Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU- No overnight stays

363 replies

Satsuma2019 · 22/02/2022 18:06

Hello, me and my DH are on different pages with regards to sleepovers at grandparents (or anybody really) house. My MIL and my mum have asked a few times and I have said no because tbh I don’t really see what they are gaining by having them sleep. I’m more than happy to drop DDs off at their house for them to spend the day whilst I get on with some errands and pick them up at a convenient time. My MIL thinks I’m being selfish but I think since I’ve done all the hard parts like night feeds, teething and the troublesome twos without any help and the DDs are now easier to watch, why shouldn’t I reap the rewards and enjoy their time rather than palming them off. Plus if I say yes to one then how can I say no to everyone else and then what time will I get to spend with them?

Aibu?

OP posts:
esloquehay · 22/02/2022 19:28

@Satsuma2019, did you need/reach out to ILs et al for time out from your DC when he/she/they were younger? If so, was it forthcoming? Has CoVid Climate had an impact on family being backward in coming forward with offers of help?
Honestly, I wish I had family TO help out, as solo Mum to twins (now 4) and my bio family are dead, so not sure I understand why you're feeling annoyed about people asking to have your DC overnight, when I would have thought it's pretty obvious that it's easier for family to have (aka cope with;) 2+ DC overnight than babies and younger toddlers? 🤷
I would compromise/agree to it, as long as there are boundaries in place that you are comfortable with.
It's SO beneficial for our children to spend different pockets of time with family, as long as relationships/connections/attachments are healthy.
I think you are being a little selfish, thinking about this solely from your perspective, not how it might (would!) benefit DC.

Thisisit2022 · 22/02/2022 19:27

I struggled massively with my baby - mostly because of Colic. The baby time was awful. I barely slept and it was bloody hard work. I kept that away from my parents (though I would have gone to them for help if I felt it was unmanageable). They'd raised their children and I wanted them to enjoy grandparenthood, which they have. It wasn't their job. Jeez. Oh and sleepovers with my own grandparents were magical.

Tonsiltrouble · 22/02/2022 19:27

I think the dynamics of this changes massively depending on the geography and closeness of the relationship. My PIL are 2 hours away so even if they did have them overnight it’s not exactly helpful to us who would have to drop off and pick up. My parents are even further away. I think it works well for those families who are just around the corner from each other.

worriedatthemoment · 22/02/2022 19:27

@mummykel16 well then not much hope in a relationship is there if they can't compromise and agree
Then dad could do what he wants in his time I suppose
Just ridiculous that you think a mum has more say than a dad, legally thats generally not true
The Op only seems to have an issue as they never had them when young , maybe the kids don't even want to stay so thats issue over maybe they really want to

Tequilabeliever · 22/02/2022 19:27

@Satsuma2019

I just don’t understand how they can be so little involved during the tough parts and suddenly want to be so involved now that the children are more interesting that’s what I meant in my OP by reaping the rewards. Obviously it seems I’m being unreasonable but based on my parents, my in laws and siblings all offering to have DDs overnight I don’t think it’s extreme to think it will be a constant thing being badgered.
They are your children, not those of your parents or inlaws, therefore it stands to reason that you will shoulder the tough times.

My parents never wanted to even have my children for an afternoon, never mind overnight, so I’d jump at the chance of an overnighter.

There could be other info that you’ve not told us, behind your decision, but I would let them go. Your children may really enjoy it. If they don’t then you don’t have to repeat it. Enjoy the break, maybe think about whether your children would have fun, rather than how you feel about it.

CallMeNutribullet · 22/02/2022 19:26

What's the issue op? It actually sounds like you want to punish your family for not being there during the "hard parts".

rogueone · 22/02/2022 19:25

DickMabutt73962 well my inlaws did enjoy the 'blub' of a baby. Enjoyed having us over and staying at weekends and MIL would jump up to take baby in the morning to let me have a rest. It was my favourite breaks as I new I would get support. I wasnt looking for anyone to wake during the night but having a lie in was brill, food made etc was all part of support.

Classicblunder · 22/02/2022 19:25

It must be so hard having so many willing babysitters

Mamamia7962 · 22/02/2022 19:25

Angelina - what a lovely post.

AngelinaFibres · 22/02/2022 19:25

My parents didn't have my children to stay over until the youngest was 3. At the time I found it difficult but years later my mother said that it was because she was terrified of cot death. It was the time when Anne Diamonds son Sebastian had died. SIDS and 'back to sleep' was all over the news. She couldn't deal with the responsibility and the devastating consequences if something happened . Cot death was far more common than it is now. I completely got that once she explained. But ,even without that knowledge, I just accepted that babies are absolutely knackering and older people cannot cope with that level of work. When the boys were slightly older they stayed over often. Dad and my youngest brother took them fishing,played board games and table football with them. They read so many stories to them. They had time and endless patience. Don't punish people who want to help. It's daft.

