Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who’s in the right?!

213 replies

wonderwoman26 · 23/02/2022 08:07

I will try and explain as clear as I can

To get into my car park for work you have to turn right off a main road and straight into the opening for the car park. There is a path/cycle Lane either side of the opening.

For the second time this morning, the same cyclist has not stopped to see if the coast is clear to cycle across the turning, meaning I have had to slam my brakes on/he’s swerved to miss me. This means I’ve had to stop dead in the middle of the other side of the road to ensure I don’t hit him.

Am I right in thinking cars have the right of way turning in and cyclists should wait on the path until it’s clear?

Tempted not to bloody stop next time. Grrrrr

OP posts:
wonderwoman26 · 23/02/2022 13:09

Criminal? Hahahah give it a rest my gosh.

Can’t wait to do time for making a joke - wonder how long I’ll get

OP posts:
Blossom64265 · 23/02/2022 13:08

You aren’t supposed to initiate the turn unless the incoming cyclist won’t have to stop. Think of it as turning into the path of an oncoming car? Would you do that? No. You wouldn’t. You know you need to wait for traffic to clear. It’s the same with the cyclist, the cyclist is a vehicle and you need to wait.

Notjustanymum · 23/02/2022 13:07

YABU, unless the cycle lane has a stop line on the ground each side of the car park entrance, and with the latest changes to the Highway Code, even this doesn’t give you right of way now…

incognitoforthisone · 23/02/2022 13:06

@wonderwoman26

Okay I’ll accept it appear via Highway Code that I am in the wrong.

However in both instances with this cyclist I believe he’s been going way way to fast and using his newly given power to abuse

Regardless of which, he still has the right of way, and you are still in the wrong.
TooBored1 · 23/02/2022 13:05

@wonderwoman26

That is absolutely mental. I hate cyclists at the best of times but given he’s safer on the path then I am in the road, that decision baffles me
You are unreasonable for this alone. And threatening to not stop next time? Criminal.
wonderwoman26 · 23/02/2022 13:05

@SugarAndCoffee i have obviously drip fed slightly as I can’t evaluate the junctions/paths/cycles lanes whilst trying to right turn and not kill speedy cyclists - but the jumping to conclusions on this post without knowing the area is nothing short of hilarious.

As I said either way entering or exiting the car park is a giant hazard, teamed with the cycle path being the opposite side of the road and heavy traffic it’s an accident waiting to happen

OP posts:
SugarAndCoffee · 23/02/2022 13:02

@wonderwoman26 ha glad I read on I was like hang on I never said that!

Some people are more concerned about their bloody strata time than their safety

wonderwoman26 · 23/02/2022 12:55

@SugarAndCoffee

They are idiots then that means stop/give way
Hold on!!!! Does that mean I’m not ‘vile, murderous, entitled, arrogant, moronic, a dangerous driver’ after all?!

Ps - not aimed at you @SugarAndCoffee just trying to make another (I’m sure will be taken awfully!) joke :D

OP posts:
wonderwoman26 · 23/02/2022 12:50

@Escargooooooo

Ok, so I have no idea about right of way, but I do clearly understand the set up, so maybe if I explain it more clearly than OP, someone can say who has the right of way?....

OP is making a right hand turn, into her car park, which is via the opening of a junction into an industrial estate. On that side of the road is a cycle lane (on the road, not on the pavement). However, the lane is not continuous. It stops at one side of the mouth of the junction, and the reinstates the other side. So the junction bit OP drives through/into doesn't have a lane.

Should the cyclist be stopping as his lane terminates to allow traffic to pass into the junction, or is his right of way inherent, lane or not?

Genuinely no idea myself, although, I would assume that the car does not have right of way.

Also, noting from OPs diagram, the direction of the cyclist...is he riding the wrong way up the cycle lane? Surely if he's going the same initial direction as OP, he should be on the same side of the road as she is? I think that makes a difference, I wouldn't be looking behind me for traffic going the wrong way up a road.

I suppose yes technically he is riding against the oncoming traffic
OP posts:
SugarAndCoffee · 23/02/2022 12:49

They are idiots then that means stop/give way

wonderwoman26 · 23/02/2022 12:44

Okay update:

So as I was coming out of the car park for lunch I did a thorough checking of the turning.

There is indeed a cycle Lane, that has one of those little triangles at the end of the path to signal stop/end I am guessing, although I am sure I’ll be corrected if it means something else. It then turns into a road to allow entrance to the car park and returns to a cycle lane the other side.

