Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU with my 13 year old daughter?

384 replies

GeekyGirl42 · 22/02/2022 01:56

Had to work late one evening this week and daughter said she wanted this evening. So I worked whilst she got on with her evening (I WFH). She had a shower, and came to say goodnight.

I finised work around midnight; when that happens I like to unwind in the shower... Except this evening after 30s it went freezing cold. I squealed. My daughter came out of her room and shouted at me for waking her up.

I told her (this is not the first time by any means that this has happened) that she must remember to think about whether she's used the hot water up, because I don't mind as long as I know to put it on again. It is ridiculous that this would be necessary, as is just the two of us and the tank is massive.

She went bonkers.... Threw stuff around the room and shouted at me. I told her that if she was going to keep arguing with me about whether she should have been more mindful about the hot water, then she can choose between taking another shower now or loosing her phone for a day.

She went to take another shower and when she realised how cold it was she said she couldn't do it. So I told her to be more thoughtful next time, and that tomorrow she will have to have her shower at the gym after her tennis lesson.

She went nuts. She hates me and wants to live with her Dad. I've sent her a text saying that I am hurt by her unkind words and that there are consequences for saying things like that to people... In this instance, she'll find that I've taken back half of this week's allowance.

AIBU? I am so sick of the shower being cold. And she's been really horrid the last few days... I feel like she's walking all over me

OP posts:
LuckySantangelo35 · 22/02/2022 08:54

@Bouledeneige

Put the hot water in before your shower. Try not to wake up a teenage at midnight on a school night. And don't have a shouty roe afterwards. And don't impose sanctions for such minor issues. Pick your battles.
@Bouledeneige You don’t think that throwing a massive tantrum and throwing things around possibly breaking them in the process is behaviour worthy of sanction? Wow
SleepingStandingUp · 22/02/2022 08:51

She did the typical teenage "I want to live with the other parent" so you took her pocket money away? So she can only have it if she says she loves you the mostest? It's literally like you're paying her to pick you.

The cold shower, screaming etc isn't great, you were both tired and over reacted. You apologise, you show her how to apologise and you move on.

But the taking your money because you were mean to me was a calm and rational decision and u think its actually much worse

DrSbaitso · 22/02/2022 08:50

AlexaShutUp is completely right. Harsh punishments are used for one purpose only: to force compliance. You may, perhaps, get obedience on the occasion out of term, but there's a good chance you won't. And if you do, it'll be reluctant and angry and you've just set yourself up for more trouble later because you've effectively made the child hate you.

I know none of us are perfect, but the best thing we can do is model the behaviour we want (including apologising and trying to make good when we fuck up, as humans inevitably will). Then it becomes a team effort about learning to live together and respect each other and check ourselves, not Parent Enforcing Rules Upon Teen With Absolute Authority And Last Word. That's combative and adversarial; everything you're supposed to be trying to avoid.

The argument is rarely about what the argument is about. They don't exist in vacuums.

Dryshampoofordays · 22/02/2022 08:48

“How dare you wake me up?” Sounds similar to “how dare you use all the hot water and not tell me?” Model the behaviour you want your daughter to use. If you want her to grow up to be be kind and considerate, be that. Check the hot water yourself an hour before you need it. Be quiet in the evening. Stop punishing her (it won’t help change your daughter’s behaviour, it will just make her resent you and make everyone’s life harder). If you want her to grow up to be argumentative and punitive then keep modelling that.

TheOccupier · 22/02/2022 08:46

I feel your pain but most teens are selfish and thoughtless at least some of the time. Something to do with their brains. Natural consequences work best - waking her with a shriek when the cold water hit you kind of counts but more effective would have been to quietly have a bath with water from the kettle and let her be the one to discover the shower was cold when she got in it the next morning. I think docking her allowance is a step too far - it's not an appropriate punishment for losing her temper and saying hurtful things in the heat of the moment - but you could work out the cost of heating 1 tank of water and tell her you'll dock it by that much every time she does this and you have to heat a second tank of water in one day.

Bootothegoose · 22/02/2022 08:46

My granddad used to say any arguing past ten o’clock can always wait until the morning.

