Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

do I gently challenge?

162 replies

stressedheiress · 22/02/2022 10:45

Obv name changed. My parents have both recently died. In short succession. I'm heartbroken, particularly by the second death, which I think is common.
The wills are standard - to each other, then to children. In the last months months of Mum's life she expressed a lot of concern that she'd given my sister too much already (think millions). To be fair some of this money was offered to me but I am (as my son tells me) stupidly independent and earn a comfortable living. Anyway, I told mum that sister didn't put a gun to her head and it had been her choice. And left it at that. But she picked at the scab - saying she'd had too much, wasn't responsible, and that sister was probably giving a lot of the money to second husband's family and that upset her.
Anyway, we've recently seen the wills and there isn't mention of anything other than 50/50.
BUT. I have found a very clearly written note in her desk saying £x extra must go to the me to equalise the situation.
What do I do? i don't need the extra money. But I am very clear in my mind that Mum's wishes had changed and that it was only her ailing health (not dementia) that prevented a change being made.
Do I show sister this note and tell her what mum was saying?
I don't like confrontation. But I also don't like unfairness! Equally I don't want to break sister's heart any more.
FWIW (and I know there'll be doubters) I would be donating a big chunk of the inheritance since I don't believe money way beyond your needs makes you happier. I'm fortunate - good education, me and DH had good jobs etc (in fact sister used to justify her taking the money on the basis i was 'lucky')
Please advise how to tread through this situation.... It's literally keeping me awake at night

OP posts:
MichelleScarn · 22/02/2022 13:46

@BoredZelda

But I definitely know she was deeply uncomfortable with sister getting such a big sum when she's already had an incredible amount.

In which case she should have changed her will. It wouldn't have been difficult to do. A simple phone call to her solicitor would suffice. She chose not to.

You don't even want the money, seems a bit spiteful to take it from your sister.

Just leave it alone.

This, your mum seems to have chosen to give the money in the past to your sister, you sat that you were OK about it. You don't need the money, will give it away?
GiftWrappingLikeItsXmasEve · 22/02/2022 13:44

If you are giving money to charity I wouldn’t say anything. Your mother could have left it to a charity. Save/keep the relationship with your sister. She will undoubtably see it as you taking it from her.

Totalwasteofpaper · 22/02/2022 13:43

@Mundra

I'm struggling to understand why you care about 50/50. You don't want the money anyway, why do you care that your sister ends up with more (overall)? Not everyone finds it easy to stand on their own two feet and it sounds as though she is less resilient than you, and indeed, places less emphasis on needing to be self reliant. We're all different, one way is not superior to another.

I am sorry for your loss, it's a big blow losing them both in a short period of time. Please be kind to yourself too, and don't give this headspace that you don't have right now Thanks

Yeah I agree with this.

Your sister doesn’t sound as though she is gone to say “oh cool well here is an extra £3m then” so you’lleother be wasting your breathe or going down a legal route.

if you go through the courts to fight it, fees will swallow a significant portion of the estate potetionally.

The time for your mother to resolve it was when she was alive unfortunately
Flowers

freshcarnation · 22/02/2022 13:37

Leave it be.

RB68 · 22/02/2022 13:36

AN executor should look back over the last 7 years for any monies given or sent to others from the estate. It may be that this would cover those amounts your sister had and these would also be considered part of the estate both for IHT and part of the distribution of monies - time for an independent executor e,g, solicitor rather than family

2DogsOnMySofa · 22/02/2022 13:34

You're stuck between a rock and a hard place. Have a chat with the solicitor and see if the note carries any weight first of all. If it does you've several options, if your sister is money oriented you can kiss any relationship goodbye with her if you go via the solicitors, or you could show her the note and see if she does the right thing. My opinion is that she won't. I think either way the relationship will break.

If the note doesn't hold water then you could speak to your ds but I wouldn't hold you breath and it's likely it break the relationship

The only way not to ruin your relationship with your ds is not to say anything, but it's likely to eat you up and you'll end up resenting your ds, so it will break anyway

Trytryandtryagain11 · 22/02/2022 13:34

Such a tricky one, and you sound so lovely, I'm really sorry for your losses. I think as you don't 'need' the money as such, I would show your sister the note and explain the conversation you had. Tell her the information is for her to do with as she will - then the burden of it over to her, and you don't have to make the decision - I'd hope she would do the right thing but hey-ho!

Crinkle77 · 22/02/2022 13:33

@Mundra

I'm struggling to understand why you care about 50/50. You don't want the money anyway, why do you care that your sister ends up with more (overall)? Not everyone finds it easy to stand on their own two feet and it sounds as though she is less resilient than you, and indeed, places less emphasis on needing to be self reliant. We're all different, one way is not superior to another.

I am sorry for your loss, it's a big blow losing them both in a short period of time. Please be kind to yourself too, and don't give this headspace that you don't have right now Thanks

I agree. You don't want or need the money. It's not worth the fight just to then give it to charity. If I was your sister I would think you'd just done it out of spite and it will more likely cause a bigger rift in your relationship.
EdithRea · 22/02/2022 13:32

Charity donations will just end up in the pocket of some CEO. Keep it for your children. They need it more than some rich tosser needs another yacht.

