Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH has suggested division of childcare/housework unfair...

456 replies

ooooopsididit · 23/02/2022 14:01

Just that really!

DH works full time, from home until recently, but is now back in the office two days per week.

I am a SAHM of two nursery age children.

Both children are at nursery four half days and one full day per week.

DH and I split the morning get up and ready routine, and bedtime routines between us.

The housework is also split about 50/50, although I do more cooking and all laundry.

I also do all lunchtime pickups of DC.

For the complete picture I do have a little cleaning job of about four hours a week, but I could give that up if I wanted the extra time back.

I thought this was fine but DH his just said he thinks it's a bit unfair... I suspect he may be right.

AIBU to expect this to be fine
YABU to split this way as he works full time

OP posts:
OnceuponaRainbow18 · 24/02/2022 11:01

@saraya7

He does respect her, respect works both ways.

You should very defensive

DillonPanthersTexas · 24/02/2022 11:01

OP: Am I being Unreasonable?

Everyone: Yes

OP: No I'm not.

saraya7 · 24/02/2022 10:59

Well, they need someone around. Any signs of him stepping into that role? Er, No. So if he wants them with their mum so that he can continue in his career trajectory unaffected, then he should respect her for being prepared to do that.

Perfect28 · 24/02/2022 10:50

'need their mum around'. Offensive to those who work tbh, like so many of us do (now it's not 1955).

saraya7 · 24/02/2022 10:47

No she doesn’t have 4 free mornings and a free day. Please read the thread - the kids are at nursery at different times. She has one free morning, plus Friday.

Even with a cleaner, there will still obviously be stuff house-related stuff for her to do in that time. I’m just saying, being a SAHM should not be equated with “SAH housework martyr.”

Nor should she feel guilty about having a bit of headspace in the week, fgs. Bring a SAHM is not really comparable to a “full time job.” It takes a different kind of resilience to being out at work for money. You can very easily “lose yourself” if you’re not careful. But there are “perks” to the SAH role for sure. If that’s being able to meet a friend every single often for lunch; or a few hours Netflix; or the gym - so be it! If the DH is at work and it’s a slow day; or someone says, “let’s go out for a long lunch,” or whatever the case may be, is he supposed to say, “No sorry - I must justify my existence by being nose to the grindstone because my wife has my kids today.” No I don’t think so!

Aderyn21 · 24/02/2022 10:36

I never said they aren't obliged to consider it, I said they aren't obliged to agree. Not if they think it will negatively impact their business. There are some roles where it's straightforward to have a job share or accommodate pt but some jobs just don't lend themselves to reduced days. And what can happen is a person ends up working harder/longer during their 4 days to get everything done but loses the wage for the 5th day.

OnceuponaRainbow18 · 24/02/2022 10:34

@saraya7

Good for you guys but the real world doesn’t work like that for most.

VirginMedium · 24/02/2022 10:30

@Aderyn21 employee IS obliged to consider the request. most reputable employers accommodate PT working these days.

maddening · 24/02/2022 10:28

"She's free 2.5 days per week.

He's free 2 days per week (the weekend)."

She is without the kids for 4 mornings and 1 full day when they are in the nursery.

So in the week she has 4 half days (2 days) and 1 full day to herself. 3 days in total.

They both have the weekend, so she has 5 days and he has 2.

I would suggest that all house cleaning etc should be done in the 3 days in the week, weekend should just be meals and tag teaming the kids.

I would expect all adults to pick up after themselves.

saraya7 · 24/02/2022 10:17

Put it this way, when I became a SAHM, my husband was extremely grateful because he wanted his children with their mother. That’s all there is to it. Yes they went to nursery a couple of mornings a week when they were about three. Just like all the other kids tend to do round here, so they learn how to be apart from you before school. So what? My husband wasn’t instantly on my case, wanting to know what housework I was doing in these amazing free hours of 9am to 12pm. If anything, he wanted to know why I wasn’t doing more for myself in this time because he appreciates young kids are relentless. Why on earth would he want a wife who feels she has to be a domestic drudge - while he jetted round the world building up his business interests with no worries at all about his kids because she was taking care of that for him? Does that sound like “equality.” No. When he wanted me “at home” it wasn’t to do housework. Let make that clear. I always had a cleaner. If I needed any extra help, then I would ask her. Not him. I understood his time is better spent on his work and we all benefit from that. You don’t make your money, faffing about part-time. His salary has put three kids though independent school; bought the home I always wanted; and secured all of our financial future. What would be the point of me trying to stifle that? Do this is why I say, if OP is not happy, she should just get some help in the form of a cleaner and he should be on board with that, as she’s supporting his career. I bet she’s as educated as him. They are equals, right? Why should she become a housework skivvy, just because he is the higher earner and they have young children who need their mum around?

UnexpectedItemInShaggingArea · 24/02/2022 10:05

@madmomma

Yeah your husband is right. I'm a sahm of school aged kids and I do all the domestic stuff and 98% of the kid- related stuff. Dh grafts and pays all the bills. I wouldn't dream of asking him to clean the kitchen or cook. If you go for traditional roles you've got to crack on and get everyone fed and the house sorted. I'd still far, far rather be us than them, but of course it wouldn't suit everyone.

