Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

WIBU to have prevented my DC having to (temporarily) share their home with 5 children they don't know?

108 replies

LazyMareofEastown · 22/02/2022 19:21

A few weeks have passed since this happened and I'm just reflecting. It's long and complicated so will try and keep it factual.

I co-parent my DC with their dad. All amicable. He lives a few mins away from me and we do things 50/50 with flexibility on both sides.

We both have partners. I don't live with my DP. EXH lives with his partner. Neither me nor ex have gone on to have any more DC and his partner (will call her B for convenience) doesn't have any. She's a nice enough person and adores my kids.

B's sister lives 1.5 hours away and has a very chaotic lifestyle. Sister has 6 kids (aged from 19 to 8). 4 or 5 different dads, none of whom are involved. She's had intense input from Child Services and the younger kids are on a Care Protection Plan. Between them, the kids have a variety of health conditions, behavioural issues and mental health problems (self harm, gender dysphoria). One has suspected autism but has never been diagnosed as mum doesn't take him to appts. The two youngest (8 and 9) display incredibly challenging (often hypersexualised) behaviour and my two DC have found being around them very difficult in the past on visits to where these kids live. My DS has told me he doesn't like going there.

For added context I work in a job that heavily incorporates safeguarding and have good knowledge of how social services operate.

To get to the point. A HV was done by the police a few weeks ago. Police called SS due to the state of the house and the kids were temporarily removed from the house while mum was questioned re: neglect.

B offered to have 5 of the 6 kids come to stay in her and my EX's house. The house is a small 3 bed with the only spare bed being my 13 year old DD's other bunkbed. DS (7) has a tiny box room (so small they had to buy a non-standard bed).

Ex rang me to ask what I thought. I told him that if this went ahead, I'd be keeping our DC at mine until these other kids went back home. Simply put, I had genuine safeguarding concerns for my DC if this were to go ahead not to mention the obvious overcrowding issue. Obviously they didn't need my consent but Ex was on the same page as me - he just didn't want to upset his partner.

They went back to SWs (I even spoke to the main SW on phone - she tried to guilt trip me into agreeing) and said that I had said it was a definite no.

As I had predicted would happen, SS suddenly came up with a new plan and found a house in the kids home area where B could stay with the kids until they went back to their mum (a few days later - house had been cleaned sufficiently for SS to be happy with this).

Ex told me he was relieved that I had said no as he knew B's suggestion was not a good one (albeit an understandable emotional reaction to the situation). He thanked me for being rational and clear.

B is now being super frosty with me. I'm not massively bothered by this as we're not mates and my kids safety will always be something I'm taking zero chances with but I'm just wondering how it looks to an impartial observer.

Biblical length, thanks for reading if you made it this far.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Macademiamum · 24/02/2022 11:08

They sound like they have mostly or possibly all been sexually abused. Trauma can mirror ASC in some children, in others it shows up us hyper sexual behaviour, other mental health issues, and sometimes as gender dysphoria.

oishutup · 24/02/2022 10:59

I think you did exactly the right thing OP.

Onlyforcake · 24/02/2022 10:28

B was obviously being supportive (and really was their for family, very commendable) the situation was the best one. Difficult for B as obviously support from partner would have helped BUT totally right for ALL the children involved to have full focus of adults involved AND the needed space. I think it was the best for the children in very challenging situation and the adults made the right safeguarding calls. B might not see it that way,but may on reflection. The children being in too small a space and then potentially having other children who are more at home in that space would be too much!

LazyMareofEastown · 24/02/2022 09:34

"i think B and your EXs relationship is now on the rocks - which is sad for all concerned when ultimately B was doing the right thing by stepping up for her family.

Sad situation all round and no right or wrong answers but I feel for B - who must feel very unsupported by her DP right now."

Well this is just made up bollocks. How would you have any inkling whatsoever as to the status of my ex's relationship? Don't be so ridiculous 🤣

For those moaning that all B wanted to do was help her family and that I prevented that. She DID help her family, just not in her own house. I don't get why that's so hard to grasp for some MNers 🤯.

The only thing I prevented is my own DC being exposed to the consequences of someone else's shitty parenting and I would do exactly the same thing again every single time.

OP posts:
Winday · 24/02/2022 09:34

Your decision was entirely reasonable, OP. Your youngest already said they didn't feel comfortable around the other children. I wouldn't expect to send any child to sleep in a house where they would feel uncomfortable, or unsafe.

ChargingBuck · 24/02/2022 09:27

I am however expressing the view that the OP has overstepped and effectively prevented someone from helping their sister and her nephews and nieces in what must have been an awful situation.

Don't be ridiculous @@cansu
OP's actions ensured that help was received from the correct channels, rather than being dumped on a family without the experience or safeguarding awareness to handle the situation.

Finallylostit · 24/02/2022 09:25

i think B and your EXs relationship is now on the rocks - which is sad for all concerned when ultimately B was doing the right thing by stepping up for her family.

Sad situation all round and no right or wrong answers but I feel for B - who must feel very unsupported by her DP right now.

Burnshersmurfs · 24/02/2022 08:57

I suspect B’s response might have more to do with a touch of jealousy and insecurity than with a difference of opinion. When the chips were down, her partner sided with you. Obviously this doesn’t mean anything apart from your decision was objectively the correct one- but it’s still something that probably hit her quite hard emotionally.

LaChanticleer · 24/02/2022 08:56

OP has overstepped and effectively prevented someone from helping their sister and her nephews and nieces in what must have been an awful situation

But @cansu B was still able to help- as I understand it, she went temporarily to the emergency housing arranged for the children, and cared for them there.

Far better than bringing 5 disturbed and upset and damaged DC to a 2 bedroom house away from their own local area.

