Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH has suggested division of childcare/housework unfair...

456 replies

ooooopsididit · 23/02/2022 14:01

Just that really!

DH works full time, from home until recently, but is now back in the office two days per week.

I am a SAHM of two nursery age children.

Both children are at nursery four half days and one full day per week.

DH and I split the morning get up and ready routine, and bedtime routines between us.

The housework is also split about 50/50, although I do more cooking and all laundry.

I also do all lunchtime pickups of DC.

For the complete picture I do have a little cleaning job of about four hours a week, but I could give that up if I wanted the extra time back.

I thought this was fine but DH his just said he thinks it's a bit unfair... I suspect he may be right.

AIBU to expect this to be fine
YABU to split this way as he works full time

OP posts:
saraya7 · 23/02/2022 19:59

My advice OP would be get a cleaner in at least once a week. Take your chances to relax when you can in the day, but then use that energy to take the pressure off him in the evenings. Make an effort with dinner a few times a week and make him feel valued. This is all most men want. He will really appreciate what you do. Don’t worry about the people in here telling you you’re lazy because you are just normal (obviously). Wait until your kids get to school - the same posters will no doubt be telling you to clean the house inch by inch with a toothbrush 24/7. As if. Take no notice.

Mydogmylife · 23/02/2022 19:56

@saraya7

Nothing MN lives more than to tell a SAHM what she should be doing.

OP, if I were you, I’d get a cleaner on the Monday morning or the Friday when both are in nursery. As a SAHM, you need your ‘me’ time and a mental break. When the cleaner is there, this should be your three hours if whatever to take yourself out if the house and do something just got you. Don’t neglect yourself.

Good grief! So DH has to work full time , do 50% of the chores AND pay for a cleaner so op can have even more ' me' time . Surely not
Perfect28 · 23/02/2022 19:55

So you are saying he gets time to himself in the evening when you put the kids to bed, but you don't count the time he puts the kids to bed in your free time?

VirginMedium · 23/02/2022 19:54

I think you owe your husband an apology, OP

FFS Hmm

GemmaAlone · 23/02/2022 19:38

@ooooopsididit

There are, obviously, no easy answers here.

It sounds as if part of the problem is that part of you doesn't actually enjoy being a SAHM and have sort of become one as a result of circumstances rather than positive choice.

My suggestion (which you won't like) would be to embrace this phase fully, on the grounds that it's just a phase. I know any SAHM is vulnerable in terms of future employment prospects - but from that point of view, it makes no difference whether you are finger painting or sitting on your own with a coffee and the newspaper. You are currently out of the job market and, should you ever wish to return to it, you and your husband would both have to try to find ways for this to happen.

For the time being, though - and, again, it's a very short time in your and your children's lives - I would, if I were you, simply accept that your role, at the moment, is to do stuff for everyone else. If your children are nursery age, they are presumably in bed early enough for you to spend evenings meditating/talking to your husband/reading/watching TV/having a bath/doing whatever you find relaxing and that's just for you.

If you spent the 1.5 days when the children are both at nursery doing all the pretty shit stuff that most SAHMs have to do whilst also looking after their children, the four of you could then do more enjoyable family things at the weekends. Do the DC do any weekend activities yet? Assume not, as they are clearly still little, but that will come - and then you'll probably find that one of you takes X to swimming (say) while the other takes Y to a party. And so on.

I think it can all be renegotiated once they both start school and if/when you think of returning to work. But at the moment, your husband is getting the rough end of the deal - working all day and not seeing the children much. Parents of young children generally have to accept that 'me time' isn't really going to happen. But it will come later.

CurlyhairedAssassin · 23/02/2022 19:38

I think you owe your husband an apology, OP. He seems to be doing far too much. The way I see it, if you don't have a paying job so are not contributing to the household in that monetary way, then your responsibility to the family and household is to take on the lion's share of the practical side of things instead.

When mine were little we were lucky enough to have the choice of whether I stayed at home to look after the kids or not instead of sending them to a childminder or putting them in nursery. So I stayed at home FT for 3 years until DS1 got his half days at nursery. DH has a full on job and is out of the house from 6am. He doesn't come home until at least 6pm, often later than that and used to work away a lot too. I've always done ALL weekday morning get ups and nursery/school drop offs and pickups till I worked more hours later on when they went to a childminder or afterschool club 3 days a week. I did all night wakings too as his job role at the time meant he would have been unsafe at work it overtired.

