Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to wonder why people get with deadbeat dads

237 replies

WobbleMolly · 22/02/2022 21:16

So ex was abusive + cheating. We separated with one child. He moved to another country and the child maintenance people could never get hold of him. He's contributed a grand total of about £50 towards his child's upbringing since we separated. Does not keep in touch even though I've never said 'no calls' or anything.

His sister and parents send birthday and Christmas cards but nothing else. And he remembers maybe every other year, no gift, just a text to dc. Just a full on deadbeat dad.

So he's got a new partner got married and they've had a child.

Who knows what he said about me. Obviously only the two people in the relationship know the full truth.

But you know he's got a child (he used to put pics on Facebook when we were together & me & his new partner have a few mutual acquaintances). And you know £0 of the household budget is going to pay for the child he already has.

But if he's said 'I'm not allowed see my child." Where's the paperwork showing you've tried to get visitation? Even a letter from a visit to a lawyer.

I would love to understand the mental gymnastics of why a person would be with a man who doesn't take care of his kids.

Even if they've been told "ex is a harpy who said I can't see the kids", that doesn't mean not paying for them. And even someone on minimum wage, after a few years can scrape together money for a lawyer to get visitation.

Yes, I sound bitter - I am. He is awful, but I also feel she disgusted by the people who partner with such men in full knowledge of their deadbeatness (that's a word now).

OP posts:
VelvetChairGirl · 24/02/2022 11:48

[quote bluedodecagon]@WobbleMolly

Do you honestly think the only real red flags are going to prison or having kids that you don’t see? The problem is you don’t understand how to spot emotional and psychological red flags. You can only see “obvious” red flags and the problem is that when you meet people with “obvious” red flags if you can’t see past the emotional ones, then they’ll just explain themselves away anyway.

In theory, someone out there is being falsely accused of rape. In theory, some guy out there is being denied access to his kids. Your guy can always claim to be the exception. But being able to spot subtler signs of abuse AND LEAVE is more protection that being able to tot up statistics and make guesses.

The fact that you have gone from one abusive relationship to another then to another and still insist “there were no signs” and you are just unlucky is, frankly, delusional.[/quote]
So what is your education to know that? how many degrees in psychology do you have, how many abusive men have you worked with? how many abused women?

VelvetChairGirl · 24/02/2022 11:46

@Oblomov22

He was though. Because he did do it. So he was a deadbeat dad when you met him. You just didn't recognise the signs. It was all within him right at the start.

Or rather he had the potential to be.

And then he did do it. But you don't seem to want to look back at why. Or what subtle signs you missed. Or are you implying he was really good man but suddenly had a complete personality transplant. because realistically that's unlikely.

Do you have strong morals? are you the kind of person who is going to suddenly become a deadbeat and just leave people? no! probably not because most of those characteristics are solid and deep within us.

I have studied psychology and you are talking are bollocks, what planet are you on?

do you just enjoy trying to upset people and victim blame, why are you so determined that you are right and everyone else who ends up with a bellend is a moron? is this coming from a position of utter narcissism on your part or fear?

felulageller · 24/02/2022 09:14

Society just facilitates these losers.

Not paying child support needs to be criminalised. Throw the non payers into jail!

WobbleMolly · 24/02/2022 08:52

I have never said 'there were no signs and I was just unlucky.' I have said there are different levels of signs, some which can be missed and some which are blinking neon.

OP posts:
felulageller · 24/02/2022 08:24

We live in a patriarchal society. People believe men not women.

Oblomov22 · 24/02/2022 08:08

Thank you Bluedodecagon. Someone who posted exactly what I was trying to say, only phrased it much better.

wingscrow · 24/02/2022 08:08

Well, you were attracted to him and fell for his lies...

So why is it a surprise to you that others would too?

Some women will believe the 'psycho ex who does not let me see my child' story. others simply don't care about previous partners or other people's kids.

But really you should focus on yourself and try not to let him win by still being bitter about it all. It is hard but you moving on with your life and being happy is the best revenge you can have.

bluedodecagon · 24/02/2022 07:54

@WobbleMolly

Do you honestly think the only real red flags are going to prison or having kids that you don’t see? The problem is you don’t understand how to spot emotional and psychological red flags. You can only see “obvious” red flags and the problem is that when you meet people with “obvious” red flags if you can’t see past the emotional ones, then they’ll just explain themselves away anyway.

In theory, someone out there is being falsely accused of rape. In theory, some guy out there is being denied access to his kids. Your guy can always claim to be the exception. But being able to spot subtler signs of abuse AND LEAVE is more protection that being able to tot up statistics and make guesses.