Irrelevant of all this, the carpark was obviously designed/created before disregarding any Highway Code laws as the entire carpark is surrounded by a 5ft brick wall, meaning the path is not visible from the carpark.
You have to physically pull out of the carpark and stop directly in the cyclists line to be able to view either anyone on the path or any vehicles coming either side of the road.
But it’s always fab to know that even if a cyclist was to drive into the side of my car whilst I was edging forward to see round the corner, it would still be my fault

OP posts:
Momicrone · 23/02/2022 12:17

Why do cars hate stopping so much

DropYourSword · 23/02/2022 12:11

@wonderwoman26

Can I also be clear - both times I have already initiated the turn before he’s got to the opening, so I have started to turn first before he attempts to cross. Yet he still chooses not to stop
So...you could see them approaching?
NorthSouthcatlady · 23/02/2022 11:59

The cyclist has right of way. Especially as they are going straight and you’re cutting across their path in effect. Why would you have right of way, whether they were on the pavement/ cycle path / pavement?!

zxcvzxcvz · 23/02/2022 11:52

Irrespective of the new rules the person going straight has right of way. The person turning ie crossing into the path must give way.

sunshinesupermum · 23/02/2022 11:41

Cyclist has right of way as would a pedestrian.

Onlyforcake · 23/02/2022 11:38

Cycle lanes are generally not on both sides of the road. Where they are cyclists use the same side as cars. Where they are only on one side they are two directional unless it says otherwise.

Escargooooooo · 23/02/2022 11:06

Ok, so I have no idea about right of way, but I do clearly understand the set up, so maybe if I explain it more clearly than OP, someone can say who has the right of way?....

OP is making a right hand turn, into her car park, which is via the opening of a junction into an industrial estate. On that side of the road is a cycle lane (on the road, not on the pavement). However, the lane is not continuous. It stops at one side of the mouth of the junction, and the reinstates the other side. So the junction bit OP drives through/into doesn't have a lane.

Should the cyclist be stopping as his lane terminates to allow traffic to pass into the junction, or is his right of way inherent, lane or not?

Genuinely no idea myself, although, I would assume that the car does not have right of way.

Also, noting from OPs diagram, the direction of the cyclist...is he riding the wrong way up the cycle lane? Surely if he's going the same initial direction as OP, he should be on the same side of the road as she is? I think that makes a difference, I wouldn't be looking behind me for traffic going the wrong way up a road.

MostlyNormalSometimesOdd · 23/02/2022 10:53

The cyclist has right of way and you have to wait until they've passed before you execute the manoeuvre in the same way you'd have to wait for a car to pass.

Onlyforcake · 23/02/2022 10:21

You do realise you would always have been responsible if you deliberately hit a cyclist with your car?! That if there was a hazard you failed to stop for that the driver has always been responsible for their car?!
Perhaps you should stop using your car, get out and use a road on foot or on a bike in order to develop your awareness of other road users, and that stopping for hazards is very much in you, as a driver? Road. Not a race track.

inheritancetrack · 23/02/2022 10:15

Of course he has the right of way. Are you really so arrogant as to think he should stop. A cycle path on the opposite side of the road is the same as a car in the opposite carriageway. A cycle paths isn't the pavement and regardless you stop. Seriously are you annoyed at having to wait a minute for him to pass. It doesn't matter if you are turning. Are you actually saying you don't look at oncoming vehicles or pedestrians

OrinoccoFlew · 23/02/2022 10:08

@wonderwoman26

To be clear - I am not some maniac that is driving 100mph and turning into oncoming traffic.

I am obviously waiting for the coast to be clear in which it is when I initiate my turn, both times he has been nowhere near when I started my turn but because of the speed he’s flying down the path he reaches me very quickly.
I am going a suitable speed as there is a speed bump to cross also, and I obviously stop in time to not kill him

As a driver, you should be able to judge that speed, just as you would with anything else coming towards you from the opposite direction. He has right of way.
yossell · 23/02/2022 10:07

@CailleachGranda

You're getting a right kicking here OP, so much anger and rudeness.

The cyclist is on the pavement and is not stopping at an entrance. That's how I'm reading it

So by the new Highway Code rules, you need to give way to the cyclist. The one who is bit on the road but is whizzing down a pavement and not stopping to check it's clear to cross

You are in the wrong but the cyclist is the real twat here.

The op wrote that she hated cyclists; the op wrote that she was tempted not to stop next time. And you somehow agree that, although the cyclist is technically in the right, s/he is the 'real twat here.'

And you wonder at some of the responses?

EveryAvenue · 23/02/2022 10:07

I think we need a better diagram of where the cyclist was before you were about to turn in?

Personally I wouldn’t keep going with my turn if I knew a cyclist could be about to cross it (and that was before the code changed!). If a pedestrian was ten feet away from crossing a junction I wouldn’t make the turn and if I did it would only be to slowly position my car and if they crossed I wouldn’t be having to slam my breaks on. A cyclist travels much faster than a pedestrian so really I would be stopping much sooner than him being a few feet away.

Unless he was literally all the way down the other side of the road, which I doubt he could travel that fast on a bike, and given the fact you had to slam on you were obviously going a considerable speed yourself, I think he was much closer than you’re making out.

fuckoffImcounting · 23/02/2022 10:03

Cyclists and pedestrians have always had right of way when they have begun crossing - if a motor vehicle is turning from a major road into a minor road. I know many motorists did not understand this and so would put other road users at risk. This is why the code has been made more explicit - to protect more vulnerable people.