My role during the week was mainly childcare. My days were filled mainly interacting with them or taking them to toddler group or soft play, to the park most days, to the library, to the shops, or to visit family. I didn't plonk them in a playpen while I did bigger/longer chores such as ironing, no way was I going to that as I wouldn't expect that a childminder or nursery worker would so why would I? (DS2 wouldn't have let me anyway, he was extremely demanding as a baby and toddler).

When they were pre-nursery age I did:

  • the breakfasts and lunches and the cleaning up after that.
  • putting laundry on, drying and folding it.
  • sorting and acting on post/bills/booking appointments etc
  • all food shopping.
  • preparing bottles and washing them (but sometimes DH would do these if I'd had a particularly bad day)
  • feeding the kids their tea
  • bedtime routine including bath

DH generally got home from work on a good day sometime during bathtime, between 6 and 7pm. ,He got stuck straight in helping however was needed. So if I was already upstairs bathing them he'd clear up downstairs a bit or start doing our own evening meal or washing botttles or emptying the dishwasher. If I hadn't started bathtime yet he'd run the bath and then bath them. Then the 45 mins after bathtime was his bonding time with the kids while I could mentally switch off a bit. He'd make us both a cuppa and we'd relax for a bit watching kids bedtime TV with them.

I did bed time when we just had DS1 and DH started cooking. When DS2 was born he helped with bedtime and then started cooking. So we ate later when both kids were settled and asleep.

It was at the weekend when we did proper housework like hoovering or cleaning the bathroom, with one of us keeping an eye on the kids and then swapping over. He hoovered and I did the bathroom. The kitchen we did kind of between us. I did mine and the kids' ironing and he did his own. He mowed the lawn in summer while I minded the kids, then when they got a bit older I could get on with weeding/planting while the kids pottered about with us.

When I did finally have some proper child free time during the week for a couple of hours a day while they were in nursery I took on the hoovering, did some ironing and more deep cleaning/sorting kind of jobs. I honestly laugh at those suggesting I should have sat on my arse for those 2 hours, how lazy! Yes, if I was feeling under the weather with a cold I may have done that. But honestly why should have I just had that as leisure time while I knew that DH was at work doing a demanding stressful job all those hours and paying all our mortgage and bills without me having to pay anything towards them? I'm astounded that people somehow think that SAHMs "deserve" this "sitting on their arse" time while their other half is at work earning so that we could all have a home and food on the table.

Re weekend lie-ins, DH got up one day, I got up the other.

Now we both work FT and the kids are mid-late teens so much more independent and need us a lot less, obviously. Unfortunately, DH's had a couple of promotions the last couple of years so he's often working a lot on his laptop in the evenings and at weekends now just to keep up with his workload so our house is a bit of a shit tip as I'm buggered if I'm working FT AND spending all my weekend doing household chores. (I haven't got the energy anymore to do much housework in the evenings so just the bare minimum gets done which means it builds up). DH does enjoy cooking so he does that mostly. He ignores his ironing pile and irons one outfit daily instead Hmm.

Christ, what a long and quite boring post, actually, now I look at it. Grin

ooooopsididit · 23/02/2022 19:37

@girlmom21

OP does he want some days where he can just come home and do nothing other than play with the kids and read them a story? Is that what he's saying?

Maybe agree on the days where the kids are in nursery you do bedtimes and one day at the weekend, then the days where you have them both at home and the other day on the weekend he does bedtime?

Bed times are already split, with us alternating nights. So on the nights I put the dc to bed he has his own time.

He does vacuum and dust a lot but I've never taken Too much notice because they're things I'd do, if he hadn't already done them!

He's a good man and not one to mention much so I was surprised when he commented earlier. I'd been oblivious to it as I was just glad it was getting done. But now he's mentioned I'll be a bit more proactive.

He's also told me he's glad I get some time to myself 😊

OP posts:
PeakyBlender · 23/02/2022 19:31

When I was a SAHM I did most of the household chores. I think he's been very patient not to bring it up before Grin

Perfect28 · 23/02/2022 19:30

Why does he have to be at work full time so you can live? Clearly you have an excess as you can afford to not work and pay for childcare whilst you're at home for two children. Couldn't you both work part time to make things more equitable? You said you've worked for 20 years so what's stopping you going back to that?

girlmom21 · 23/02/2022 19:29

OP does he want some days where he can just come home and do nothing other than play with the kids and read them a story? Is that what he's saying?

