Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think employers will have to get used to treating staff better?

164 replies

Monopolyiscrap · 22/02/2022 00:28

In my field like many, there is a shortage of experienced staff. Suddenly the shit employers are all complaining about how they can not get any staff. In a Facebook group for people who do my work, you often get employers posting asking people to advise why they are getting no responses to their job advert. When you look, it is usually because they are being unrealistic in what they are expecting for the money. But they generally do not like being told that.

Good employers are still attracting staff. I got my current job as a friend who was working at the company and told me they were a great employer, and the salary is competitive. Managers treat people well and go out of their way to praise people and offer training and support. Meanwhile, the shit employer I worked for five years ago can't find anyone.

Employers are going to have to get used to treating staff better. AIBU?

OP posts:
Rantypanties · 22/02/2022 16:22

I used to work in retail part time to bolster my self employed income, did it for many years until recently when my 4 hour contract suddenly became only viable if I could commit to being fully flexible. I had 3 days I couldn’t do and yet my manager kept putting me on shift for those days so I had to keep swapping and in the end had to quit because I was sick and tired of it.

Retail expects to put all its staff on low 4/8 hour contracts, expect you to do twice as much and expect you to be fully committed to the job all week but don’t want to return that flexibility. It makes it so hard for single parents or people like myself to be able to take the vacant positions.

DGRossetti · 22/02/2022 16:02

Another reason for low productivity is that employers did not have to automate because they had access to cheap unlimited EU labour for the last 20 years.

British productivity has been low for more than just the past 2 decades. It's endemic. Probably because we've developed a culture that would rather someone else spent millions on the costs of treating and supporting road traffic accident victims (for example) because it saves a few quid in streetlighting because "it's someone else's budget".

Even on this thread you've heard tales of firms that would rather pay £500 a day on a contractor than invest in permanent staff.

All of which feeds into the oft-cited trope of "why should I pay for your children's education ?". Which is still a thing.

"Why should I pay for ?"

ILoveAllRainbowsx · 22/02/2022 15:45

@Monopolyiscrap

Yes it is a failure of business. But businesses like to blame employees for everything. It has long been noted that British employers are very poor at training up and investing in their workforce and this is one recognised reason for low productivity.
Another reason for low productivity is that employers did not have to automate because they had access to cheap unlimited EU labour for the last 20 years.
EatSleepRantRepeat · 22/02/2022 15:32

Attitudes of management really don't help - DH is looking for his next fixed term contract and companies are expecting a process of up to 4 interviews, drawn out over a few months, because the leaders aren't making time in their diaries and then expecting external candidates to wait around for them.

The job where I felt the most engaged of my career was in a small business, where I could see the difference my efforts made on the bottom line on a daily basis. Wages were too low but there wasn't a huge gap between top and bottom - the owner was a modest man who drove a ford mondeo, not a top of the range tesla, and often spent his own money taking us out for dinner as a thank you for a job well done. He sat in the same office as us, got his hands dirty and helped out when there were difficult clients, instead of just shouting about targets and throwing verbal p45s around.

In contrast, I'm in the most senior role of my career now, but my director chooses not to contact me directly, conducts everything through their PA, and I'm lucky to get 5 minutes with them for projects I'm doing on their behalf. They turn up occasionally to show their face but barely remember anyone's name, because deep down they just don't care.

Monopolyiscrap · 22/02/2022 14:26

Yes it is a failure of business. But businesses like to blame employees for everything.
It has long been noted that British employers are very poor at training up and investing in their workforce and this is one recognised reason for low productivity.

OP posts:
formalineadeline · 22/02/2022 14:21

If employers are not producing a skilled workforce then isn't that a failure of business?

Monopolyiscrap · 22/02/2022 14:18

Yes, we need an increase in tax.
My DP who is not well-paid finally left the NHS a few years ago. His pay increased, but more importantly, his job became more manageable. He always swore that he would never leave the NHS as he was so committed to it. But the job just became unbearable.

OP posts:
PowerhouseOfTheCell · 22/02/2022 14:18

My last employer loved to boast how much revenue had gone up during covid and then announced they’d be halving shift allowance and anyone who wanted to come off shift had to take a pay cut. I wasn’t getting up at 4:30am for shits and giggles Hmm. When I finally left HR hounded me about reimbursing the bonus I had been given a year ago

Woahthehorsey · 22/02/2022 14:16

@EvenMoreFuriousVexation

Companies might need to offer higher salary, but if the money isn't in the budget then it will have to come out of other areas. So expect to see companies dropping to statutory minimum sick pay, annual leave, parental leave, travel/subsistence allowance frozen, bonus schemes removed, subsidised canteens removed, free parking withdrawn, no budget for staff events, the cheapest fixtures and fittings possible...
That's it.

There's been recruitment issues in the NHS for years, but without putting up tax or reducing the services offered, wages cannot increase.

Same with care providers - huge amounts of their income cones from local authority contracts, local authorities cannot pay more without increasing council tax and cutting other services.

Monopolyiscrap · 22/02/2022 14:11

@MaryMcCarthy I find in a booming economy the well off do better, but it does not trickle down. That is a lie. So no I don't care about a booming economy. I care about people on not so great wages finally doing a bit better.

OP posts:
MaryMcCarthy · 22/02/2022 14:07

[quote Monopolyiscrap]@MaryMcCarthy we have been told during the past years that the economy has done well, while in real terms lots of wages have been falling. And it is not just about wages, but about employers treating you decently.
I care about my job, what am I paid and how am I treated. I don't really care if productivity is down or up. Too many times when the economy is booming, it simply means rich people make lots of money.[/quote]
You might not care if productivity is improving, but it's the thing that determines the size and scope of the economy for years to come. Missed opportunities now mean fewer high quality, well paying jobs in the future. It means less innovation, less value being created. It means being left behind by international competitors and in such an economy there's less motivation for employers to treat employees well. It's a race to the bottom.

