Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think employers will have to get used to treating staff better?

164 replies

Monopolyiscrap · 22/02/2022 00:28

In my field like many, there is a shortage of experienced staff. Suddenly the shit employers are all complaining about how they can not get any staff. In a Facebook group for people who do my work, you often get employers posting asking people to advise why they are getting no responses to their job advert. When you look, it is usually because they are being unrealistic in what they are expecting for the money. But they generally do not like being told that.

Good employers are still attracting staff. I got my current job as a friend who was working at the company and told me they were a great employer, and the salary is competitive. Managers treat people well and go out of their way to praise people and offer training and support. Meanwhile, the shit employer I worked for five years ago can't find anyone.

Employers are going to have to get used to treating staff better. AIBU?

OP posts:
ILoveAllRainbowsx · 22/02/2022 13:24

@DGRossetti

Well, if people don't want that to happen then they can vote for another party at the next election.

People will get what they damn well get. I would have thought that message would have entered even the thickest of skulls by now.

Last election people "voted" for a competent government. And that didn't happen. And it's hardly a complex requirement really.

So why don't you become an MP instead of criticising the people who are at least prepared to do it and put up with abuse and death threats?
SweetFelicityArkright · 22/02/2022 13:22

@BoodleBug51

What a nasty goady post.

DH and I run a niche bespoke business, and have got an amazing team of staff some of whom have been here 20+ years. We can't train people on the job because funnily enough, people don't want mistakes made on their high end products. We need skilled reliable and professional craftsmen... and they're like gold dust. Most applicants we get nowadays aren't from the UK and have only worked in cheap mass production factory equivalents where quantity is more important than quality.

We pay good wages, we've got a well stocked kitchen with tea/coffee/nespresso, they get their equipment provided at great expense which is almost unheard of in the trade. We pay tea breaks and lunch breaks. And yet we need to be better? ODFO.

This attitude pretty much sums up the attitude of employers imo. It's nasty and goady for workers to want better pay and conditions for the work that they do to support the business they work for, you may feel you're a good employer and that may well be true, that doesn't mean that every employer is, or that it's nasty and goady to discuss bad employers (in a general way) and what effect the shortfall of workers and skills in the workforce is having on changing that.
Jmaho · 22/02/2022 13:18

@Ifailed

The IT industry generally (my niche) has been bleating about a "skills shortage" for decades.

I agree. A few years ago I was working for a major UK employer who imposed a strict salary cap on jobs (by grades). The end result was hiring 100s of contract staff on 3 times the cost of normal staff within the IT department.
These people were capable but had no idea of how the company worked, or what went on at the front line and were far less efficient than the existing people. Still senior management wouldn't budge as they had made a 'promise' to share holders to not increase wages.
When the inevitable redundancies came, most people walked out with a nice pay off into a better paid, less stressful new job, yet still the company would not change its ways.

My husband left an IT role in education after being there for 10 years. There were 3 people doing his same role when he started and then by year 5 he was on his own doing the same amount of work as 3 people. Complete recruitment and pay freeze and no increase in pay bands. Constant promise of re grading his role that never happened. Final straw was when they cut annual leave and rewrote job titles and roles so that people had to sign new contracts and were forced to drop out of very generous pension scheme and go into a much poorer scheme (many put up with the poor pay because of the pension and annual leave) Two contractors are now doing his job on £500 a day rates and doing it very badly it seems! Makes zero sense, they have pretty much lost all their long term loyal knowledgeable staff
MaryMcCarthy · 22/02/2022 12:58

I work in medical device and technology innovation which involves universities, the private sector and the NHS and we've never seen skills shortages like we're seeing today. We can't recruit anywhere near the required number of researchers, scientists, engineers, medics etc, and this is being seen across my industry and others.
You could argue that rising wages are a silver lining but that's a short-sighted view. Skills shortages are weighing on productivity which means businesses won't grow to their potential and jobs won't be created in the numbers, or the quality, they used to be. If a company has vacancies it can’t fill then it can’t do everything it wants to do. People seem to be overlook this aspect when presenting “a million vacancies” as a good thing.

Another key point is that wage rises caused by shortages are nowhere near as positive for the economy as wage rises driven by increased productivity and profit. Of course if you engineer a shortage of something then it’s going to rise in value, but a shortage by its nature represents inefficiency and lost potential. The inconsistent wage growth we’re seeing across the economy will therefore have a deleterious, uneven impact on inflation. Wage growth is simply not keeping up with inflation for the majority of workers and it’s going to be getting worse for a good while before it gets better.

Similar situations are being seen across various developed countries but the sheer number of unfilled vacancies in the UK economy, coupled with the current trajectory of inflation (with another large hike due post-April) coupled with logistics issues with import and export all represent a unique storm. And yes, implementing Brexit without a plan has made this all so much worse than it needed to be. If anyone thinks Brexit is helping ANY of this then I’d love to hear how.

Monopolyiscrap · 22/02/2022 12:57

Also boodlebugs no one is saying you need to be better. If you can recruit staff with what you do then fine. If not tough.

OP posts:
DGRossetti · 22/02/2022 12:57

Well, if people don't want that to happen then they can vote for another party at the next election.

