Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

do I gently challenge?

162 replies

stressedheiress · 22/02/2022 10:45

Obv name changed. My parents have both recently died. In short succession. I'm heartbroken, particularly by the second death, which I think is common.
The wills are standard - to each other, then to children. In the last months months of Mum's life she expressed a lot of concern that she'd given my sister too much already (think millions). To be fair some of this money was offered to me but I am (as my son tells me) stupidly independent and earn a comfortable living. Anyway, I told mum that sister didn't put a gun to her head and it had been her choice. And left it at that. But she picked at the scab - saying she'd had too much, wasn't responsible, and that sister was probably giving a lot of the money to second husband's family and that upset her.
Anyway, we've recently seen the wills and there isn't mention of anything other than 50/50.
BUT. I have found a very clearly written note in her desk saying £x extra must go to the me to equalise the situation.
What do I do? i don't need the extra money. But I am very clear in my mind that Mum's wishes had changed and that it was only her ailing health (not dementia) that prevented a change being made.
Do I show sister this note and tell her what mum was saying?
I don't like confrontation. But I also don't like unfairness! Equally I don't want to break sister's heart any more.
FWIW (and I know there'll be doubters) I would be donating a big chunk of the inheritance since I don't believe money way beyond your needs makes you happier. I'm fortunate - good education, me and DH had good jobs etc (in fact sister used to justify her taking the money on the basis i was 'lucky')
Please advise how to tread through this situation.... It's literally keeping me awake at night

OP posts:
stressedheiress · 22/02/2022 15:37

I don't regret it actually. I feel
I've set a better example to
My children by being independent. I do however regret being too gentle and not encouraging mum to change the Will to match her wishes as told to me. That was clearly, in hindsight stupid.

OP posts:
TempName01 · 22/02/2022 15:36

Please don’t show her the note, it will hurt her and question her mother’s feelings towards her which could stay with her for life. You don’t need the money and you have the note which can bring you some comfort that your mum had fairness in mind. You would destroy your relationship with your sister forever. Let your sister enjoy the money and make her own mistakes. You will end up looking selfish and greedy (I know you are not!).

Theluggage15 · 22/02/2022 15:34

Your sister has also lost both parents and is presumably upset and now you want to show her a scribble from your mum which may hurt her feelings and just cause trouble. If your mum had really wanted to do what she said in the note then she should have discussed it fairly with both of you.

You sound as if you regret turning down money in the past but it’s too late now and if you would give it to charity anyway how is that your mum’s wishes?

iwantmyownicecreamvan · 22/02/2022 15:34

Hi OP - I'm sorry about your losses and the kicking you have had from some posters. I do understand your predicament - my parents died a month apart in 2020. Their wills were the same as your parents although the amounts were not as large as it sounds they are in your family's case.

I noticed a lot of payments had gone out in the last 12 months to my sibling - who had been in need of the money, I'm not denying. Then I found out that some of the money had been paid back and the sibling told me that my mother had said I had had similar amounts. I hadn't - at least not recently, but they did help me out 15 years ago when I divorced. They told me at the time that my sibling had had similar. So I didn't really know what to believe - but in the end I had to let it go and I did.

Of course there was no note which does make a difference. I think you have to show the note to your sister at least, even if nothing comes of it. If she says no and dismisses it, then you know where you stand and she realises that you know what sort of person she is.

Things will start to become easier I promise once the first anniversaries of birthdays/Christmas etc are over.

JustHereWithMyPopcorn · 22/02/2022 15:28

Personally, if you don't need the money and intended on giving it away then I would leave it well alone. Families often turn vile where wills are involved and cause permanent damage. I speak from bitter experience from when there wasn't anything contentious in the will at all.

UnderTheSea20k · 22/02/2022 15:26

It would be spiteful and selfish of you to show her this note. Really, what purpose does this have beyond making you feel superior? When people die, it's not normal to take an inventory of the bad things they have said to people and then pass this on.

SpiderinaWingMirror · 22/02/2022 15:26

I had a similar conversation with my elderly mum recently. She is giving money to my dbro. (Not millions).I was very clear with her that unless her will states it (and therefore she changes it) whatever is left will go between the 3 of us. As executor I won't be trying to balance anything after the fact. That's where families fall out. If your mum didn't want to give it to your sister, she shouldn't have .
Maybe she was just warning you because you were going to find out anyway.
Split it evenly and move on

Winter2020 · 22/02/2022 15:22

I have read the whole thread and I do think it's relevant that your parents chose not to change their wills. I know you have said that the last year was awful and ill health would have prevented it, but it sounds like these unequal gifts go back much further than that.

Your mum might have ummed and aahed over it but she did not choose to change her will.

AmaryllisNightAndDay · 22/02/2022 15:21

The note doesn't explain any of the hurtful things mum said. It's a simple statement of facts.

It's a statement of intent not fact, and an intent which your mother did not fulfil and (sadly) is not here any more to confirm or deny. What good will it do for your sister to find out that possibly her mother did not want her to have everything that her father left to her in his will? That will be very hurtful in itself.

CheltenhamLady · 22/02/2022 15:18

As it is your father who has just passed away I am unsure what relevance the note would have.

I think that as a parent I would just want my kids to get on after my death, and showing your sister the note will serve no useful purpose apart from opening up a chasm between you.

I would take the view that your mum did not legally make her wishes known and that it was just a note that is best left in the past.

