Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To admit I have no idea wtf is going on with Russia and the

538 replies

Dustlandcinderella · 21/02/2022 22:54

I follow the news and can see that There is a lot about Russia and the Ukraine. But I can’t quite figure out what is happening , what the background is, and what the truth is (bearing in mind in any war there is propaganda on each side).

Am I the only person who doesn’t actually understand what’s going on

OP posts:
socksnjumpers · 23/02/2022 11:30

@Keepyourheadscrewedon following on from what other posters have said, if you want a decent link to the history of Ukraine vs Russian, 2013 to the present day I can provide one from a decent source. It is worth looking at what is being reported by news agency outside the UK and the US - for example there is an Indian news agency which is award winning, and India is very commited to neutrality.

Diplomacy is being urged from many quarters, not because people are "pro Russian" but because sanctions do not work and risk further instability. My concern about Truss, Biden et al is that they don't have a decent handle on the issues and I don't think either of them understand about sanctions vs diplomacy. Macron was involved in negotiating Minsk, I think, and the French govmt website has a decent and balanced review of the situation but at the same time they have commitments to allies and so I don't know what move they will make in future.

In relation to doctors jumping out of windows, it was reported to have happened 3 times and there was and is speculation you are right - but there are shades of grey here, and complexities, and the same applies to our political and human rights behaviour in the West. But confusing these issues with the current crises will not help.

The Russians you know will evidently have their own views but just because they are Russian will not mean they are necessarily well informed?

Keepyourheadscrewedon · 23/02/2022 11:25

I don’t believe any of the propaganda that you post socks, and I won’t be watching it

socksnjumpers · 23/02/2022 11:21

@Keepyourheadscrewedon

I think ordinary Russians must also be horrified, they are not stupid and will see the propaganda for what it is. They will know precisely what Putin is doing and are largely helpless to stop him.

I have Russian friends here in the UK and they are unsurprised by his actions. He does far worse to doctors/activists etc every day. People are regularly pushed out of windows or are involved in accidents because they express even the smallest dissent.

@Keepyourheadscrewedon this is a video done by France 24 (NB - French, mainstream) last week about what Russians think, it will give you a different perspective:
Wanderingowl · 23/02/2022 11:13

@Keepyourheadscrewedon

Correction Hitler did not start WW1 just WW2. Germany was responsible for starting both wars.
What? That is such a very, very, very weird oversimplification to the point of utter falsity. That's a level of understanding that I would honestly be disappointed in from my 9 year old. For it to come from an adult who is trying to use these historical events as a comparison for current events is honestly concerning. And so very indicative of why we are where we are right now. Your assertions about WW1 come from an understanding based on propaganda from over a century ago. Your assertions about current events come from the propaganda of today. Because the news coming from our corporate and state medias is every bit as much propaganda as that being disseminated in Russia now and that which was disseminated on every side before during and after the World Wars too.

The foundations of World War One were essentially set in place at the end of the Crimean War. The shift in power structures during Crimea resulted in the settlement of the alliances that along with the tensions caused by barely abated colonialist expansionism led the "world" to war in 1914.

But if you want to look at any one action as the beginning of World War One, it was in fact the Austro-Hungarian invasion of Serbia on July 28th 1914. While Germany was allied with the Austro-Hungarians and could possibly have prevented the war by withdrawing their support following the assassination of the heir to the Austro-Hunagrain throne. (Franz Ferdinand not being a minor aristocrat as I learned in school, but rather one of the highest ranking people in the world.) It was absolutely not German expansionism that sparked the war. That's bullshit propaganda from 1914 that has no place being repeated in 2022.

Anyone who does think Germany started WW1, needs to accept that they have swallowed generations old propaganda. About events that have since been so studied and written upon that it's easy for anyone with a few hours to spare to learn about what actually happened in greater depth. And maybe needs to consider that if it's so easy to keep believing in old, easily debunked propaganda, just how much of the opinion on today's events is based on modern propaganda. Propaganda that it's much harder to get to the bottom of due to it's still unfolding nature and none of us being able to have the benefit of hindsight.

Keepyourheadscrewedon · 23/02/2022 10:23

I hope you feeling okay Alex, genuinely.

Alexandra2001 · 23/02/2022 10:22

You are right to ask for sources, and everyone on here should be able to post links to verify any claims/information they are posting

Ha ha lets see the one which shows Hitler started WW1 and that Putin intends to take over ALL the ex Soviet states?

