Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

WIBU? How much do you parent your children in the pool?

86 replies

justkeepswimmingandoverthinkin · 22/02/2022 23:43

To set the scene: private spa type place attached to a non-chain hotel in a non-particularly touristy area. I’d say about 80% of the members are retirees as the facilities are small and it doesn’t really compete with the likes of David Lloyds / Ballentynes etc despite charging more. I only joined with my kids (who get set hours after school + all day weekends & holidays) because an elderly relative prefers the smaller, quieter setting.

We go together most mornings and I take the kids a couple of nights a week. Sometimes we’ll be the only people there and sometimes everyone will be sharing lanes and moving over to let others past.

All good.

So when I take my kids (6 and 11) there are rules (unless we’re the only ones there).
⁃ You want to play shark etc you go in the kids pool.
⁃ If you’re in the adult pool you’re swimming in lanes (one needs help and still at the V splashy stage so we use the lane closest to the side so people can avoid us and I’ll lift her up if Betty with her perm is passing so we don’t soak her).
⁃ If you just want to float around, fine, but stay in a lane if there are other people trying to swim.
⁃ Respect other people and try not to get in others’ way / soak them etc.

I thought this was normal and honestly the only other kids I’ve seen have been babies having a float with their parent in the lane nearest the wall (and I don’t care if they splash me - they’re babies!), or older teens just swimming normally. The handful of times there have been kids ages with mine the parents have all been doing similar - that I’ve noticed.

Obviously if this was a fun type pool with flumes and a wave machine then all bets are off and kids will be kids.

So - AIBU? Is this normal? Would you expect the same in this situation or are the kids entitled to do otherwise because we’re paying members using the set child hours and if people don’t want to be bothered by children they should go when they’re at school?

I ask because I went alone this morning - completely forgetting that English half-term is different from ours. There were 3 families there and it was just COMPLETELY DIFFERENT. They were all loud, splashing, and using the entire pool (basically what you’d expect kids to be doing in a “fun” pool).

One particular family of 3 children (ages with mine) was the worst. Nobody could swim a single length without having to stand up or swim around them. My hair was drenched. Everyone was drenched. I know swimming caps exist but I've never ever needed one for 40 mins worth of breaststroke or even when I've been teaching my youngest to swim. An elderly lady got hit in the face. Another almost knocked over. Forget the fact it’s supposed to be 2 under 14s per adult, this Dad had 3 of them and he sat on one of the chairs at the side the entire time and didn’t tell them off or adjust their behaviour or tell them to take it to the kids pool once. Not even when the lady got hit. Adults were practically on top of each other trying to avoid these kids and I just couldn’t believe anyone would be so oblivious to this?!

But… nobody else seemed to say anything. No passive aggressive tuts or slightly longer than normal stares (except maybe me one or twice haha! I was just so shocked and couldn't help checking if he just wasn't seeing this - but he was!).

So, while I would never let my kids behave to that extreme - are my rules militant in comparison? Is there some happy medium that most parents do and most adults accept and I should give my kids more free reign?

They don’t dislike the way things are - they absolutely love it - but I’m not going to lie it CAN be exhausting sometimes feeling like I have to have eyes on the non-swimmer, while making sure the older swimmer isn’t just drifting around in front of people, while keeping track of who is swimming by so I don’t soak them, while reminding them to shout across the pool and the other swimmers at each other.

And I feel like the Dad was definitely being unreasonable but feel free to change my mind. Is it me or him or both of us? Grin

OP posts:
HiJenny35 · 23/02/2022 00:28

It's a hotel pool, if you want adults only go in adults only time. If I take my kids on holiday and they go in the pool for the hotel they can jump in, splash, play games, children being allowed to play in the pool during the time children are allowed in is what you pay extra for a hotel with a pool for. I wouldn't let them knock anyone over but to be honest I think you're probably exaggerating as if people were actually getting hurt I'm pretty sure other people would have been frowning. Kids can play in play sessions.

justkeepswimmingandoverthinkin · 23/02/2022 00:26

Thanks Grin I recognise that's a valid POV to have. I just think your kids right to be there doesn't equal having the right to do what they want or trumps the right of other people to swim?

There are two set swimming lanes but it's one person per lane and you have to schedule a 20min slot. They were all full for the next hour understandably. Everyone actually naturally migrated to the side of the pool nearest the cordoned off lanes, trying to do the whole clockwise + overtaking thing you do when the pool is busy but it was just impossible.

