Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Stranger picked baby niece up.

37 replies

Whiskersonkittens21 · 22/02/2022 23:43

I was out for a meal with my 10 month old niece today, my mum, my dad and my partner. As I walked in and said Hello to my niece a lady from a couple tables over shouted over "she's coming home with me". I have anxiety so a stranger talking to me would set me on edge anyway so I just laughed and sat down. My mum and dad went up to the bar to order so my niece became fussy and began crying as my mum went out of sight. Within seconds this woman swooped over and grabbed my niece out of her high chair and began hugging her. I was literally too stunned to speak. I took her off her and took her away as I was absolutely baffled.

AIBU to think she shouldn't of grabbed her or was this woman just being friendly?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Flickflak · 23/02/2022 02:12

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Tilltheend99 · 23/02/2022 02:10

I can only assume that a number of fake Russian bots are on here peddling propaganda as the conversation has turned from the acceptability of picking up a strangers baby to the merits of being from different Nationalities.

Tilltheend99 · 23/02/2022 02:06

@Divebar2021

British people can be strangely uptight

And aggressive apparently. I can remember visiting Italy when my DD was about 18 months. I think she got whisked off or picked up by every waiter or waitress we had.

Italy was affected quite hard during the pandemic so I’m sure most Italians would have more sense then to pick up a strangers baby without permission in the current climate.
EmmaMaya · 23/02/2022 01:27

V strange behaviour!

xprincessxjanetx · 23/02/2022 01:23

I wouldn't like this either and would have reacted the same way as you

Bromse · 23/02/2022 00:59

@Chonfox

Wondering why the Italians didn't deem my babies worthy of being picked up now... Grin
Maybe, at the resort you visited, the were told that the British don't like that.

I think picking her up and cuddling her was a bit much but showing an interest is OK.

oakleaffy · 23/02/2022 00:57

@Divebar2021

It isn’t really weird… it’s slightly disconcerting that’s all. Best you don’t ever visit Italy.
Agreed! My son got so much fuss-Italians and Southern Europeans generally aren’t like the uptight British.

However i never touch other people’s babies.
If they are especially sweet or well behaved - Again as a lot of non UK babies seem to be- I do acknowledge how good they are.

toomuchlaundry · 23/02/2022 00:54

What gives a stranger the right to pick someone else’s baby out of a high chair? Fine if they ask first and you are ok with it

Do some of the posters who think it is fine just grab random babies out of pushchairs as you are walking along the street just because you want a hug.

What age does it become a no and your child has a choice?

AnnesBrokenSlate · 23/02/2022 00:49

I don't think it's British people that are uptight about it. I think it's English people. In Scotland and in Ireland, it wouldn't be odd for someone to talk to a baby or lift them if they were crying.

LoveFall · 23/02/2022 00:43

My dear Mum had four children. In her last few years she had dementia. During one of our last family get togethers we were all in a restaurant.

There was a baby crying for quite a long time. I was sitting next to Mum and she kept telling me that the baby was crying.

When I got up to take her to the loo, she veered off to see the baby.

I had to stop her touching the baby. It was heartbreaking to be honest. The baby's mother gave me a very filthy look despite my attempt to explain.

NonagonInfinityOpensTheDoor · 23/02/2022 00:39

I remember being passed around by all the awful men in Turkey, I absolutely hated the fact my parents let complete strangers pick me up and even kiss my cheek. Why bother advocating bodily autonomy when apparently strangers forcing hugs and physical contact is absolutely fine.

And perhaps British people are “uptight” but perhaps Italians or Greeks have no respect for others? Or don’t understand boundaries? Works both ways the whole cultural differences thing doesn’t it.

OhWhyNot · 23/02/2022 00:35

Chonfox maybe they feared you would have knocked them out you know being British Grin (assuming you are)

I’m a single parent maybe ds looked throughly bored of my company Grin

SmallPrawnEnergy · 23/02/2022 00:33

You can fuss over a strangers child without picking them up for fucks sake, unless you’re a complete bore I suppose and can’t engage a child?

Not asking is incredibly rude and crossing so many boundaries, imagine if a stranger just came up to you and put their hands all over you, I certainly bet you’d have something to say. Why not advocate that for your child? That’s worrying that you wouldn’t tbh. What else would you let a stranger do to your child just because it “brings joy”.

Loneliness might bring “acute pain” but at the same time you have absolutely no idea what am that family / mother / child is going through, something like this could cause a great deal of upset, so why does strange woman with no boundaries trump that?