Tohaveandtohold · 22/02/2022 13:30

However I personally won’t bother

Spitspatspot · 22/02/2022 13:29

OP, I’m so sorry for your losses, to have lost both of your parents in such a small amount of time must be heartbreaking.
I can understand the weight of responsibility you feel to your mum’s memory, but I agree with other posters that it is unlikely to stand, legally, and I think you’d be opening yourself up to more pain by raising it with your sister. If I were you, I would let the will stand as is, make best of use of the legacy your parents have given you, and cherish your mum’s letter privately as an acknowledgment of how much you clearly meant to her.

Tohaveandtohold · 22/02/2022 13:29

If you want the extra money then by all means challenge it.
I know your sister is entitled and she has had a lot of money from your parents in their life time however if what you’ll be doing with the extra is reducing your sister’s entitlement and donating to charity ( which I don’t think your mum would have wanted otherwise she would have done this herself) then I think yabu.
At the end of the day, your parents are dead and it’s left to both of you alive to live with this. If you need the money then challenge it

MarinoRoyale · 22/02/2022 13:28

I’d leave it alone. I think you’ve been through a lot with the loss of your parents and this could very well be displacement of your grief over that. It’s never going to end well, even if you win do you think it’d be worth all the drama and stress that always goes hand in hand where challenging wills is concerned?

This would be one of those situations where I’d employ “just because you can doesn’t mean you should”. I’d make peace with it and access some counseling for your grief. Your mum may have wanted you to have more money but that doesn’t mean she’d want you to go through all the hoops you’d have to jump through to get her will overturned.

BoredZelda · 22/02/2022 13:24

But I definitely know she was deeply uncomfortable with sister getting such a big sum when she's already had an incredible amount.

In which case she should have changed her will. It wouldn't have been difficult to do. A simple phone call to her solicitor would suffice. She chose not to.

You don't even want the money, seems a bit spiteful to take it from your sister.

Just leave it alone.

looklikeanelephant · 22/02/2022 13:24

@WheresYourSnickers

Unless you really need it I think you should make peace with the 50/50 and let it go.
I agree with this
Thisisyourvaginatalking · 22/02/2022 13:19

*think

Thisisyourvaginatalking · 22/02/2022 13:19

Just to switch it around, if my bro suddenly came up with a note challenging 50/50, I would assume it was fraudulent. I would thank that it was just too 'convenient '. No way will your sister trust it.

PerseverancePays · 22/02/2022 13:19

So sorry for your loss.

In my experience inheritance brings out the worst in people. Give yourself time to grieve and space to come round from losing both your parents. As people have said, take comfort from the note that your mother was thinking of you.
Put the money away safely for a year and then come back to it. Things will look different in a year's time. Take care of yourself.

godmum56 · 22/02/2022 13:18

[quote stressedheiress]@Fere because I've explained the last year has been the worst imaginable - dad very ill then mum herself having a catastrophic stroke. Although she complained about sister I really don't think she had the energy to do anything and stupidly I didn't push it because I felt it was low priory in the maelstrom that was raging around us[/quote]
Strokes can affect capacity too even if its not evident.

stressedheiress · 22/02/2022 13:17

@Metalguru22 she does have access. Or did. Now parents are dead the banks have frozen them. Basically she busied herself with the money stuff and I did the caring/health bits. It's how we got things done in the last (awful) year.
Me, her and a solicitor are joint executors.
I think I need to bow out now fir my own sake. Last parent will be buried next week and I came on here fir advice (which some great people
Have given me). But I sense a bit of a kicking too and frankly I'm not robust enough for that at the moment
Thanks for the advice - even the advice I might not have wanted to hear x

OP posts:
godmum56 · 22/02/2022 13:16

If its about how either decisions will affect how you feel, then no one can tell you that. If your mum was of sound mind, why did she not just change her will? She has left you in a horrible situation, I'd be a bit cross about that myself.
If it were me, I would privately take legal advice then if you have no legal basis for a challenge let it go. Either way it seems like your relationship with your sister is shot. I have been in a similar situation and a legal challenge to the will is a long and expensive process. If you do have a hood legal basis then the next step would be to duscuss it with the executor.

Aprilx · 22/02/2022 13:14

If the will says 50/50 then that is what should be done and no note you have found is going to change that.

Intentions need to be written down, into wills, following the proper process of being witnessed otherwise they don’t count. This note has no legal meaning and all you are going to do is damage relationships with your sister by what sounds like, imposing your own opinion of what you think your mum wanted.

Fere · 22/02/2022 13:11

In all honesty and no disrespect to your mother she had means to do it. She didn't do it.
A note left like that means nothing but a mere token of her guilt of not dealing with the situation. And putting thst burden on you? An asy way out for her. A burden for you.
Just move on.
Therapy may be good.
Love is too short to dwell over past.

Karatema · 22/02/2022 13:08

A friend of mine was in your situation. Sister had been given thousands of pounds and DM had been offered equivalent but he hadn't taken. He was told the will would reflect the difference; it didn't. Nothing my friend provided was acceptable to solicitor and estate divided 50/50 and Sister took all she inherited. They now don't talk.

SartresSoul · 22/02/2022 13:07

I’d mention it to a solicitor first and see what they say, it’s probably not legally binding anyway since it wasn’t in the will.