Which goes back to my point - I'd agree they have the same right to be there and wouldn't have cared much if they were even taking up half the pool and leaving one or two lanes for everyone else. But they were constantly spread out across the entire pool which made doing a single length uninterrupted by them (specifically) impossible. They could play on one side while the adults swam on the other (despite there being a kids pool for the sole purpose of playing and splashing but whatever).

OP posts:
Kite22 · 23/02/2022 00:26

I agree with LittleOwl
If my dc were allowed in a hotel pool during restricted hours, then I would expect them to be allowed to play in that pool in a fun way.

If I went to a restricted lane session then I would expect lane swimming, but a pool doesn't need to have flumes for it to be fun.
When mine were that sort of age we always booked somewhere with a pool, as they could spend ages in there on a rainy day and entertain themselves.

Now, obviously it shouldn't end up with anyone being hit in the face, and I would certainly have intervened either when that happened or if it looked like there were a risk of it happening, but in terms of generally playing, I think YABU. That's what most dc do in a swimming pool and is to be encouraged.

negomi90 · 23/02/2022 00:26

If there are kid hours and its mostly kid free, then I would expect kids to be able to play in the pool during those hours. That means shouting and splashing and playing.
It needs to stay within safety rules, no running on the side, no pushing people under etc but I wouldn't expect children in a hotel pool in specific children allowed hours to be quiet and obey lane rules.
There's a balance, but in general pools are special playgrounds for children. Loud boisterous but safe and polite play. They aren't libraries for indoor voices.

nocoolnamesleft · 23/02/2022 00:21

YANBU. Hitting an elderly woman in the face and nearly knocking over another one is not acceptable, or safe, behaviour.

Mummy1608 · 23/02/2022 00:17

Yabu, the kids have as much right to be there as the elderly ladies imo. And passive aggressive tuts would drive me bonkers. They need to have a slow/calm lane for the elderly ladies, why not suggest it to management

justkeepswimmingandoverthinkin · 23/02/2022 00:17

@Lucked good point about the difference between being a member and being on holiday.

@LittleOwl153 I have never actually thought of it as a hotel pool but maybe that's just me? For example there is a holiday inn type place near to me with a beefeater type place and a ballantynes type place, all sharing the same carpark and "together" but not connected. I assume this is quite a common set up country wide? You couldn't get between the restaurant/ pool/ hotel without going outside. They all have different brand names and owned by different people. But hotel stays get discounts in spa / restaurant and members get discounts on hotel stays / meals. So it's not actually like the pool is inside the building (I don't even know if that makes a difference to my unreasonableness Grin) and again it's not exactly a "holiday location" or inside a main city centre where people would be having city breaks - I can only think they're here because covid has stopped loads of people from going abroad, so wouldn't you "read the room" in a place like that?

The rule is definitely 14. Like I said the place is mostly retirees so I expect the club is catering to the target market with that. And RE set hours, to me, they're very wide (basically any time a child isn't at school they can go) and I think that's because there would rarely be ENOUGH children to make going during child hours a problem for anyone to complain and the club to make them more limited? It's mostly people taking their grandchildren on the odd occasion or a handful of families and mums on maternity leave.

So the only time this has ever happened is school holidays, but because the hours are so wide you'd have to be in and out by 8am to avoid it? For a week it's not a huge deal I guess but a bit shit in the long summer holidays if it turns into a "holiday pool" the entire time.

OP posts:
LittleOwl153 · 22/02/2022 23:56

Amd the adult ratio often doesn't apply in hotel pools (it should in my view) but is usually 1 adult to 2 under 8s not 14s.
Both of mine are perfectly competent swimmers - much better than their dad if he were roped in to supervise! In fact my dd would probably be joining you in the lanes (not that that would help your hair - as she is fast but splashy!)

LittleOwl153 · 22/02/2022 23:53

Its a hotel pool. If the kids are there during restricted kids hours I woukd expect them to play like they are on holiday. Especially if they are only allowed in for limited hours. Those wanting to swim lengths can swim at other times.

Maybe they were a bit much if someone got hit/hurt but I don't think getting splashed and tour hair wet in a swimming pool is out of order!

Lucked · 22/02/2022 23:51

Well I wouldn’t let my kids behave wildly unless a ‘fun’ pool but I think there is a difference to how you might behave on a once off holiday vs being a permanent member who will meet Betty a couple of times a week.

I am quite like you with behaviour requirements but going to a pool with children who aren’t competent swimmers is always going to be exhausting. Not sure how you can relax if they might drown.

justkeepswimmingandoverthinkin · 22/02/2022 23:48

  • NOT to shout across the pool at each other Grin

Whoops.

And when I say it can be exhausting I mean... well, parenting in public is kind of exhausting Grin

OP posts: