Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU- No overnight stays

363 replies

Satsuma2019 · 22/02/2022 18:06

Hello, me and my DH are on different pages with regards to sleepovers at grandparents (or anybody really) house. My MIL and my mum have asked a few times and I have said no because tbh I don’t really see what they are gaining by having them sleep. I’m more than happy to drop DDs off at their house for them to spend the day whilst I get on with some errands and pick them up at a convenient time. My MIL thinks I’m being selfish but I think since I’ve done all the hard parts like night feeds, teething and the troublesome twos without any help and the DDs are now easier to watch, why shouldn’t I reap the rewards and enjoy their time rather than palming them off. Plus if I say yes to one then how can I say no to everyone else and then what time will I get to spend with them?

Aibu?

OP posts:
lucylucyapplejuicy · 22/02/2022 18:38

There was nothing better as a kid than sleepovers at my grandparents I loved it! And I do think it's special for grandparents to have them over night it's different than just watching them for a few hours. You sound a bit selfish to me. Wait till you have more kids you'll be begging for a babysitter. Mine all disappeared once DC2 arrived

APurpleSquirrel · 22/02/2022 18:38

YABU - I'm counting the days until PIL agree to take both DC overnight again (all stopped due to Covid & has really restarted yet)! It was a great break for DH & I to go out & do stuff together. & Dc loved it - they get spoilt rotten, have a great time & learn to be away for us.
DD will be going on school residential me next year so it helps she's slept away before.
I take it your DH wants the DC to stay with the DGPs?

irregularegular · 22/02/2022 18:37

It's not just OP's choice though, despite what others say - doesn't her DH get a say? Different if there are genuine concerns about safety etc but that doesn't seem to be the case here.

GreenFingersWouldBeHandy · 22/02/2022 18:37

I used to love having sleepovers at my Nan's. Hot chocolate and Penguin biscuits and she'll tell me stories about my Mum's childhood. That's what your children will gain; along with a closer relationship with their grandparents.

It's not just about you 'reaping the rewards' as you put it. Why are you so against it?

Go out for the evening and have fun!

Emily199034 · 22/02/2022 18:36

I used to remember having sleepovers at my Grandparents growing up and I have such fond memories of that. I remember my Grandad reading me bedtime stories and having breakfast in bed with my Grandma. They are such treasured measures. When my children are older I would be more than happy for them to sleep at my parents.

Satsuma2019 · 22/02/2022 18:36

I just don’t understand how they can be so little involved during the tough parts and suddenly want to be so involved now that the children are more interesting that’s what I meant in my OP by reaping the rewards. Obviously it seems I’m being unreasonable but based on my parents, my in laws and siblings all offering to have DDs overnight I don’t think it’s extreme to think it will be a constant thing being badgered.

OP posts:
irregularegular · 22/02/2022 18:35

Really? Unless there is some backstory here, I think it is lovely for grandchildren to spend a night with their grandparents! I have exciting memories of sleeping over as a child and clearly it would make your DM and MIL happy. Plus you get a nice grown-up evening, possibly going out, and a lie in! What's not to like???

"reap the rewards by enjoying their time"? Really? Unless you get to spend very little time with them for some reason....

And no, it doesn't mean they have to sleep over with everyone! Though sleepovers with aunts/uncles/cousins sound like fun to me! And later on their own close friends. Which is likely to go more smoothly if they have already practiced with granny, rathe than never having spend a night away.

grapewine · 22/02/2022 18:35

Some of my best childhood memories is sleeping over at Gran's house. It was special. It was also the groundwork for the close relationship I have had with my grandparents in adult life.

Blueberryflavour · 22/02/2022 18:34

As a doting grandma I have my grandchildren sometimes during the day and sometimes overnight. From a grandparents point of view snuggly cuddles and a child friendly programme on the TV after a warm bath is a very different vibe to outdoor playing and baking/crafting during the day. To be honest I never sleep deeply when they stay over, too much on alert not because they don’t sleep. There is a benefit to their parents in knowing that their children are safely looked after by the people who love them the most ( after their own parents of course) and they can go out for a meal, or stay home and have uninterrupted couple time and a lovely lie in and a relaxed breakfast the next day. My own kids loved staying over at my parents even when they were too young for sleepovers at friends. Also if something unexpected happened to their parents and we suddenly had to have the grandchildren for a few days, then the children would not be distressed as it was already part of their usual lives, surely better than it being the first time ever? My son and his partner ask us regularly to have them overnight and if they haven’t stayed over for a while we will ask to have them. We also share the driving and will pick up or drop as requested.

