Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think employers will have to get used to treating staff better?

164 replies

Monopolyiscrap · 22/02/2022 00:28

In my field like many, there is a shortage of experienced staff. Suddenly the shit employers are all complaining about how they can not get any staff. In a Facebook group for people who do my work, you often get employers posting asking people to advise why they are getting no responses to their job advert. When you look, it is usually because they are being unrealistic in what they are expecting for the money. But they generally do not like being told that.

Good employers are still attracting staff. I got my current job as a friend who was working at the company and told me they were a great employer, and the salary is competitive. Managers treat people well and go out of their way to praise people and offer training and support. Meanwhile, the shit employer I worked for five years ago can't find anyone.

Employers are going to have to get used to treating staff better. AIBU?

OP posts:
thecatsthecats · 22/02/2022 08:31

I'm wondering about how to word this to my current (new) employer.

I happened to be on the lookout for an easy role which was remote and with shorter hours compatible with my studies. Hence ended up in a role several grades of pay below my usual whilst I'm retraining.

In my old role I had a lot of power and worked quite hard at improving conditions for staff - introducing more flexibility, more holidays, increased pay and reduced hours. And reaped the benefits. Happy, engaged, loyal staff.

They're advertising for a new role at my new place and they've only had six applications. I just want to shout "because the pay is crap for what you're asking!".

But since they're only paying me for £30k level advice, they're not getting my £60k pay level advice (If it sounds harsh, I have no ambitions with this employer, and they're already getting my other (technical) skills at a bargain rate - their strategy RELIES on hiring someone of my 60k abilities, but they were only offering half the rate. They are just very lucky that I was in the market for an easy ride alongside my course.)

Beseen22 · 22/02/2022 08:31

I'm a nurse on a ward that is hemorrhaging staff at the moment. Just signed 3 goodbye cards last night alone. Was talking to a colleague who had 22 hours annual leave to take but she was refused as there wasn't enough staff. She went to hr and spoke to the manager who came up with a compromise of leaving early. She came in excited to have a half day to discover thst the manager had taken 1 hour off every shift so she got to leave at 7 instead of 8 for her next 14 shifts. Who would do that?????!!

Theluggage15 · 22/02/2022 08:29

*oversubscribed

Theluggage15 · 22/02/2022 08:27

There isn’t a shortage of teaching assistants, each job is hugely oversupplied, one reason the wages are so low, supply and demand. The reason for fewer teaching assistants is schools don’t have the budget for them.

Ifailed · 22/02/2022 08:26

The IT industry generally (my niche) has been bleating about a "skills shortage" for decades.

I agree. A few years ago I was working for a major UK employer who imposed a strict salary cap on jobs (by grades). The end result was hiring 100s of contract staff on 3 times the cost of normal staff within the IT department.
These people were capable but had no idea of how the company worked, or what went on at the front line and were far less efficient than the existing people. Still senior management wouldn't budge as they had made a 'promise' to share holders to not increase wages.
When the inevitable redundancies came, most people walked out with a nice pay off into a better paid, less stressful new job, yet still the company would not change its ways.

JuergenSchwarzwald · 22/02/2022 08:24

@Orangade

Agree. The shortage of teaching assistants speaks for itself.
I thought that was because schools don't have the budgets to recruit them, not because they don't want them.
JuergenSchwarzwald · 22/02/2022 08:23

@Brefugee

one American labor law I look forward to seeing here, now we're free of EU tyranny.

is there an EU law that prevents this?

No there isn't, although loads of people on LinkedIn moaning about why this would not be a good idea (I disagree and think the salary range should always be posted).

There are plenty of EU laws protecting employment rights that you can wave goodbye to in the next five years. It would have already happened if covid hadn't happened.

JuergenSchwarzwald · 22/02/2022 08:21

I think you're right to an extent OP.

But with the Brexity government we have, they will want to reduce employment rights as soon as they can (as part of the "Brexit opportunities").

If you are in a niche or even not so niche role where good staff are sought after, you'll be ok - employers will need to be flexible (generally, not just in relation to things like WFH - for example they might to accept that you are good at some parts of the role but not others and either retrain you in those or get other employees to do them whereas in the past they would have sacked you for not being perfect) if they want to recruit and retain staff. But otherwise, you'll find that protection against discrimination and unfair dismissal is heavily reduced.

