Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are we crazy - WWYD?

308 replies

Corneliafunk · 22/02/2022 08:00

DH and I have won a trip away for 3 nights towards the end of next month!! We have to decide soon what we will do, but taking the kids with us is not an option. We are thinking of leaving them at home alone. They are 13 and 15 years. I have confidence/trust that they will keep to the usual routine during this time and get themselves off to school on the bus etc. The eldest one does most of the cooking anyway, so can do dinners ok although we would keep everything simple while we were away. They do argue but say they will spend most of the time separately in their rooms. Their grandmother lives nearby and can keep an eye on them. Alternatively, she could come to stay but doesn't keep great health so we can't really rely on this. She is also v worried about Covid..
And Covid is in some of the local schools. We have been told to prepare them for remote learning if there aren't enough teachers available on-site (which we have done).

We have friends who could each take one, but the kids don't want to do this and it would mean mattresses on the floor and disruption for our friends, altho they wouldn't mind for the short time. The prize means the distance we will be away is a couple of hours by car, but then a short boat ride to an island in a lake which sounds very cool! Not sure about cell coverage, but suspect not.
Would you think the kids are old enough and just do it and leave them at home alone (which is what we want to do), or should we make some sort of arrangement for them where they are with adults even if it is just in the evenings? Would you think we could leave them even in the knowledge that remote learning could suddenly be required while we are away?

YANBU - leave the kids at home alone
YABU- don't leave the kids home alone

OP posts:
Chewbecca · 22/02/2022 14:04

But to answer the question, I think they could do 1 night alone but 3 is too much for another couple of years.

Chewbecca · 22/02/2022 14:03

Just wanted to say your kids sound awesome OP!

beautifullymad · 22/02/2022 14:01

Not safe. If anything were to happen that would be on the 15 year olds shoulders forever.

Is there anyone who could come later to stay overnight but not need be about during the day?

They need an adult in the house at night really. As a bare minimum.

ThrobbingToothacheOfTheMind · 22/02/2022 13:58

@HollowTalk

It's completely irresponsible. If you ever need to check whether you're being unreasonable, think of it as a Daily Mail headline.

"A couple go off on holiday leaving young teens at home alone"

Can you imagine the comments?

😂 who gives a shit about daily mail readers' opinions? They're spitting with rage over everything anyway.
2Gen · 22/02/2022 13:57

@PurpleNebula84

The children definitely need an adult.

Although the law doesn't specifically state what age a child can be left over night, the general consensus/guidance is not to be left over night under the age of 16.
Copied this from gov.uk:
The National Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Children (NSPCC) says:

children under 12 are rarely mature enough to be left alone for a long period of time
children under 16 should not be left alone overnight
babies, toddlers and very young children should never be left alone

This! Parents have a responsibility to make sure their kids have an adult with them when they go away. A 15 year-old is not an adult, no matter how capable and sensible they are. A 13 year old is definitely still a kid!
Migrainesbythedozen · 22/02/2022 13:56

@BIWI

Just out of interest, which country are you in *@Migrainesbythedozen* if not the UK?
@BIWI Australia.
PferdeMerde · 22/02/2022 13:52

What exactly are SS going to do? Probably sigh and roll their eyes that you wasted their time reporting this.

Partyatnumber10 · 22/02/2022 13:51

[quote Migrainesbythedozen]@Partyatnumber10 Approaching the child and getting details of adults/friends/neighbours then contacting adults/friends the child gave them would have been better than leaping straight to reporting the mother to social services. There were ways without resorting to that, and putting her on record with them, especially when she was ill in hospital and least deserved it or needed it. Support, contact friends or neighbours first. SS very last resort.[/quote]
So I'm only responding to this as you seem a bit upset. I don't really want to derail a thread.
I haven't given anywhere close to the full story of what we did or didn't do here. I only commented on the part where SS felt that a 15 year old taking care of a 10 year old for 7 days was "safe enough" in their eyes. As that was relevant to the thread.
The rest isn't relevant and I can't/won't share details.
Rest assured though that the mum is well, happy and has a good relationship with both school and SS.

unname · 22/02/2022 13:50

I remember being 15. I wouldn't leave me alone for one night, never mind 3.

Teateaandmoretea · 22/02/2022 13:49

Would the risk be less then if the mother was in hospital

Clearly not, but being in hospital is apparently virtuous whereas going on holiday isn't. Why this would make any difference to the kids home alone I have no idea. I'd have thought the worry of mum being in hospital would make it a more risky situation, personally.

BIWI · 22/02/2022 13:47

Just out of interest, which country are you in @Migrainesbythedozen if not the UK?

BobbingWilson · 22/02/2022 13:46

@ancientgran

One of my kids got meningitis at uni, I had to go as it was serious and hospital phoning repeatedly. I had to leave the 15 year old alone for a week, didn't get a chance to discuss it with him, phoned the school to check he had a key. Left him money and phoned that night.

He was fine, as was the sick one. Most nightmare week of my life.