I would certainly not give any major part of the inheritance to charity though if I had DC. No one knows what is around the next corner.

RachelGreeneGreep · 22/02/2022 15:12

Just want to express my condolences to you, OP. This must be a very difficult time for you Flowers losing both of your parents so close together.

I won't offer any advice except to say it's probably best to leave things as they are. In the long run, it will give you more peace of mind. (I presume any kind of challenge would possibly lead to court proceedings.)

Take care and take time to grieve.

tara66 · 22/02/2022 15:11

Estate will get double tax allowance for both parents = GBP650,000.

stressedheiress · 22/02/2022 14:59

The note doesn't explain any of the hurtful things mum said. It's a simple statement of facts.

@traintraveller I asked for advice. Which I've received from some lovely people. Not a kicking.

OP posts:
AmaryllisNightAndDay · 22/02/2022 14:57

I think I will show sister the note. Won't mention the conversations (that would be hurtful), and see what she says.

Really, don't. The note will also be very hurtful and there will be no going back from it.

Either give the note to the solicitor or destroy it. It's not going to add to anyone's peace of mind.

traintraveller · 22/02/2022 14:55

I agree it appears you are doing this out of spite, you clearly don't like your sister and judge her for not being as good a daughter as you feel you were. If you don't care about your relationship with her show her the note but I'd imagine it will be the end of your relationship.

stressedheiress · 22/02/2022 14:46

@MrKlaw this thought had struck me! But i think I don't have the energy to take that fight on

I think I will show sister the note. Won't mention the conversations (that would be hurtful), and see what she says.

That way responsibility is forced into her.

I just have to be able to accept her decision and view of the note if she dismisses it. Hey, she may not!

OP posts:
MrKlaw · 22/02/2022 14:38

@Associatepeggy

there is inheritance tax due on gifts made to your sister in the last seven years and she wants that paid from the estate, then doesn't that mean those gifts form part of the estate so should be deducted from her half share?

I think (certainly not saying it's a fact) that the tax would be paid room estate and then the remaining split.

if any gentle pushing is to be done, I'd attempt to see if you can get the 50/50 based on current gross estate value, so any additional tax due because of gifts to the sister are effectively paid by the sister's 'half'. Otherwise you would be subsidising her again
PoshPyjamas · 22/02/2022 14:34

It’s coming across as that the sole purpose of this is to try and make your sister feel bad, as some sort of penance for not being as ‘good’ as you.

I don’t doubt that you don’t want the money, but I do doubt your motives.

TheLadyGrayson · 22/02/2022 14:32

If the note was left by your mum alone, but she passed away before your dad, would the will not be carried out according to your dad’s wishes? I think referring to the note will be emotionally challenging for you at an already difficult time, if you don’t need the extra funds I would be tempted to not raise it, just to make your life a bit more peaceful. I’m sorry for your loss Flowers

SamphiretheStickerist · 22/02/2022 14:31

@VanGoghsDog she's also getting some incorrect 'legal' information too. That's beyond the scope of most here.

We all have opinions. But the best advice is to step aside when you don't know what the legal ramifications actually are.

GatoradeMeBitch · 22/02/2022 14:30

I don't think notes are legally enforceable. If a sibling came to me with a note clearly from a parent saying they should inherit more, I would honour that. But clearly your sibling won't.

Try to let it go. Perhaps leave the note in a spot where your sister will see it when she goes through your mother's belongings - bedside table? Maybe her own conscience will prompt her to say something. But at least then she will know, and without you being in the middle of it.

And do consider keeping the money you inherit for yourself. You never know how things can change. You sound like you are almost repelling money like you have some guilt over it or distaste for it. Money is not a bad thing. (If you're determined to donate your inheritance, don't send it to the massive corporate charities because it will just go towards re-paving a CEO's driveway or on champagne for a Christmas party. Look for small local charities.)

SamphiretheStickerist · 22/02/2022 14:29

all your mum's estate went to your dad. Your dad's will is 50/50, so the note has no relevance. Not necessarily, There is a 28 day rule that could possibly come into play.

That and we have no idea what the legal set up between them was.

There can only really be one bit of advice gven --> solicitor.

VanGoghsDog · 22/02/2022 14:28

As this thread has shown, many are willing to give their opinion on what you shoud do

Which she asked for 🤨

Bournetilly · 22/02/2022 14:27

If you don’t need the money and you are going to donate it I would just leave it as a 50/50 split. It sounds like your sister needs the money and I’m sure your mum would rather she be taken care of than donating the money to charity (she could of done this if she wanted).

VanGoghsDog · 22/02/2022 14:26

[quote stressedheiress]@VanGoghsDog as I explained, Mum died in January, and dad died last week. Funeral next week. He obviously has no view. And besides had advanced dementia[/quote]
Sorry, I must have missed it, it felt like your mum was the more recent death.

You have even less to rely on - all your mum's estate went to your dad. Your dad's will is 50/50, so the note has no relevance.

I know you're not trying to rely on the note, I'm just putting the legal facts so you know where you stand.

I knew your father had died but thought any view he might have had when alive, ore dementia, might be worth considering.

Your sister is correct that any gifts within seven years are notionally added back to the estate for IHT purposes (and only for that, not for distribution) and the estate pays the tax, not your sister (unless this means the estate runs out of money).

I see you are going to revert to the solicitor and your sister to act as executors, which probably makes sense.