Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That vulnerable people shouldn’t be advised to have counselling

43 replies

Hollyandlilac · 22/02/2022 10:27

I’m not suggesting people shouldn’t have it if they want it, but AIBU to think that it being presented as something that will help heal or cure you is wrong?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
OlympicProcrastinator · 22/02/2022 13:16

I’m really glad you started this thread. Counselling is always seen as a helpful solution and it’s never acknowledged that for some people it’s not helpful and in some cases can be harmful. It’s often pushed on people to help them find solutions to problems that don’t exist to the person it’s being suggested to, simply because the person suggesting it doesn’t understand the other persons life / behaviour. I’m not sure if I’ve explained that very well. I have lots of personal experience with this.

Echobelly · 22/02/2022 13:00

I'd say YANBU. I've read about research that suggested that in some scenarios, such as a, traumatic event, for many people talking to family and friends is enough and counselling could be focusing on it too much and making it harder to move on. So, sure, if people want it, but certainly no one should be told they have to have it and won't be able to cope without it. People are resilient and a lot of the time our own resources are enough. Although I totally believe in therapy etc when appropriate.

Swear · 22/02/2022 12:43

I do think that counsellors can make things worse, not better. Not all counsellors are both ethical and good at what they do.

iklboo · 22/02/2022 12:36

@DysmalRadius - I agree. Mine spent more time talking about herself & her own problems than focussing on me. Because I was 'easy to talk to'. Hmm

Hollyandlilac · 22/02/2022 12:33

I’d be very suspicious of a cure for cancer that

had to be self funded
where the patient is told that if the treatment didn’t work, they are doing it wrong
or maybe if someone else did the treatment it might work

Very suspicious of that indeed.

OP posts:
AffIt · 22/02/2022 12:26

@rainbowmash

I work for an organisation that provides counseling for vulnerable people, but I think I can see what you mean, OP.

Too often people with little knowledge of mental health treatment talk about "counseling" as if it's the only, and best, treat-all for anything from bereavement to psychosis. And often they think it's the same thing as psychotherapy, which it isn't.

It's often dished out to patients who won't benefit from it, because GPs can't access better options. As a result, people who need more intensive care are rerouted to unsuitable lightweight talking therapies and CBT, which works to prevent them from seeking the psychotherapy and medication that would actually help.

Yes, you've explained this in a better way than I did in my post above.
AffIt · 22/02/2022 12:25

I'm not entirely sure what you mean by 'vulnerable people', but there are some 'fixes' that are repeatedly pushed on Mumsnet, in particular, that are not suitable for all.

Client-centred counselling doesn't work for many neurodivergent people, for example. CBT isn't particularly helpful for complex trauma (and can exacerbate it, in some instances). Mindfulness is not recommended for people with a history of psychotic episodes.

So, yes, I kind of agree, in the sense that 'just get counselling' isn't particularly helpful.

Whatdramain2022 · 22/02/2022 12:18

My GP always insists I have counselling for my anxiety and depression.

Firstly I know all the local counsellors because they used to use my workplace and I wouldn't want to talk about personal problems with any of them.

Secondly I know exactly why I have the problems I have. I can analyse exactly why I'm insecure etc.

I hate counselling being pushed as a solution. My DSis had years of it and it caused a complete breakdown of her relationship with our DM, which was very sad. Maybe it helps some people, but I see it as extremely unhealthy and unhelpful.

Whatwouldscullydo · 22/02/2022 12:13

I think it depends doesn't it.

I mean I don't agree with pathologising what should be considered normal rational feelings in order to make life easier fir everyone else around them.

I dont agree with counselling as a way to erode someone's personal boundaries like their feelings are a problem when in fact they are perfectly normal understandable and rational..

But a safe space to talk and learn the tools to deal with problems is a good thing surely?

Although I think its imperative that the ficus remains on the person and their are actual.problems to he dealt with. Being difficult or inconvenient or a source if shame for others should not necessarily be the reasoning.

EmmaH2022 · 22/02/2022 12:13

I know what you mean OP

Both mum and I have regular check ups for physical health things. When my dad died, we both felt they pushed counselling and I even got a follow up call! We don't have the same GP.

I wondered if the NHS have a target now.

FridayiminlovewithRobertSmith · 22/02/2022 12:13

It does do all 3 of the things you suggest, although it’s not a panacea and it’s not the primary intervention in crisis as others have said. You may not get the right counsellor immediately and it can be that you require support for years but I don’t believe it’s harmful or wrong to suggest.

Sparklesocks · 22/02/2022 12:10

Counselling/therapy does help a lot of people after a bereavement or going through a difficult time though. Having a safe space to vent openly with someone impartial can help release and ease a lot of the pain and hurt they’re carrying.

That said, it’s not for everyone and not a fix all for every problem. It sounds like maybe you have an issue with the semantics of saying someone ‘needs’ counselling rather than the treatment itself. But I don’t think most people mean it to be offensive or upset anyone, they’re just trying to offer a solution, maybe a bit clumsily.

rainbowmash · 22/02/2022 12:10

I work for an organisation that provides counseling for vulnerable people, but I think I can see what you mean, OP.

Too often people with little knowledge of mental health treatment talk about "counseling" as if it's the only, and best, treat-all for anything from bereavement to psychosis. And often they think it's the same thing as psychotherapy, which it isn't.

