnson before the Johnson being dropped. He's also bemused by the choice of smithson rather than her maiden name. He is convinced that she would rather him not be involved at all. He's partly correct in that.

A thought he'd remain as uninvolved when they separated as he was when they were together and she has found it hard that he's stepped up now rather than when she was begging him to in order to save their marriage and she has found being without the DCs difficult. She acknowledges that and has said she'd prefer him to get a new partner, new kid and leave her to it. But not to the extent I think that she would deliberately erase him but she wouldn't be sad if he erased himself if you know what I mean?

The last name she chooses for herself is none of his business.

And if, having double barrelled, she attempts to ‘erase’ his name, then he had cause for complaint. However, that hasn’t happened and he has nothing to prove that it will. In a few years, it’ll be completely up to the kids, anyway.

I’m not really seeing his argument here.

CourtRand · 23/02/2022 17:22

The child wants to change his name so should be allowed.

SickAndTiredAgain · 23/02/2022 17:22

Both of them are unreasonable to drag friends into it to this extent. Fair enough to talk to your friends about it, but don’t involve someone and then get pissy if they disagree with you.

Jennifer2r · 23/02/2022 17:21

Why do you need to agree or disagree? Struggling to see what this has to do with you at all, really. If they are insisting on talking about it I'd tell them I didn't want to be involved because it's none of my concern.

BlueEyesWhiteDragon · 23/02/2022 17:18

A is adamant that she will never remarry but with the caveat that if she does she won't change her name again.

B is highly likely to remarry. Even if not C he will not remain single for long.

OP posts:
BlueEyesWhiteDragon · 23/02/2022 17:16

There is probably an element of me that thinks well you had the same name as them why change it if you / DC were that bothered. I can see why that's maybe not completely wrong but not right either.

OP posts:
CallMeDaddy58 · 23/02/2022 17:14

& if A remarries one day & changes her name for a third time? My Mum had my Dad’s name until I was 5. Then she had her maiden name. Then she remarried when I was 10 & took her new husbands name. I had my Dad’s name the whole time despite him living in a different country to me and my Mum. I now have my husbands name which is a double barrel of his Mum & Dad’s name. Both his Mum and Dad don’t even have those names anymore as they remarried and re double barrelled with new partners!

The name isn’t going to traumatise her 7 year old. The petty bullshit between her and his father will. Speaking from experience.

BlueEyesWhiteDragon · 23/02/2022 17:11

B is convinced that it will start off as smithson-Johnson before the Johnson being dropped. He's also bemused by the choice of smithson rather than her maiden name. He is convinced that she would rather him not be involved at all. He's partly correct in that.

A thought he'd remain as uninvolved when they separated as he was when they were together and she has found it hard that he's stepped up now rather than when she was begging him to in order to save their marriage and she has found being without the DCs difficult. She acknowledges that and has said she'd prefer him to get a new partner, new kid and leave her to it. But not to the extent I think that she would deliberately erase him but she wouldn't be sad if he erased himself if you know what I mean?

OP posts: