Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Just invited to “After” party

606 replies

Cantleave · 23/02/2022 10:21

My Dsis has a big birthday (60th) coming up next week. My DN messaged me to invite me to a ‘surprise’ party. She said the plan was for DN, her siblings and their DCs to take Dsis out to lunch and then to all go back to my Dsis and bil’s house where the rest of the guests would be for the ‘surprise’ part. I was asked to make something and bring wine for the party! I was happy to make something, but a bit miffed at being asked to take wine too (I don’t drink), as I had already bought my Dsis a lovely gift, which cost a lot more than I could really afford!

However, firstly I am disabled and no cars are allowed at Dsis’s house, which means I will have difficulty getting there and back. With the other costs, I can’t afford a taxi. Secondly I am really struggling with my mental health (I lost my dh a few months ago) and really struggle to be in large groups, especially with people I don’t really know very well. I have been trying to overcome the issues with my mental health, but I feel really unwell, even at the thought of going out alone!

I decided to ask my brother, if I could get a lift with whoever is taking them. My brother wasn’t in when I phoned, so I spoke to sil (who I don’t really get on with). She took great delight in saying that wouldn’t be possible, as they were going to the lunch! I just said to her okay, I would try someone else, to which she replied saying not to ask A,B,C and D as they were also going to the lunch!

I am so hurt that it isn’t just Dsis’s immediate family at the lunch as DN said, but a wider base of family and friends, just not me!😓 To be clear, ‘D’sis knows who is going to the lunch, but obviously not the party afterwards, so as far as she is concerned I am just not invited!

I really don’t want to go at all now, as apart from the issues I have described, I am really embarrassed that I don’t seem to matter to my ‘D’sis. I know if I go, I will be asked why I wasn’t at the lunch and if I don’t go, I will be accused of being petty!

I am not going to get in touch with DN (who is also my goddaughter) and tell her how hurt I am, but would I be unreasonable to just say at the last minute that I’m not feeling well so can’t go?

OP posts:
Queenkarm · 24/02/2022 14:45

Another thought if my dsis was grieving for her dh, had very little money and anxious about meeting new people I would pay for her meal and a taxi to the restaurant as a treat. As it was a family meal with dsis friends the OP would know most of the party if not all of them. It is probably the after party OP would struggle with who OP may not know and her anxiety would be high. No good trying to dress it up they have treated OP in a dismissive way. OP for your sake I hope it is a misunderstanding and not done out of spite. Wishing you well OPFlowers

BiBabbles · 24/02/2022 14:43

Entirely NBU to not go. It seems not that well thought out. How is your relationship with your other family members otherwise?

It might be an idea to get emotional support for yourself like counselling

Counseling is not emotional support. A counselor can help a person develop emotional support through other people in their life, but counseling and emotional support are very different and one shouldn't go into counseling expecting that.

You know that the reality is your extended family does love you and would like to see you at that party

Her sister isn't her extended family - , she's immediate family and we cannot assume she has an inkling of anything before getting into evidence otherwise like that their brother is invited to the lunch. Why would he and SIL be invited if the sister knew she'd see them later?

While I agree that there may be a jump to the negative if this is the only situation like this in their relationship and the OP said anything about entirely cutting off which she hasn't, assuming a positive that equally can not be assumed to be 'reality' either is not helpful. Their unloving actions may be unintentional, but trying to make it a positive or that it's not really a big deal is dismissive and a block to accepting and being able to discuss the pain caused.

There may be another explanation like the sister badly thought she could assume what the OP would say if she had been asked and unintentionally did something hurtful with good intent. It's also possible that the reality is that they've become related strangers - neither negative or positive on it's own, it can be viewed as a neutral that many family members end up with time and distance. It can be very frustrating, and the opposite of emotional support, to have someone push the narrative that being related means anything about how someone feels about us. Judging that takes more than one event, even a large one like this, but trying to make everything positive and about what we can gain can be just as unhealthy as assuming the worst (like assuming she's going to cut off her nose to spite her face but just not going to a party her sister didn't invite her to and sending an alternative gift). The most likely result is in the middle.

GabriellaMontez · 24/02/2022 14:28

@Ihatebullies2022

Gosh, imagine being one of the 17 friends waiting in the middle of nowhere to surprise your friend on her birthday, only for her to arrive with all the people she actually wanted to be with, and realising you weren't one of them. 17 people going out of their way to make her birthday special and all of them getting a massive 'fuck you' in return.

I'd be slipping out the back door with my king prawn platter and they'd never see me again.