MsSquiz · 22/02/2022 18:32

I used to love staying at my DGM's house every Saturday night (because my DM worked in a pub) and even continued to stay well into my teens.

I'm gutted my DM died before DD was born and MIL died last year when DD was only 18 months as she now only has 1 grandparent (FIL) and he wouldn't be confident having her overnight or longer than an hour so she and DD2 (on the way) will never get a grandparent sleepover.
It's always handy in case of any kind of emergency to have someone your kids could happily stay overnight with. When I go in to have DD2, SIL (who has her own 3 kids) will be coming to ours to look after DD1 because we don't know how she would be staying out

lollipoprainbow · 22/02/2022 18:32

I'd love my dd to stay at her grandparents !! Think yourself lucky

mummykel16 · 22/02/2022 18:31

Your child your choice, and you don't need to explain why either

2018SoFarSoGreat · 22/02/2022 18:30

I'm a grandparent and having DGS's over to spend the night is such a joy. It is not babysitting, but it does give parents a break, and a long lie in the morning if no work next day. The DGS's love it and ask to come; we have to bargain how many nights with the 5 year old! There is something totally different from a visit to an overnight - we get to read stories, sing songs, make special breakfast that becomes 'their GP thing' - ours is DH makes crepes, and they love it.

Totally up to you, OP, but it is just offering your DC a different experience.

Cas112 · 22/02/2022 18:30

My favourite thing to do as a child was stay at my nanas house, don't take that away from them

DetailMouse · 22/02/2022 18:29

Some of my fondest childhood memories are time spent staying with GPs and my DC undoubtedly benefited hugely from the mini breaks they had with my parents.

If you don't see what GPs gain from having them while they're asleep, what are you losing?

RedskyThisNight · 22/02/2022 18:29

Surely you'll spend more quality time with your DC during the day (when you're happy for them to spend time with their GP) than over night? I'm not sure I understand your argument.

Darkstar4855 · 22/02/2022 18:29

What do the children want? They might really enjoy staying overnight with grandparents once a month or so. It’s good for them to learn a little bit of independence and have an adventure without you occasionally.

My son only has one grandparent and they’re a long way away so sadly we don’t have this option.

Holly60 · 22/02/2022 18:28

Did you never stay over at your grandparents OP? I absolutely LOVED going to stay with my Granny and Grandad as a child. It was exciting to be in a different bed, we got different food at breakfast and I got to snuggle down with my beloved grandparents. It was a very safe and cosy feeling adventure. Also if you can imagine that you might one day want your possible future grandchildren to come and stay with you (or your DH can imagine that he might) you might want to instil that in them now, otherwise you risk that they might refuse to
let you do it when the time comes, as it won’t seem natural to them.

BooksAndHooks · 22/02/2022 18:28

Some of my best memories are staying at grandparents house, even though it was down the road and we saw them all the time it’s completely different. I’d never begrudge either my parents or my children that experience. I look after my nieces and nephews all the time in the day, they still love coming for sleepovers.

Unless there are specific concerns I think it’s mean to stop a fun part of childhood.

peboh · 22/02/2022 18:26

I can understand not feeling comfortable, and that's completely reasonable. However you've put in your op, that you feel like you deserve the overnights because you've put the hard work in during teething etc. That's harsh to not allow overnights because you should reap the rewards. They're your children, it's your basic human job to do the hard work with them. You can't punish others for that.

EsmeSusanOgg · 22/02/2022 18:24

YANBU. Your children, your call. It might be a nice adventure every once in a while though. How often are they proposing these sleepovers happen?

Lazypuppy · 22/02/2022 18:24

They get the evening time and the next morning, and you and your DH get a child free evening

VariationsonaTheme · 22/02/2022 18:23

I think it’s a good opportunity for children to get used to being away from parents, in an environment they’re comfortable in. I would have hated it if the first time mine were away from home was because I was seriously ill in hospital for instance. It doesn’t need to be every week, but every now and then won’t hurt surely?

Fairyfalls · 22/02/2022 18:23

I have so many happy memories of staying over at my grandparents growing up. Tea and toast in the morning in front of the fire and just a warm coziness feel of being loved by my family. They would get so much out of the quality time with grandparents. I think it would be lovely for all of them.

SeasonFinale · 22/02/2022 18:23

Ask whether they will either pick up or drop back so you only do the trip once. Use the time to go out with DH even if just the cinema where you may not usually go to the expense of a paid babysitter.

The kids will love it , the grandparents will love it and it sounds as though DH would too. I suspect you might too if you try it.

Why not give it a go and if you really don't like being apart for one night then you don't have to do it again.