Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

do I gently challenge?

162 replies

stressedheiress · 22/02/2022 10:45

Obv name changed. My parents have both recently died. In short succession. I'm heartbroken, particularly by the second death, which I think is common.
The wills are standard - to each other, then to children. In the last months months of Mum's life she expressed a lot of concern that she'd given my sister too much already (think millions). To be fair some of this money was offered to me but I am (as my son tells me) stupidly independent and earn a comfortable living. Anyway, I told mum that sister didn't put a gun to her head and it had been her choice. And left it at that. But she picked at the scab - saying she'd had too much, wasn't responsible, and that sister was probably giving a lot of the money to second husband's family and that upset her.
Anyway, we've recently seen the wills and there isn't mention of anything other than 50/50.
BUT. I have found a very clearly written note in her desk saying £x extra must go to the me to equalise the situation.
What do I do? i don't need the extra money. But I am very clear in my mind that Mum's wishes had changed and that it was only her ailing health (not dementia) that prevented a change being made.
Do I show sister this note and tell her what mum was saying?
I don't like confrontation. But I also don't like unfairness! Equally I don't want to break sister's heart any more.
FWIW (and I know there'll be doubters) I would be donating a big chunk of the inheritance since I don't believe money way beyond your needs makes you happier. I'm fortunate - good education, me and DH had good jobs etc (in fact sister used to justify her taking the money on the basis i was 'lucky')
Please advise how to tread through this situation.... It's literally keeping me awake at night

OP posts:
nokidshere · 22/02/2022 13:05

It's not legally binding unless it's signed, dated and witnessed. What have you got to gain from showing your sister apart from upset? There is absolutely no point in 'what ifs'. If your mum wanted things differently then she should have changed her will.

Metalguru22 · 22/02/2022 13:04

@stressedheiress

She's talking of paying all inheritance tax on gifts through the estate. Unsure whether that can happen. Urgh It's such a little note but it's weighing so heavy!
Sorry if I've missed this, I have looked at your posts. Who is the executor of the will? There is a process to follow, even if she's executor your sister can't decide how the estate is used before it's divided. If there is a solicitor as executor it might be worth having a conversation about all of this. I'm hoping your sister doesn't have access to any bank accounts.
stressedheiress · 22/02/2022 13:01

@Fere because I've explained the last year has been the worst imaginable - dad very ill then mum herself having a catastrophic stroke. Although she complained about sister I really don't think she had the energy to do anything and stupidly I didn't push it because I felt it was low priory in the maelstrom that was raging around us

OP posts:
Fere · 22/02/2022 12:58

If you mother wanted to leave more to you why didn't she change her will?

stressedheiress · 22/02/2022 12:58

@formalineadeline sounds like a good idea. Something I'd never heard of. Both parents died this year. One will be buried next week. I suppose I haven't thought things through very sanely yet.
The note was a surprise. But was nestled alongside a note giving details of what music mum wanted at her funeral. Was lovely to find that

OP posts:
Gizacluethen · 22/02/2022 12:57

No point going to your sister, you need legal advice if they say it stands then take it to your sister. If they say its worthless then no point arguing with your sister over it. She's not the type of person to hand you money is she so it'd just be a waste of argument.

Leave the money to your kids if you don't want it though.

formalineadeline · 22/02/2022 12:56

Separately I might consider locking away your actual inheritance to be donated via a legacy in your own will.

That way your mum can still step in to help you in future years (so to speak) if your family's circumstances change adversely, but it doesn't compromise your beliefs or change your lifestyle in the present.

stressedheiress · 22/02/2022 12:54

Wow @UnderTheSea20k Thanks for putting it so gently.

OP posts:
UnderTheSea20k · 22/02/2022 12:50

I'm sorry, but are you actually serious??? You clearly think you're some kind of saint here when you're actually being extremely selfish. You didn't have to take money from your mother when she was alive but she's leaving money to family with the intent for it to benefit family and you want to give it away? You don't think for one second that you're basically discounting her wishes and stealing from her grandchIldren? And you want to cut down your sister's share so you can give more of it away, how the hell is that your mother's wishes??? If she wanted it to all go to charity she should have done that.

Take your half of the money and put what you don't want in trust for your children. Stop thinking you're morally superior.

wildseas · 22/02/2022 12:49

I think @JustLyra has got it spot on here. Your mum didn’t need to change her will because it was never about the money for either of you - it was about acknowledging that she was proud of you for standing on your own two feet. And the note does exactly that.