You're right that a booming economy means rich people making lots of money, but the truth is that in the opposite of a booming economy, we all suffer in one way or another. Of course it's normal to care about your job and your situation, but it's the overall picture that ultimately determines the jobs available to us.

Alexandra83190 · 22/02/2022 14:02

No, they don't have to get used to treating staff better, they will just recruit from abroad, like the insurance company near me who now imports workers from South Asia.

Monopolyiscrap · 22/02/2022 13:54

My favourite pub keeps most of its staff for years. It is independent and seems to treat staff really well. Weatherspoons though is struggling.

OP posts:
goawaystormy · 22/02/2022 13:46

@BoodleBug51

It's not nasty or goady to say if you can't recruit then you need to look at your business and why it's not attracting people rather than blaming people for being lazy or not wanting to work. If you haven't got a problem with recruiting then this post isn't about you, if you have, well then take a hard look at your business model - it might just not be viable.

Nothing annoys me more than a sad-face photo from a local cafe that's having to shut down because they can't find any staff. I think if they were paying the going rate and treated staff well they would be fine. Otherwise the business isn't sustainable.

This with bells on. The hospitality industry is rife with calling workers lazy and complaining of a staffing crisis but so many businesses pay minimum wage, don't even provide you with a staff meal, expect you to come in at the drop of a hat, and give you no flexibility over hours. Of course people don't want to work there!

formalineadeline · 22/02/2022 13:42

Democracy means we can and should criticise MPs.

Monopolyiscrap · 22/02/2022 13:41

I have worked for two different lawyers, never again. They were by a long shot the very worst employers I have ever had.

OP posts:
ILoveAllRainbowsx · 22/02/2022 13:38

@Monopolyiscrap

Boris Johnson should be in prison. Not our Prime Minister.
Totally agree with this
SecondhandTable · 22/02/2022 13:38

@stuntbubbles

I’d love for this to be true. Some recent “perks” I’ve seen listed on job adverts:

Pension (er, you mean the mandatory minimum pension scheme?)
Statutory holiday allowance
Free fruit bowl in the office
Half a day off on your birthday (just half, mind)
1 day a week WFH! (Treat yoself)
Wine Friday with colleagues (would rather die)
Newly decorated London office (???)

Yet the responsibilities are vast and the salary pathetic. Just pay people properly so they can afford their own manky bananas, offer decent holiday, and flexi as standard FFS.

But with a cost of living crisis, energy crisis, housing crisis, climate crisis, pick your own crisis, impending war, inflation, etc, I think it’s going to go the way of employer’s choice and be grateful for your free bruised fruit and £22k for a senior role that was £22k 15 years ago.

Do you work in law by any chance? That list is almost verbatim what I see on law firms websites haha. I know exactly what you mean.
ILoveAllRainbowsx · 22/02/2022 13:37

@DGRossetti

So why don't you become an MP instead of criticising the people who are at least prepared to do it and put up with abuse and death threats?

Because I don't particularly want any power over my fellow subjects. And I am very wary of those that do.

I also have a rather peculiar expectation of those that are elected.

Oh so that is why you want to be in the EU where we can't vote for anything.

In that case I can understand why you were a remainer but I want to be able to vote for what happens in the UK.

Monopolyiscrap · 22/02/2022 13:37

Boris Johnson should be in prison. Not our Prime Minister.

OP posts:
ILoveAllRainbowsx · 22/02/2022 13:35

[quote Monopolyiscrap]@ILoveAllRainbowsx in what universes are we not allowed to criticise MPs unless we are prepared to become an MP?
There are decent MPs. But the ones who currently have power are incompetent and corrupt. Any decent conservative MPs have been expelled from the party or sidelined.[/quote]
Of course you can criticize MP's but the person I was replying to was saying that there is no point in voting because it doesn't change anything. In that case she should change the system.

The reason that all the decent conservative MP's have been pushed out is because the only way that AT&t conservative party felt it was going to win a majority was to have Boris as prime minister.

I can't stand Boris Johnson but if that's what people want then that is what we get.

I couldn't stand him as London mayor and I was horrified when he became the party leader.

DGRossetti · 22/02/2022 13:33

So why don't you become an MP instead of criticising the people who are at least prepared to do it and put up with abuse and death threats?

Because I don't particularly want any power over my fellow subjects. And I am very wary of those that do.

I also have a rather peculiar expectation of those that are elected.

Monopolyiscrap · 22/02/2022 13:29

@ILoveAllRainbowsx in what universes are we not allowed to criticise MPs unless we are prepared to become an MP?
There are decent MPs. But the ones who currently have power are incompetent and corrupt. Any decent conservative MPs have been expelled from the party or sidelined.

OP posts:
Monopolyiscrap · 22/02/2022 13:27

@SweetFelicityArkright I agree. It is not nasty or goady for employees to get the best deal they can. And specialist crafts always had apprentices in the past. It is how this sector used to work before they could easily recruit people from abroad.

OP posts:
Monopolyiscrap · 22/02/2022 13:24

@MaryMcCarthy we have been told during the past years that the economy has done well, while in real terms lots of wages have been falling. And it is not just about wages, but about employers treating you decently.
I care about my job, what am I paid and how am I treated. I don't really care if productivity is down or up. Too many times when the economy is booming, it simply means rich people make lots of money.

OP posts: