Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think employers will have to get used to treating staff better?

164 replies

Monopolyiscrap · 22/02/2022 00:28

In my field like many, there is a shortage of experienced staff. Suddenly the shit employers are all complaining about how they can not get any staff. In a Facebook group for people who do my work, you often get employers posting asking people to advise why they are getting no responses to their job advert. When you look, it is usually because they are being unrealistic in what they are expecting for the money. But they generally do not like being told that.

Good employers are still attracting staff. I got my current job as a friend who was working at the company and told me they were a great employer, and the salary is competitive. Managers treat people well and go out of their way to praise people and offer training and support. Meanwhile, the shit employer I worked for five years ago can't find anyone.

Employers are going to have to get used to treating staff better. AIBU?

OP posts:
DGRossetti · 22/02/2022 09:58

I think pay is definitely one element. Although I often think pay is almost more important in retaining staff - nothing makes a person feel less valued and motivated than realising they're not being paid but being asked to do more.

Speaking for myself, it's never just about pay. It's the whole package. Travel time is a massive factor. Sometimes a £40K job is worth £50K if you don't have to travel 200 miles a week. Also conditions. Even if hybrid isn't on offer, flextime can be a big draw. This is probably the only reason why just putting a number in a job advert is a little misleading. (But still no excuse for not doing it).

BlingLoving · 22/02/2022 09:55

I think pay is definitely one element. Although I often think pay is almost more important in retaining staff - nothing makes a person feel less valued and motivated than realising they're not being paid but being asked to do more.

But there's a skills shortage too. I don't really understand why considering for years there was a lot of competition for jobs. But I find it quite interesting.

I run a small business and employ freelancers on an ad hoc basis. I have a number of brilliant ones who are all extremely loyal and reliable, not least because I pay top rates, provide realistic deadlines and good briefings.

But whenever I need to find new freelancers, I'm always shocked at how bad so many of the people I contact are. In many cases, I don't even get around to seeing their work because their engagement with me is so poor that I realise I can't risk putting them in front of my clients, even if the work itself is brilliant (which seems unlikely).

What I don't fully understand is how this happens. How are these skills not being developed? How did these people earn money (or how do they? Is this why their rates are so low?)

Rosewaterblossom · 22/02/2022 09:54

Unfortunately we are now seeing the aftermath of nearly 2 decades of employers being able to hire cheap labour from abroad. People who worked for less money and less employee benefits/good working conditions. It was always going to be a ticking time bomb.

Thehokeypokey · 22/02/2022 09:41

@stuntbubbles

I’d love for this to be true. Some recent “perks” I’ve seen listed on job adverts:

Pension (er, you mean the mandatory minimum pension scheme?)
Statutory holiday allowance
Free fruit bowl in the office
Half a day off on your birthday (just half, mind)
1 day a week WFH! (Treat yoself)
Wine Friday with colleagues (would rather die)
Newly decorated London office (???)

Yet the responsibilities are vast and the salary pathetic. Just pay people properly so they can afford their own manky bananas, offer decent holiday, and flexi as standard FFS.

But with a cost of living crisis, energy crisis, housing crisis, climate crisis, pick your own crisis, impending war, inflation, etc, I think it’s going to go the way of employer’s choice and be grateful for your free bruised fruit and £22k for a senior role that was £22k 15 years ago.

We're having a consultation at work (public sector) about losing something which could be seen as a perk (it really isn't though). Various people responded to the consultation saying they thought it would be harder to recruit if this 'perk' is lost. The employer's response? It will be easy to recruit because of the great conditions in the public sector, the examples given being annual leave (took the hump when I pointed out this was a legal requirement) and a pension (days of amazing final salary pensions long gone, at least in my part of the public sector). Meanwhile roles are going unfilled and morale of remaining staff has gone through the floor. People leaving left, right and centre for fellow public sector organisations who do value their staff (and I don't just mean through higher pay).
Hrpuffnstuff1 · 22/02/2022 09:37

I think employers need to focus on OTJ training, rather than just expecting a ready-fit employee who needs very little care and attention.
That will enable them to choose from a wider pool of applicants, although this means a change in not only the recruitment process but a change in those working for companies in recruitment.
I also feel that some employers are fire-fighting multiple problems in the background, this doesn't make for a happy environment. There's plenty been thrown in at the deep end.

UserWithNoUserName · 22/02/2022 09:36

I think it depends really.
Jobs that need some kind of minimal standard qualification, yes. Smaller field of people for more jobs.
Unskilled labour that you need no formal training for- no. There're always going to be people who need jobs and who are desperate for work. They will continue turning over staff and not caring.

