Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask my parents about their money?

65 replies

parentsfuture · 22/02/2022 07:06

You often read about the “bank of mum and dad”, but that’s something I’ve never been fortunate to experience. Unlike all of my friends (as far as I am aware), they’ve never been able to financially support me. I’ve had jobs since I was 15, and if I wanted or needed anything I had to pay for it myself as my parents simply couldn’t afford to. I had to pay for my piano lessons myself in the last few years as they struggled. (They did provide food and I didn’t have to pay rent though). I moved out when I turned 19 to go to university. From time to time I’d have to give them money, nothing huge just £5-£20 every now and again, but still a lot for a teenager in school. Absolutely nothing wrong with the above, just giving background.

In my late teens my parents nearly lost our home by defaulting on mortgage payments. My parents worked, but my dad was made redundant and was only able to pick up jobs every now and again. I have two younger siblings who were in school at this time. I’m 30 now, so this was all around the crash in between 07-09. In the end they managed to sell our house and downsize to smaller home in cash over an hour away from where we live.

They do work but on very low incomes - I don’t know if it’s this or just that they just seem to be awful with money management, or both. One of my grandparents regularly gives them money every month - they are a pensioner themselves. And there have been times I’ve had to help them out with money too.

I struggle to understand where the money goes if they don’t have a mortgage or children to look after. It’s definitely not gambling, they don’t drink or smoke. I know they must send money to family abroad from time to time, but I can’t imagine it being such a huge amount that they’d continue to struggle themselves and put my grandparent under pressure with?

I’m worried about their future, their pensions (if they even have any, I imagine it will be state only) and just what their expectations are. They are now 60 so still a few years away from being able to claim their pensions.

My mum mentions how she wants to retire soon but I don’t think there has been any detailed thought process around this. I have my own family to support and look after too, and my siblings also are not great with their money. I am starting to worry theres going to be an expectation of me as the eldest and “naturally responsible” child that I will be something they can continue to fall back on and be there to help them always. Of course if they ever needed real help I would, but I can’t do this always.

AIBU to sit them down and ask them about their finances and what their plans are for the future as a concerned child? I feel awful for my grandparent who only gets a state pension but is giving them a significant amount of this every month as they also worry! Or is it none of my business and should I just leave it until they ask for more money again?

AIBU = none of your business
AINBU = try and have a chat if concerned

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
loantopil · 22/02/2022 13:39

I would definitely raise it. We are now having to cover PIL to some degree and I am frustrated that DH and siblings didn't address it with them sooner. My DParents are the opposite and consciously make decisions to ensure they are comfortable in retirement and it infuriates me that my PIL consider them 'lucky' whilst I work full time to pay for PIL to have a standard of living they can't afford alone

Chocomelon · 22/02/2022 13:16

I think you should ask them if they may have expectations of you.

parentsfuture · 22/02/2022 13:11

@THisbackwithavengeance

As soon as you said they were sending money abroad, I thought: that's the problem.

Having been married to a man who originated from a poorer country, i know the pressure they must be under to send money to people who very often don't work themselves but think money grows on trees in the UK. You are expected to send money without question and without gratitude because you are deemed to be loaded merely by the action of living in the UK. If you refuse or complain, then you are mean, spiteful and tight.

Requests are constantly sent for money and for gifts like the latest iphone for cousin Johnny and branded trainers.

It's shit.

Oh I’m sorry to hear this. I can appreciate how this can easily happen and the perspective on living in the U.K. too. It fortunately has never been the case with our family as they have usually been ok - it’s only been the odd time in true emergencies. For example, my cousin who is autistic and an only child lost both his parents, so my other aunt had to give up working to care for him (no social support systems for SEN). After this she was struggling with different health issues, so that’s when we were able to help her get the medical treatments she needed etc. It’s never been the case for luxuries or even just day to day things. They are all getting older there too without partners or families of their own to help them, though they all live together or just beside each other which does help. It’s times like these I feel fortunate to be able to help them as I can afford to - but I really do need to find out what my parents role is in this if any it seems as they cannot afford to.
OP posts:
zxcvzxcvz · 22/02/2022 11:13

Same childhood. DM.is 80 and only has state pension. Mortgage paid, not smoker, drinker or driver. She says shes never been so well off and actually has savings now.

TillyTopper · 22/02/2022 10:57

I wouldn't specifically open up the subject - but the very next time they mention retiring I would. I think you need to make clear that you can't continue to help them (as otherwise they'll continue to give/send money abroad and you'll suffer for it). They need to understand that if they give money away it won't come from anywhere else. It's definitely a conversation you need to have but you need to be firm about not providing for them - it's also pretty shocking they are taking money from a pensioner unless they have ample funds.

THisbackwithavengeance · 22/02/2022 10:42

As soon as you said they were sending money abroad, I thought: that's the problem.

Having been married to a man who originated from a poorer country, i know the pressure they must be under to send money to people who very often don't work themselves but think money grows on trees in the UK. You are expected to send money without question and without gratitude because you are deemed to be loaded merely by the action of living in the UK. If you refuse or complain, then you are mean, spiteful and tight.

Requests are constantly sent for money and for gifts like the latest iphone for cousin Johnny and branded trainers.

It's shit.

caringcarer · 22/02/2022 10:35

Sounds like when they are 67 and get their state pension they will also be eligible for Pension Credit. Read up on it and tell them about it. If they get it they also get free TV licence and help with paying council tax.

OnTheBoardwalk · 22/02/2022 10:29

I originally voted YANBU but after reading the comments on here I’m going to change my vote.

You getting involved in the conversations will make you part of the problem/solution

As other posters have said advise them to get pension forecasts etc then for them see a financial advisor. Let the FA have the conversation with them about their income

DaphneduM · 22/02/2022 09:46

That sounds a good plan. You can then maybe suggest that they both get state pension forecasts to ensure that they're both on track for full pensions.

I think if you only have the basic state pensions, then other benefits are available to help with things like council tax and dental treatment. The CAB will be able to advise them on that. You could also suggest that they do a monthly budget of their fixed outgoings and anticipated costs of food, etc. to see how things stack up.

You're absolutely right to be concerned though. We're pensioners on a fixed income but do have various buffers in place and we're getting concerned about the cost of living increases coming down the line. Anything you can to to prepare them for the realities of life on a fixed income would be very helpful. They're very lucky to have such a caring child - I hope your chat with them goes well.

parentsfuture · 22/02/2022 09:19

@ThreeLocusts

Hi OP, it seems to me to depend very much on the character of your relationship with your parents. If you're close enough, I'd definitely sit them down and make a complete list of outgoings and income, in the name of establishing what is possible in terms of early retirement. But only if your relationship allows for it.

It's interesting how diverse responses on this thread are. A reminder that it's not just about cultural differences at the country level, but also about class and family cultures. So it's really your call.

Thank you - yes its definitely interesting to see the different approaches and as you say, dependent on their character. It has definitely been useful though to gather thoughts and opinions form others.

I think I’ll have an informal and uncomfortable chat with them - even just on behalf of my grandparent as I don’t think they’d want to say anything about their concern but at least I can express that for them.

OP posts:
parentsfuture · 22/02/2022 09:16

@billy1966

OP,

You sound lovely.

However lovely you think your parents are they are stressing out and leaning on a pensioner for money.

THAT is neither good nor kind.

It is very wrong.

Is the pensioner going without to give your parents money?

Who does that.

I think the pensioner needs protecting from them.

I think you need to look after your children better than you were looked after.

Put your own children first.

I would be very unhappy to see my grandparents exploited like this.

They are being taken advantage of.
I would be speaking to them on that basis.
Flowers

My grandparent isn’t going without - they don’t need much but they are very well taken care of by kids and grandchildren. My parents would take them out and about and help them practically going to the shops or on day trips. I wouldn’t class them as a vulnerable pensioner - very much present and capable, but just concerned for my parents. I have told them to stop giving them money - or at least asking them what it’s for.
OP posts:
ThreeLocusts · 22/02/2022 09:14

Hi OP, it seems to me to depend very much on the character of your relationship with your parents. If you're close enough, I'd definitely sit them down and make a complete list of outgoings and income, in the name of establishing what is possible in terms of early retirement. But only if your relationship allows for it.