The fact that you have gone from one abusive relationship to another then to another and still insist “there were no signs” and you are just unlucky is, frankly, delusional.

Oblomov22 · 24/02/2022 07:50

He was though. Because he did do it. So he was a deadbeat dad when you met him. You just didn't recognise the signs. It was all within him right at the start.

Or rather he had the potential to be.

And then he did do it. But you don't seem to want to look back at why. Or what subtle signs you missed. Or are you implying he was really good man but suddenly had a complete personality transplant. because realistically that's unlikely.

Do you have strong morals? are you the kind of person who is going to suddenly become a deadbeat and just leave people? no! probably not because most of those characteristics are solid and deep within us.

Willyoujustbequiet · 24/02/2022 07:49

To those pathetic idiots suggesting the signs are always there.....

I was happily married for 20 years before he had a mental health crisis and the violence started. 20 years before he raped me.

We had longed for and much loved children who he abandoned overnight and in the many years since has continued to not give shiny shit about or pay for. 20 years before we had to get a restraining order.

Don't give me the crap that the signs are always there. Fuck off with the victim blaming.

Check your internalised misogyny. People change and abusers walk among us. It appears with some enablers on this thread.

Oblomov22 · 24/02/2022 07:45

"major red flags are 'prison penpal', 'moroccan waiter who can't speak your language and half your age.'"

Are you just joking OP, trying to make the thread lighter? Because I don't find the above very funny. It's extremist and silly. We don't need Shirley valentine comparisons.

Your original question, re why so many women can't spot a deadbeat, is an important one. Why women don't spot red flags and marry twats is a serious issue.

And why women don't have the sense to look beyond the smooth talking, to look to the bigger person: Is this person really a good person, are we really compatible, does this relationship have the potential for longevity for him to father my children and us to grow old together happily. Is a problem.

WobbleMolly · 24/02/2022 07:41

@Oblomov22

I feel like you are deliberately misunderstanding the premise of the thread. Yes, I was in a relationship and I did not see until too late what he was like behind his false charm.

There are things however which are so obvious. Someone who kicks their dog; someone who cheated on their previous partner; etc. But these things can be hidden. I thought having kids and not taking care of them is something in plain sight, but PPS have shown how that is also sometimes hidden.

He was not a 'deadbeat dad' when I met him.

OP posts:
Oblomov22 · 24/02/2022 07:31

pp asked about the fact you you chose to be in a relationship with him. For how long, how many years?

How about you turn it on your head and question why you had such poor self worth or emotional skills to not spot that he was a deadbeat. Why are women so poor at spotting this, red flags. Most of mn relationship boards are filled with women married to men who are cheaters, deadbeats, workaholic, controlling, rigid mentality etc. why are women marrying these twats in the first place?

VelvetChairGirl · 24/02/2022 07:14

@CJsGoldfish

Yes, some people are wilfully ignorant, but this was someone I had known for years. Charming and lovely The signs are always there. You went ahead and had a child anyway so your choices are not necessarily superior to hers. At least she got the marriage though clearly that's not such a prize. Like I said, I get your bitterness and I really do. Have been in a not dissimilar situation. You just have NO idea what has been said about you or your child and, if he's as charming as you say, he's in a great position to spin it his way whilst you're so bitter and angry. Not that you don't have the right to be. It's a pointless question really and only serves to make you feel angrier. Neither of you have made good choices but you cling to yours being not as bad which is irrelevant. You will never know the truth and it serves you no purpose to obsess over it. Concentrate on yourself and your child because they are what truly matter
No the signs are not always there stop victim blaming to try and make yourself feel superior and kid yourself that you would never fall for it.

the number of men in work today, everyday working next to you, seemingly hard working, lovely family men etc who go home and beat their wifes/kids is off the scale, thats how they get away with it for so long, whats done behind closed doors stays behind closed, "he couldn't possibly be like that", "but he's such a nice guy butter wouldnt melt in his mouth", "he cant be doing all that for no reason it takes two to tango".

here you are buying into misogyny hook line and sinker, victim blaming instead of looking at the perpetrator, on one level I understand it, its a comfort zone to you, but dont you ever feel any guilt for putting your sisters down.

go read "Why Does He Do That" maybe that'll help you figure out that no they dont all walk around with big red flags sticking out their heads.

VelvetChairGirl · 24/02/2022 07:03

@OshaOsha

it doesnt bode well at all if they treat their own flesh and blood like shit

I suppose you mean "treat their own children like this" rather than "flesh and blood", because you don't have to be nice to people just because they are related to you.