BoredZelda · 22/02/2022 09:22

Employers are also being too fussy - they're used to being able to recruit from Eastern Europe on exploitation wages, rather than train people for the job. If they want a pipeline of good quality employee in future years, pick an eager beaver and train in-house.

We have never employed any staff on exploitation wages.

We can’t even find “eager beavers” to train in house. We’ve just spent a year training one and he’s just left.

BoredZelda · 22/02/2022 09:20

Maybe my experience is different because I would like to go back to work, and I am finding it very hard. I am not sure that the staff shortages are extending much beyond the hospitality industry, it is still extremely competitive market for the job hunter as far as I can tell.

We’re not hospitality and are struggling to recruit all levels of staff.

Partly it is because the company isn’t brilliant, small compared to our flashier competitors. But, to be fair, they are struggling too.

DGRossetti · 22/02/2022 09:10

@Oblomov22

I can't get over FunnyInjury post. Turn away clients? How shortsighted is this? What salary are you offering? say £40k? Offer £45k. Or £50. You will make up that £5k or £10k on the clients you don't then need to turn down, quickly, surely?
I can well believe it. There really are employers out there that would rather go bust than pay decent wages.
BarrowInFurnessRailwayStation · 22/02/2022 09:07

Ds1 has just landed his first job and they're falling over backwards to look after their employees. I'm pleasantly surprised by how well he's being treated and he's just landed a pay rise after having been there only six months.

Employers will have to keep up or fail to retain people.

Justkeeppedaling · 22/02/2022 09:06

@Aprilx

Maybe my experience is different because I would like to go back to work, and I am finding it very hard. I am not sure that the staff shortages are extending much beyond the hospitality industry, it is still extremely competitive market for the job hunter as far as I can tell.
The NHS is desperate for non medical (admin) staff. And I know the Building Society I work for can't recruit enough people in branch roles.
DGRossetti · 22/02/2022 08:57

@Brefugee

one American labor law I look forward to seeing here, now we're free of EU tyranny.

is there an EU law that prevents this?

Of course not. But since we now have to live with the ongoing shitshow of Brexit, we may as well make it as uncomfortable as possible for the scum that caused it. One way is to make Brexiteers squirm by asking for nice things and justify it by "being out of the EU".

For example isn't it great that Dyson can just up his workers salary by 10% because we are finally free of the yoke of EU tyranny.

Similarly the fact that Wetherspoons are introducing employee councils now we are feeling the sunshine of British freedoms on our EU-covered faces.

You get the idea.

EatSleepRantRepeat · 22/02/2022 08:57

Employers are also being too fussy - they're used to being able to recruit from Eastern Europe on exploitation wages, rather than train people for the job. If they want a pipeline of good quality employee in future years, pick an eager beaver and train in-house.

I'm not hearing we have no applicants, but that we have no quality applicants - which can range from not qualified to "face doesn't fit". It's a seller's market, which is a good thing.

Alarae · 22/02/2022 08:51

My sector is struggling to recruit as there is just a lack of talent out there. It doesn't help that when the graduates qualify (accountants) they are so sick of the boring day to day job they leave as management doesn't dish out the 'cooler' work to everyone so they all get experience.

Heard one story where all the grads in a cohort got promoted except one, with the excuse being that 'he never talked about it'. He wasn't worse than the other grads at all, his management just failed him. Surprise surprise, he left a month later as he felt undervalued and now they are even worse off with resource.

Luckily my team is awesome and I have no plans to leave.

Everythingsokreally · 22/02/2022 08:49

‘Companies might need to offer higher salary, but if the money isn't in the budget then it will have to come out of other areas.’

It is so much more complicated than this though. I (honestly!) work for a good employer. If you raise wages for the new starters, what becomes of all the existing people? Our salaries are truly not bad and we have always been very concerned about wage equality between employees. The competition for candidates is so steep at the moment that less scrupulous employers in the same field are throwing money at even under-qualified people. We are reluctant to do that as we just can’t match those kind of increases for every existing employee, and that means we keep losing out on candidates to companies that I know are less pleasant to work for (bcs I have worked for them!) who are willing to just pay a few grand extra to get people through the door, before they start to treat them like rubbish. It is frustrating.

fulanigirl · 22/02/2022 08:49

@Aprilx

Maybe my experience is different because I would like to go back to work, and I am finding it very hard. I am not sure that the staff shortages are extending much beyond the hospitality industry, it is still extremely competitive market for the job hunter as far as I can tell.
I work in finance, one of the biggest employer in the industry and trust me we are struggling to find and keep staff.
Oblomov22 · 22/02/2022 08:48

I can't get over FunnyInjury post. Turn away clients? How shortsighted is this? What salary are you offering? say £40k? Offer £45k. Or £50. You will make up that £5k or £10k on the clients you don't then need to turn down, quickly, surely?