He cannot because he doesn't possess the capability to do so with just 150k troops (which took him 10months to amass) and in most cases, equipment that is way behind anything the 'west has.

Sorry supervisor came in, and forced me at gun point to reply to you.

Keepyourheadscrewedon · 23/02/2022 10:14

I totally agree not the wrong information can lead to very very poor outcomes, and everything should be double and triple checked for accuracy, independent observers are invaluable in this instance. On the ground fact checking with no agenda apart from to report on actual facts.
You are right to ask for sources, and everyone on here should be able to post links to verify any claims/information they are posting.

Keepyourheadscrewedon · 23/02/2022 10:12

I hope seriously that the people of Russia will be okay, both in St Peters where you are Alex, and elsewhere. They are also innocent and do not deserve to be terrified in their beds of retribution and where this is all leading. Their children and babies deserve to be safe. There are no winners in war.

notimagain · 23/02/2022 10:11

I’m absolutely not mixing anything up and you have now clarified your comment…thanks…

The point I am making is that I suspect if you ran a straw poll in this place on what “ballistic missiles” do or what “warheads” are I would put money on the majority automatically making a nuclear connection and they would wrong to do so.

Yes, I’m being picky because IMHO we all some understanding of what the reality of this is and at least be able to run a credibility check on what the MSM/politicians say.

This is really important…one classic example for it being so is the way many in the west (some public, certainly some MPs) got spooked initially at least into supporting Gulf War Two because they didn’t realise that what they were being sold in the UN/HoC/MSM was highly questionable…all they heard was buzz words and phrases such as “improved Scud” “delivery systems”, “weapons of mass destruction,” “45 minutes…”..many no understanding of what the terms meant or if they were credible, they just heard something scary.

I’d hate for us to go down that road again.

Keepyourheadscrewedon · 23/02/2022 10:09

I would be swigging vodka in your position as well - to be fair - its not every day your leader starts a war.

Alexandra2001 · 23/02/2022 10:06

@Keepyourheadscrewedon Its a bit cold here in St Peters, so a cuppa keeps me warm and a swig of vodka to keep me sane when i come across crazy people on MN.

MGMidget · 23/02/2022 10:06

Keepyourheadscrewedon, I am not sure Trump would have done anything. He looked like in the pocket of the Russians and they ‘had’ something on him!

Alexandra2001 · 23/02/2022 10:04

Hitler started WW1 and WW2 right?

enjoy the rest of thread, i have better things to do than argue with anyone who believes this or as i suspect isn't being totally serious.

Keepyourheadscrewedon · 23/02/2022 10:02

Both world wars began by annexing and invading other European countries. Sound familiar? Or are you still claiming Putin is there for diplomatic reasons?

Or perhaps you are on a tea break finally alex?

Keepyourheadscrewedon · 23/02/2022 10:01

Correction Hitler did not start WW1 just WW2. Germany was responsible for starting both wars.

Keepyourheadscrewedon · 23/02/2022 09:59

Of course I know WW1 was started by Hitler and Germany declaring war on Russia but invading France

WW2 was started by Hitler by invading Poland.

Does this remind you of anyone in particular? Can you not see why people are making the comparison?

I am not sure why YOU don't know the basics.

Keepyourheadscrewedon · 23/02/2022 09:52

This link will tell you all about the ballistic missiles being trucked into Ukraine, I read the full article this morning and it makes it very clear that the missiles now inside Ukraine can take out the captial:

www.telegraph.co.uk/world-news/2022/02/23/russian-military-hardware-war-torn-donbas-presents-ballistic/

No one has mentioned nuclear weapons on this thread so I am not sure if you have it mixed up with another. By whilst we talk about nuclear weapons this is something Putin has raised himself and is currently doing nuclear drills. Hardly encouraging.
Still, Alex thinks cool heads will prevail and a diplomatic solution will be found in a matter of hours/days so hopefully we will all sleep better knowing that Confused despite the nuclear drills and ballistic missiles in the background.

Alexandra2001 · 23/02/2022 09:48

We learnt a great deal from Hitler, the first and second time around, I doubt we will be making the same mistakes again

What did Hitler do twice? do you think he started WW1 as well?

Do you not know that the causes of WW1 and WW2 were completely different.

