Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

do I gently challenge?

162 replies

stressedheiress · 22/02/2022 10:45

Obv name changed. My parents have both recently died. In short succession. I'm heartbroken, particularly by the second death, which I think is common.
The wills are standard - to each other, then to children. In the last months months of Mum's life she expressed a lot of concern that she'd given my sister too much already (think millions). To be fair some of this money was offered to me but I am (as my son tells me) stupidly independent and earn a comfortable living. Anyway, I told mum that sister didn't put a gun to her head and it had been her choice. And left it at that. But she picked at the scab - saying she'd had too much, wasn't responsible, and that sister was probably giving a lot of the money to second husband's family and that upset her.
Anyway, we've recently seen the wills and there isn't mention of anything other than 50/50.
BUT. I have found a very clearly written note in her desk saying £x extra must go to the me to equalise the situation.
What do I do? i don't need the extra money. But I am very clear in my mind that Mum's wishes had changed and that it was only her ailing health (not dementia) that prevented a change being made.
Do I show sister this note and tell her what mum was saying?
I don't like confrontation. But I also don't like unfairness! Equally I don't want to break sister's heart any more.
FWIW (and I know there'll be doubters) I would be donating a big chunk of the inheritance since I don't believe money way beyond your needs makes you happier. I'm fortunate - good education, me and DH had good jobs etc (in fact sister used to justify her taking the money on the basis i was 'lucky')
Please advise how to tread through this situation.... It's literally keeping me awake at night

OP posts:
AllOfUsAreDead · 22/02/2022 12:08

I wouldnt show the note. Not sure if it stands up legally, maybe it does, but what little bridges you have with your sister now (and from the sounds of it there isn't much there), that will be destroyed with this note. She won't believe your mum wrote it on her own, she will believe that you made your mum do it.

Realistically, you're going to have a dodgy relationship with her now anyway though. Now she doesn't have your parents to turn to for money, who do you think she will turn to once she squander this away? You. You're going to have issues from her wanting more help from you in future too. Guess you could avoid that by annoying her now with this note and break all contact. Either way, I think your relationship with your sister won't ever be a good one again.

stressedheiress · 22/02/2022 12:08

She's talking of paying all inheritance tax on gifts through the estate. Unsure whether that can happen.
Urgh
It's such a little note but it's weighing so heavy!

OP posts:
Bubblesandsqueak1 · 22/02/2022 12:06

Tbf any large sum given in the last 7 years I believe has to be declared and included in the estate so she may end up with less anyway before that is a write off

stressedheiress · 22/02/2022 12:03

And actually what I probably need is some therapy to sort this out and let it go...

OP posts:
stressedheiress · 22/02/2022 12:02

@FudgeSundae I think you're right; over the years I've liked her less for her 'bring it on' ( her words) attitude to asking for and taking money and being bailed out continually at the same time as not being particularly supportive of two aging parents. So yes. I'll fess up to that.
Re whether mum could have changed the Will... yes of course she could. But the last year was appearing.. she was initially caring fir dad with dementia, then she was struck down by a catastrophe stroke With me and sister having joint POA - she couldn't even sign her name. Very hard. Which is why I batted away her worries, thinking it would stress her more to see solicitor. I realise now I was wrong..
Now it's just eating away at me!

OP posts:
Associatepeggy · 22/02/2022 11:52

I think you should leave it.

You want to, essentially, reduce her inheritence and give it to charity instead.

I don't really see how it benefits anyone to tell her.

FudgeSundae · 22/02/2022 11:49

To put it another way, if you don’t need or want it then why can’t your sister have it? Seems like you just don’t like her and don’t want her to have any more tbh Hmm

FudgeSundae · 22/02/2022 11:48

I think you’ll find the more has no legal value but you can both agree as beneficiaries to vary the will. My mum wanted various gifts to be made that weren’t in her will so my sister and I just made the variation and did it.

But I’d be quite annoyed if I was your sister and you got me to give up some of my inheritance so you could give to charity. If you think some should go to charity, the estate can make a gift and if it’s10% or more the whole estate pays less inheritance tax. As your sister I’d be happier with that way round even if I ended up with the same amount, as then the giver is you both/ your mum, not you being virtuous…

Babadook76 · 22/02/2022 11:44

I agreed with you until you said you’d be giving a load away to charity. You can’t contest the will and upset the family over a note saying you should get more money, then give it away to someone else. That’s family money left to benefit the family. If you don’t want it then give it away to other members of your family or leave it in trust for the children

LostMyLastHatfulOfWords · 22/02/2022 11:44

You didn't take the money when offered it - though you could have. (Yours was the nobler choice but choice it was.)