In your position I wouldn’t show the note unless you actively want to have the money and keep it to use yourself. Showing it will only give one of two outcomes - either sister gives you the money (which you then give to charity which will provoke an almighty row) or she doesn’t (also likely to provoke a row).

The person who receives the gift pays any subsequent inheritance tax - that’s taxation law so you can definitely stand firm on that.

formalineadeline · 22/02/2022 12:47

@stressedheiress

Gosh *@JustLyra* that's a lovely way to look at the note: as a comfort. Thank you. Not much is confronting at the moment :(
The note doesn't have any legal standing (wills would be worthless and open to fraud otherwise).

I would see it in a similar way - of your mum wanting to ensure you understand she loved you equally. I would take the worries she expressed to you in life in the same way.

Most people whose parents leave unequal shares to siblings do find it very hard not to feel it reflects differences in love from their parent.

Trying to 'do' anything with this note would achieve nothing except to damage your relationship with your sister. I sincerely doubt that is what your mum would want.

I say all this as someone who struggled for a very long time with feeling I had to base my decisions on what my mum would have wanted or else I was failing her - before ultimately realising the one thing my mum would have wanted for me was to live free from such a burden.

Carry forward her love for you and how she shaped the person you are. You don't need to do more than that to be true to her memory. Flowers

tara66 · 22/02/2022 12:45

Money is money - everyone likes and needs it really (no matter how much they protest). Your mother wrote down her wishes - whether that is legally binding - who knows? You are obliged to take a copy of original and show it to DS. You could need this money in the future - you may become sick, disable etc . Perhaps help buy your child a house with it? It certainly shouldn't go to DS's ILs .

jytdtysrht · 22/02/2022 12:43

Whilst I can see that your sister is grossly irresponsible and a bit of a liar/faker, I personally don't think you should fight the 50:50.

For two reasons:

  1. To put it horribly bluntly, your mum has gone and she did not sort this out properly before her death. It could be argued that if she had the agency to write the note, then she could easily have phoned a solicitor to sort it out legally. Alternatively, it could be argued that this note was written at 3am during a sleepless night when she felt emotional and that in the cold light of day, she decided not take further action. All this would cost legal fees and I'm sure your mum would not have wanted her money to have been used for this purpose so that neither of you get that part of it.

  2. Your plan to donate inheritance. Your sister does not sound like a great person, but fighting legally to deprive a sibling of their inheritance in order to donate it (rather than being in desperate need of it yourself) does not sit well with me. Further to this point, you should keep whatever you get anyway because you never know what's going to happen in life. You ought to help your children as much as you can because life is bloody hard and money can make it easier. Money/income can be easily lost as well.

  3. You now know for sure that your mum fully acknowledged your independence and your sister's fecklessness. So the note can help you emotionally, if not financially. And despite all your sister's failings, she was still your mum's child.

Anything other than equal splits is generally a total family wrecker anyway.

JustLyra · 22/02/2022 12:33

@stressedheiress

Gosh *@JustLyra* that's a lovely way to look at the note: as a comfort. Thank you. Not much is confronting at the moment :(
It’s just a little note, but if you think of it it says a lot.

It’s acknowledging that there is an unfairness, but it’s also acknowledging every time you say that you were ok. Every time you were able to stand on your own feet. Every time you didn’t take the piss.

Take comfort where you can get it.

billy1966 · 22/02/2022 12:30

Her asking for her inheritance tax on previous gifts to be paid from her mother's estate is disgusting.

Make sure via legal advice that THAT does not happen.

You spent years taking the high ground and you are now furious with yourself....well THAT is very silly.

Point scoring of that nature is very unwise as it was not genuine, hence your irritation now.

Spend money on therapy to help you accept your past decisions and motivation.

Step away from your sister.
You don't like her and she takes your peace.

But do not compound your earlier foolish decisions with giving away any further money which may help your children.

I sure as hell am very very careful about donations for the past 15 years since the periodical exposè of the obscene salaries of charity CEO's.

stressedheiress · 22/02/2022 12:26

Gosh @JustLyra that's a lovely way to look at the note: as a comfort.
Thank you. Not much is confronting at the moment :(

OP posts:
JustLyra · 22/02/2022 12:24

The note is very unlikely to have legal standing. Anything not straight forward with a will is always calm expensive to sort.