B has been a great sister to do this. And @LazyMareofEastown did not stop B from caring for her nephews and nieces. Just sensibly kept her own DV away from a stressful situation. It would hardly have been good for 5 traumatised children to be sent somewhere away from home and have to be in close quarters with other DC they don’t know very well, in stressfully crowded living quarters.

IWishIWasABaller · 24/02/2022 08:56

Excellent parenting op thank goodness you made the decision you did. God only knows what your children would have been exposed to, I think you were 100 percent correct.

OnlyClothes · 24/02/2022 08:50

OP didn’t prevent anyone from doing anything. Her ex could have said yes we’ll have them, I’ll see my kids at my ex’s house while this is going on. (I’m also unsure why the SW called OP though)

B can’t express her anger at the situation, her sister having failed to look after her own children, her mother for being unable/unwilling to look after her grandchildren temporarily, her own failure to look after her nieces and nephews at her mother’s home, so her anger is directed at the only person who has no responsibility to these children, and is the only one not actually related to them.

OP you did fine 👍.

EenieWeenie · 24/02/2022 08:45

You did the right thing. Anyone who has worked in this area would see the red flags and agree with you

Brefugee · 24/02/2022 08:23

OP i think you and your DP did exactly the right thing. It keeps your children safe, it got B's nieces/nephews back in a cleaner home relatively quickly and since you are not bothered about what B thinks about you, together with your knowledge of SS it worked out very well.

In your shoes I'd have been worried about the safeguarding and that it wouldn't be a couple of days. I don't know how SS works but I'm going to assume that it was some sort of private rental and SS got the kids home quickly as it would be eating into their budget.

Maybe in time B will understand why you did what you did, can it be she doesn't really think her sister's children aren't "that bad"?

cansu · 24/02/2022 08:16

Great. Glad you feel you were right. Smile

LaChanticleer · 24/02/2022 08:14

Excellent parenting from you and the DC’s father. B clearly has different boundaries and experiences - due to her sister’s situation perhaps - but these are not her DC and she needs to understand that.

LazyMareofEastown · 24/02/2022 07:54

Of course you can express whatever viewpoint you wish cansu but in this instance I'll go with the 97% majority who think I handled the situation correctly.

🙂

OP posts:
cansu · 24/02/2022 07:27

Chargingbuck I have two children with severe asd one of whom also has epilepsy and challenging behaviour. I am consequently very well aware what it takes to look after kids with issues. I am not trying to get a rise out of anyone either. I am however expressing the view that the OP has overstepped and effectively prevented someone from helping their sister and her nephews and nieces in what must have been an awful situation. Since when has it been the wrong thing to express an opposing point of view.

Ursusmajor · 23/02/2022 15:33

Sounds perfectly handled OP. Your ex’s partner will continue to be frosty with you, but you and your ex have kept your children safe in a tricky situation.
Hopefully all the kids involved get the support they need and a safe stable living situation sorted.

SartresSoul · 23/02/2022 15:16

Probably wouldn’t mind if they were nice kids who didn’t have to share a bedroom with my DC. Wouldn’t be happy with the troubled children you mentioned and definitely wouldn’t be happy with them sharing a room. Definite obvious safeguarding concerns and you were right to point them out. Sounds like it all worked out in the end though so no worries.

Ironfloor269 · 23/02/2022 14:57

OP you were 100% right. Ignore @cansu, she's just trying to get a riss out of you.

ChargingBuck · 22/02/2022 23:35

@cansu

I think you were wrong. It was only going to be short term and was a genuine emergency. I am sure your ex partner has been put out by your kids and gone beyond what she has to on occasion. You could have spoken up after a few days if needs be. I am not surprised she is unhappy. I hope you never need a favour from her on the future.
OK @cansu Let's find you a chaotic family of neglected kids who have behavioural difficulties & MH issues & bring them round to yours to play with your kids.

You won't mind their self-harming & hypersexualised behaviour around your DC, will you? After all - you might need a favour from their aunt one day - it's a small price for your kids to pay.

ChargingBuck · 22/02/2022 23:31

B is now being super frosty with me. I'm not massively bothered by this as we're not mates and my kids safety will always be something I'm taking zero chances with but I'm just wondering how it looks to an impartial observer.

B is being partisan because she feels judged by proxy for her sister.
B is also being a silly bitch. What kind of parent would willingly expose their DC to hypersexualised acting out from another family of troubled DC's?
B not being a parent herself is no excuse.

Well done for standing up for your kids OP & for showing their dad the way. He just didn't want to have to say NO to B. Although he should have - flat out, & hang the consequences.
B's frostiness is no skin off your nose btw. You can just quietly congratulate yourself for doing the right thing - it's her own problem that she didn't like it.

KimDeals · 22/02/2022 23:31

@LazyMareofEastown

Sweet

"Well your ex is a genius anyway. He knew you'd say no so now you're the bad guy and he didn't have to do what he didn't want to."

This is exactly what my DP said. Tbh I don't mind being the bad guy if it takes the heat off Ex. I have no horse in that race.

Ex knew he didn't need my consent but he also told me he wouldn't make a decision that would impact on our kids that I was dead against. Nor would I if the roles were reversed. We are friends and repsect each other's opinion and input.

Bit side of topic but I love the way you two are co-parenting.
PerditaPerdita · 22/02/2022 23:22

You did absolutely 110% right.

And those other kids were fine and had a place to stay.

All fine.

TyrannosaurusRegina · 22/02/2022 23:06

You did absolutely nothing wrong. You were shielding your children from a multitude of issues, the major one being the 2 hypersexulised children, which often means they have witnessed or been a victim of sexual abuse themselves. You did the right thing in keeping your children away from that, who knows what could have happened. I do feel desperately sorry for the kids who were in that situation but your number one priority is your own kids.