Foolsrule · 22/02/2022 08:48

Also work for a pretty good employer but they simply won’t accept that their salaries have fallen behind. We are in one of the most expensive cities in the SE and people can’t afford to move for work here. Every HR meeting starts with a moan about how hard it is to recruit. I sit and scream internally - FUCKING PAY MORE! The company continued to do well despite Covid so there really is no excuse.

Ogel · 22/02/2022 08:42

Hopefully. I work for a very good employer- above industry standard wages, up to 6 months full pay sickness, 6 months full pay paternity leave (and then 3 months half pay- can take up to a year off and apply for extended with no pay), good work/life balance, no expectation of unpaid overtime, investment in training etc and we are struggling to recruit. Had a job out for nearly a year now and only a smattering of applicants, not particularly niche either!

womaninatightspot · 22/02/2022 08:41

@ANameChangeAgain

I suppose schools are the classic for this! I really can't work out why a TA is considered a minimum wage job! I've seen so many qualified TAs leave to work in a local supermarket due to pay.
I think TA is a sought after job because of the hours. Term time, school hours, no child care costs. I'm not a TA but I work c. min wage for school hours. I could get a better job but by the time I pay childcare costs even with UC helping I'm worse off financially.
donquixotedelamancha · 22/02/2022 08:40

loads of people on LinkedIn moaning about why this would not be a good idea

Well, it would be a bad idea for poor employers.

Better market information leads to more efficient markets. We highly regulate inefficient markets like energy supply to prevent abuse but employment is perhaps the most power unbalanced market there is yet we leave it opaque.

Publishing all salaries and requiring them on adverts would go a long way to making the job market work better.

Footnote · 22/02/2022 08:39

There can’t be an EU law preventing posting salary since in some EU countries it’s illegal to post a job without giving the salary in the advert.
In general, EU laws don’t stop countries giving their citizens more rights. It’s giving them less that is prevented (and all the Member States have previously all agreed to pass the EU law, don’t forget).

Theunamedcat · 22/02/2022 08:39

Its madness friend a has children worked around them for years recently the care agency she works for has a change of management not a problem suddenly management has an issue with the people working around children insisted that they were given calls after school before her husband got home so she would have to oay for childcare this makes her job unworkable and not worth it she is a genuinely great carer who can work late at night just not till after 5pm under previous management she had a rest between 2-5 then back out till 10 no problem nope this one wanted her to work 2pm till 10pm this did not work for her and many others so after many discussions they left the care company is now recruiting heavily and failing honestly take care of your employees and they take care of you

PureBlackVoid · 22/02/2022 08:36

I hope the practice of avoiding numbers in job adverts is dying. Although it's axiomatic that any company advertising £competitive almost certainly isn't.

I agree, job adverts really need to be standardised to include basic information like pay. It’s probably the most frustrating thing about job hunting, especially when you consider that these days application processes are getting lengthier - full application not just a CV, 2 stage interview and an assessment for what turns out to be a 20k salary.

I’ve seen it explained as it allows for ‘negotiating’, but employers will know the max they are willing to pay, so just state the range at least!

I also get annoyed when adverts don’t specify shift patterns, or contracted hours. FT can be anywhere from 37-45 hours a week. Big difference to your working day there. ‘Any 5 out of 7’ doesn’t cut it, when you find out later that it’s a mixture of mornings, afternoons and evenings in that 5, and you only get 2 days off together once in 6 weeks.

I skip past these adverts now, because I don’t want to waste my time on an employer who isn’t transparent.

Kazzyhoward · 22/02/2022 08:32

@NuNameNuMe

Companies might need to offer higher salary, but if the money isn't in the budget then it will have to come out of other areas.

If the "money isn't in the budget", reconsider your business case. if you can't cover your costs through your income then that is not a business.

Hence why we have High Streets with boarded up empty shop units, why a huge amount of our manufacturing shut down and is now done abroad in cheaper countries, why customer service is being converted into voice recognition and online support instead of real people, why bank branches are closing, etc etc.