Not telling you what to do. However if I was you I’d just see the note as a comfort thing from your mum - she knows that you stood on your own two feet and if she could have she’d have equalised the balance. That’s quite precious - a lot of people have unfairness that they never understand.

Have some counselling to deal with your conflict.

And please sit on any money you are going to give away for a while before you do. I know two people who quickly gave away inheritance which now regret it because years later circumstances mean they could have put the money to better use than they ever expected. I refused an inheritance from my father (I lived with my grandparents from age 7). I now have a younger child who’ll never be independent and whilst we’re comfortable I do regret that amount not being in the pot to help with her care in the unlikely event she outlives me.

stressedheiress · 22/02/2022 12:19

@Ponoka7 she may have done. I've never made any attempt to hide the fact I think wealth ought to be spread. And I'm quite sure that influenced the abundant gifts my sister has received since the age of 18 (she's in her fifties now).
But that doesn't change the fact that in her final year (ish) mum hated the thought she'd given her too much. Sister had started giving the money to second husband's family and that pissed mum off. Both she and husband had stopped working too. And spending 'beyond their means' in mum's words

OP posts:
SamphiretheStickerist · 22/02/2022 12:18

[quote stressedheiress]@Mundra I'm struggling too. And to express genuinely that it's not about the money (I realise that I'm probably eliciting hollow laughs and eye rolls). It's about mum's wishes. For almost the last year of her life she worried that the 50/50 was wrong for all kinds of reasons.
And yes a little bit of me really resents the way sister passes off the early inheritances she's had as her own hard work. It most definitely isn't.
Maybe I should just leave it..[/quote]
Show it to the solicitor who has the will. See that they advise. At best they can be the ones who discuss it with your sister rather than you!

Also check the costs with the esate paying inheritance taxes. I can't remeber the ins and out osf it, and it will have changed in the last 20 years. But there are pros and cons to doing it that way. Get a solicitor to explain it. Your mum's estate can pay for impartial legal advice!

GiantSpider · 22/02/2022 12:17

I am strongly in favour of the older generation helping out the younger generation (if they can, of course) before death rather than making them wait for it, which probably influences my answer, but I would say leave it and make peace with it. As other posters have said, if your main aim here is to respect your mother's wishes, she may prefer you to have it rather than your sister, but she may also prefer your sister to have it rather than a charity. And she definitely won't want this to cause irreparable damage to her daughters' relationship. Showing the note will just cause upset between you and your sister.

Sorry for your loss Flowers

Sausagedogsarethebest · 22/02/2022 12:17

OP I'm sorry for your losses.

If you do show your DS the note then I suppose it will indicate to her that your DM must have been disturbed enough to have written it a while ago - you say it was clearly written and that in the last year she had a stroke which left her unable to write - so it's not something she could have written at the end of her life.

Whether it makes your DS reconsider her share is another matter. The note may not be legally binding. Did your DM sign and date it? Can you prove it was written by her? If your DS chooses to ignore the note you could of course say you're thinking of contesting the will and that her previous cash gifts will be revealed. Could be embarrassing if she's been passing them off as obtained through her own hard work.

However, if your relationship with her is already not good then this would probably ruin it forever, so you need to weigh that up. If you don't need the money then I personally would leave it be.

Ponoka7 · 22/02/2022 12:16

"She probably did a really sensible thing giving it to your sister to avoid inheritance tax and also to see her enjoying it whilst she was alive. By refusing money you have probably ensured more money to the tax man already."

That's also true. Given what the government has spent billions on since coming to power, is your sister less worthy?

stressedheiress · 22/02/2022 12:16

Gosh Clearly the right thing to do was to be grabby then!
I think that argument depends on your politics though doesn't it? High earners have relatively low taxes so we have inheritance tax. I don't think that's a bad thing personally.

OP posts:
Ponoka7 · 22/02/2022 12:15

Did your Mother have any inclination that if you got the money you would be giving it away anyway? Does your sister have children?

Fairyliz · 22/02/2022 12:13

Your mum has given millions to your sister so she must have been incredibly rich.
She probably did a really sensible thing giving it to your sister to avoid inheritance tax and also to see her enjoying it whilst she was alive. By refusing money you have probably ensured more money to the tax man already.