Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to wonder why people get with deadbeat dads

237 replies

WobbleMolly · 22/02/2022 21:16

So ex was abusive + cheating. We separated with one child. He moved to another country and the child maintenance people could never get hold of him. He's contributed a grand total of about £50 towards his child's upbringing since we separated. Does not keep in touch even though I've never said 'no calls' or anything.

His sister and parents send birthday and Christmas cards but nothing else. And he remembers maybe every other year, no gift, just a text to dc. Just a full on deadbeat dad.

So he's got a new partner got married and they've had a child.

Who knows what he said about me. Obviously only the two people in the relationship know the full truth.

But you know he's got a child (he used to put pics on Facebook when we were together & me & his new partner have a few mutual acquaintances). And you know £0 of the household budget is going to pay for the child he already has.

But if he's said 'I'm not allowed see my child." Where's the paperwork showing you've tried to get visitation? Even a letter from a visit to a lawyer.

I would love to understand the mental gymnastics of why a person would be with a man who doesn't take care of his kids.

Even if they've been told "ex is a harpy who said I can't see the kids", that doesn't mean not paying for them. And even someone on minimum wage, after a few years can scrape together money for a lawyer to get visitation.

Yes, I sound bitter - I am. He is awful, but I also feel she disgusted by the people who partner with such men in full knowledge of their deadbeatness (that's a word now).

OP posts:
SnowFlo · 23/02/2022 15:17

But I guess having a fresh new grandchild to play with is more fun than cutting off your son for not doing right by his first child.

You think his parents should cut him off and also not see their new grandchild, because he didn't bother with yours? So you are hoping for another child to end up like yours?

Bananalanacake · 23/02/2022 15:15

I am also astounded at the amount of women who let a man move in with them after less than a year together. You can have a happy relationship without living together you know. So much easier to get shot of if they turn out to be a twat. I always tell new boyfriends, no living together for at least 5 years, if they don't like it they can fuck off.

WobbleMolly · 23/02/2022 15:06

@Macademiamum
(((hugs)))

And hugs to all on this thread who have been through this kind of mess.

OP posts:
lunar1 · 23/02/2022 15:04

Have you seen this shit on here people will believe or behaviour they will justify.

The ex was lazy, she did nothing, just sat on her arse with 5 month old twins and was having an affair...

She was abusive, neglectful, shit mum and wife...

We were living separate lives, hadn't had sex in 5 years, she's alienated me from our baby and toddler and won't let me see them...

She gets her nails done every month, I'm not paying maintenance for that...

People are deliberately misinterpreting your op. It doesn't take much digging to see through the lies. Decent dads don't leave their children at the mercy of abusive mothers.

She is posting about men who are already dads and the fact that many women are happy to give them a second chance to screw up a child.

There would be court papers, solicitor meetings, money for legal fees and maintenance. If he genuinely fought for his children there would be evidence.

I will probably get a lot of criticism for this post, I've just no idea why anyone wouldn't want better for their potential children.

Macademiamum · 23/02/2022 15:01

My ex claimed to be a victim of parental alienation by a bitter ex partner after they had a baby together as teenagers
Now I am the bitter ex he claims made him the victim of parental alienation (again) after we had a baby together in our thirties.
He claimed to be fighting it in the court to get contact (wasn't) & claimed he would fight me in court to get contact (didn't).
He is having a baby with somebody else now. I will never fall for that again. He was an abusive violent POS that's why he doesn't have contact with his kids.

WobbleMolly · 23/02/2022 15:00

But @mogul & @highwind doesn't that speak to his character to you? He's let down his own children, so why do you think he won't let you down too? Maybe when you are sick or at a vulnerable time?

It's like taking on an employee who was fired for stealing at their last job. Maybe they've learnt their lesson or maybe they are a habitual thief. Why not hire one of the other people you interviewed who were just as good?

OP posts:
Highwind · 23/02/2022 14:55

[quote Mogul]@wobblemolly My question is about when you are with a person who you know has kids but expends zero effort to their care, how can you be in a relationship with them. And I've had some really enlightening answers.

My OH isn't in this situation but it wouldn't bother me if he was because I'm not with him for his parenting I'm with him for his relationship skills, if they were sub par it would be a different answer[/quote]
This is exactly it for me as well.

I don't care how or why he is failing anyone else expectations of him, as long as he isn't failing mine.

WobbleMolly · 23/02/2022 14:55

@babyroobs

If someone told you they were a good driver, and they showed you their licence, you would probably get into their car when they offered you a lift.

You don't have evidence to the contrary.

But if, parked in their front garden was their car, all smashed up and a write off from a serious accident, you might think twice.

A young, unmarried man without kids is not the same as a man with kids when you are thinking about getting into a relationship.

