Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

do I gently challenge?

162 replies

stressedheiress · 22/02/2022 10:45

Obv name changed. My parents have both recently died. In short succession. I'm heartbroken, particularly by the second death, which I think is common.
The wills are standard - to each other, then to children. In the last months months of Mum's life she expressed a lot of concern that she'd given my sister too much already (think millions). To be fair some of this money was offered to me but I am (as my son tells me) stupidly independent and earn a comfortable living. Anyway, I told mum that sister didn't put a gun to her head and it had been her choice. And left it at that. But she picked at the scab - saying she'd had too much, wasn't responsible, and that sister was probably giving a lot of the money to second husband's family and that upset her.
Anyway, we've recently seen the wills and there isn't mention of anything other than 50/50.
BUT. I have found a very clearly written note in her desk saying £x extra must go to the me to equalise the situation.
What do I do? i don't need the extra money. But I am very clear in my mind that Mum's wishes had changed and that it was only her ailing health (not dementia) that prevented a change being made.
Do I show sister this note and tell her what mum was saying?
I don't like confrontation. But I also don't like unfairness! Equally I don't want to break sister's heart any more.
FWIW (and I know there'll be doubters) I would be donating a big chunk of the inheritance since I don't believe money way beyond your needs makes you happier. I'm fortunate - good education, me and DH had good jobs etc (in fact sister used to justify her taking the money on the basis i was 'lucky')
Please advise how to tread through this situation.... It's literally keeping me awake at night

OP posts:
SamphiretheStickerist · 22/02/2022 14:26

As this thread has shown, many are willing to give their opinion on what you shoud do @stressedheiress

All I can reiterate is that you need to give anything you have to the solicitor. The letter, the desire to have IHT on gifts paid by the estate and anything else that comes up. Don't YOU worry about them. Just hand them over to the solicitor and let them inform you and DSis about the legalities.

It's a bit like safeguarding. You don't make any decisions, you just push any information you have upstairs, to someone who has more training, more knowledge etc.

Anything else is supposition, opinion, just noise.

HazelBite · 22/02/2022 14:26

Please do nothing, I say this as someone who used to work in the Courts and would see what problems this sort of thing would cause.
If you want to maintain a good relatioship with your sister do nothing and leave it all a 50/50 split.

My younger sister and her H treated my DDad very badly and when he was in the Hospice he was asking me and my older sister to arrange a solicitor to come in and change his will as he felt that he didn't want either younger Dsis and her H to benefit from his will.
Nature took over and DDad died before it could be arranged, which as it turned out was fortunate as the pair of them were so obstructive in the admin of the estate and decided that me and other sis as executors had run off with some of the money and tried to take us to court!
30 years on family relations are still strained and I doubt will ever be repaired, wills, families always cause problems and emotions run high.
Op it is only a "note" probably (although I'm no expert) not legally binding. How do you honestly expect your sister to react if she is expecting X from the estate and then it is suggested to her that she "should"(according to her late Mother) recieve X minus Y?

Totalwasteofpaper · 22/02/2022 14:25

A good therapist even 🤦‍♀️

Totalwasteofpaper · 22/02/2022 14:25

[quote stressedheiress]@VanGoghsDog as I explained, Mum died in January, and dad died last week. Funeral next week. He obviously has no view. And besides had advanced dementia[/quote]
This is really fast and I imagine its been very stressful

I'd honestly leave it and use the time, money and energy to find a food therapist to help you with grief counselling and frame your thoughts around your sister Flowers

Associatepeggy · 22/02/2022 14:23

there is inheritance tax due on gifts made to your sister in the last seven years and she wants that paid from the estate, then doesn't that mean those gifts form part of the estate so should be deducted from her half share?

I think (certainly not saying it's a fact) that the tax would be paid room estate and then the remaining split.

that1970shouse · 22/02/2022 14:19

If there is inheritance tax due on gifts made to your sister in the last seven years and she wants that paid from the estate, then doesn't that mean those gifts form part of the estate so should be deducted from her half share?

I don't think the note has any legal standing and therefore to bring it up with your sister will only cause upset and more bad feeling between you. However IANAL and you should definitely get expert legal advice.

stressedheiress · 22/02/2022 14:13

@VanGoghsDog as I explained, Mum died in January, and dad died last week. Funeral next week. He obviously has no view. And besides had advanced dementia

OP posts:
MerylSqueak · 22/02/2022 14:13

With the best will in the world, I don't think a challenge of this sort, especially in such a difficult time for you both, will be gentle.

I have been in a similar position. My father altered his will in my favour when he knew he was dying. He told us all in person together with his reasons, let us have our say, put it all in writing to us and then changed his will as everyone was happy about it. I think that was about the gentlest way of doing it but I don't think you bringing it up now will go down in the same way.

VanGoghsDog · 22/02/2022 14:05

[quote stressedheiress]@Mundra I'm struggling too. And to express genuinely that it's not about the money (I realise that I'm probably eliciting hollow laughs and eye rolls). It's about mum's wishes. For almost the last year of her life she worried that the 50/50 was wrong for all kinds of reasons.
And yes a little bit of me really resents the way sister passes off the early inheritances she's had as her own hard work. It most definitely isn't.
Maybe I should just leave it..[/quote]
You can't change the will, so all you would be doing would be showing your sister that her mother thought poorly of her. And that's unkind.