And somehow having arrived in the middle of nowhere without a car... I'd love e to know how exactly its going to work. Will they all jump out of the bushes when the important people arrive from the main party?
ifIwerenotanandroid · 24/02/2022 14:27

Thinking about my post above, it happened a long time ago & I think we arrived at the venue & everyone was sitting round a big dining table - so the meal had happened there.

RachelGreeneGreep · 24/02/2022 14:22

@Ihatebullies2022

Gosh, imagine being one of the 17 friends waiting in the middle of nowhere to surprise your friend on her birthday, only for her to arrive with all the people she actually wanted to be with, and realising you weren't one of them. 17 people going out of their way to make her birthday special and all of them getting a massive 'fuck you' in return.

I'd be slipping out the back door with my king prawn platter and they'd never see me again.

I love this, especially the slipping out the back door with the platter. 'All around to mine, you second class party people. And bring your grub and wine with you' Grin
ifIwerenotanandroid · 24/02/2022 14:21

@Ihatebullies2022

Gosh, imagine being one of the 17 friends waiting in the middle of nowhere to surprise your friend on her birthday, only for her to arrive with all the people she actually wanted to be with, and realising you weren't one of them. 17 people going out of their way to make her birthday special and all of them getting a massive 'fuck you' in return.

I'd be slipping out the back door with my king prawn platter and they'd never see me again.

I had something like this once. Close friend of the family organised a party for her son's 18th with lots of his schoolfriends & invited DH & me, who were much older than that. I tried to refuse on the grounds that we'd be out of place there, but she insisted & so we went to the venue with a present, thinking at least it was nice that she wanted us to celebrate with them. Nope.

We arrived & found lots of older members of my family there, & it turned out they'd all just been to a restaurant for a birthday dinner. They left, the party started & we found that it was actually a loud disco & we were simply there to help out in some way which was never made clear to us. After 3 hours of boredom, watching teenagers dance & attempting shouted conversations with the boy's parents, we left - to the apparent anguish of the parents, who wanted us to stay till the very end. I don't know what they were expecting us to do at the end, presumably help clear up.

They were really nice people who were very hospitable to us at other times, so I've no idea what went wrong that night.

Ihatebullies2022 · 24/02/2022 14:14

Well it's not really different to having some to the meal at a wedding & others arriving later for the buffet & dancing is it?

Not really. All the wedding guests are invited by the bride and groom. The surprise party guests have not been invited by the birthday girl. She doesn't want them at her birthday celebration.

FrenchBoule · 24/02/2022 14:08

@irene9 I suggest you get on your high horse and gallop away to RTFT

RachelGreeneGreep · 24/02/2022 14:07

@liliainterfrutices

Hmmm. I suppose it's possible that the sister may have thought she was considering OP's feelings when not inviting her to the lunch, but she's managed it incredibly badly. If it were me and my sister in that position I'd phone her up, tell her I was having the lunch and ask her how she felt about it with the option of just the two of us having a lovely lunch together on a separate day, if she chose not to come. What I would not do is have a secret lunch party and risk the very hurt feelings that the OP is now experiencing. And for the record, OP, your SiL is an absolute bitch.
That was exactly what I was thinking. It would have been nice to simply have a quiet lunch together, in the circumstances.
RachelGreeneGreep · 24/02/2022 14:05

@HenryIV

I think you’re avoiding a very awkward ‘surprise’ party. Your SIL is going to be blindsided when faced with 17 people who weren’t important enough to attend the lunch, particularly with an entourage of 32. You’re best out of it but I’d love to be a fly on that wall. You sound lovely OP and have behaved with absolute dignity. You’re niece, btw, sounds lovely, as do you and you deserve better.
That reminds me for some reason of Friends when Monica's friends for her surprise party hide, and she says to Monica and Phoebe she didn't care about seeing them anyway. And then they all pop up from where they were hiding. Awwwwwkward.

Glad you are keeping the gift, OP. It sounds lovely and you deserve it.

liliainterfrutices · 24/02/2022 14:05

Hmmm. I suppose it's possible that the sister may have thought she was considering OP's feelings when not inviting her to the lunch, but she's managed it incredibly badly. If it were me and my sister in that position I'd phone her up, tell her I was having the lunch and ask her how she felt about it with the option of just the two of us having a lovely lunch together on a separate day, if she chose not to come. What I would not do is have a secret lunch party and risk the very hurt feelings that the OP is now experiencing. And for the record, OP, your SiL is an absolute bitch.

JustLyra · 24/02/2022 13:54

Well it's not really different to having some to the meal at a wedding & others arriving later for the buffet & dancing is it?