Bakewelltart987 · 22/02/2022 19:24

So dh wants them to stay out. I agree with him. Have you asked the dc if they would like a sleepover? Even if they stayed at your mums 1 night a month then 1 night in mil that's only 2 nights a month. So off course you still have plenty of time with them.

BoredatHome321 · 22/02/2022 19:24

@mummykel16 you're not answering the question though. Why should mum get more of a say than dad?

Abraxan · 22/02/2022 19:24

At some point a decision must be made, mom should get final say.

Why?
Why can't dad get the final say, as an equal parent?

GreenFingersWouldBeHandy · 22/02/2022 19:24

Just a bit convenient it’s now that the children are easier they want to be involved

Of course they waited until it got easier. Don't forget they also raised you and your DH through the 'hard parts' - why would you expect them to do it again?

Abraxan · 22/02/2022 19:23

Obviously neither of you have to agree to it, but your reasons for not wanting them to stay over appears to come from them not helping out more when the children were small.which seems unfair - they are children's grandparents, not parents.

How old are your children? If old enough to be asked, what would they say?

I have lovely memories of staying over with my grandparents. It was often last minute ad-hoc occasions, and I can still remember how lovely it was. My memory still brings up the smell of my grandparent's bedding on the spare bed, and the joy of helping grandad in the garden or walking to the shops with my nana and being able to choose some sweets for the evening. I even got to go on holiday once with one set, as did my siblings individually.

My dd stayed over with grandparents from being about 3. Initially for a reason, such as us going out, later at her request. She's been on holiday with them and she used to have an annual visit to London with my parents to visit my grandparents, when they were alive. Such precious memories for her,

She's always loved staying with her grandparents. She is now almost 20y and at university. She's been for 'sleepovers' at her grandparents whilst there - catching the train and spending 2 or 3 evenings with them, going out for a meal and, now she's older, sharing a bottle of wine, etc with them.

I think often a stronger bond can form through those slightly extended times together, without parents in the way. And obviously a perfect chance for grandparents to 'spoil' the children with too much sweets/sugar than mum and dad allow, and maybe getting to stay up a bit later for a while as part of the treat.

Justwatching1 · 22/02/2022 19:23

one day their grandparents wont be there i dont have any grandparents left my first one died when i was 12

mummykel16 · 22/02/2022 19:23

[quote worriedatthemoment]@mummykel16 you compromise like you do in relationships and be grown ups
What if they split ? On his time he can do what he wants
If op had safety concerns then fair enough she would have a more valid argument
But according to you mums trump it all [/quote]
So they can't agree a compromise, with some things that's not possible, what next?

DickMabutt73962 · 22/02/2022 19:22

@Satsuma2019

I’m not bitter at doing the hard parts. I never asked for help and just got on with it with little help from DH too. But DGPs had very little contact during this period. Was never really bothered about visiting etc they were offered quality time but always had a reason why they couldn’t see us and now suddenly they want phone calls every day, visits every week and now sleepovers. Just a bit convenient it’s now that the children are easier they want to be involved Blush
Well your kids are more interesting now! Sorry that they didn't find staring at a blub of a baby all that engaging.
Shamoo · 22/02/2022 19:22

Unless the adults in question have issues that make them unsuitable to care for children, it seems super odd to me that you wouldn’t be biting their hands off assuming your kids are a reasonable age.

My inlaws have announced they want to take our DD to Spain for three weeks without us each year. Now that I have an issue with!

WhatisanODP · 22/02/2022 19:22

Yab a bit unreasonable. The kids will love it, and you can have a lie in!

What’s not to love!?

saraclara · 22/02/2022 19:21

At some point a decision must be made, mom should get final say.

I'd love to know your reasoning for this thinking @mummykel16

SickAndTiredAgain · 22/02/2022 19:21

Ok, dad says yay mom says nay, what next?

A reasonable discussion where no one says “I’m the mum so I always decide”? Like every other disagreement in a reasonable adult relationship.

(I’m not suggesting OP is doing this)

If it’s the case that every time you disagree you play your “mother” trump card, you must make all the decisions and always get what you want regardless of their father’s feelings on it?

Mamamia7962 · 22/02/2022 19:21

I find this really sad. One of the best parts of childhood is going to stay at grandparents. I used to go and stay with my grandmother for a week or more during school holidays, and my children would stay with my parents regularly as well. Happy childhood memories.

elenacampana · 22/02/2022 19:20

I loved my sleepovers at my nan’s growing up, they’re some of my best memories. I also loved my relationship with her, her home was my home. I’ve missed her immeasurably since she died in 2014. If my mum had kept me away because she wanted me all to herself, she’d have been robbing me of my whole other life that meant so much to me. It’s not the same as daytime visits, the overnights are special.

My daughter is only 3 months so she doesn’t know whether it’s Wednesday or Wembley half the time, but we’ve let her stay out twice at my MIL’s house and she’s going to my mum and dad overnight soon. I really want her to have the lovely time with grandparents that I had.

So yes, I think YABVU because it seems to be all about you.

Leggingslife · 22/02/2022 19:20

Yabu