I think you both reacted in the heat of the moment.

You were pissed off (rightly so) and offered a potential punishment to be take a cold shower - never ok.

She was pissed off, frustrated and overly tired over her friends and lost it when she was called out about the shower and (wrongly) reacted by throwing shower bottles.

You should have sent her back to bed and dealt with it in the morning. However, hindsight is a wonderful thing. Today is a new day.

Reiterate about the hot water and simply say next time it happens the next day you’ll take her phone. She can stick up a note in the bathroom or her bedroom, you can remind her etc. Or every time she showers, just stick the hot water on for ten minutes. Would showering before her be an option?

I don’t think showering is the issue, you’re frustrated you’re the only one in the trenches and it’s thankless and she’s frustrated her dad is nowhere to be seen and it’s impacting her social life when she does get to see him.

You’re doing the best you can, teenage years are turbulent enough without screaming matches over water. Put it on yourself or stop with reactionary punishments.

You’ll take her phone three times and suddenly she’ll remember. She was instantly defensive because she knew she was in trouble. I would be more pissed off with the shower gel throwing but again - it can wait until morning when everyone has calmed down.

I think the posters saying you’re abusive are ridiculous. You’re not abusive, you’re a tired and frustrated mum at the end of your tether who reacted defensively of ‘you try it!’

User0610134049 · 22/02/2022 08:44

I can see why you lost it
And my 13yo Dd can be challenging too and rude.
But I don’t think it’s a good idea to get into an confrontation at midnight. Better to talk about it the next morning and impose consequences then if you think that’s reasonable.

I also was shocked that you forced her to choose between losing her phone for a day (presumably end of the world for a 13yo already missing her friends) and attempting to take a cold shower at midnight. She was backed into a corner.

She also shouldn’t have thrown stuff around and been rude to you. But it’s not the time of night for those arguments.

JamSandwich89 · 22/02/2022 08:43

YABU

It sounds like the argument wasn't really to do with the shower but more that that's the thing that tipped you both you're both stressed.

When I was a teenager it was just my Mum and I living together too. Any punishments like 'Do X or you don't get your phone' neeeever worked. All they did was make me more stressed and more frustrated with her. And did you say somewhere it was a 30 minutes shower? That sounds like a normal washing hair shower to me.

As PPs have said, I think you should have taken control of the situation and said late at night wasn't the time to talk about it, and you should both go to sleep and talk about it again in the morning, or later the next day when you'd both had time to calm down. She's only 13, not 18. I think you should be the adult in the situation.

Regularsizedrudy · 22/02/2022 08:42

Her behaviour was bad but you also acted like a teenager. This should have all been dealt with in the morning also this:
“I flipped and told her to take a shower in it or loose phone for 24 hours.”
Is really bad

Ramalamadingdongs · 22/02/2022 08:41

So you woke your 13 year old daughter up at midnight on a school night, and then made her get in a cold shower as punishment when she didn't need a shower

The ops posts are highlighted. Maybe go back and have a go at reading them again.

AlexaShutUp · 22/02/2022 08:39

@mudgetastic

If you sailed through the teenage years with no punishment you either have a particularly compliant child or you have raised a selfish nightmare

Not all children are the same

No, not so children are the same, but I have worked extensively with teenagers, including some very challenging, troubled ones. In my experience, harsh punishments never really work. No teenager responds well to an adult trying to assert their power in order to impose their will. They will generally push back against this, and you will just become the bad guy who is making their life harder for no good reason. They will absolutely lose the ability to engage with what you're trying to make them understand.

I have always found that you get much better responses from them when you adopt a calm, reasonable, respectful approach that focuses on communication not sanctions.

Progress2019 · 22/02/2022 08:38

I haven’t read he whole thing, but if I were you, I’d have a break at around 6pm, and have my shower, then whatever happens with the hot water won’t affect you.

Onlyhuman123 · 22/02/2022 08:37

she wasn't 'forced to stand under an icy shower'....read the OP updates...