So you think its perfectly fine to treat your own children like shit?

hope your not a parent.

WobbleMolly · 24/02/2022 06:53

@bluedodecagon

We are legally separated. You think I sound arrogant. That I'm imagining the flags were subtle. You're allowed an opinion based on whatever you want.

The reason I used that figure was to show that 100% of people go into a relationship hoping it will work out, but that is not always the case, and it is unreasonable to say 'It was obvious.'

OP posts:
malificent7 · 24/02/2022 06:31

Arsehole whispererGrin brilliant!

I think these women are vulnerable and hope to tame him as others have said.

bluedodecagon · 24/02/2022 06:24

Have you left the husband? Yes or no? Because it sounds like you are still with the cheats-with-prostitutes-guy? Are you?

Yes, there are divorces but not all divorces end due to abuse so you can’t point to 42% as some sort of comfort about your own poor decision making.

You just seem convinced that all your abusive relationships are you being unlucky because these men were all subtle. You are going to insist there were no signs whatsoever and you have great judgment. That you are smarter than a woman who would date a deadbeat dad.

I truly doubt it. You just seem very arrogant and silly.

WobbleMolly · 24/02/2022 06:16

And yes, I know some couples have separate finances, but I didn't think that meant never even looking at a bank statement.

OP posts:
WobbleMolly · 24/02/2022 06:15

I am not preaching. I came here asking a question about something that seems like a massive red flag to me.

I think it is obvious that some red flags are more obvious than others.

The vast majority of relationships end. Even where the couple get married, 42% of those end in divorce. How many of those end badly? Who knows. But probably, for those millions of people there would have been 'red flags' that it's not going to work out. Not that they are bad people, just not right.

I don't think anyone can disagree that some flags are subtle and some are blatant.

I came here asking about one which seems very blatant.

Pp have jumped on saying I've had bad relationships. If you can point out what obvious flags I missed that would be wonderful.

I'm talking about one specific red flag, and I've had answers about how the flags are hidden.

OP posts:
HikingforScenery · 23/02/2022 23:46

You know some couples have separate finances right?
If he’s told the wife you’re a nightmare concocted convincing evidence, what do you want her to do?
He’s probably bring s wonderful dad to his new children and she cannot believe s world exists where he wouldn’t be involved with his child with ex, if it was a possibility at all.

bluedodecagon · 23/02/2022 23:22

I just don’t understand how you can be baffled when all you’ve had are abusive relationships. if you have a great relationship record it would make sense to be baffled by other peoples choices.

It probably sounds like I’m being mean but I think that obviously detaching from your situation is a defence mechanism of yours and the fact that you can’t see yourself in that woman or the similarities between you and that woman isn’t a good thing. It’s actually really sad. Because you obviously won’t accept the way you approach relationships. Which means that you are still likely vulnerable to more abusive relationships.

Have you left your ex husband btw? Not the baby daddy? The last loser?

CJsGoldfish · 23/02/2022 23:00

Yes, some people are wilfully ignorant, but this was someone I had known for years. Charming and lovely
The signs are always there. You went ahead and had a child anyway so your choices are not necessarily superior to hers. At least she got the marriage though clearly that's not such a prize.
Like I said, I get your bitterness and I really do. Have been in a not dissimilar situation. You just have NO idea what has been said about you or your child and, if he's as charming as you say, he's in a great position to spin it his way whilst you're so bitter and angry. Not that you don't have the right to be.
It's a pointless question really and only serves to make you feel angrier. Neither of you have made good choices but you cling to yours being not as bad which is irrelevant. You will never know the truth and it serves you no purpose to obsess over it.
Concentrate on yourself and your child because they are what truly matter

WobbleMolly · 23/02/2022 19:23

I agree that there were probably red flags I missed.

And I know this is Mumsnet and the law is to take extreme positions. But surely there are some flags which are cocktail umbrella sized and some are a full Soviet parade.

Pp said I am contemptuous. I am not, I am genuinely baffled.

To use a previous example, major red flags are 'prison penpal', 'moroccan waiter who can't speak your language and half your age.' I can understand those people are lonely and want to believe.

I would have put deadbeat dad at that same level of red flag, but many people here have shown what lies that sound plausible they have heard.

OP posts:
OshaOsha · 23/02/2022 19:18

it doesnt bode well at all if they treat their own flesh and blood like shit

I suppose you mean "treat their own children like this" rather than "flesh and blood", because you don't have to be nice to people just because they are related to you.