Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who’s in the right?!

213 replies

wonderwoman26 · 23/02/2022 08:07

I will try and explain as clear as I can

To get into my car park for work you have to turn right off a main road and straight into the opening for the car park. There is a path/cycle Lane either side of the opening.

For the second time this morning, the same cyclist has not stopped to see if the coast is clear to cycle across the turning, meaning I have had to slam my brakes on/he’s swerved to miss me. This means I’ve had to stop dead in the middle of the other side of the road to ensure I don’t hit him.

Am I right in thinking cars have the right of way turning in and cyclists should wait on the path until it’s clear?

Tempted not to bloody stop next time. Grrrrr

OP posts:
DameOctaviaOstrich · 23/02/2022 09:05

Even though you are in the wrong I think you are right. I've noticed more cyclists undertaking and going through red lights just because the road is clear
I'm so glad they have brought in the law about passing cyclists and horse riders though. Some car drivers are tits

EnjoyingTheSilence · 23/02/2022 09:03

Btw I once knocked a cyclist off his bike. It wasn’t funny. Luckily we were both ok but it was one of the worst experiences I’ve had as a driver. He was technically wrong (he admitted this) but that wouldn’t have mattered if he’d been killed, it would still have been my car that killed him.

Daisydoesnt · 23/02/2022 09:03

both times he ended up swerving behind me to not hit into the side of me - as I was already that far into the turning that I wouldn’t have hit him with the front of my car, he would of hit me if that makes sense

Just wow - it gets worse!!

OP if you pulled out in front of a car that you'd failed to notice, and that car had to swerve to miss your back end, would that have been their fault or your fault? It would have been your fault, of course, for failing to observe and not having enough time to complete your manoeuvre.

In the same vein it doesn't matter that you'd nearly got across your turning this morning; you'd not allowed enough time for you to complete your manoeuvre without the cyclist having to take emergency evasive action. The fact that he had to swerve to avoid hitting hit you is because you pulled out in front of him!

wonderwoman26 · 23/02/2022 09:02

@Fizio

OP your attitude towards cyclists does need a rethink. DF was out cycling on a country road (not going for any Strava records at his age Hmm) and saw a tractor approaching so pulled in to let the tractor by. The uneven road surface meant his wheel got caught as he stopped and he fell off and broke his hip. Nobody at fault here but due to the broken hip, he will never be able to run again which is something he had done his whole life. My point here is just to show you how vulnerable cyclists are. A bump to your car can be life changing for somebody on a bike.
I have no doubt a car would come off better than a cyclist, and contrary to belief I am not driving around aiming for cyclists. I was just wondering who had right of way. Believe it or not, I’m not some psychopath who had a hidden agenda to take all cyclists off the road.

Sorry that happen to you DF though xx

OP posts:
Fizio · 23/02/2022 09:01

OP your attitude towards cyclists does need a rethink. DF was out cycling on a country road (not going for any Strava records at his age Hmm) and saw a tractor approaching so pulled in to let the tractor by. The uneven road surface meant his wheel got caught as he stopped and he fell off and broke his hip. Nobody at fault here but due to the broken hip, he will never be able to run again which is something he had done his whole life. My point here is just to show you how vulnerable cyclists are. A bump to your car can be life changing for somebody on a bike.

EnjoyingTheSilence · 23/02/2022 08:58

Omg you’re still going on. Thought you’d accepted you were wrong and we’re going to get on with your day.

Your latest post makes you sound even worse. You slammed your brakes on and the cyclist had to swerve behind you. So you didn’t stop in the middle of the road in oncoming traffic (like you first suggested) you didn’t stop so the cyclist could continue in their journey, you stopped right in their path.

And talking about knocking someone off their bike is not funny, it’s never a joke.

Dishwashersaurous · 23/02/2022 08:57

Perhaps a good tip for the next time is to think of the cyclist as a car in another lane. Then would you do the manoeuvre if it were a car coming towards you.

wonderwoman26 · 23/02/2022 08:57

Oh Lordy lord. It must be so miserable being so serious every second of every day.

I am wrong, you are right and I am the most Tetris human that ever lived. Shall we all move on now?

OP posts:
AllOfUsAreDead · 23/02/2022 08:57

[quote Bullandbush]@AllOfUsAreDead we know though that cyclists come off worse in a collision.
Both the driver and the cyclist shouldn't be proving a point.
Everyone should use the roads with more consideration.[/quote]
Agreed but the law doesn't agree. Its now drivers that need to pay the most consideration technically, because they have to watch for vulnerable users, like cyclists. Really it makes sense because if a driver hits a cyclists, the driver will likely walk away. The cyclist probably won't. So while the cyclist should also watch out for shite drivers, they also don't have to stop if they choose not to and if you hit them, you'll still be in trouble for it regardless of the situation. This is because, as proven by this thread, you can't expect people to be reasonable anymore or drive considerately. Someone must take the blame and be at risk of being in the wrong, and that is the driver, rightly so. They can do more damage.

luxxlisbon · 23/02/2022 08:57

“Almost” isn’t enough. Omg I can’t believe some people are even allowed on the road 🤦‍♀️

wonderwoman26 · 23/02/2022 08:55

I am not driving around with my eyes closed despite contrary belief on this post, I drove past the cyclist way before the turning, checked again that he was a safe distance. But I guess between checking the paths, the on coming traffic and the lorry in which was turning behind me, I obviously misjudged his speed.