People will get what they damn well get. I would have thought that message would have entered even the thickest of skulls by now.

Last election people "voted" for a competent government. And that didn't happen. And it's hardly a complex requirement really.

DGRossetti · 22/02/2022 12:54

@BoodleBug51

What a nasty goady post.

DH and I run a niche bespoke business, and have got an amazing team of staff some of whom have been here 20+ years. We can't train people on the job because funnily enough, people don't want mistakes made on their high end products. We need skilled reliable and professional craftsmen... and they're like gold dust. Most applicants we get nowadays aren't from the UK and have only worked in cheap mass production factory equivalents where quantity is more important than quality.

We pay good wages, we've got a well stocked kitchen with tea/coffee/nespresso, they get their equipment provided at great expense which is almost unheard of in the trade. We pay tea breaks and lunch breaks. And yet we need to be better? ODFO.

So how has recruitment the past 20+ years been ?

How many vacancies a year do you have, how many ads do you place, how many people do you interview and of those how many get placed ?

ILoveAllRainbowsx · 22/02/2022 12:53

*allDGRossetti Tue 22-Feb-22 12:43:05
ILoveAllRainbowsx

Yes, now that we do not have unlimited immigration from the EU, employers will have to pay and treat staff fairly.

very s..l..o..w..l..y..

That's not going to happen

Instead you will get (or rather have gotten) relaxed immigration requirements for whichever industry whinged loud enough last month. Basically we're still in the EU as far as other EU citizens are concerned. It's just UK citizens that can't move freely for labour.*

very s..l..o..w..l..y.

Well, if people don't want that to happen then they can vote for another party at the next election. It's called democracy. We could not vote on who immigrated to the UK when we were in the EU.

Monopolyiscrap · 22/02/2022 12:49

@BoodleBug51 why can't you train people? Most bespoke crafts firms used to have apprentices that they did train up. If you refuse to, then I suspect you will always struggle.

OP posts:
BoodleBug51 · 22/02/2022 12:43

What a nasty goady post.

DH and I run a niche bespoke business, and have got an amazing team of staff some of whom have been here 20+ years. We can't train people on the job because funnily enough, people don't want mistakes made on their high end products. We need skilled reliable and professional craftsmen... and they're like gold dust. Most applicants we get nowadays aren't from the UK and have only worked in cheap mass production factory equivalents where quantity is more important than quality.

We pay good wages, we've got a well stocked kitchen with tea/coffee/nespresso, they get their equipment provided at great expense which is almost unheard of in the trade. We pay tea breaks and lunch breaks. And yet we need to be better? ODFO.

DGRossetti · 22/02/2022 12:43

@ILoveAllRainbowsx

Yes, now that we do not have unlimited immigration from the EU, employers will have to pay and treat staff fairly.
very s..l..o..w..l..y..

That's not going to happen

Instead you will get (or rather have gotten) relaxed immigration requirements for whichever industry whinged loud enough last month. Basically we're still in the EU as far as other EU citizens are concerned. It's just UK citizens that can't move freely for labour.

DGRossetti · 22/02/2022 12:39

But then society doesn't want to pay higher taxes, nor lose their inheritance on care fees, and in any discussion about it, many will claim they'll be off to Dignitas anyway should it happen to them so it won't affect them.

I wonder if there's a market for bulk bookings at Dignitas ? Off one, get one free sort of thing. Coach party discounts.

I think I'm getting the hang of post-Brexit opportunities. As the Rolling Stones noted: you can't always get what you want. But you might just get what you need ....

ILoveAllRainbowsx · 22/02/2022 12:39

Yes, now that we do not have unlimited immigration from the EU, employers will have to pay and treat staff fairly.

DGRossetti · 22/02/2022 12:36

The problem with social care is that it's a 'vocation' - you're supposed to accept the shit pay and conditions because you're supposed to be in it for the job, not the money, and it's seen as a low skilled job that anyone can do.

Other vocations include "politician" ...

Puzzledandpissedoff · 22/02/2022 12:35

I find this varies by sector, but as with so much ikt's a question of balance
Certainly there are employers who expect far too much, but then that also applies to some employees, and the aim is to find the sweet spot where everyone's mostly happy - not an easy thing anyway, especially ATM

DGRossetti · 22/02/2022 12:33

Offshoring was all very well until it levelled up the skillsbase in India and Pakistan. Now those people (quite rightly) want more pay and a lot of offshoring isn't profitable anymore.

Anyone who has ever hung wallpaper and tried to get the air bubbles out might understand the landscape. Herding cats is a similar pastime.

thecatsthecats · 22/02/2022 12:32

I partially agree with this, but think it's deeper. If you are advertising excellent pay, great client work etc, and you're still finding that candidates don't have basic skills, you have to ask what has been happening over the last 10-20 years that means skills haven't been developed. Is it because it just wasn't important? You could be incompetent and no one cared?

I agree with this, and:

I do not have any sympathy for firms consistently failing to recruit staff. There will be an issue they are failing to address.