Its hard to debate with someone who has so little basic knowledge & seems to get their information from the 'express

blingkerching · 23/02/2022 09:47

Does Putin want world war 3 or does he just want Ukraine? I don't find the comparisons to Hitler that helpful as he had a clear fascist ideology that he wanted to implement. I don't really know exactly what Putin wants.

Keepyourheadscrewedon · 23/02/2022 09:46

I know you don't like us comparing to Putin to Hitler for some reason, I would like to ask you what the differences are?

Putin has a thread of opportunity now to avoid that label. He has one last chance to stop now, and not be condemned to being another Hitler, but I somehow doubt he will take it, he has convinced himself he is taking back what is his, his rewriting of history gives us great insight into his thinking. He is not turning back and yes he just about to become a Russian Hitler, the world will hold him to account.

notimagain · 23/02/2022 09:44

Too many Cold War buzz words and cool phrases are being chucked into some of these posts and it’s probably frightening a few trying to follow this:

  1. What ballistic misses are being trucked over what border?
  1. The reality is many short range missiles are ballistic or have a ballistic element to their trajectory.
  1. Most most importantly short range ballistic missiles being deployed, if they are, does not in any way shape or from inevitably equate with the deployment of nuclear weapons.

For example the Scud missiles used widely in the Gulf Conflict(s) and currently occasionally being chucked in the direction of Saudi Arabia are ballistic missiles…you wouldn’t want to be under one when it comes down but they are not nuclear weapons.

Keepyourheadscrewedon · 23/02/2022 09:37

Cool heads? Do you not think that moment has truly passed?
There is nothing cool about Putin terrifying his ministers into agreeing with this action.
There is nothing cool about the potential loss of thousands of innocent lives - including children and babies.
There is nothing cool about starting a war in Europe.

Putin planned this invasion long ago, he has amassed the troops since May of last year, there is a clear and organised plan to carve up Ukraine bit by bit until they have taken over the country. The 'diplomacy' about NATO and the minsk agreement was just abit of light entertainment along the way for Putin. He enjoyed watching the leaders such as Macron clamouring to 'fix' it before ejecting their suggestions and solutions into obscurity publicly as he tore up the Minsk agreement.

Unfortunately Putin only responds to action and strength, so I strongly suspect that is whats going to need to happen to prevent the loss of millions of lives. We learnt a great deal from Hitler, the first and second time around, I doubt we will be making the same mistakes again.

Alexandra2001 · 23/02/2022 09:29

@Keepyourheadscrewedon Cool heads are required, not insane idiots like Trump or people comparing Putin to Hitler.

Hasn't Putin got a sex tape of Trump being pissed on?

190k are NOT troops moving across Ukraine, most are still in Russia, your talking rubbish again.

Where Ballistic missiles are positioned is irrelevant, they have ranges of 1000s of miles, though there is no evidence he has moved nuclear weapons into the Ukraine.

The EU isn't a military alliance, so i don't see why you think they are?

NATO has art 5, that will protect any NATO member threatened, which the USA/UK/France etc will honour, Putin knows this, which is why he is targeting Ukraine and not the Baltic states, which militarily would be a far easier prospect for Russia.

The UK needs to be acting on the Russian report, halting troop cuts and increasing defence spending, not least bring forward the Challenger 3 program.
Because though i disagree with your tone, i do agree that strength is what Putin understands but it has to be a two pronged approach, so diplomacy is vital, even at this late hour.

notimagain · 23/02/2022 09:22

Care needs to be taken when simply comparing number of troops, size of armies etc, country by country….it can be very poor metric to use when you are trying to work out relative threats and capability.

For an invasion/incursion it’s generally thought you (and that’s a generic you) just need an overwhelming advantage in numbers at the point where you decide to use them, if you decide to use them…

And as an aside whilst many of the Russian troops are not well treated many units in the other bad news is that Russian forces are now often equipped with some very very capable and advanced equipment.

Keepyourheadscrewedon · 23/02/2022 09:18

I think ordinary Russians must also be horrified, they are not stupid and will see the propaganda for what it is. They will know precisely what Putin is doing and are largely helpless to stop him.

I have Russian friends here in the UK and they are unsurprised by his actions. He does far worse to doctors/activists etc every day. People are regularly pushed out of windows or are involved in accidents because they express even the smallest dissent.