Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think employers will have to get used to treating staff better?

164 replies

Monopolyiscrap · 22/02/2022 00:28

In my field like many, there is a shortage of experienced staff. Suddenly the shit employers are all complaining about how they can not get any staff. In a Facebook group for people who do my work, you often get employers posting asking people to advise why they are getting no responses to their job advert. When you look, it is usually because they are being unrealistic in what they are expecting for the money. But they generally do not like being told that.

Good employers are still attracting staff. I got my current job as a friend who was working at the company and told me they were a great employer, and the salary is competitive. Managers treat people well and go out of their way to praise people and offer training and support. Meanwhile, the shit employer I worked for five years ago can't find anyone.

Employers are going to have to get used to treating staff better. AIBU?

OP posts:
Chely · 22/02/2022 12:10

Dh's employers have staff shortages and are still a bunch of thunder cunts.

BlingLoving · 22/02/2022 12:07

Their recruitment processes simply do not typically attract candidates with even basic professional capabilities. And it's good staff who are at the core of business progress. With the current cohort, I can't work miracles.

I partially agree with this, but think it's deeper. If you are advertising excellent pay, great client work etc, and you're still finding that candidates don't have basic skills, you have to ask what has been happening over the last 10-20 years that means skills haven't been developed. Is it because it just wasn't important? You could be incompetent and no one cared?

The NHS is a good example. My doctor's surgery is fantastic. efficient, proactive, helpful. The doctors themselves are universally pleasant and I've never experienced that sense that they're not listening/taking me seriously. I have a number of friends who have moved to my doctor's surgery and found the same experience. However, this is not universal. Those friends who have moved have done so at my recommendation after complaining about their old surgeries - one couldn't get a smear appointment for love or money. Another consistently was told there was nothing wrong with her child, from multiple doctors. She assumes they had a note on her file that she was difficult. New surgery diagnosed a serious (but not life limiting) condition and had it sorted within 6 months...

So what is the difference? For years, the old surgeries either got away with it OR their service has deteriorated. Why? How? What guidelines/targets have traditionally been set that service itself wasn't a priority?

the NHS is an easy target, but of course, its' true in multiple other industries. I worked for a massive global city organisation. In our team, we had endless problems and staff turnover.... all because of the head of department. Since his departure, the team has been stable, are, I believe, successful etc etc. But it took more than 100% turnover of staff before he was finally removed from post... why?

Rosebel · 22/02/2022 12:03

Three people have left my husbands work in recent months and they can't replace them because the pay is crap.
They can't recruit where I work as the pressure is unbearable and the pay is rubbish.
Company is making millions but won't spend it on staff wages and there are no perks.
They seem shocked people are leaving in droves but despite being told why at exit interviews nothing changes.

30kperannum · 22/02/2022 11:58

My husband is in the tech sector, and started someone this week with five years experience at £80k. They walked after two days for £115k. He can't just up eighty other programmers' salaries by 35k, 80 other programmers who have more than five years experience.

One big employer is trying to make a monopoly (and they've been successful in other sectors) and doing it by buying up all the talent and squeezing out all competition.

They have billions upon billions to spend, and it doesn't matter to them how much they pay now as five years down the line they'll be the only player in the game, and can charge the users whatever they want.

DGRossetti · 22/02/2022 11:49

Regarding Brady ... well that's a whole other kettle of fish about whether the education system is fit for purpose. Although the real answer to that question really depends on what your think the education system is supposed to do in the first place are. It's clearly not intended to educate kids, but I'm sure there are other metrics that make it a roaring success. (The cleanliness of the cheese shop in the famous sketch being a parallel).

formalineadeline · 22/02/2022 11:46

don't understand that the company doesn't have an endless pot of many to provide all of this

Mneh. In my experience, business owners who witter the loudest about how they can't possibly afford the inexpensive changes employees are requesting are taking dividends / profit shares 10-100 times greater than the employees' salaries.

They can afford it and still have a very good income, they just don't want to reduce their obscene earnings. Critical distinction.

Monopolyiscrap · 22/02/2022 11:42

@thecatsthecats Brady has always been recognised to be extremely intelligent. And it was commonplace then for working-class kids to leave school at 15 for work. Some will have been very intelligent and skilled, some will not have been. It really is not comparable to now.
When I was at school nearly everyone left my school at 16 years old for work - I am in my fifties. That included some very bright and capable kids.

OP posts:
formalineadeline · 22/02/2022 11:42

Of course not. But since we now have to live with the ongoing shitshow of Brexit, we may as well make it as uncomfortable as possible for the scum that caused it. One way is to make Brexiteers squirm by asking for nice things and justify it by "being out of the EU".