It's interesting how diverse responses on this thread are. A reminder that it's not just about cultural differences at the country level, but also about class and family cultures. So it's really your call.

parentsfuture · 22/02/2022 09:13

@Calmamongthechaos

I have a similar worry with my parents although their financial circumstances are different, middle incomes so never in poverty and not quite retired yet. They also suffered during the crash and almost lost the family home. I recall having to lend money due to cash flow issues although it was always paid back promptly. The money was never for necessities however it was always for the luxuries, wine etc. At the start of the pandemic there was a concern over my fathers job and the prospect that he might not be paid for months. My mother at that point was acting like they were a bit screwed and said they would just put things on a credit card, no thought to actually seeking to curtail their massive outgoings. My brother and I had much discussion at the time and we agreed no hand outs until they could show that they had drastically taken steps to help themselves. I couldn’t justify giving them money when they had two cars, expensive food shopping, the most up to date house gadgets and all the various subscriptions, big 5 bed house heated to the max all day.

So my advice is not to intervene unless they truly are doing all they can to help themselves.

Thank you for sharing. Did you find they took action themselves in the end?

I must admit my parents barely shop for clothes for themselves - if they do it’s through charity shops or sales. Or if it’s shoes etc it’s good quality so they last. They aren’t even shopping or living luxuriously at all!

OP posts:
billy1966 · 22/02/2022 09:11

OP,

You sound lovely.

However lovely you think your parents are they are stressing out and leaning on a pensioner for money.

THAT is neither good nor kind.

It is very wrong.

Is the pensioner going without to give your parents money?

Who does that.

I think the pensioner needs protecting from them.

I think you need to look after your children better than you were looked after.

Put your own children first.

I would be very unhappy to see my grandparents exploited like this.

They are being taken advantage of.
I would be speaking to them on that basis.
Flowers

Calmamongthechaos · 22/02/2022 09:10

I have a similar worry with my parents although their financial circumstances are different, middle incomes so never in poverty and not quite retired yet. They also suffered during the crash and almost lost the family home. I recall having to lend money due to cash flow issues although it was always paid back promptly. The money was never for necessities however it was always for the luxuries, wine etc. At the start of the pandemic there was a concern over my fathers job and the prospect that he might not be paid for months. My mother at that point was acting like they were a bit screwed and said they would just put things on a credit card, no thought to actually seeking to curtail their massive outgoings. My brother and I had much discussion at the time and we agreed no hand outs until they could show that they had drastically taken steps to help themselves. I couldn’t justify giving them money when they had two cars, expensive food shopping, the most up to date house gadgets and all the various subscriptions, big 5 bed house heated to the max all day.

So my advice is not to intervene unless they truly are doing all they can to help themselves.

Keepyourheadscrewedon · 22/02/2022 09:05

Stay out of it.

Let them know you won't be able to help at any point in the future.
Then it is their choice, and they live with the consequences if they choose to stop working. They are not going to starve, so just stop getting involved. By getting involved you start to become part of the decision making and by default the solution.

' I am sure you know what you are doing. I won't be able to help financially now or in the future. Please factor that into your decisions for the future' End of.

The fact you are even thinking they will ask/expect you to step up shows a very disordered family dynamic. They should be looking out and caring for you op! Not the other way around.

parentsfuture · 22/02/2022 09:03

@Keepyourheadscrewedon

just fear in the back of their minds they’ll know I’ll be there to help if that makes sense?

Well then be very clear you can't and won't be a financial backstop. It is beyond me why any parent would expect that from their child, life is hard enough without the added strain of supporting two extra people.

You seem to doubt your own ability to 'not help' op. It is not ingrained in me that I have to help my family financially, not at all, I expect them to be responsible adults and take care of themselves which is probably why it would never happen, they make good decisions for themselves as independent adults.

You have to be crystal clear, if you retire and run into money problems I will not be able to help. As clear as day. And stick to it.

I did say they have never expressed an expectation that we look after them financially in old age. I wouldn’t expect that of my children either.

But you’re right in that it’s probably more “me” than them, and part of my cultural upbringing to help others is factoring into that, especially because as you say “life is hard”.