DrSbaitso · 22/02/2022 08:37

@ChiselandBits

From what I've read, YANBU op. I think if you'd phrased it slightly differently you'd be getting different answers. 'asked dd if sec wanted to have family time today or tomorrow. She chose tomorrow so I was working til midnight, a 16 hr shift. She had a long shower that she's been asked repeatedly not to do without telling me so I can boost the tank. I'm a single parent, old house, money is tight so need to be careful. End if shift I was startled by freezing water and squealed. She came running in yelling at me that it wasn't cold and throwing things. I asked her to test the water by sticking her hand in it or go a day without her phone. She did and agreed it was freezing but didn't apologise. None of that is different to what happened and I bet you'd had more YANBUs. Rude, entitled teen with zero appreciation for anyone else. I teach hundreds of teenagers. Not all of them are arseholes by any means.. Most are really quite nice. There's no imperative that they must be awful and there can be consequences if they are.
"If you'd phrased it slightly differently", meaning: "If you'd told it in a completely dishonest way that lies both explicitly and by omission."
cooldarkroom · 22/02/2022 08:36

OP, I feel for you, Both my Dc did this frequently. My water heats at cheap rate in the night.
I had to put on the hot water tank again in the early evening to ensure that I, as the last one in, didn't have a cold shower. This doubled the elec bill. I cannot afford this
DD would open hot water, then go & get her toothbrush & brush her teeth under steaming hot water before even starting to wash.. then there's shaving, & conditioning long hair....
We have 300l tank, which should be fine for 4 showers. (there's even a circulator, that means hot water comes immediately at peak use times to limit waste, & I washed up with cold water for years to allow for all the showers)
I said "I am paying for the electricity, if there is no hot water for me, then there is no hot water for you". & turned the hot water off....
They learnt fast

ENoeuf · 22/02/2022 08:36

‘ What I sowed’

StrictlySinging · 22/02/2022 08:36

Btw sending her for a cold shower in the night is very very unreasonable.

ENoeuf · 22/02/2022 08:36

I wish I had imposed some sanctions and boundaries at this age because I am reaping what is owed with a selfish 19 year old who is entitled and rude and thinks they run the place. Team op. I spent far too much time listening to criticism of me and trying to resolve non issues and demands instead of putting my foot down.

StrictlySinging · 22/02/2022 08:35

A 30 minute shower (it that’s not exaggerated) is unreasonable: expensive and unenvrironmantal

Managing the hot water is your responsibility though so for me the rule would be 10 mins in the shower max. DH has put a three minute egg timer in the wall in ours lol enough said about that.

You are both unreasonable for carrying on a midnight spat into the next day. Apologise
For waking her up say the tank doesn’t cope with long showers and from now on both of you will limit showering to max x minutes. Problems solved.

babyjellyfish · 22/02/2022 08:33

So you woke your 13 year old daughter up at midnight on a school night, and then made her get in a cold shower as punishment when she didn't need a shower?

And you're surprised that she wants to go and live with her dad?

ChateauxNeufDePoop · 22/02/2022 08:32

I flipped and told her to take a shower in it or loose phone for 24 hours

Disgrace.

Bouledeneige · 22/02/2022 08:29

Put the hot water in before your shower. Try not to wake up a teenage at midnight on a school night. And don't have a shouty roe afterwards. And don't impose sanctions for such minor issues. Pick your battles.

ChiselandBits · 22/02/2022 08:27

then presumably speakout you did very well in the early years and got lucky with a nice kid. They do exist. And I simply can't believe that you raised a child to adulthood without every once, even as a toddler, having to impose some form of consequence for poor behaviour.

DysmalRadius · 22/02/2022 08:24

Have you discussed changing the arrangements with her dad so that she gets some holidays to actually do the things she would enjoy?

speakout · 22/02/2022 08:23

If you sailed through the teenage years with no punishment you either have a particularly compliant child or you have raised a selfish nightmare

Not at all.
My DD was head girl at school and now an intensive care nurse. My children were taught about respect from a very early age. To think about their actions and how that impacts others. To consider situations from other people's points of view.
My children have never been punished at home, and never at school either. If they were self centred brats I think I would have had that feedback from school.