Maybe agree on the days where the kids are in nursery you do bedtimes and one day at the weekend, then the days where you have them both at home and the other day on the weekend he does bedtime?

ooooopsididit · 23/02/2022 19:24

@GemmaAlone

I do take my children out so he'd be perfectly able to have the house to himself for the day, if he wanted, or he could go out. He'd be free to chose, like I am on my day off

OP, you are being silly. He presumably wants to see the children at the weekends because he doesn't see them that much during the week, not through choice.

You have it all ways at the moment - you have the luxury of not having to go to work, plus the luxury of a day and a half entirely to yourself. Plus you spend lots of time with your children, so wouldn't understand the point of view of a parent who has barely seen them all week (if I hadn't seen my children all week, I wouldn't want their other parent to take them out on Saturdays).

You really are being very unreasonable here.

So what is the answer then?

I've already said I'm prepared to do more around the house so he doesn't have to.

I haven't gone back to work because I can't find anything that wouldn't impact his work, and will work Around our children's nursery hours. He doesn't want them to go full time and neither do I.

He has to go to work full time so we can actually afford to live. So I can't change that.

I've said he can have a day to himself at the weekend because that would be fair as I get a day in the week. But that's not good enough either because he hasn't seen the kids all week.

So really what shall I do? Short of putting more hours in the day, or an extra day in the week, what do you advise?

OP posts:
WonderfulYou · 23/02/2022 19:22

I won't be spending my free day scrubbing skirting boards.

OP what did you think being a SAHP entailed?

It’s not a free pass to do nothing all day.
Your ‘job’ throughout the week is to do the childcare and clean etc.
As your kids are in nursery sometimes you should find this easier than most SAHP.

On the weekend it should be 50/50.

GemmaAlone · 23/02/2022 19:15

I do take my children out so he'd be perfectly able to have the house to himself for the day, if he wanted, or he could go out. He'd be free to chose, like I am on my day off

OP, you are being silly. He presumably wants to see the children at the weekends because he doesn't see them that much during the week, not through choice.

You have it all ways at the moment - you have the luxury of not having to go to work, plus the luxury of a day and a half entirely to yourself. Plus you spend lots of time with your children, so wouldn't understand the point of view of a parent who has barely seen them all week (if I hadn't seen my children all week, I wouldn't want their other parent to take them out on Saturdays).

You really are being very unreasonable here.

Aderyn21 · 23/02/2022 19:15

Nursery funding is there because its good for kids to socialise - it's not for the parents benefit but for the child's.
It doesn't exist to provide free childcare for wohp anymore than sah ones!

Aubree17 · 23/02/2022 19:12

Chores can be done an hour a day if your totally on top of them.
I think you should be doing them all.
You oh spare time should be spent with the children .... bathing, bedding etc.

Foxglovers · 23/02/2022 19:04

@Perfect28

Man I get so annoyed at parents putting kids in childcare and then sitting at home doing nothing. I guess they are over 3 and getting funding? I don't understand why all kids get funding at 3 regardless of what parents are doing when that money could be better spent funding younger babies who's parents need to work.
All kids don’t get funding. It’s only if you earn under £100k
VirginMedium · 23/02/2022 18:57

@toomuchlaundry

I don't have an iron, but this is how laundry (doesn't) work in this house;

admire empty laundry basket
kids dump laundry into basket that they have been hoarding in their rooms, for what looks like months
ask kids to carry very overflowing basket down stairs, because I can't
child carries basket down stairs a week later, dropping items the whole way, like hansel and Gretel
wash a load
string it on radiators and on line and put what is allowed in drier
put on second load
fold up dry clothes from drier
unload 2nd load into basket to wait for radiator and line space
it rains, but no where to put clothes so leave them on line
fold clothes from radiator into basket
put half wet clothes onto radiator
put clothes from line back in washer because they smell
unload
put clothes that were in basket waiting for radiator space back in washer because they now smell
repeat a few times
run out of baskets because no one is putting away clean laundry and there is a bottle neck and basket of clean and dry/clean but wet/dirty etc clothes all over the place