Orangade · 22/02/2022 08:18

Agree. The shortage of teaching assistants speaks for itself.

NuNameNuMe · 22/02/2022 08:17

Companies might need to offer higher salary, but if the money isn't in the budget then it will have to come out of other areas.

If the "money isn't in the budget", reconsider your business case. if you can't cover your costs through your income then that is not a business.

SookieHouseboat · 22/02/2022 08:14

Yes, agree with being treated as a commodity …. All while maintaining to the public that they’re a cut above. What a crock.

Brefugee · 22/02/2022 08:14

one American labor law I look forward to seeing here, now we're free of EU tyranny.

is there an EU law that prevents this?

Brefugee · 22/02/2022 08:13

sorry posted too early

Sadly it won't last. On any thread about employment conditions you get loads of people insisting the OP should do whatever their employer tells them, no matter how unreasonable (or even illegal).

that is because, as i have come to realise, a lot of people don't know what to ask for. It doesn't occur to some people to say "well, look you want me to be flexible and come in for a 6:30am meeting, but then you won't be flexible enough to offer me a 3:30pm finish one day a week. So sell me on the idea that i should be more flexible than you"

I personally think that employers and employees need to do far more investment in their relationship. Sure, you may not like a Friday evening bottle of wine, but how about a monthly lunch together? or regular (need only be once a quarter) "meetings" where you all work a bit more on your interpersonal relationships? it is far far easier to work with people you know a bit more, even if it is still relatively superficial. Or why not have teams discuss a bit more about what their actual work entails? i work in a big team and it's always interesting to know that A does X and B does Y, if later on i need to know something and realise, because i know a bit more about their work, to ask B about it rather than A.

It doesn't have to be intrusive into personal life, but knowing what your employees short to mid-term career or work goals are, is very helpful. Even if it is "i don't mind staying in this job doing this relatively easy no responsibility work for ever"

DGRossetti · 22/02/2022 08:10

@ThatsGoingToHurt

I does make me chuckle when I get contacted by the agencies for the same jobs that come up every year. They want someone professionally qualified to work on site 5 days a week (sat at their laptop) with no flexibility on working days hours but pay 20/30k under the going rate! Then they also try to recruit someone on a fixed term contract instead of a permanent contract (it’s a permanent role) so if they don’t like them they can just let them go after 6 months!
The IT industry generally (my niche) has been bleating about a "skills shortage" for decades. And without exception, every role that is "hard to find someone for" is considerably under the going rate.

It's one reason why I really don't pay too much attention to the CBI et al. Which makes it harder to totally condemn Boris "fuck business" Johnson over his cynicism too.

If nothing else, it's amusing to see comments on LinkedIn job ads about posting the bloody salary of late. And it's thanks to LinkedIn I heard that it's the law in NY state now

www.forbes.com/sites/jackkelly/2022/01/06/in-a-big-win-for-workers-new-york-city-will-make-it-mandatory-for-companies-to-disclose-salaries-on-job-advertisements/

one American labor law I look forward to seeing here, now we're free of EU tyranny.

BackwardsPrawn · 22/02/2022 08:09

I fear YABU.

If there's one thing true since the dawn of time, it's that employers will find ways to treat employees worse again. Sadly.

Brefugee · 22/02/2022 08:05

this is a topic of discussion where i work, recruitment and retention are the two big things that companies (big and small) need to address.

If you can't recruit - why can't you get anyone? is what you are asking for too niche? then you must offer OTJ training, with full salary, or you're stuffed. Are your T&C good enough? lots of studies by reputable agencies point to things like diversity in senior management as attracting a bigger pool of better candidates. You can't just pick and choose, employees are now the pickers and choosers. Why should they work for you? think about it

And since headhunting at all levels is now huge, what are you doing to retain your employees? are you moaning that they all want to WFH? why is this? what makes not coming to your physical premises unattractive? are you offering hybrid working? flexible hours (full time as well as part time). Why should your employee stay rather than go somewhere offering better terms?