Your sister did take the money. This was her choice and your mother's to give it.

That part is over.

Your mother was bothered by your refusal to take a 'fair share' and perhaps wanted to make it up to you... but she didn't actually change her will. She chose not to over the years.

You can show the note to your sister she might want you to have the money.

However if you press to have things divided differently, your relationship with her will be at further risk.

Would you Mum want to be the cause of further dissent between you?

Sittingonabench · 22/02/2022 11:43

I would seek legal advice but my go to would be to leave it. I understand the desire to respect your mother’s wishes but they were her wishes at some point and were put in legal documents. It is not your duty to make sure her last thoughts on this are legally binding. I agree that money doesn’t make you happy but it can be the cause of a lot of unhappiness and I suspect that if you challenged this it would cause a lot of upset for everyone. In the grip of grief this can be appealing as a distraction from what is really hurting but it won’t stop the grief and will leave a bigger mess. It might not be fair and your mother may have felt guilt at some point over this but you shouldn’t have to fight that battle (especially if you don’t need the money), you’ve got enough to get through.

pumpkinpie01 · 22/02/2022 11:43

I would say the note does not stand legally as it has not been witnessed and signed the same as a will is . I really can't see your sister willingly letting you have more when legally she doesn't have to , annoying as that is.

Briony123 · 22/02/2022 11:40

Tune of!

Billybagpuss · 22/02/2022 11:40

I think the note is already eating away at you. I think you need to get together with her and say I’ve found this note from mum, I don’t necessarily need the money but maybe we should donate that amount to mums favourite charity before we do the final split?

Briony123 · 22/02/2022 11:40

You'll be reducing your sister's inheritance to the tube of millions, money you don't want or need, and intend on using it to top up charity executives sky high salaries - there's nothing "gentle" about that. I'd challenge the will and keep the money, but I wouldn't kid myself I was doing anything "gently".

SeasonFinale · 22/02/2022 11:38

I am sorry OP but if it truly were your mum's wishes she would have changed the Will. Even if her health was ailing she could have arranged that. Maybe she actually decided that your sister actually needed that extra more than you do (and that the money she had earned/saved was better off in her family than being given away however good a charity is).

moose62 · 22/02/2022 11:36

You will probably find that the note is not legally binding in any way unless it was added to the will, signed and dated. By bringing it up with your sister, especially if you find it is not legal, will just make the relationship worse. If it is still a significant amount of money perhaps you can put yours in trust for your children. No one knows the way this world is going at the moment and they will probably be very grateful for some financial help in the future.

interferringma · 22/02/2022 11:32

What I'm getting from OP is that this is eating away at her and soiling her relationship anyway. I say gently challenge!
And yeah keep some money for yourself, although I'm sensing there may be more than enough for you and charity. Your first post mentioned millions did it not?

Keepyourheadscrewedon · 22/02/2022 11:31

Get some proper legal advice then tell your sister.

She has taken millions already, so why on earth would you feel bad? Just say your mother wished to make things as equal as possible.

It is not your decision or problem. Your sister can take it how she pleases - please put the money away for your children, you have no idea what the future will bring and they may need it.

billy1966 · 22/02/2022 11:25

Wishes!

billy1966 · 22/02/2022 11:25

Obviously you find out the legal position first.

Then you honour your mothers dishes.

You make provision for your children first.

Should yours or their circumstances change and you have given money away that would be of use, they will rightly think you very foolish.

See your children sorted and will some money upon your own death.

stressedheiress · 22/02/2022 11:23

@Mundra I'm struggling too. And to express genuinely that it's not about the money (I realise that I'm probably eliciting hollow laughs and eye rolls). It's about mum's wishes. For almost the last year of her life she worried that the 50/50 was wrong for all kinds of reasons.
And yes a little bit of me really resents the way sister passes off the early inheritances she's had as her own hard work. It most definitely isn't.
Maybe I should just leave it..

OP posts:
randomchap · 22/02/2022 11:22

Can you talk to your sister about it? Show her the note and explain what your mum's wishes were and see how she reacts? Make it clear that your only interest is in seeing your mum's wishes carried out and to work together to come up with a solution that respects her wishes without hurting your sister, or damaging your relationship with her.

Tigersonvaseline · 22/02/2022 11:21

Agree wouldn't bother for charity

Maybe show sis the notes but say you won't act on them
Being frail is absolutely not a barrier to a will update
People do it on their death beds!

Lime37 · 22/02/2022 11:18

To be honest if your giving it away to charity I wouldn’t say anything. Surely if your mum wanted the money to go to charity she would have done it her self.