You say you mother thought this for the last year of her life. What's that, an eightieth? It's not really relevant in the big picture. And as you say, your mum was happy to give the money away at the time.

Also, what was your dad's view in this? I know all assets transferred to mum when he died first, but if it was very close together as you say, did he have any view on the equity split or the earlier gifts?

Personally, I'd leave it as is because legally you have no grounds to change it. You'd be relying on her to "do the right thing" where that "right thing" would actually be very hurtful to her.

I have a not entirely dissimilar issue with my sister and inheritance. I chose the "why upset people?" route.

Friendofdennis · 22/02/2022 14:04

Your mum should have talked to your sister about this and then maybe adjusted her will. Now it will just make your sister feel awful and she will feel judged and less than you in the eyes of you and others and especially her deceased mum.

2reefsin30knots · 22/02/2022 14:04

If you both have children could you suggest putting all of the money in trust for them as your sister has already had a lot of money and you don't want it?

NinjaQueen · 22/02/2022 14:02

I would forget you have seen the note and split the estate 50:50. You are prepared to damage your relationship with your sister to then give it away anyway.

Just seems a little spiteful to me. Like a punishment to your sister.

godmum56 · 22/02/2022 14:02

@OnceuponaRainbow18

Could you photocopy the note and leave it somewhere she may read it but subtly and see if she raises it?
Oh yeah thats really going to help!
godmum56 · 22/02/2022 14:01

@RB68

AN executor should look back over the last 7 years for any monies given or sent to others from the estate. It may be that this would cover those amounts your sister had and these would also be considered part of the estate both for IHT and part of the distribution of monies - time for an independent executor e,g, solicitor rather than family
No they should not.....please don't give wrong advice. The executor must only consider what is in the estate and what the will says must happen.
MajorCarolDanvers · 22/02/2022 13:59

Leave it.

You will break your relationship with your sister if you pursue this.

And I don't think its that likely you would win.

Honeyroar · 22/02/2022 13:55

I’m really sorry about the loss of your parents. You must be reeling.

I also understand why this is important to you, even though you don’t want the money. You think it was important to your mum - one of her last wishes.

But if it had been that important to your mum she could have gone to change her will. Someone would’ve taken her. She didn’t..

You’re having a tough enough time - i wouldn’t go through all the stress and fall outs this is probably going to cause, just to give the money away.

Lubeyboobyalt · 22/02/2022 13:54

I'd just leave it as it is and not mention the note - you're not bothered so no reason to upset sister

Your mum would have got the will properly changed if she was that determined

OnceuponaRainbow18 · 22/02/2022 13:54

Could you photocopy the note and leave it somewhere she may read it but subtly and see if she raises it?

Lemons1571 · 22/02/2022 13:54

Have you worked out how much tax is owed on any significant money gifts your mum made in the last 7 years?

Do you know how much tax is owed on your mums estate (will be calculated as on the day she died minus funeral and other related costs).

The note will have no legal effect and if you challenge your sister it will take years to drag through the courts.

You need good legal and financial advice. I’d also forget the note - the time to change the will shares has passed. It should have been done legally through changing the will when your mother was alive.

Why would you give it all to charity? If you fell on hard times through illness, loss of earnings etc, wouldn’t you regret it? I doubt the charity would give it back to you!

Mistymountain · 22/02/2022 13:52

If I were you I wouldn't mention it. If your mother's wishes had seriously changed she would have changed her will , I think.

Moneyhunter · 22/02/2022 13:52

The note means nothing. Leave it be and accept what’s yours.
You’re mum offered you money and you declined it, that’s not your sisters fault

stressedheiress · 22/02/2022 13:51

One small thing before I really do bow out. Mum was generous to charities in her lifetime, and there are bequests in her Will to various charities. i think most people do this, and she was no different (except perhaps in scale). i would not think her a fool for donating, even at the risk of enriching CEOs. She quite enjoyed the whole process of doing due diligence on the charities in question and checking they were being effective. Many charities employ a lot of good people who do a lot of good work.

OP posts:
Subbaxeo · 22/02/2022 13:49

The love of money really is the root of all evil. If your mother was that concerned, she could have changed her will. If you are all very comfortably off, in the scheme of things, why let this harm your life? You could mention it to your sister but say that legally you understand the position if she chooses to do nothing about it. And the forget it and remember your mum in other ways.

MrsClatterbuck · 22/02/2022 13:49

The maximum amount you can give to your children each year is £3k I believe. If you give more the 7 year rule comes into play. If this money given to your sister is less than 7 years ago then she must pay tax pro rata. Paying less the longer it was paid ago. That is less tax if 6 years ago as opposed to two years ago. You need legal advice. HMRC will be very interested in this I imagine.
Also if your mum wanted to even things up then instead of leaving a note she should have just adjusted her will which would have made it legal and left you out of having to do anything.

MauraDeLaura · 22/02/2022 13:47

I'm sure this has been said but if it's just a note and hasn't been signed by two witnesses, it won't have any legal effect. So you would be relying on your sister's goodwill to give you the money. I would just leave it.