To quote the carry on films "they* don't like it up 'em!"

*where they = employers

ThatsGoingToHurt · 22/02/2022 08:03

I does make me chuckle when I get contacted by the agencies for the same jobs that come up every year. They want someone professionally qualified to work on site 5 days a week (sat at their laptop) with no flexibility on working days hours but pay 20/30k under the going rate! Then they also try to recruit someone on a fixed term contract instead of a permanent contract (it’s a permanent role) so if they don’t like them they can just let them go after 6 months!

littledrummergirl · 22/02/2022 08:01

I've just left a job where I was not a good fit. The salary was ok but I was told by a member of the management team that my previous job role (patient care as gp receptionist) was not on a par with my new role as we were client care and i needed to forget my previous role. For fucks sake, if you have that little respect for the skill set involved why employ me?
They also didn't like that I gave honest client feedback to the management team where the client was unhappy with management. Told me I should have just written conversation with client in the notes rather than laying it out for management. I stand by what I did and accept that this job was a bad fit for me and that I refuse to lower my standards to fit with with someone else's idea of how to do the job.

Money is the reason to go to work, it's not the reason to work for them.

DGRossetti · 22/02/2022 07:56

Until the UK develops a culture of employees expecting to be treated like human beings there will always be a lot of shit employers.

I think the sheer numbers of people who can - and now will - move if treated that way is bringing some pressure to bear. Some employers will choose to go bust rather than level up, obviously.

Put another way, as someone who has agitated for remote working since 1996, the last 2 years have seen a sea change.

KatherineJaneway · 22/02/2022 07:54

We're recruiting at the moment and HR have been clear that for some roles it is a candidates market. We've been told hybrid working is a must for this role, luckily that is how we are working but would be difficult if we were not.

gettingolderandgrumpy · 22/02/2022 07:52

@EvenMoreFuriousVexation

Companies might need to offer higher salary, but if the money isn't in the budget then it will have to come out of other areas. So expect to see companies dropping to statutory minimum sick pay, annual leave, parental leave, travel/subsistence allowance frozen, bonus schemes removed, subsidised canteens removed, free parking withdrawn, no budget for staff events, the cheapest fixtures and fittings possible...
You can argue that and valid point but in my experience those that offer the crappiest pay , benefits but are doing quite well financially. They don’t want to pass this onto their employees who work very hard . Why should they ? Yes well then why are they then surprised that you leave for a better paid job with better benefits . Something a lot of employers don’t get .
DGRossetti · 22/02/2022 07:51

We’re recruiting for one qualified member of staff and can’t find anyone! It’s a very small, established, reputable business! Twice before we’ve recruited for the same qualification in the last 8 years and never had such a dismal response, don’t know what we’ll do tbh 🤷‍♀️ Have to start turning potential clients away I suppose, it’s hard atm!

Offer more money?

Well, yes. Except what do you do about the existing staff on what would be relatively low pay ?

I've been in a couple of companies that ended up having to take a new start on at a few grand more than people already doing the job. And you can imagine how that went down when they foun out. Especially as existing staff have to train the new as well ...

I hope the practice of avoiding numbers in job adverts is dying. Although it's axiomatic that any company advertising £competitive almost certainly isn't.

Selfraising · 22/02/2022 07:49

School support staff generally - not just TAs. I manage a school office, manage all the support staff, basically run the school from an admin point of view,
the stress and responsibility is sky high, and I get paid less than £10 an hour. Local supermarket is on a recruitment drive... It is genuinely tempting.

donquixotedelamancha · 22/02/2022 07:48

To think employers will have to get used to treating staff better?

Sadly it won't last. On any thread about employment conditions you get loads of people insisting the OP should do whatever their employer tells them, no matter how unreasonable (or even illegal).

Until the UK develops a culture of employees expecting to be treated like human beings there will always be a lot of shit employers. In turn we will continue to have low productivity compared to similar nations.

Aprilx · 22/02/2022 07:46

Maybe my experience is different because I would like to go back to work, and I am finding it very hard. I am not sure that the staff shortages are extending much beyond the hospitality industry, it is still extremely competitive market for the job hunter as far as I can tell.