In my firm's case, it is that the board/senior team themselves have a low level of professional skills that just wouldn't fly in other sectors I'm familiar with. For example a bid manager given responsibility for a technical bid that's relevant to my role. She didn't know whether she had a smartphone or a basic phone, and didn't understand why we didn't use Dropbox instead of a CRM. Yet she's paid a consultancy rate equivalent to a 60k salary whilst only working one day a week. Yes, she does her own job well enough.

However, this is just one piece of a puzzle where the management are the blind leading the blind when it comes to normal professional standards, and the business fails to develop because they have no idea how their low standards come across to the public.

They then have a staff turnover issue because competent staff like the business, but don't want to hang around tied to a staff and management who don't have the wits that nature gave the pigeon.

SweetFelicityArkright · 22/02/2022 12:30

@Theunamedcat

Its madness friend a has children worked around them for years recently the care agency she works for has a change of management not a problem suddenly management has an issue with the people working around children insisted that they were given calls after school before her husband got home so she would have to oay for childcare this makes her job unworkable and not worth it she is a genuinely great carer who can work late at night just not till after 5pm under previous management she had a rest between 2-5 then back out till 10 no problem nope this one wanted her to work 2pm till 10pm this did not work for her and many others so after many discussions they left the care company is now recruiting heavily and failing honestly take care of your employees and they take care of you
The problem with social care is that it's a 'vocation' - you're supposed to accept the shit pay and conditions because you're supposed to be in it for the job, not the money, and it's seen as a low skilled job that anyone can do. Conversely though, you have providers who are running a business that they want to make a profit from, which is apparently acceptable. And you have a client base that can't easily vote with their feet and go elsewhere nor have a loud enough voice to complain. Combine that with the hybrid system of payment, large fees for self funded clients, LAs not paying enough and it's an absolute mess that's not getting any better. When you add Brexit and covid to that, and the knock on effect of losing staff to both, I reckon a lot of providers are making more money than they were by running short shifts and saving on the wage bill, with no one able to do much about it because everywhere is the same, while providers are bleating that they can't get enough staff - at the same time as doing nothing about the working conditions or pay, instead blaming the 'work shy' wanting to live on benefits and never do a days work in their lives. But then society doesn't want to pay higher taxes, nor lose their inheritance on care fees, and in any discussion about it, many will claim they'll be off to Dignitas anyway should it happen to them so it won't affect them. Everyone wants someone else to make the sacrifice to provide good quality care.
DGRossetti · 22/02/2022 12:30

A lot of targets cause incredibly dysfunctional and counterproductive behaviour.

Best cheese shop in the county sir !

And how, pray tell, was that decided ?

Very clean, sir.

Well it's certainly uncontaminated by any suggestion of cheese ...

NorthSouthcatlady · 22/02/2022 12:29

Yep. I think it’s hilarious! In the industry l work in then it hard to get people and employers are having to up their game. They now need to start paying more money, being more respectful (e.g. not expecting people to work every weekend when they were told at interview they get 25% of them off) and more flexible etc

Franklin12 · 22/02/2022 12:27

Company I used to work for thought for cost reasons they would recruit offshore. This went on for years and years. Constant cover up and they didnt want to know it didnt work because they signed off on it.

One idea was to have a UK based person responsible for say a group in India. We all knew it was so that they could blame the UK person for the issues and for not 'helping out'. India in particular were not comfortable in dealing with high level clients. Due to the language difference they were much happier filling in spreadsheets and reports but they couldnt stand up to a client or do a sale to save their lives.

This went on for years and years. The accountants loved it because offshore resource was considerably cheaper than UK. It was just awful trying to help and support people who you were never likely to meet. There was a high churn which meant anyone you worked with and was showing some promise wasnt there 6 months later.

Awful awful practise and I am glad to be out of it.

PastMyBestBeforeDate · 22/02/2022 12:21

I work in the public sector, in a role that exists and attracts at least 200% of my fte salary in the public sector. I stay for complicated reasons but I am now reconsidering that.
The public sector pay has been falling in real terms for a long time and it's controlled nationally with little room to manoeuvre around grades. With inflation rising this is getting worse. We haven't been able to recruit easily for years and we have to rely on agency staff. And these agency staff are expensive.
There's no drive at a government level to treat the permanent staff better in pay or pension so expect budgets to be in crisis paying agency staff and services to continue to worsen.

formalineadeline · 22/02/2022 12:20

What guidelines/targets have traditionally been set that service itself wasn't a priority?

This is a very good question. A lot of targets cause incredibly dysfunctional and counterproductive behaviour. Even dangerous behaviour in cases like the csection targets that were finally abolished this week because they were putting lives at risk and causing harm.

Monopolyiscrap · 22/02/2022 12:19

I do not have any sympathy for firms consistently failing to recruit staff. There will be an issue they are failing to address.

OP posts:
NowEvenBetter · 22/02/2022 12:17

It makes me so happy to see shit employers suffering. They’re reaping what they’ve sowed. If you won’t pay your labourers at bare minimum thriving wage plus benefits, you don’t deserve staff and you don’t have a viable business. Anyone thinking poverty wage is acceptable for jobs they consider ‘unskilled’ (no such thing) is scum.