School aged kids very different to tiny kids doing 3-4 hours at nursery.

TrufflesAndToast · 24/02/2022 10:04

Let’s be honest, how many men have you seen that CHOOSE to go part time whilst their dcs were little?

My husband did. He went to a four day week and I did the same. As a result I have had two significant promotions since having my first baby which I wouldn’t have had by working a three day week. He has also been promoted in that time. Both of us working four days has meant we both get career progression whereas him working five days and me three would have been no better for him and my career would have stalled. He loves his day off with the kids and is incredibly close with both of them and more than capable of looking after them in a practical sense because he’s done it just as much as I have.

Several of my male colleagues work some part time or flexible pattern and share childcare with their partners. Of those that have kids, more work part time than don’t.

It can be done and many men want to.

It can be done and many men want to.

UnexpectedItemInShaggingArea · 24/02/2022 10:01

She's free 2.5 days per week.

He's free 2 days per week (the weekend).

She's got a baby and a toddler and does the lion's share.

Sounds fair to me. No one really has any down time with two very small kids.

saraya7 · 24/02/2022 09:58

Even if it is possible for him to reduce his hours (which I doubt), how does it help the family to have the OP working in these hours for less money? Confused

If you don’t want your kids in full- time childcare, then you don’t want your kids in full time childcare. End of story. You don’t change your children’s lifestyle to make sure you can do this 50/50 housework business and both be part-time. Where is their future in that?

Perfect28 · 24/02/2022 09:57

If working is so great why can't she work outside the home in this free time she has? I think so many people are failing to realise that most people with young children simply do not get free time or me time. That's just how it is. Starting to think this post is more about a money/class divide than anything else. The fact is, having free time is a luxury most can't afford. If one person in a couple has free time then so should the other.

Perfect28 · 24/02/2022 09:53

@TravellingFrom why is pleasing him the goal exactly? Aren't they a team?

Aderyn21 · 24/02/2022 09:52

There are some jobs where it just isn't possible to go part time - it just doesn't suit the nature of the work. And the employer isn't obliged to agree if it's going to negatively impact their business.

I think the dh is being a bit petty tbh - he is getting to keep his career and all its benefits (progression, pension, not being looked at as a layabout who sponges off their spouse). OP has lost all that. Looking after children is boring, has no social value and disadvantages women in career terms. It also saves the family a lot of money in childcare fees and makes day to day life easier (no losing all your annual leave on plugging childcare gaps). It is a financial contribution, just not a direct one.
And it is a sacrifice even for women who willingly choose to do it because there are costs to her.
And he resents her having a day to herself? Seems mean to me. She's probably not sitting on her arse all day anyway - she's probably doing the shopping or doing little bits and pieces.
The husband wants this arrangement for his children, I just think he also fancies not doing so much in the house.

Perfect28 · 24/02/2022 09:52

Saraya it means reducing your working days or hours. You seem very confused by the idea. This couple currently have spare money to fund two children through nursery even whilst a parent is available to care for them. That suggests he could afford to reduce his hours doesn't it. And if she has free time that suggests she has time to work outside the home.

saraya7 · 24/02/2022 09:47

“@saraya7 he can go 80% or 90% then.”

How on earth can you know this? Do we even know what he does?

You must know that unless you work in a factory job or something where you clock in and click off, most jobs don’t work like that.

‘Going 80 or 90%’ - what does that even mean in actual reality?

madmomma · 24/02/2022 09:46

Yeah your husband is right. I'm a sahm of school aged kids and I do all the domestic stuff and 98% of the kid- related stuff. Dh grafts and pays all the bills. I wouldn't dream of asking him to clean the kitchen or cook. If you go for traditional roles you've got to crack on and get everyone fed and the house sorted. I'd still far, far rather be us than them, but of course it wouldn't suit everyone.

GracieLouFreebushh · 24/02/2022 09:44

Of course that is not fair you should be doing much more

VirginMedium · 24/02/2022 09:42

There is far more to life and a family than obsessing about 50/50 housework!

well there is definitely more to life than doing everyone's housework and looking after the kids

VirginMedium · 24/02/2022 09:41

@saraya7 he can go 80% or 90% then.

what nose? what face? what's the goal?...earning as much money as possible? if they can manage a decrease in income, why not?

TravellingFrom · 24/02/2022 09:39

@Perfect28 the DH hasn’t asked for that though.

What he asked for is to do less in the house/with the dcs.
He hasn’t asked to spend more time with them.
He also asked for the dcs NOT to be in childcare full time., that means the OP can’t have a full time job (or even a part time one to fit around him).
That’s what HE wants.

So yes there are probably some men who would be happy to go part time. This particular man hasn’t given any signal that this is what he wants.

saraya7 · 24/02/2022 09:37

If he earns significantly more than her, both ‘just going part-time’ could well be essentially cutting off your nose to spite your face. More hectic lives and more juggling for less money. Both parents kind of stuck as ‘Jack if all trades, master of none,’ for any of a better description. Nobody gets to progress career-wise, just working on a part-time basis (well they’re much less likely to), so that’s it. Fixed income for life. How is that helping the children in terms of their future options? There is far more to life and a family than obsessing about 50/50 housework!