OP posts:
Babyroobs · 23/02/2022 14:51

@RoseGoldEagle

I think you’re being a bit unfair. There are lots of people that would look at you in your original relationship with him and think- how does someone end up having a child with someone like that, surely there must have been signs of how abusive and awful he was long before that point? And presumably you’d argue there weren’t and he changed after you had kids etc? But can’t you see how you judging her is the same thing?
Exactly this ! You fell for him and must have thought he would make a good dad, but someone else can't think the same?
Mogul · 23/02/2022 14:44

@wobblemolly My question is about when you are with a person who you know has kids but expends zero effort to their care, how can you be in a relationship with them. And I've had some really enlightening answers.

My OH isn't in this situation but it wouldn't bother me if he was because I'm not with him for his parenting I'm with him for his relationship skills, if they were sub par it would be a different answer

nagsarse · 23/02/2022 14:42

My very lovely, very intelligent friend ended up with one of these men. When they met she knew he had a child who lived with his ex and assumed he spent time with the child when they were not together. As their relationship got more serious he gradually fed her a story about his ex being jealous that he had moved on and making it difficult for him to see his child, then that ex and child had moved away. He told her he's spoken to lawyers etc but the fighting and arguments were too upsetting for his child so even though it broke his heart he agreed not to push for access- and that as part of this his ex had agreed that he didn't need to pay her any maintenance. He also claimed that instead of maintenance he was putting money in to an account each month to be given to the child on his 18th birthday to pay for university/deposit on a house or whatever he needed at the time. He and his family rarely mentioned the child- as he said he found it all too upsetting. He was very good at seeming to be a wonderful, caring father who was prevented from seeing his child by a crazy ex.

It was only when they had a child together that she started to see the truth. He treated her badly, cheated on her and eventually left her. He claimed he didn't think the child was his, as a way to try to get out of paying anything and to explain why he didn't want to see the child. it became apparent that the fund she thought was for this other child was actually his exit fund.

WobbleMolly · 23/02/2022 14:21

@bluedodecagon

How am I trying to make myself look better or rewrite history?

He was not a monster I was writing to on death row, and then got surprised that he's 'not very nice?'

We grew up in a small community. I was friends with his sister, I was friends with him too from about age 16 and we went out in groups together, funny, charming. We became a couple a few years later, and when I got pregnant he stopped being charming and lovely.

My question is about when you are with a person who you know has kids but expends zero effort to their care, how can you be in a relationship with them. And I've had some really enlightening answers.

OP posts:
MrsBerthaRochester · 23/02/2022 14:19

My ex moved in with his gf and her kids after just a year of dating. He is overweight, has huge debt and pays her no rent. She pays for them to go weekends/holidays. He pays me less than half of what cms suggests as he still pays mortgage(due to him refusing to sell house) He was emotionally and financially abusive and on three ocassions put his hands round my neck and choked me.
He sees our two ds once a week and our dd refuses to see him after his gf tried to physically assault her. She is welcome to him. Pair of scum.

thepeopleversuswork · 23/02/2022 14:17

[quote WobbleMolly]@thepeopleversuswork

it's not rocket science and I can't believe you haven't worked this out for yourself.

His new wife is a former acquaintance, we know people in common, they know the situation. I really DON'T know how to work it out. I just feel like if I knew Bob has young kids, and when Lisa worked at the shop for 5 years she seemed normal, and there is no money going to the kids, no Christmas cards - I wouldn't touch it with a barge pole.[/quote]
See previous point on cognitive dissonance.

Chances are she knows deep down but for reasons best known to herself has decided she can square that circle. Probably because she "looooves" him. She will have written her own internal mythology to deal with this, probably aided and abetted by him telling her you were a psycho etc.

Its depressing behaviour for sure but she's hardly the first woman to do this.

VelvetChairGirl · 23/02/2022 14:17

@bluedodecagon

seriously *@WobbleMolly* you are rewriting history when it comes to your relationship. Stop looking down on other women! You are trying to make yourself seem better than them and you just aren’t.
no she isnt, she is just pointing out he has obvious baggage now he didnt have before and why are they ok with that baggage.

its very clear

Mogul · 23/02/2022 14:16

@drsbaitso I don't know her reasoning, the conversations I've had with her have been illogical and unpleasant. I think it's that he didn't want to be with her

My reasoning is he contributes, sees them regularly etc

DrSbaitso · 23/02/2022 14:16

[quote WobbleMolly]@thepeopleversuswork

it's not rocket science and I can't believe you haven't worked this out for yourself.

His new wife is a former acquaintance, we know people in common, they know the situation. I really DON'T know how to work it out. I just feel like if I knew Bob has young kids, and when Lisa worked at the shop for 5 years she seemed normal, and there is no money going to the kids, no Christmas cards - I wouldn't touch it with a barge pole.[/quote]
Well, maybe not, but you've hinted that there are other things you did overlook. Whatever he did to make you overlook that, he's doing to make her overlook this. And she may be an arse who doesn't care; some people don't as long as it doesn't affect them.