But as stated, he swerved behind me - I was almost completing my turn before he reached me

OP posts:
luxxlisbon · 23/02/2022 08:55

The hitting with the front/ side of car is a totally stupid argument. If you pull out at a T junction without looking and the oncoming traffic hits you with the front of their car you are still at fault for pulling out into traffic when you didn’t have the right of way.

This is the same thing, it doesn’t matter if you think the cyclists is hitting you - you are the one crossing their right of way. I

vivainsomnia · 23/02/2022 08:54

Your all giving me a right chuckle this morning
Glad that you think it's funny. Having been the cyclist almost run over by someone irresponsible like you, I can assure it's not funny at all.

Can't you just for a second look into your attitude, admit that you have been very wrong, that your hated of cyclist might come from the fact that you are rude to them regularly because you don't know the highway code that eating a slice of humble pie might be very appropriate at this point, rather than making light of the issue and your attitude?

MotherCupboard · 23/02/2022 08:53

If the OP is turning her car into the entrance and the cyclist hits the side of her car....so the cyclist basically turns up during the manoeuvre would she still be the cause of the collision?

Yes, because cyclists don't just turn up out of nowhere. The cyclist would have been there to be seen.

Arabellla · 23/02/2022 08:53

This was one of my curiosity’s also, because both times he ended up swerving behind me to not hit into the side of me - as I was already that far into the turning that I wouldn’t have hit him with the front of my car, he would of hit me if that makes sense.
But by the looks of the Highway Code I’d have still been at fault

Because you are at fault. Check the pavements / cycle paths.

Bullandbush · 23/02/2022 08:52

@AllOfUsAreDead we know though that cyclists come off worse in a collision.
Both the driver and the cyclist shouldn't be proving a point.
Everyone should use the roads with more consideration.

oviraptor21 · 23/02/2022 08:52

Maybe try not to hate cyclists so much? There are good ones and bad ones, just like there are good and bad drivers. But the chances of even the bad cyclists killing someone are much lower than the chances of even the best driver.
And no, he is not safer on the path than you are on the road, as you are clearly demonstrating every time you brake/swerve to avoid him.

luxxlisbon · 23/02/2022 08:51

“ I also thought it was just the polite thing to do, but clearly we are in the minority”

So do you stop for all motorists wanting to cross over your lane then? Surely it’s the polite thing to do…

wonderwoman26 · 23/02/2022 08:51

@poorbuthappy

Ok playing devils advocate a little bit.

If the OP is turning her car into the entrance and the cyclist hits the side of her car....so the cyclist basically turns up during the manoeuvre would she still be the cause of the collision?

Yes I know it's unlikely because unless it's such a massive hill that the cyclist can get up to 80mph and appear from nowhere then actually the cyclist is in the vicinity and therefore obviously needs to be taken into account.
Just wondered Grin

This was one of my curiosity’s also, because both times he ended up swerving behind me to not hit into the side of me - as I was already that far into the turning that I wouldn’t have hit him with the front of my car, he would of hit me if that makes sense. But by the looks of the Highway Code I’d have still been at fault
OP posts:
Wiennetta · 23/02/2022 08:50

Nobody is trolling you @wonderwoman26. You said you hate cyclists and said next time you’ll just plough into him. That plus you actually not being aware of the current Highway Code is what’s worrying people - you sound like a dangerous and unpleasant driver. I hope you read the responses on here and rethink.

FrangipaniBlue · 23/02/2022 08:50

OP - AIBU?
The Highway Code - yes, you are in the wrong
OP - ok that's what you say are the rules, but your rule are silly and I'm still not BU

MN gold.

wonderwoman26 · 23/02/2022 08:49

I am more than happy with being wrong - it’s not a knock to my ego and I am now better off for knowing the Highway Code changes - the reason for the post was to find out if I’m wrong and that’s totally fine. I don’t have any issues with that, confused by those comments saying I’m having my arse handed to me? Good! Means I am getting an answer to my question.

If any of genuinely believe I would run someone over for the sake of it - your off your rockers. It’s called a joke, but clearly the seriousness of mumsnet doesn’t allow for such a thing.

OP posts:
User1367349 · 23/02/2022 08:48

It’s fascinating, isn’t it? You joke about killing a cyclist, say you hate them and then complain vigorously about everyone else’s “shitty” comments. Please take a look at yourself. If you have kids I hope you are raising them better than this.

From what you’ve described, you didn’t have right of way before the rules changed. Now they have changed you have even less excuse. Look where you are going.

poorbuthappy · 23/02/2022 08:47

Ok playing devils advocate a little bit.

If the OP is turning her car into the entrance and the cyclist hits the side of her car....so the cyclist basically turns up during the manoeuvre would she still be the cause of the collision?

Yes I know it's unlikely because unless it's such a massive hill that the cyclist can get up to 80mph and appear from nowhere then actually the cyclist is in the vicinity and therefore obviously needs to be taken into account.
Just wondered Grin

GrendelsGrandma · 23/02/2022 08:46

If having a right chuckle = having your arse handed to you because you have shown yourself not to know the rules you're required to follow as a driver, then yeah sure, hah ha ha.

You came on to get people to bitch about cyclists. The 'stoopid cyclists deserve to get knocked down' attitude is very dangerous. Sort yourself out. I don't think the police or your insurer would have a sense of humour about it either.