@ancientgran What a nightmare. A relative of mine died of meningitis at the age of 16. Her brother got her to the hospital but it was sadly too late. It took less than 24hrs. Her parents were on holiday abroad, didn’t make it home in time. They were never the same again.
PferdeMerde · 22/02/2022 13:44

They're teenagers, they'll be fine for a few days. MN is weird.

mrsrat · 22/02/2022 13:43

Never in a million years I als think it might be illegal

Ohhelpicantthinkofaname · 22/02/2022 13:42

[quote Migrainesbythedozen]@Partyatnumber10 Approaching the child and getting details of adults/friends/neighbours then contacting adults/friends the child gave them would have been better than leaping straight to reporting the mother to social services. There were ways without resorting to that, and putting her on record with them, especially when she was ill in hospital and least deserved it or needed it. Support, contact friends or neighbours first. SS very last resort.[/quote]
It sounds like the poster who did this did so in a professional capacity. You have a duty of care to those children you work with. If you are concerned you have to escalate it or risk being investigated yourself.

She was just doing her job. Please don’t be so offended by it.

Migrainesbythedozen · 22/02/2022 13:39

@Partyatnumber10 Approaching the child and getting details of adults/friends/neighbours then contacting adults/friends the child gave them would have been better than leaping straight to reporting the mother to social services. There were ways without resorting to that, and putting her on record with them, especially when she was ill in hospital and least deserved it or needed it. Support, contact friends or neighbours first. SS very last resort.

ancientgran · 22/02/2022 13:39

@Lovelteers

'We recently reported a 15 year old left at home for 7 days to care for his 10 year old severely autistic brother whilst mum was in hospital. Social services were completely fine with it and we were treated as if we were being really precious'

There's a big difference between how SS would view the above situation than one in which the parents go off on holiday.

Would the risk be less then if the mother was in hospital. I'd have thought 7 days with a 15 year old caring for a child who was severely autistic would have been more of a worry.
hiredandsqueak · 22/02/2022 13:37

Df did this leaving her two "capable" teens 17 and 15 home alone whilst she and dh went on a long weekend away. PILs were five minutes away. They invited a few friends round for dvd's Word spread, the girls daren't call their grandparents when there were thirty teens turn up, an hour and a half later her neighbours called the police because of the noise and the numbers in the garden. Df got home in the early hours to the house ransacked, carpets ruined sofas with cigarette burns, her bed pissed on, a sink off of the wall etc. The girls didn't know many of them as friends had invited friends who invited more friends. I certainly wouldn't leave them if they arent even sixteen anyway wouldn't school raise concerns.

Migrainesbythedozen · 22/02/2022 13:36

[quote Lovelteers]@Migrainesbythedozen

'17 year olds are moving out of home into flats and dorms at uni. You're saying a 17 year old needs a babysitter?

If your 16 year old can't cook pasta without starting a fire, you've failed as a parent. 13 year olds can cook family meals.'

But mostly they aren't moving out to flats and dorms, mostly they're still under the care of adults in some way or have adult support.
Not that it really matters here as the children are 15 and 13 not 17.
Bit harsh on the 16 year old. Adults start fires accidently, let alone kids.I don't think you've 'failed as a paren't because your kid has a mishap in the kitchen...[/quote]
@Lovelteers That poster indicated her daughter can't cook, and can't cook without setting fire, at the age of 16. That really is not normal. You should be able to boil water at say, 10 or 11 years old without starting a fire.

Teateaandmoretea · 22/02/2022 13:34

@Realis have you read some of the comments from teachers on here and how they would have to report?

What do you think social services can actually do? If they take teens into care they can just walk out and go home again. Teachers report lots of things, it doesn't mean anything will be done about it.

I personally wouldn't do this but the idea that they would be in significant danger is also baffling.

looklikeanelephant · 22/02/2022 13:33

My kids aren't that age so I don't know what I'll do, but I'll say my mum and dad left us to go to lanzarote with my youngest sibling who was 6 when I was 12 and sister was 15 and we were fine.

Partyatnumber10 · 22/02/2022 13:30

@Lovelteers

'We recently reported a 15 year old left at home for 7 days to care for his 10 year old severely autistic brother whilst mum was in hospital. Social services were completely fine with it and we were treated as if we were being really precious'

There's a big difference between how SS would view the above situation than one in which the parents go off on holiday.

In the long term yes, a parent in hospital, support until well again then withdraw, a parent in holiday may warrant further parenting discussions.

In the short term though, the only concern would be how safe they considered the two children.

I only shared this example to illustrate that Social services may be less concerned by this than people think.

Fairytoast · 22/02/2022 13:30

I have a very sensible 16 year old ds and a 13 year old dd. I still wouldn’t leave them alone for 3 days/nights. We haven’t been away on our own for 10+ years, would love to but just need to wait a couple of years.. It must feel wonderful to win a weekend away, sorry it’s crap timing.

Lovelteers · 22/02/2022 13:30

@Migrainesbythedozen

'17 year olds are moving out of home into flats and dorms at uni. You're saying a 17 year old needs a babysitter?

If your 16 year old can't cook pasta without starting a fire, you've failed as a parent. 13 year olds can cook family meals.'

But mostly they aren't moving out to flats and dorms, mostly they're still under the care of adults in some way or have adult support.
Not that it really matters here as the children are 15 and 13 not 17.
Bit harsh on the 16 year old. Adults start fires accidently, let alone kids.I don't think you've 'failed as a paren't because your kid has a mishap in the kitchen...

Bumply · 22/02/2022 13:28

I've left 15 year old home alone for a couple of nights, but we live in flats where he could ask a neighbour for help.

Not sure about leaving 15 year old in charge of younger sibling. Sounds like too much responsibility.

I'd aim for grandmother staying over, with friends as backup if she wasn't well enough at the last minute