I have now stopped having a communal laundry basket and everyone has to do their own, but situation hasn't improved 🤣

peboh · 23/02/2022 18:57

@ooooopsididit I absolutely agree that as a parent you deserve time to yourself. I'm a sahm myself, and with dd in nursery (15 hours per week) I get plenty of time to myself, whilst also getting the majority of housework done too. My DH doesn't do much in terms of housework during the week once dd is in bed, as that's his alone time. He chips in more at the weekend with picking things up etc and that's when we do a more "equal" split because we're both at home, managing the house and caring for dd.

rogueone · 23/02/2022 18:54

Sitting there counting the hours, making excuses about how much you do when he seems to do alot despite having a full time job. Stating your not giving up your freetime to scrub skirting boards. I have 4 DC and with my last i took longer mat leave. It was lovely pottering to the baby groups, going out for lunch with friends, went to baby friendly movies. Absolutley nothing like being at work. My job was stressful so i made the most of my time off. I did the bulk of the housework, laundry and meal prep. I enjoy cooking anyway. I dreaded going back to work as I enjoyed my life but hey ho it had to be done.

With your attitude i wouldnt be surprised your DH leaves as he gets resentful especially with your 'me time' and when he gets the kids 50/50 he realises he gets more of a break. You seem to think his 'me time' is when he is at work

namechangetheworld · 23/02/2022 18:53

Christ. The way that some MNetters are desperately twisting themselves in knots in order to justify the OP's laziness simply because she's a woman is embarassing. If she was a man posting this she would have had her arse handed to her in every single response.

You're taking the piss OP. You know it and your DH knows it. Although judging from your responses you've clearly already decided you're in the right.

ooooopsididit · 23/02/2022 18:50

[quote peboh]@ooooopsididit are weekends not family time though? Given he does 50/50 house work split, when we he see his children and spend quality time with them if you take the children out without him on the weekend?
I feel like you've had one poster who has said you aren't unreasonable, and now your backtracking on the fact that you previously agreed that perhaps he was right and you just hadn't though of it that way. [/quote]
I do agree that it's definitely split in my favour, and as I've said many times, I'm glad he's mentioned it. We'll talk about it and find a way forward that is fairer for him.

What has surprised me is how many posters are shocked that I would want some time to myself, time that doesn't consist of doing stuff for others.

DH has been doing more that his share in some areas and we will work towards balancing that. But why should I feel bad because my children go to nursery so I can have a bit of time to myself.

OP posts:
saraya7 · 23/02/2022 18:45

OP, did you say what he actually does as a job? Is it particularly physically demanding?

I totally agree with you. Make the most of your Friday. You have to for your sanity. Then you won’t resent him if he wants to go off and do something on the weekend. It’s a win win.

I don’t know why people’s heads start spinning about this kind of thing. It’s not a competition.

You are home for his convenience. He can go to work with a clear head, secure in the knowledge that you are default parent, come what may. I bet he has his lunches out and adult chat when he’s at work? When he has a free moment in between meetings or whatever - does he feel the need to start cleaning his workplace? No he does not.

Kanaloa · 23/02/2022 18:44

@TravellingFrom

I said working in childcare is nothing like being a sahm. Which it isn’t. I don’t know about office jobs or how long you can relax in them, but I’ve always managed to have a cup of tea, watch telly, relax etc when a sahm as well, so I don’t buy this ‘oh it’s actually easier to go to work than be a sahm to two children at nursery.’ In my experience it’s not true.

theleafandnotthetree · 23/02/2022 18:43

The solution to historically unfair divisions of labour between men and women, the disproportionate share of housework and childcare still done by women when they work full time is NOT to take revenge by taking the piss out of the good and fair men in our own lives. The OP seems so determined not to be a martyr and to make sure she's not being treated badly that she is, in my view, being very unfair to her husband. I don't like cheeky fuckers, I care not what sex they are..

peboh · 23/02/2022 18:42

@ooooopsididit are weekends not family time though? Given he does 50/50 house work split, when we he see his children and spend quality time with them if you take the children out without him on the weekend?
I feel like you've had one poster who has said you aren't unreasonable, and now your backtracking on the fact that you previously agreed that perhaps he was right and you just hadn't though of it that way.