OP posts:
Thisisyourvaginatalking · 22/02/2022 09:02

Keep out of it and don't give them anything. They've had years to sort their affairs. If they're giving money away to someone else then more fool them.

parentsfuture · 22/02/2022 09:00

I maybe need to chat with them to see if they have been supporting my siblings (I have 2) the last couple of years. They are both studying but also working and nearly full time hours to support themselves, but they could be struggling too and parents trying to help. Though one of them isn’t great with money management either. Messy!

OP posts:
Keepyourheadscrewedon · 22/02/2022 08:59

just fear in the back of their minds they’ll know I’ll be there to help if that makes sense?

Well then be very clear you can't and won't be a financial backstop. It is beyond me why any parent would expect that from their child, life is hard enough without the added strain of supporting two extra people.

You seem to doubt your own ability to 'not help' op. It is not ingrained in me that I have to help my family financially, not at all, I expect them to be responsible adults and take care of themselves which is probably why it would never happen, they make good decisions for themselves as independent adults.

You have to be crystal clear, if you retire and run into money problems I will not be able to help. As clear as day. And stick to it.

saleorbouy · 22/02/2022 08:58

YANBU. Pensions and retirement are important and if they are struggling on their current income then it's unlikely their pension income is going to be that high.
If you are going to be the one who has to take responsibility for them then you should know their situation so that you can make plans for them and yourself. If they currently rely on an elderly relatives pension contribution to keep afloat then this income stream is not going to last forever.
It would be good if they opened up their finances up to you so you could help them budget, perhaps cut costs by changing suppliers etc.
I they expect your support then they should be open and honest with you to start off with.

parentsfuture · 22/02/2022 08:53

@Keepyourheadscrewedon

I believe you feel burdened by maybe a cultural expectation to look after the elders into old age? Is there an expectation of this? Because this will need addressing op, if you have other priorities and commitments.

Are they letting you know now is the time they expect you to start stepping up and looking after them?

They have never once mentioned us looking after them financially in old age in all fairness. My concern is more that they just haven’t thought it through so then I’ll end up having to! I’ll need to just bring it up casually the next time it comes up in conversation - though I know they’ll confirm that they don’t expect it, just fear in the back of their minds they’ll know I’ll be there to help if that makes sense?

My dad is from the U.K. and we very much grew up with a U.K. culture, but I guess there’s part of that ingrained in most people that you always want to make sure your family are ok.

OP posts:
parentsfuture · 22/02/2022 08:50

@ThinWomansBrain

wow - sounds weird reading about something as if ancient history, then realising 2008 crash - that's just me being old.

House large enough to sell and downsize mortgage free when if you were a mid-teenager the mortgage was probably only 15 years in, several children and private music lessons? Sounds like they've either always lived beyond their means, or not really adjusted to low income and periods of unemployment.
If your uncertain about what money is going on now, could they have remortgaged at some point? If that's the case, with poor mortgage history behind them they may not have got a great rate.

Yes I think there’s definitelt been an element of living beyond their means growing up when wanting to give us music lessons etc at the time it could be afforded but then after the crash, not so much but I paid myself as I wanted to finish them.

The house wasnt large - typical semi and we are in one of the cheapest parts of the U.K. to live. They sold the house and when I say bought another house in cash, they bought a small place in the countryside in the middle of nowhere over an hour away from family, and paid probably a significant amount less than what some peoples salary would be even for a year - they did this as they knew they would not be given a mortgage based on the history.

OP posts:
Keepyourheadscrewedon · 22/02/2022 08:48

I believe you feel burdened by maybe a cultural expectation to look after the elders into old age? Is there an expectation of this? Because this will need addressing op, if you have other priorities and commitments.

Are they letting you know now is the time they expect you to start stepping up and looking after them?

Octomore · 22/02/2022 08:48

House large enough to sell and downsize mortgage free when if you were a mid-teenager the mortgage was probably only 15 years in, several children and private music lessons? Sounds like they've either always lived beyond their means, or not really adjusted to low income and periods of unemployment.

Exactly.

My parents have always been low income, and did not have these things. Poor people generally can't realise much/any capital by downsizing because either they rent or, if they own, the house is a very small one already.

Swipe left for the next trending thread