I like your style. I'll have to try this. Grin

Monopolyiscrap · 22/02/2022 11:40

@lurkingattheback if the employer is offering competitive pay and terms and conditions, then they need to look at their recruitment process. But many employers do not realise things have changed and are unrealistic.

OP posts:
lurkingattheback · 22/02/2022 11:35

I think it works both ways. Many employees in some industries are expecting huge salaries, even when inexperienced, full health care and all the perks but wanting 4 day weeks (not being productive on their other days) and don't understand that the company doesn't have an endless pot of many to provide all of this.

thecatsthecats · 22/02/2022 11:32

@BlingLoving

I think pay is definitely one element. Although I often think pay is almost more important in retaining staff - nothing makes a person feel less valued and motivated than realising they're not being paid but being asked to do more.

But there's a skills shortage too. I don't really understand why considering for years there was a lot of competition for jobs. But I find it quite interesting.

I run a small business and employ freelancers on an ad hoc basis. I have a number of brilliant ones who are all extremely loyal and reliable, not least because I pay top rates, provide realistic deadlines and good briefings.

But whenever I need to find new freelancers, I'm always shocked at how bad so many of the people I contact are. In many cases, I don't even get around to seeing their work because their engagement with me is so poor that I realise I can't risk putting them in front of my clients, even if the work itself is brilliant (which seems unlikely).

What I don't fully understand is how this happens. How are these skills not being developed? How did these people earn money (or how do they? Is this why their rates are so low?)

As I mentioned, I'm at a new employer, and have purposefully stepped down to fit in with my studies.

I too have found the skills gap very surprising. My husband has only ever worked for employers with stringent professional standards (as opposed to qualifications) so is always shocked by my anecdotes.

I've been brought in to try and fix this (and they have no idea how much they'd have to pay for my level of skills normally), and find that the gap is way beyond some basic training. Their recruitment processes simply do not typically attract candidates with even basic professional capabilities. And it's good staff who are at the core of business progress. With the current cohort, I can't work miracles.

(Incidentally, I was watching the Moors Murderers documentary last night, and was struck by Brady's high level of literacy - for a school drop out at 15, especially. It's a bit grotesque that a psychopathic murderer showed more aptitude for self improvement than a typical employee at my firm.)

Monopolyiscrap · 22/02/2022 11:29

Increasingly in my field people offering lower wages i.e. £20k, £22k, are being advised in groups to recruit someone new and send them on training. But employers still want someone experienced. They do not seem to realise you have to be competitive. And if you are not you will only get desperate people who will not stay long, or people who are shit at their jobs.

OP posts:
irishfarmer · 22/02/2022 11:28

I really think it should be mandatory to put a salary on a job posting, it is such a waste of time applying if you know you will never work for that sort of money. I did go for an interview before and they had posted €35k - €40k DOE salary. She offered me €26K, it was through a recruiter. I actually laughed when the recruiter called to offer me the job at that salary. I told her I was really insulted and I have the experience to get the full salary. She said she knows, just her client wanted to advertise at a higher salary to attract a higher candidate and hopefully persuade them to join. I did not join.

I don't think it is just a brexit thing, in ROI we are having issues attracting staff in lower paid jobs too and we are in the EU. A lot of people retrained during furlong and no longer want to be customer facing and get abuse from the public and I don't blame them. Some wagon giving out to you, and you're earning min wage. I did waitressing/ bars/ shops in uni, so 10 yrs ago. It seems way worse now, people are way too rude/ entitled/ I will record this.

Franklin12 · 22/02/2022 11:02

I used to work for a large FTSE company with over 100,000 employees. We were literaly numbers to them, when someone left or took ML others in the team were expected to cover. Managers changed at least once a year due to the endless reorganisations. People constantly covered their bums so if there was anything tricky to resolve or manage with our clients the senior mgt were no where to be seen.

Constant half soaked ideas often by bean counters who had NEVER met or dealt with a client. They just saw the cost savings, hot desking where the offices were kept so cold that I often saw people in coats and hats!

Having to justify going to see a client (where the client in there contract paid for the travel). Being asked to stay in the cheapest place in town when out visiting a customer. This meant Travelodges on the motorway. No women wanted to do that so were travelling 500 miles in one day to avoid.

I could go on but I left with a large payout. Their answer was to try and get someone offshore to do my role. Only issue was I had Government Security Clearance so they couldnt do anything. Some poor sod eventually was found who lasted 12 weeks and then left.

Look at British Airways. Treat their staff like dirt. Cabin crew look about 12 and will live at home with Mum and Dad because the pay is so bad. Are they really expected to manage passengers in First and Business Class. Yet they still want to charge premimum prices. They have had huge issues with baggage handlers at Heathrow and are blaming the wind. There was chaos this weekend and no back up plan.