Only if you have evening guests who are being told that only immediate family are going to the wedding, but actually the bulk of the guests are going - just not them.

diddl · 24/02/2022 13:53

@Eddielizzard

If I were DN I would just cancel the surprise party and give some excuse. It's a bit of a shit show.
I does seem odd to have people coming back from lunch to be greeted by people clutching wine & platters doesn't it?

Or are the lunch people supposed to go home from the restaurant?

LookItsMeAgain · 24/02/2022 13:52

@Totalwasteofpaper - She set up an immediate family lunch and a surprise party after for a larger extended group.
So far so lovely nice.

Except for the fact that it wasn't an immediate family lunch. It was a family lunch minus the sister of the birthday 'girl' so not an immediate family lunch to me.

So far not so nice niece.

washingmachines4 · 24/02/2022 13:36

OP I see everyone is very much on your side and I am absolutely with you that you have been treated badly and asking you to bring wine when you don't drink it is out of line.
I do wonder though as you have mentioned quite a few times that you are short on money whether they didn't want to put you in a position where you couldn't pay for dinner and had to refuse on that basis? Also, if you thought you were closer to your sister than it appears I do wonder if there is another explanation. I have friends/family I see in a group, and others I prefer to see on their own. I am definitely closer to the ones I catch up with one on one, I wonder whether there was a plan to catch up with you separately knowing you aren't a fan of groups but they invited you to the after party so you weren't excluded from the day.
There are definitely things here you are justified to be hurt by, but if you really think you are close then I do suggest not throwing it back at them just yet and getting to the bottom of it calmly when you feel able.
sending hugs.

OperationDog · 24/02/2022 13:19

I'd be slipping out the back door with my king prawn platter and they'd never see me again

Grin Grin

irene9 · 24/02/2022 13:17

I'm neither the sister or the niece! Smile
There's more to this than meets the eye.
I'm merely hoping the OP will pause before any cutting of nose to spite face goes on. To see what can she gain from this situation.
It's a lose lose situation currently.
It depends what's more important to the OP.
Nobody said that those people at the lunch are going back to the OPs house.

ThumbWitchesAbroad · 24/02/2022 13:16

Yes, I have to agree that, once the OP's sister expanded the lunch plans, the surprise party should have either been totally scrapped, or OP's niece should have just told her mother about it so that it was no longer a surprise.

It's now an epic fuck up and will cause a lot of hurt feelings, I think - not just OP's!

Eddielizzard · 24/02/2022 13:11

If I were DN I would just cancel the surprise party and give some excuse. It's a bit of a shit show.

diddl · 24/02/2022 12:57

@Ihatebullies2022

Gosh, imagine being one of the 17 friends waiting in the middle of nowhere to surprise your friend on her birthday, only for her to arrive with all the people she actually wanted to be with, and realising you weren't one of them. 17 people going out of their way to make her birthday special and all of them getting a massive 'fuck you' in return.

I'd be slipping out the back door with my king prawn platter and they'd never see me again.

Well it's not really different to having some to the meal at a wedding & others arriving later for the buffet & dancing is it?

But having such a big number to the lunch & less for the party seems odd to me.

32 to lunch-why not 49??

Needdoughnuts · 24/02/2022 12:51

Poor dn! So awkward now for everyone involved! Why didn't dn or dbil say no at the beginning and reiterate it was a family lunch? Then if she insisted either come clean or ask the new invitees to say no as they'd obviously know there was a surprise party in the evening.
Once it got this big it does seem odd that op wasn't invited or even suggested by dn to her mother.
I think dsis needs to know everything now and see what she thinks should happen.

DonNotKeith · 24/02/2022 12:48

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

bettytaghetti · 24/02/2022 12:48

[quote NotMyselfWithoutCoffee]@irene9

Okay...are you the niece?

Bit of a tangent lol Hmm[/quote]
Or the sister?! 🧐

NotMyselfWithoutCoffee · 24/02/2022 12:40

@irene9

Okay...are you the niece?

Bit of a tangent lol Hmm

peboh · 24/02/2022 12:35

@Ihatebullies2022

Gosh, imagine being one of the 17 friends waiting in the middle of nowhere to surprise your friend on her birthday, only for her to arrive with all the people she actually wanted to be with, and realising you weren't one of them. 17 people going out of their way to make her birthday special and all of them getting a massive 'fuck you' in return.

I'd be slipping out the back door with my king prawn platter and they'd never see me again.

So true. It's embarrassing. I get the idea of the surprise party if it was only ops sisters immediate family as she originally thought ... not every one she's ever met and their plus ones.