ButtercupOfFlorin · 23/02/2022 00:32

Then again, I have always loved and cared for my children, and take a dim view of complete strangers picking them up and 'cuddling' them

Nope, not even in ITALY!

They really do (some people have left their hometown, just so you know). There are places in the world that are different to your world. You’re welcome.

Oh I must be a terrible mother because I don’t go around assaulting anyone who dares glance at my little Messiah 😂😂

I sincerely hope you don't have children

I do, and they’re independent well rounded happy children who literally never came to any harm interacting with strangers. I wouldn’t go round thumping random people in front of my kids so as not to make them violent, anxious, dysfunctional messes thanks.

Chonfox · 23/02/2022 00:32

Wondering why the Italians didn't deem my babies worthy of being picked up now... Grin

GriffinSsoup · 23/02/2022 00:31

@BearOfEasttown - Gosh you sound like some of the thugs in my home town. 😒

Cissyandflora · 23/02/2022 00:30

@Divebar2021

It isn’t really weird… it’s slightly disconcerting that’s all. Best you don’t ever visit Italy.
Ha yes agree! It’s not horrific, shocking, weird or an offence worthy of being knocked out over. It’s picking up a baby for a cuddle. It wasn’t welcomed and it is overly familiar and a little disconcerting perhaps but now move on. Tomorrow is another day.
Divebar2021 · 23/02/2022 00:29

British people can be strangely uptight

And aggressive apparently. I can remember visiting Italy when my DD was about 18 months. I think she got whisked off or picked up by every waiter or waitress we had.

ButtercupOfFlorin · 23/02/2022 00:28

Well I must be a complete 'scally' as I WOULD knock someone flat out, if some random weirdo laid a finger on my baby, and tried to pick them up. Yes I really fucking would

Yes I’m sure you would approach and middle age woman and assault her so hard she’d be unconscious. Because that actually happens in real life.

Give over, you’d probably sit there with a face like a slapped arse and whinge about it on the internet later.

If you WOULD ‘fucking knock her out’ may I suggest you seek medical help? It’s not normal to want to do that to someone who is not harming you or a loved one in any way.

OhWhyNot · 23/02/2022 00:26

BearOfEasttown you are coming over as a totally over the top dramatic mouthy prat 🙄

ButtercupOfFlorin · 23/02/2022 00:25

@Divebar2021

It isn’t really weird… it’s slightly disconcerting that’s all. Best you don’t ever visit Italy.
Or Greece!

British people can be strangely uptight about things like this and I really don’t think it does our children any favours at all.

BearOfEasttown · 23/02/2022 00:25

@Chonfox

I visited Italy when both my DDs were babies and no one did this! No one ever picked them up without asking, no one barely picked them up at all except immediate family - I was so sick of holding them day and night that at one stage I probably would have welcomed this weirdo intervening Grin
Exactly! Most people aren't weird enough to pick up a stranger's baby. Nope, not even in ITALY! Hmm

I can't believe this conversation is happening here. Such bollocks. As IF anyone would be OK - in real life - with some random stranger picking their baby up and 'cuddling' it. Do me a fucking favour!

BearOfEasttown · 23/02/2022 00:22

@ButtercupOfFlorin

Oh I’m sorry that I’m not a completely overreacting weirdo who would ‘fucking knock them out’ (which we all know you wouldn’t, unless you’re a complete scally?)
Well I must be a complete 'scally' as I WOULD knock someone flat out, if some random weirdo laid a finger on my baby, and tried to pick them up. Yes I really fucking would .

Then again, I have always loved and cared for my children, and take a dim view of complete strangers picking them up and 'cuddling' them. Hmm

FFS, what kind of person thinks this is OK? I sincerely hope you don't have children.

Chonfox · 23/02/2022 00:21

I visited Italy when both my DDs were babies and no one did this! No one ever picked them up without asking, no one barely picked them up at all except immediate family - I was so sick of holding them day and night that at one stage I probably would have welcomed this weirdo intervening Grin

OhWhyNot · 23/02/2022 00:21

I’m in the minority too

I found it lovely when ds was fussed over that he could make others happy just by smiling he loved the attention I appreciate not all children do. In Italy he was passed around the next table and Turkey helped the waiters serve dinner I was watching all the time nothing sinister was going on at all

The joy and happiness little children and babies bring to adults is something to be celebrated not frowned upon or seen as weird.