Ogel · 22/02/2022 10:59

@Sloth66

TheHealth sector seems to be really struggling. I’ve seen agency rates have increased, but if the awful working conditions aren’t also addressed, retention is poor. I read an article describing the trend of people retiring earlier if they can, know a few people who’ve done this.
This is case around the world too- mixed in with the poor pay and conditions here the biggest risk to the NHS is the hemorrhaging of staff, it will be a catastrophic issue in the not too far away future.
Sloth66 · 22/02/2022 10:40

TheHealth sector seems to be really struggling.
I’ve seen agency rates have increased, but if the awful working conditions aren’t also addressed, retention is poor. I read an article describing the trend of people retiring earlier if they can, know a few people who’ve done this.

SalsaLove · 22/02/2022 10:39

For the first time in my 25 year career (just retrained in HR) in higher education admin, I submitted an application on Sunday and was contacted for an interview on Monday. If I’m made an offer I will ask for the highest bank offered.

DGRossetti · 22/02/2022 10:33

if Brexit actually does mean employers have to get off their bottoms and train people, there will be a silver lining

Just remember it wasn't meant to. However there is a rare chance to put the promoters of Brexit to the sword over this (and boy, do they not like it ...).

You can take a similar tack with Covid. The more the government bang on about how brilliant the UKs covid response has been, it's another stab at any excuse that economic problems are "down to covid" ...

(I'm old, grumpy, and had it with lying scumbag politicians ...)

LookItsMeAgain · 22/02/2022 10:30

@FunnyInjury

We’re recruiting for one qualified member of staff and can’t find anyone! It’s a very small, established, reputable business! Twice before we’ve recruited for the same qualification in the last 8 years and never had such a dismal response, don’t know what we’ll do tbh 🤷‍♀️ Have to start turning potential clients away I suppose, it’s hard atm!
If you can't offer more money to the prospective employee, offer better terms and conditions.
WishIwasElsa · 22/02/2022 10:18

I would like to say that this would happen where I work but I doubt it. In fact most of my team just had a pay rise (retainer fee) and a few of us with less qualifications have not. Fuming doesn't even cover it, it's like a massive fuck you right to my face and shows me exactly how much they value me and all the years of hard work I've given them.

applewhitenights · 22/02/2022 10:17

My last employer was one of those with unrealistic expectations. Thought he gave me the greatest opportunity in the world working for him. Initially it was a lovely job but I was about £10k under the going rate for the position. However I had a 5 min walk to work, quiet location and workplace, relaxed feeling at work, nice colleagues, and had an extra 10 mins with clients which really helped de stress my work life.

He then reduced the time I had with clients to less than the industry standard, didn't increase my pay in line with this or the extra qualifications I gained to grow his business, got rid of sick pay (initially full pay for a day off sick - which I never actually used but nice to know it was there!), reduced employer pension contributions to the minimum required, moved premises so it was now a 30min drive for me.... etc. I was ungrateful apparently when I told him I was leaving for a company paying the going rate plus bonuses for the same job but with better equipment at my disposal.

JuergenSchwarzwald · 22/02/2022 10:14

money alone won't do it. They need to start making the work culture more appealing too

totally agree. I am sure many if not most people value flexible working over an extra couple of K in salary. Employer culture is very important.

JuergenSchwarzwald · 22/02/2022 10:13

@EatSleepRantRepeat

Employers are also being too fussy - they're used to being able to recruit from Eastern Europe on exploitation wages, rather than train people for the job. If they want a pipeline of good quality employee in future years, pick an eager beaver and train in-house.

I'm not hearing we have no applicants, but that we have no quality applicants - which can range from not qualified to "face doesn't fit". It's a seller's market, which is a good thing.

This is true - employers always want someone "young and dynamic, with ten years of experience - and just out of university". Hmmm.

if Brexit actually does mean employers have to get off their bottoms and train people, there will be a silver lining

balalake · 22/02/2022 10:09

It goes in cycles I think, and what may be required now to keep staff or attract them will not necessarily be so should employment prospects worsen.

PearPickingPorky · 22/02/2022 10:00

"You will be offered a competitive salary"

Oh, yeah? So competitive you won't say what it is. You're competing with the candidates to pay them as little as you can get away with.

I work in am industry that is due to hugely increase over the next decade or so, and qualified people are in short supply and good people keep getting poached. Staff retention comes up a lot, and people keep saying that the company will need to pay people more. But the thing is, the new entrants to the industry have much deeper pockets, so money alone won't do it. They need to start making the work culture more appealing too.

Not wringing every last drop of blood out of the staff that they do have would be a start.