It's often dished out to patients who won't benefit from it, because GPs can't access better options. As a result, people who need more intensive care are rerouted to unsuitable lightweight talking therapies and CBT, which works to prevent them from seeking the psychotherapy and medication that would actually help.

incognitoforthisone · 22/02/2022 12:09

If someone is struggling with something mentally that they can't work through on their own or with friends/family, and is asking for help, then counselling or therapy is a perfectly valid suggestion. Family and friends can't always provide that support, and neither can a GP. People usually only suggest counselling if it's blindingly obvious that the person needs help that can't be provided through other routes.

I have a family member who regularly struggles with mental health issues and needs a lot of emotional support from me. Their GP has suggested medication, which they didn't feel was right for them so they stopped taking it. When I suggested counselling or therapy, they told me they didn't want to do that - but in effect, they are basically using me as their counsellor or therapist, wanting to talk through their issues in detail and asking me to analyse their reactions all the time. I'm not qualified to do that, and it's a massive emotional strain on me. So yes, I do think people in some situations absolutely should be pushed towards counselling. The alternative is either that they go on being miserable and/or that their personal relationships crumble because they're leaning so heavily on the people around them for a very draining form of support.

Poppitt58 · 22/02/2022 12:08

It would be very unusual for counselling to be delivered by a psychologist

I imagine they mean psychotherapist. It’s an easy mistake to make.

Poppitt58 · 22/02/2022 12:05

How do you feel when someone with cancer needs surgery or chemo or radiation therapy?

Part of the issue with MH support is the availability and the fact it’s massively underfunded.

I know health care is struggling at all levels, however cancer treatment doesn’t get abandoned when it turns out the illness is bigger than they first thought. You also tend to get treated for as long as you need, rather than being told you can have 6 sessions because that’s all the funding will allow.

I’d recommend the long term, specialist talking therapy I had, to anyone with my experience, but in the U.K. right now it’s not straight forward to secure that level of help. If I’d been abandoned after a specific number of sessions, I’d have been more ill than I was at the beginning, but with the help removed. Unpacking trauma is hard and it can make you feel worse before it helps you to feel better.

CorrBlimeyGG · 22/02/2022 12:05

Having sessions with a psychologist regardless of the type of therapy can be extremely hard work, upsetting, and emotionally draining

It would be very unusual for counselling to be delivered by a psychologist.

formalineadeline · 22/02/2022 12:02

I’m not sure what the stats are regarding it helping people

Right. Don't you think maybe that's something you should check before you declare it doesn't help anyone and shouldn't be suggested?

Because frankly you're talking uninformed nonsense.

WeaverofWords · 22/02/2022 12:00

Another point is that people get CBT and counselling mixed up. They are radically different.

HousePlantNeglect · 22/02/2022 11:59

I think possibly people who say ‘try counselling’ don’t really know what they are talking about (unless it’s a healthcare professional referring you).

Having sessions with a psychologist regardless of the type of therapy can be extremely hard work, upsetting, and emotionally draining. So you have to be ready for it and have your expectations appropriately set. You can’t go for 6 sessions of CBT and hope to feel better if you have complex problems (speaking from bitter experience-I felt about 1000 times worse as I thought ‘fuck even therapy can’t help me’ but it was the wrong therapy and far too short term’).

I think people trying to be helpful suggest it. I also think GPs with no other options offer what is available abs hope for the best.

WeaverofWords · 22/02/2022 11:58

I disagree. A good counsellor will be supportive, help hold and solve problems, feed them back in small and manageable chunks. It can be a valuable and incredibly strengthening process.

YellowMonday · 22/02/2022 11:57

How do you feel when someone with cancer needs surgery or chemo or radiation therapy? Do you feel the same level of discomfort?

I really dislike this attitude towards mental health. Therapy doesn't cure you or solve your problem. Instead it offers a safe environment to explore your feelings/thoughts and learn tools to help you thrive.

I've undergone therapy for high functioning anxiety and grief counselling.

For high functionality anxiety I learnt about how it impacts my life, and we discovered together my triggers and successful tools to manage it.

For grief counselling, follow my mum's death my dad fell into a deep depression at the point of being suicidal. I was in my mid twenties and an only child, without having a safe independent space to express my feelings I would not have coped.

x2boys · 22/02/2022 11:49

It can help along with other forms of therapy,it's not the be all and end all but I for one have had two lots of counseling for different reasons and found it helpful
As for it being expensive the first time I was referred via work based occupational health so didn't pay and the second time I self referred through a charity and just paid a donation .

Poppitt58 · 22/02/2022 11:49

It saved my life and allowed me to start living after awful abuse. I managed to get it free and long term through a specific charity.

I kind of agree in some ways though. Some people say you need counselling with no consideration for;

  • it can be expensive
  • free sessions often have long waiting lists
  • some abuse needs specialist services that can have even longer lists
  • CBT is common on the NHS and isn’t right for everyone
  • Some people start therapy, unload their crap and get told they’re too complex, then they’re abandoned waiting on a complex list and have a pile of drugs chucked at them
  • many free services only give 6-12 sessions - no where near enough for complex issues
  • counsellors need to be matched well to clients - when you only get 6 sessions this can be tricky to organise
  • if you’re unpacking trauma you need a good support network outside of the sessions (in my experience)
Sirzy · 22/02/2022 11:48

Of course talking therapies can be helpful to people in difficult situations. Giving people the tools to understand things more can help them to deal with the situation.

It’s not a fix all solution but there isn’t a fix all solution a lot of the time.

Swipe left for the next trending thread