You're puzzled because your position means that this particular red flag is raising klaxons for you. Understandably; it's shit that you're in, so of course it's blindingly obvious to you. But to other people, it looks the same as the shit that you overlooked in the past looked like to you, with the added likelihood that he's lying and misleading about it. You say she knows the situation as well as you do...don't be too sure.

JustLyra · 23/02/2022 14:16

A lot of people on this thread seem to be forgetting, or blatantly ignoring, that is is very common for abuse to begin during pregnancy as seems to be the case with the OP and her ex.

bluedodecagon · 23/02/2022 14:13

seriously @WobbleMolly you are rewriting history when it comes to your relationship. Stop looking down on other women! You are trying to make yourself seem better than them and you just aren’t.

WobbleMolly · 23/02/2022 14:09

@thepeopleversuswork

it's not rocket science and I can't believe you haven't worked this out for yourself.

His new wife is a former acquaintance, we know people in common, they know the situation. I really DON'T know how to work it out. I just feel like if I knew Bob has young kids, and when Lisa worked at the shop for 5 years she seemed normal, and there is no money going to the kids, no Christmas cards - I wouldn't touch it with a barge pole.

OP posts:
DrSbaitso · 23/02/2022 13:52

So if you are with someone with no court paperwork trying to get visitation, no money coming out of the household budget going to kids, wouldn't that make you be like 'hang on, what's going on here?' It wouldn't add up.

How much mental energy do you think they're going to give to the workings of a different family?

They may well have separate or partly separate finances so they wouldn't see the money in his personal account.

If the setup is working for them, why would they be poring over anything else?

AllOfUsAreDead · 23/02/2022 13:48

@QuirkyTurtle

OK? Maybe he was 'charming and lovely' to his new girlfriend too. Maybe he said he'd tried to see his kids but you won't let him. Maybe he's told her you were the abusive one. Maybe he didn't tell her he had kids in the first place.

It's OK for you to be conned by him, but not anyone else? Because you were the first? This is just victim blaming with extra steps.

Sorry you're having to deal with this crap situation, but you're not somehow more innocent than any subsequent women he abuses.

If he does it once, of course he'll do it again. Some people will see through it, some won't. They'll believe him for a number of reasons, and eventually see the truth.
WobbleMolly · 23/02/2022 13:47

@QuirkyTurtle

I just meant living with someone and you see zero effort at seeing the kids; no bank transfers, not writing cards, no birthday phone calls, nothing.

But PPS have shown lies that worked on them e.g. not allowing them to see bank statements and saying they are paying.

It just seems like an enormous piece of evidence of bad character Vs smaller things a charming person may let slip e.g. ignoring your texts one afternoon. I was just wondering how the mental gymnastics work.

Like if someone said they were a millionaire, but they were living in a bedsit above a corner shop it wouldn't add up.

So if you are with someone with no court paperwork trying to get visitation, no money coming out of the household budget going to kids, wouldn't that make you be like 'hang on, what's going on here?' It wouldn't add up.

OP posts:
thepeopleversuswork · 23/02/2022 13:47

Because women are masters at cognitive dissonance when it comes to tolerating things in men when their gut is telling them they shouldn't. Same principle behind the vast amount of threads started by women whose husbands don't do any housework, or women whose husbands refuse to marry them, or whose husbands cheat/drink/gamble etc etc ad nauseam.

The reasons are varied but the principle ones are:

  • Society has screamed at us since we were small girls that we are nothing if we don't have a bloke so once we get hold of one we tend to cut him way too much slack to stop him leaving
  • Deadbeats tend to be very good at putting their best foot forward and making themselves look good
  • They are also very good at identifying women who are lonely/vulnerable and have poorer boundaries
  • They will as has been repeatedly said on here present the ex as a "psycho" or as otherwise manipulative.

I have sympathy for your situation but tbh it's not rocket science and I can't believe you haven't worked this out for yourself.

Itsnotdeep · 23/02/2022 13:41

Yeah sometimes they're just as toxic as the dad is, and have no thought for the poor child who is saddled with the pair of them.

But actually, usually there are a whole host of red flags - not just about previous children. These red flags exist whether or not the guy has kids. In hindsight, when I went out with a guy who lied about his age on the dating site, had a psycho ex, no friends and who asked me to marry him in a month and also didn't have any contact with his kids, I really should have known. I didn't have any kids with him, but someone else was mad enough to, and sure enough, he left her too.

Then again, you only have to read the board here to see that many women are told a story about the psycho ex not letting the poor man have contact with the children to see that many women do believe this stuff. I would now steer clear of any man who doesn't have contact with his children for whatever reason, no matter what he tells me, but I didn't know this 6 years ago when I first started dating.